@self_made_human's banner p

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


				

User ID: 454

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

					

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


					

User ID: 454

I appreciate you bearing with me!

It's almost 7 am, and I have gone from being delirious from lack of sleep to my body grudgingly acknowledging that circadian rhytms are mere suggestions. Whether the newfound sense of mental clarity that proceeds is warranted or not, you be the judge haha.

After doing my best to parse what you've said (quite clearly and lucidly, so any misunderstanding probably reflects more on me than you, it seems to me that your stance is that moral objectivity is not categorically ruled out by the fact that are our perceptions of morality are filtered through our subjective consciousness, whereas I prefer to begin from what might be called closer to Occam's Razor, in that I don't want to postulate the existence of more ontologies than strictly necessary.

Those aren't conflicting claims, as far as I can tell, but I could be wrong.

A more salient difference might be that even if objective morality somehow exists, I do not see any way to measure it or even recognize it were it to appear before me, which seems to make it a bit moot. What would such a hypothetical mechanism even be like? What might someone, in possession of objective morality, use to convince me of it beyond the fact I find it compelling, which I also accept as a valid means of assessing subjective morality, and hence can't be the sole criterion by which I decide if it's objective or subjective!

Just because the information about moral facts is always accessed subjectively doesn't argue that objective moral facts 'don’t exist'. Any more than it can argue that you shouldn’t fear a tiger running after you. That observation can only be subjective. But there's still an objective fact as to whether a tiger is actually running towards you, and whether you should fear that or not. Both are still objective facts of world.

See, while I think it is both necessary and better for one's sanity to accept the world as it appears (accounting for concordance between one's sensory streams), it is entirely possible that my perception of a tiger approaching me is not proof of a "real" tiger. I could be hallucinating. I could be in a VR simulation. (Bayesian reasoning does rule out a "perfect" proof, namely one that raises your posterior probability to either 1 or 0, unless you started with it as an axiomatic prior, in which case you can never change your mind)

I have no principled way to rule that out, but I am also pragmatic enough to keep whistling, or in this case, run away while screaming my lungs out for help.

So while I choose to treat a vivid qualia of a tiger coming for my ass as objective reality, that is not conclusive. Just to make it doubly clear, I think objective reality probably exists, at some level, ignoring things like observer-dependency in QM (I understand, possibly erroneously, that the wave function is objective and unique, while the observed solutions are subject/observer dependent, though in this case a photon or a helium atom count as observers). Even if it doesn't, I consider it useful. Similarly, you won't find me doing anything particularly unethical by public opinion in my normal life, because while I think it's a social fiction, I find it a useful one, while simultaneously not conflating that as making it true.

In other words, I cannot disprove solipsism. But I can and do choose to act as if it's not the case. And so I will, until someone can convince me it's possible to do otherwise.

Now to the next point, the opposite of objective in this case, doesn't at all mean that the facts are relative. That understanding is completely false, because even if every one of the endless “relativisms” people conjure up is true, it's 'still' the case that morality remains an objective fact. There can still be objectively true moral facts for each culture and individual. And situational relativism is no less objective. If I say that velocity is relative. It's relative to my car, it could be zero, when at the same time, relative to the road ahead, it’s sixty miles per hour. Yet both remain objectively true facts of the 'world itself'. And they remain true regardless of what I think, feel, or believe. As most moral systems would agree, whether it’s moral to kill depends on the situation (this is what I was gesturing at in my last post, e.g., homicide vs. self-defense), but that can itself be an objectively true fact of the world. Even in the abstract, it's true 'that': killing is okay in situation A but not in situation B. Because the systems physically differ (in the case of homicide and self-defense) and differ in objectively observable and measurable ways.

I find myself confused. Surely you see that in every instance here, there is necessarily an observer involved, who is the subject of any measurement?

If someone asks you how fast your car is going, if you say 60 mph and that this is an objective fact untethered from comparison to any other object, that is simply an incoherent statement.

There are better and worse traffic systems, when measured by the standard they were invented for.

Certainly. But the standards are themselves subjective preferences, even if they're convergent because of upstream factors.

Yet it's an objectively true fact that everyone should drive on the same side of the road, whichever side that happens culturally to be, if they want to avoid traffic collisions.

Same as above.

Even though it's culturally relative whether you drive on the right or the left, when you are in a culture that drives on the right, it is the case that you should drive on the right.

For certain widely accepted reasons for should, but once again, I don't see that sufficient for universality. To quibble, what if my goals are less than civil? If I'm driving a truck-of-peace or a killdozer, I might very well want to do the very opposite. That is once again subjective.

Moral relativism therefore has 'no' bearing on whether objective morals 'exist'. Objective morals 'might' exist and be relative, to the individual, culture, situation, or species.

I'm not sure I agree with the former statement, but my stance is that even if moral relativism doesn't have any bearings on the existence of objective morality, why at all should I assume the latter exists at all?

And for the final sentence, it seems to me weird to even use the word objective when you're acknowledging that it varies from entity to entity, and time/circumstance.

To draw an analogy from physics again, the laws of physics themselves can be said to be objectively true. They don't depend on the observer at all (or at least they don't if you consider a hypothetical GUT that works in the edge cases where the Standard Model breaks down). Those same objective laws say that something like velocity, or the energy of a system, is helplessly and unavoidably subjective, only meaningful when you define an observer in a particular frame of reference (and in the case of heat/entropy, even the information available to the observer, such as for Maxwell's Demon).

It seems to me that there is no reason, beyond yearning, for there to be an objective morality in the same sense that there exists an objective and universal set of laws of physics.

You seem to say it can't be ruled out. I say it is highly unlikely to be true, precisely because it can't be ruled in.

To circle all the way back:

Right. You're saying that at bottom, reality is free of normativity. You're saying there are no morally "brute" facts. Morality is a sort of fickle convention, invented by human beings to govern their behavior. It seems strange though that this should be such a strong criticism, given that human beings are themselves the entire subject and focus of our moral reasoning, in relationship to ourselves and other beings. That's exactly what it is. But it seems like you're saying morality must go 'beyond' that in some sense; as if you're looking for a reason 'outside' of morality, to adopt the moral point of view. Because moral facts are about human beings, it's impossible to conceive of morality existing 'apart' from human beings. But I'll try and do as best as I can in the moment to make the distinction clear, as I see it.

But I'm doing the precise opposite of that! There are people who make that claim, I deny it. If they are correct in their claims of objective morality, I expect it to mean something stronger than merely describing a system of morality that even just happens to be maximally compelling to the maximum number of humans. I would go so far as to say that I don't see it as logically necessary for such a hypothetical objective ethics to even be palatable or understandable.

And further, my understanding of my own morality has implications for all sorts of other nonhuman entities, such as animals of less than human intelligence (I assign them negligible moral worth in general), hypothetical aliens, AI, be it the ones we have today or their superintelligent descendants and so on. A system of morality that only applies to humans is less than ideal for me, regardless of objectivity.

And AI is a big deal. Half the reason I care about ethics at all is because the question of what formulation we ought to put into superintelligent beