self_made_human
amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi
I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.
At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!
Friends:
A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.
User ID: 454
Well, at least you don't need to live somewhere with particularly permissive gun laws to make it work!
So on this level I'd say Bayesianism is a worthwhile pursuit of formalizing this kind of thinking, and we can set aside the question of how well it does this for now. I say "on this level" because there are many variants of Bayesianism, and some claim Bayesianism does much more, such as Bayesianism providing a (partial) justification and rational basis for scientific theories instead of induction, which we have agreed it cannot do, i.e. it cannot elevate our theories beyond the status of a guess.
I certainly agree that Bayesianism can't solve the problem of regress or induction. But since nothing can, we have made absolutely no progress in solving it (despite many very intelligent people trying), my strong suspicion is that it's an impossible problem to solve, and so we might as well just make do.
Can you call everything a guess? Yes.
Yet guesses are certainly not made equal. We can be much more certain of some guesses than others, and while we can never get to perfect certainty in anything, we can often get close enough for government work, or even to establish extremely powerful laws of physics.
When a guess becomes so strong that we would be utterly flabbergasted if we suddenly saw evidence it was false, then we can dispense with the formalities and call it a fact, or true.
Bayesianism often gives up on this goal, and confines itself to only our expectations and related calculations. It thus gives up on saying anything about objective reality, and confines itself to talking about our subjective states of expectation and calculations of probabilty regarding those expectations. This, for me, is an unacceptable retreat from figuring out objective reality as the aim of science. I'm interested in how the world really is, I'm not interested in our subjective calculations of probabilty (other than if they can perhaps help in the former).
My stance is that this isn't a form of unwarranted cowardice or retreat, but a pragmatic acknowledgement that we are subjective observers forced to grapple with evidence acquired through sensoria. There is no scope for an actual bird's eye view, we must trudge through the territory and map it as we go.
Our probability theories breakdown utterly, or become garbled, when confronted with things like the possibility of the Simulation Hypothesis being true, Boltzmann brains and so on. I can't rule out with any degree of real confidence that this isn't a simulation, and the laws of physics as we best understand them imply Boltzmann brains are inevitable, let alone the implications if the Universe (and not just the observable part) is truly infinite, at which point every possible arrangement of matter and energy will be forced to tile over and repeat somewhere.
Or I could be crazy. I could be making mistakes.
We cannot eliminate this, and on top of that, we are computationally bounded entities.
Could this be a simulation? Could I be a Boltzmann brain about to vanish into a fizzle? Am I crazy? Regardless of my credence in any of them, I simply choose to operate as if it's not true, since that is the course of action with the highest payoff if they're not true, and if they are, nothing I do matters (we can't even usefully speculate as to what a potential simulation is for, or if the laws of physics at that level correspond to ours).
Thus, if objective truth exists, we can never know with perfect certainty (as always, without assuming the conclusion in advance), and science can only constrain our expectations and improve our ability to model things at the level of our observations of our environment.
Thus, is science useful? Absolutely. But it can never provide perfect certainty, but we can certainly operate without that, and in practise we do. We can converge ever closer to 100% confidence that our map faithfully represents the territory, and that's good enough for me.
Reality does not care about our probability calculations.
And yet we are not Reality itself, or able to stand above it. Hence we should care about our probability calculations.
The closest we have to perfect certainty is in things like logic and math, but those do not actually exist in a vacuum to be poked and prodded, they're instantiated within our brains and other computers, and thus even what you (and I, with usual caveats that I omit when the discussion does not go this deep) might consider self evident truths, like 2=2 being true, could be the product of error in our cognition. Let's just be glad that we think this is extremely, extremely unlikely, and carry on with our lives nonetheless.
Hmm.. Given that I'm single and circumcised, and I can get four times the wives at half the price, I'm tempted.
I've heard the demand for doctors is really high, can't say why.
Unemployed agents could always move into veterinary euthanasia or find work in PETA.
No chimpanzees as I find them vulgar.
This is so incredibly funny to me, but you're indisputably correct, chimpanzees are indeed rather vulgar.
I suppose orcas made it and dolphins didn't because the latter are rapist, onanist necrophiliacs who happen to have great PR?
This suggests current analytic approaches in neuroscience may fall short of producing meaningful understanding of neural systems, regardless of the amount of data.
Uh.. The paper you linked is at least 50% of an academic shitpost or meme.
I'm not kidding. I've read it before.
It has legitimate arguments about neuroscience and the validity of their analysis tools, but those tools were not designed to analyze Von Neumann architectures and transistor based circuits.
I'm not a neuroscientist, but the principles of neuroscience are both not designed for the task these guys did (and they did it at least partially as a joke) and have proven results elsewhere. Further, we have better options for circuit analysis in silicon and don't have them in neurology, so the paper correctly points out that they're flawed, we just don't have better alternatives but are working on them.
We understand a great deal about many individual pathways in the brain, such as the optic pathways, and there are hundreds of different pathways we know a great about down to the neuronal level while being very far from being able to tell what any arbitrary neuron does.
This is because neurons are complex. It takes 1000 ML neurons to simulate a single biological neuron, but guess what, it's been done.
https://www.quantamagazine.org/how-computationally-complex-is-a-single-neuron-20210902/
When the guy tried to parachute off the Eiffel tower, he did so because he'd tested the idea with models first and had some direct evidence of the thing he was attempting to harness
He didn't test it enough. His friends literally begged him to try his apparatus with a dummy before he used it himself, but he was too proud and confident in his invention.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franz_Reichelt#:~:text=Franz%20Karl%20Reichelt%20
From his arrival at the tower, however, Reichelt made it clear that he intended to jump himself. According to a later interview with one of the friends who accompanied him up the tower, this was a surprise to everybody, as Reichelt had concealed his intention until the last moment.[9] His friends tried to persuade him to use dummies in the experiment, assuring him that he would have other opportunities to make the jump himself. When this failed to make an impression on him, they pointed to the strength of the wind and said he should call off the test on safety grounds, or at least delay until the wind dropped. They were unable to shake his resolve;[7] seemingly undeterred by the failure of his previous tests, he told journalists from Le Petit Journal that he was totally convinced that his apparatus would work, and work well.
Trust me that I have the common sense not to do that. I meet the low bar of not being insane.
You all share the conviction that the human mind is arbitrarily tractable, controllable, malleable, that Selves can be engineered with no regard to their own will, and despite all evidence to the contrary.
There are many ways to control the human mind.
The only natural category these lot have is that they were completely wrong, and it's a bit rich to make that assertion about me when I'm discussing what I have clearly labeled as an extremely difficult engineering challenge. What else do you think that my belief that it would take us several decades to get there (in the absence of AI) means?
No, I think you're straightforwardly wrong about what is possible right now, and especially about what it shows. I don't think scientists can "emulate a rat brain", meaning create a digital simulacrum of a rat that allows them read/write access to the equivalent of a live rat brain. I certainly do not believe that scientists can emulate "1% of a human brain", under any reasonable interpretations of those words. My argument isn't that compute won't improve, it's that the mind is probably intractable, and that certainly no evidence of tractability is currently available. I have not looked into either the WBEP or EBRAINS, but I'm pretty confident they don't do anything approaching actual emulation of a human mind.
I never claimed that they have a virtual rat running around either. In this case, they managed to fully analyze the connectome of a rat, mapping all the neurons and their interconnections, but it takes much more than that to get an emulation running.
You need the actual weights of the neurons (in the ML sense), and for that you need optogenetics to study it, presumably in a live specimen, or you need to destructively scan the tissue with other techniques (if they were live when you started, they won't stay that way for long, hence why preserved tissue samples are used, including in the EU program. Besides, they only claim to have emulated 1% of the human brain, as a pilot program and technology incubator, your guess is as good as mine what running 1% of a brain does).
But looking back, I think it's pretty clear that this belief came from inference, not evidence, and from some pretty shaky inferences too. As you put it, "nothing in my knowledge of physics, chemistry, biology or engineering rules it out", and I wanted to believe it, and it fit neatly with other things I wanted to believe, so I discarded the contrary evidence and ran with it. That's what people do.
Do you think I peg my expected figure for how long it might take (counterfactual blah blah) because I am "discarding evidence"? No. It's because I have repeatedly acknowledged that it is an enormously difficult task.
Hell, if I was in charge of funding, I wouldn't put too much money into human brain emulation either, because AGI makes the wait-curves too steep. Anything we mere dumb humans do to painstakingly achieve that is likely going to be a waste of time and resources as opposed to a far more intelligent entity working on it, and we're building those even if they're decidedly inhuman.
Please, please, recognize the difference between "I know this is so" and "I don't know why this shouldn't be so". Both are useful; I argue that both are entirely necessary. But it pays to be clear about which one you're using in a given situation, and to not mix the two up.
Once again, if it's not contradicted by physics, then it's an engineering problem. We can emulate neurons, and to within the limits of measurement and innate noise, as the link to quanta shows.
It is a hard problem. It is still a problem that I expect will be solved eventually, and am reasonably confident I'll be alive to see it.
DALL-E 3 lol, but use Bing Image Creator, in some ways it's still less anal about prompts than ChatGPT's version of DALL-E is, for all its been censored to hell too.
"Don't tread on me" flag with a snake that is smoking a cigar, while holding a bottle of vodka with one hand and shooting a gun with the other hand
(I know it's called the Gadsden flag, I just explicitly called out the snake because I wanted it to be doing, well, that)
I grant it to ya, those picks certainly have unique aesthetics. I'm certainly fond of the Stoner 63, need to play around with it in VR some more.
I'm pretty sure Elden Ring would be a much harder game if the bosses came with AKs of dubious make. Or easier, if you could pick them up.
With all the hubbub over in the main thread with the ATF, it's the perfect time to have a favorite gun thread!
In other words, what's your favorite gun? Preferably a real one, but I'm scared you'll shoot me if I adjudicate too harshly, so if it launches a projectile from a barrel I'll let it slide.
Trick question! Anyone worthy of this contest can't have just one answer.
In my case, the top 5 are:
-
The MCX Spear. Because we were due an M5 already, .277 Fury is a wild cartridge, and while it's grossly overkill for Russian conscripts or Chinese soldiers in Alibaba armor, when the robots come for you, better come packing. I was mildly inclined to reconsider because the Textron entry to the NGSW program was a bit cooler, a bullpup with a telescoping barrel that shoots polymer rounds? If only it hadn't been a bullpup, it would be a shoe-in.
-
The G3. While the FAL is the right arm of the Free World, I simply think this one is neat. Well, at least I think it looks cooler stock. An SA-58 variant of the FAL with modernized furniture certainly tells you the 70s are back with a vengeance.
-
The MG-338. For when you still don't have power armor and can't have Infantry hoof around Brownings, but want something with more oomph than 7.62x51.
-
The Mk-18. My short-barreled beloved. Compact, all the cool kids use it, comes gucci-d out. Closely tied with a Honeybadger or Sig MCX Rattler both in .300 Blackout for small but deadly.
-
The Mk-18 Mjolnir. Do not confuse these two entries. The Mjolnir fires .338 Lapua. Because fuck you and the tree behind you (for a modestly sized tree).
-
Thought I'd stop at 5 did ya? Mistaken. The PKP, because we need some Soviet or Russian representation. Better than the M240B in almost every way, including weight. So good that new and not so new NATO countries like Finland and Poland field them.
One day, I'll make it to Battlefield Vegas, and then I will dual wield PKPs and fire them at my feet till the recoil lifts me straight to Valhalla.
Isn't AI wonderful?
It's rude to talk about caste like that. I can't help it.
She failed the exam we gave outright. I'm in limbo with a small chance I'll squeeze through and get something. We could have both been in the West if we didn't happen to prioritize exams that lead to career progression instead of dead end jobs in the NHS.
Your situation is surprising for me only in that she ditched you before gaining access to the non-Indian sexual marketplace. Want to take bets she pops up in the West before you do?
Dude, India isn't Qatar. If a middle class professional woman wants dick, we've got Tinder too. Bars. Sleazy nightclubs. I'm sure Western men would align with her feminist ideals better than the average Indian in our social class, but I'm about as egalitarian as it gets. I did dishes, the laundry and cleaned. When I slacked, it's because I'm lazy, not because it's beneath me or something.
No, I wouldn't have dated her for 1.5 years if I thought she was what you're implying. Our differences were irreconcilable, falling apart because neither of us could fix our character flaws, not because she was out for an upgrade. It's probably easier for me to get laid in the UK than it is here, but for an attractive woman? You couldn't schedule the time. And it's not like there aren't liberal men here too, if you seek a more longterm relationship. We were together and eyeing a future together because our plans aligned, I can't date someone who expects something more than a hookup without lying about how I intend to fuck right out of this country as quickly as possible, and I know she's honest, often excessively so, and wouldn't do the same.
SkookumTree commenting in PoliticalCompassMemes
A fate worse than death. He should have gone on the Hock instead.
People have claimed to have developed reactionless thrusters before. A test I've heard proposed is to hang the thruster and its power source from a pendulum, inside a sealed plastic bag, and then show it holding the pendulum off-center. In a similar vein, here's some proposals for similar tests of read/write access to the human mind: a working lie detector, love potion, mind-reader, or mind-control device would all be obvious demonstrations of the basic capability. Do you believe any of these exist, or that they will exist in, say, the next few years? If not, why not?
A tailor jumping off the Eiffel tower with a large apparatus of mostly linen did not prevent the invention of working parachutes. The dozens of people jumping off cliffs to their deaths throughout the ages did not prevent heavier than air flight.
There are reasonably robust theoretical reasons to suppose that reactionless thrusters do not work. I wish to see the equivalent for BCIs.
It certainly doesn't seem to be. I'm all for it, but this is reading output, not even input/output, and certainly not read/write.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retinal_implant
Foerster was the first to discover that electrical stimulation of the occipital cortex could be used to create visual percepts, phosphenes.[1] The first application of an implantable stimulator for vision restoration was developed by Drs. Brindley and Lewin in 1968.[2] This experiment demonstrated the viability of creating visual percepts using direct electrical stimulation, and it motivated the development of several other implantable devices for stimulation of the visual pathway, including retinal implants
(The eyes are also an extension of the brain from an anatomical and developmental standpoint, but you can write imagery to it directly, as the excerpt showing the effects of stimulation to the occipital cortex shows)
We can reliably produce different sensations and even cause muscular movements. The tech isn't at the point I can make you see HD pictures.
You can damage my brain right now, or possibly jam it. You can't write on it in any meaningful fashion, as far as I know. Again, if you could, that would necessarily imply the present existence of mind reading and mind control, correct?
Now, I can always adjust the voltage on the electrode, the indemnity documents are purely an insurance matter and not because I'm not licensed for neurosurgery. I can reliably induce plenty of somatic sensations in you and show you some really sweet colors, and once I get to the temporal lobe, I can promise meeting God Himself or your money back (and you don't even have to die, temporal lobe epilepsy or stimulation causes religious ecstasy).
We can read minds. See video linked. It literally picks up on his will to move his paralyzed arms and converts that to equivalent mouse movements. We can control minds. Just very crudely. The dude in the video says he intends to cosplay as Professor X, which is hilarious, and also not far from reality. If he can move a mouse cursor, he can move a robot, with his mind, at a distance. This has been done with Neuralink in monkeys, and with other BCIs, also in monkeys.
Mind reading and mind control exist. It's not a psychic phenomenon, it uses Bluetooth.
Marx? Freud? BF Skinner? Watson? As for affiliation with them, do you think the "God of the Gaps" is a reasonable criticism of Christianity? If so, is it just Christians who shouldn't collectively retreat to unfalsifiability, or are such collective retreats in the face of contrary evidence generally bad whoever is doing them?
Umm.. I have said some very uncomplimentary things about Marx and Freud. I believe I called the latter Fraud in a comment as recently as a day ago.
Skinner? I am neutral on him. The Skinner Box is an interesting idea, that's about all I can say from memory.
Watson? Presumably buddy of Crick? What did he do wrong? I have no idea.
I have seen plenty of Christians here happily engage in GOTG reasoning. You don't need to go back 50 years or more to find them. Yes, hiding in the dark and dank corners where you can just barely squeeze your eyes closed against the light of empirical inquiry is a shameful display.
But what's your point? I invite you to show me what I have in common with Marx, Freud, Watson and Crick. I am bemused that there exists a natural category the five of us share. I certainly denounce the former two much harder than I can recall any practising Christian here fighting against GOTG. If so, they have my thanks, I prefer an honest admission that they have an unshakable faith that I don't have to waste time debating rather than having to wait for the inexorable march of progress to squeeze them out of the gratings.
Could I get a cite on this? I would like to see some actual captures from dreams or the minds eye, because I'm pretty sure such things don't exist in the sense I understand the terms. I'm interested in being proved wrong, though.
This A.I. Used Brain Scans to Recreate Images People Saw
If. As in, in the future. As in, not in the present. You recognize that we not only can't emulate a human being, but we aren't anywhere close to being able to, right? That the capability you are reasoning from is, at the moment, entirely fictional?
The line between sufficiently hard scifi and a white paper is blurry indeed.
This is a terrible argument. You are likely using an electronic device that was "fictional" when first imagined to make it.
In the absence of AGI, I think it would take anywhere from 20-40 years to make a high fidelity emulation of a human brain. The bottlenecks are both available compute (the requirements to run a human brain on a computer are large, and the estimates vary OOMs). We also need better scanning tools, right now they're best suited for tiny slices at a time, and you can't do it while the subject is alive. Thankfully the latter is not a strict requirement, and shortcuts in compute and better algorithms probably exist. The record as it stands has long exceeded drosophila and roundworms, and the current SOTA is either an entire rat brain or 1% of a human brain.
If you disagree, please make it clear you're exceedingly confident in what I deem to be a very insane proposal that we will not have OOMs more raw compute in a few decades*, or that scanning techniques will not improve even modestly, given that new advances come out every year or two.
These are all difficult tasks. Hence the long time without AGI helping us. But nothing in my knowledge of physics, chemistry, biology or engineering rules it out, and the EU has enough confidence that it's possible that they spent a billion euros on the Whole Brain Emulation Project and are now working on its successor, EBRAINS. It's at about the same stage as the Human Genome Project was, and look where we are today. (Tbf, they did a terrible job at it. But it's a hard job nonetheless.)
*Short of civilizational collapse and mass extinction.
All direct evidence available to us shows that the human self has free will: we experience its operation every minute of every day, and can examine that operation in intimate detail. All engineering we do on humans operates on the assumption that free will exists, from education to law to navigating interpersonal relationships. Determinism makes no predictions that can currently be tested. Determinism's previous testable predictions have all been falsified. No engineering we currently do on humans operates according to deterministic principles. All these are facts, to the extent that "facts" can be said to exist.
The fact that all of the above can be so easily ignored can teach one important things about the operation of human reason, and particularly the prime role that free will takes in that operation. You can't be made to draw a conclusion by presented evidence, because the individual will has veto on what is even considered evidence. All beliefs are chosen by distinct acts of the will.
Please, not this topic again, I think we've been over this at least twice or thrice and I don't think we've made any progress. Certainly this is a starting point that would require rehashing what was a fruitless debate.
I prefer e-cigarettes, but otherwise can rally behind your flag (I bet $3.50 it has a snake on it, and that's cool). Then again, I don't know if nicotine is easy to synthesize without the plant, so maybe you can ignore my concerns for now.
To nitpick your nitpick (flea removal is nominally in my remit), doesn't the combustion of a primer and/or the main propellant charge count as a tiny bomb in a fire arm?
And if you load a far too hot handloaded .50 BMG round, well, let's say it can be a much bigger bomb.
That is an utter abomination of a username. I'm impressed.
Man, as someone who fucking loves guns, it sucks that the one country in the world where a man is free to shoot tannerite in full auto (with tax stamps, and officer, I promise that this is an oil filter, please walk very softly around the dog) does such a poor job of protecting it despite a clear constitutional right.
The ATF is a meme, goons who have far more power to ignore common sense and wider jurisdiction than they deserve. Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms, one of these isn't like the others. I don't know why Republicans didn't do their level best to de-fang it, especially when they had four years to do so, but I suppose that speaks to the general incompetence of the Trump Admin, or to the perfidy of the Deep State, depending on which of our regulars you ask today.
Was that simply not a priority? I would assume it would receive overwhelming support from the Republican voter base.
-
To completely unpack it? Yes. The ideal would be to read individual molecules down to the limits of the Uncertainty Principle. Luckily even noisy signals like external EEGs provide useful data.
-
https://youtube.com/watch?v=vpzXI1hlujw is a conclusive rebuttal. BCIs have been a thing for decades. We can reproduce imagery from dreams and even capture the mind's eye with surprising clarity, with non-invasive techniques to boot. I can write to your brain right now, just give me a scalpel, a needle, an electrode and medical indemnity documents.
-
No. Or at least I don't know of any such people, I have no affiliation with them, and their failures do not impede progress in the field.
-
No. If we emulate a human being, via brain scan or some high bandwidth side channel, and it works, then voila. That strikes me as about the same level of difficulty and temporal separation from today as a Victorian or early 20th century scientist theorizing about space flight and actual orbit. Or at least it would if not for AGI being imminent, which will likely solve the problem even if we didn't build it as a replica of the human brain (though inspiration was taken).
-
What of it? Many human institutions are built on faulty foundations. "All Men are created equal"? They can pull the other one, even if it's a useful legal and social fiction. Things do not need to be true to do useful things, a monarchy backed by divine will has fuck-all going for it, it still manages to raise armies, collect taxes and build roads. You can scare a toddler with ghost stories and stop them wandering out to be eaten by a coyote.
Uh.. I think mum is probably more common in those who use English as their primary language, but I've certainly heard both. I obviously prefer mom, though I do call her ma most of the time, even when I'm speaking in English.
There's no clear cutoff like between the US and the UK.
You bet I was very fucking fly in London.
I must thank my ex for all the pictures I can now use on Tinder. I can thank her a little less because she was the fifth person I swiped on in Bumble, today.
We can agree that treating people with depression should be our first and foremost concern regardless of existential questions, but why stop at that? Why not try to understand what's going on? This shouldn't change the attention and the care we give to depressed people, but it can help us think more acurately about the problem and who knows, maybe even come up with more effective solutions in the future.
Please don't interpret my fervent appeals for pragmatism as a lack of curiosity. If I was genuinely uninterested in such matters, I wouldn't even know the little tidbits of information I've sprinkled in! They're not in medical textbooks or my exam curriculum for sure.
Knowing more would be great. But do not expect that to necessarily mean that psychiatric treatment has firmer grounding. A lot of shit works and doesn't work and we don't know why. As with autism, even when we know why, we can't fix it (without more advanced gene therapy).
Psychiatrists are scientists and know the limitations of their discipline (or at least they should), but psychopathology is being used in all sorts of contexts where it has no business whatsoever, and this is in part because it is an epistemologically bankrrupt concept
Psychiatrists aren't scientists! Doctors, as a matter of course, are not scientists! Some of us do research and clinical studies. That isn't our core responsibility, and most doctors you see have no papers to their name.
We are engineers. We try and fix things, and if a tool works, it works. That does not stop us from seeking better tools.
I looked at the Wikipedia article again on psychopathology, and as far as I can tell, it is an entirely benign subject and I am fundamentally confused by accusations of it lacking epistemically bankrupt concept.
Psychopathology is the study of abnormal cognition, behaviour, and experiences which differs according to social norms and rests upon a number of constructs that are deemed to be the social norm at any particular era.
Biological psychopathology is the study of the biological etiology of abnormal cognitions, behaviour and experiences. Child psychopathology is a specialisation applied to children and adolescents. Animal psychopathology is a specialisation applied to non-human animals. This concept is linked to the philosophical ideas first outlined by Galton (1869) and is linked to the appliance of eugenical ideations around what constitutes the human.
Later:
Psychopathology can be broadly separated into descriptive and explanatory. Descriptive psychopathology involves categorising, defining and understanding symptoms as reported by people and observed through their behaviour which are then assessed according to a social norm. Explanatory psychopathology looks to find explanations for certain kinds of symptoms according to theoretical models such as psychodynamics, cognitive behavioural therapy or through understanding how they have been constructed by drawing upon Constructivist Grounded Theory (Charmaz, 2016) or Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (Smith, Flowers & Larkin, 2013).[7]
CBT is slightly better than the alternatives. I am exceedingly dubious that what it claims are the underlying mechanisms are what's actually going on, but it still works, and beats placebo and (barely but significantly) the alternatives.
I have done a deep dive on the topic myself, but I'd have to dig very deep into my profile to find it.
But even then, the existence of flawed models (which still do useful things) is no more a scathing critique than someone claiming that the Standard Model being unable to explain the overwhelming majority of the matter or energy in the universe makes Physics as a whole illegitimate. We know it's flawed. It's still useful.
There is something very funny about the history of psychology, because as you must know computers where made with the specific objective to imitate human thought. But then in the 70's a bunch of psychologists saw computers and were astonished at how much they reasembled human thought, and came to the conclusion that the human mind works like a computer. I'm personally against the expression "Artificial Intelligence" because computers are neither intelligent nor dumb. They do what they are programed to do. An animal, for instance, can be intelligent or dumb because it is directly involved in the outcome of its decissions, and they can be wrong or right. Computers are never wrong, therefore they lack the ability to be implied in their decissions. So even if LLMs resemble human speech, we would be wrong to believe that speaking to an LLM is the same as speaking to a person. In that sense, just the fact that we can treat depression as a brain disease does not mean that it is a brain disease. This is only technically correct because it ignores the problem by fixing over it.
The human brain is a computer. It just happens to not adhere to the Von Neumann architecture as most electronic ones do, but it is possible to simulate a single biological neuron with ~1000 artificial neurons in the ML sense..
Further, the human brain is bound by physics. Evidence otherwise is sorely lacking. We can simulate physics very well, at least if you don't want to use QM on macroscopic structures at typical temperatures, but only because that is a computationally difficult thing to do, not because it is fundamentally impossible to model.
Humans do what we were programmed to do. We just had a Blind Idiot God as a programmer, who had to bootstrap a VERY complex computer from a surprisingly small amount of code (DNA and epigenetics).
"Evolution, please grant me intelligence."
"To get more bitches and gather more berries?"
"Yes"
Invents condoms and ozempic like a boss 😎
You mistake the difficulty in unpacking the blackbox of human cognition as proof that it can't be unpacked. That is a grave error indeed.
For me, it's the commonsense notion of truth as correspondence to reality. Of course, we cannot know or be justified in believing that our theories are true, but they can still be true guesses if they correspond to reality, and it is this reality that we are interested in.
You say that this binary notion of truth is unattainable, so what do you replace it with? Probability calculations? What do those achieve? What is their relationship to reality? There are many variants of Bayesiansim, and they are often very fuzzy about this point, so I'm trying to pinpoint your position.
This might sound tautological, but it makes sense (to me). When I express high certainty in a hypothesis, that is tantamount, and fully interchangeable, with me expressing that in expectation, I do not expect to see evidence that contradicts the hypothesis.
When someone uses "true" in the usual sense, they are expressing that they have very minimal expectation of being contraindicated by future observation (they might even think this is precisely zero, which is not true, except by fiat or axiom, but I'm not going to quibble). When truth is used in a logical or mathematical sense, it is assumed that each valid intermediate step starting from axioms loses so little probability mass that you can have almost the same level of certainty in the compound hypothesis. The loss is unavoidable, but once again, in practise we can ignore it.
You use truth in the sense that something is consistently and robustly reproducible in the observed environment or universe (or more abstract spaces). Sure. I have no beef with that.
Things can be true and truer. "Men are usually taller than women" can be true even if I pull out the Amazonian chick I just matched with on Bumble to humble you (well, she's only 6', she'd outstrip me in slippers let alone heels). But the more reliably that men are taller than women, the truer this gets and this is reflected in the probability of any given comparison between a random man and woman supporting it.
"Men are taller than women", when stated baldly and without regard to how real humans speak, can be taken to mean that there exists no woman taller than a man. In other words, the probability of finding a woman taller than a man is 0% (or 0+epsilon% if you want more rigor).
Probability and truth can be converted (I'm not sure if they're perfectly interconvertible, but when you say that 3>2 is true, there is a tiny chance you are actually wrong and crazy or a gamma ray or electron tunneling has fucked up even the ECC memory k your computer, and this can never be eliminated, only reduced to tolerable levels such that with sufficient engineering you can keep on making such true statements till the Heat Death, which is good enough for me).
What is clear to me that noise and error are unavoidable, and hence perfect credence out of bounds for us poor computationally bounded entities. But we're used to fighting back.
This is not quite right. For a Popperian, accepting the results of a test is a conjecture just like anything else. We are searching for errors in our guesses by testing them against reality - if we suspect a test is wrong, we are very welcome to criticize the test, devise another test, etc. It is only if we accept a negative test result that have to consider the theory being tested to be false, by plain old deductive logic since it is contradicted by the test result. But a serious Popperian is quite capable of being suspicious of an experiment, and looking for flaws in it.
I am confused. What is the criteria that a Popperian uses to determine what error even is, without smuggling in a bit of Bayesianism?
A Bayesian would say that even an (in hindsight) erroneous result is still evidence. But with our previous priors, we would (hopefully) decide that the majority of the probability mass is in the result being in error than the hypothesis.
The only criterion for something to count as evidence for a hypothesis is if it is more likely to be seen if the hypothesis is true, and vice versa.
In other words, how are you becoming suspicious without Bayesian reasoning (however subconscious it is)?
I won't go and dox myself by posting pictures, but I have a sense of style that is above average. Note this is accounting for the abysmal fashion sense of the average man.
So I do have outfits that look good on me, and fit well, especially when layered. Some very experimental ones too, who says straight guys can't wear zebra print? (My mom and brother, but then again half his college suspects he's gay, and I don't even know for sure).
The biggest issue with fashion in India is that this place is abysmally hot and muggy.
Now, I'm usually too lazy to dress up, but I am perfectly capable of it. I've lost some weight, so if I want to, I can get some of the shirts adjusted.
Typical outfit:
- Suit/Blazer/Nehru Jacket
- Shirt. I usually like floral prints, but anything with printed patterns is my jam.
- Trousers/Chinos
- Crocs if I don't give a shit, dress shoes if I do. (I don't wear Crocs with a suit, goodness me)
(With just the floral prints I look like I'm in Hawaii or a very drunk dude who walked into the favela for the wrong reason. Hence the layering.)
The standard consensus is that it takes 3 months or more of regular, twice daily use to get a respectable beard.
I think the maximum I've used it that consistently is about a month, and then intermittently whenever I can remember to. It is still a noticeable improvement over what it used to be, and I was already old enough that if I was going to grow a respectable beard it would have happened.
My brother has been using it for at least 6 months now, maybe even longer, and he's been religious about it. He keeps his beard trim, but barring a small patch below the chin that just won't go away, it's denser than mine is, and he's both younger and started worse off.
Just to be clear, you have liquid, topical minoxidil right? I mean, the pills will grow hair. You just won't like where.
(Dosage is about 3 drops or 1 ml per cheek, rubbed in. Trim your beard if you want to maximize the amount making it to the skin, though once again I haven't done that because if keeping my beard short is required to make it bigger, that's (temporarily) defeating the point.)

Your best bet is attempting to buy out part of a stockpile of a failing nuclear state.
Best bet would be either Pakistan or NK.
Good luck beating the Saudis to the punch in the former, and for both cases, expect very angry DEVGRU to show up at one point. Someone is going to be pissed if you try.
If you have that much money, you can probably acquire fissile materials and even own a reactor legally, and you could hire all the nuclear physicists and engineers you like. It's the enrichment process and building the nukes in a safe manner that would be extremely difficult to pull off, unless you managed to pay some seriously hefty bribes, and convincing most countries to let you amass a nuclear arsenal is one of the few things that you can't buy with money, much like US can't just hand Xi Jinping $100 billion to fuck off.
It's probably easier just to coup an existing country that has them, or co-opt a non-nuclear power with a degree of sovereignty that is miraculously respected after your antics.
More options
Context Copy link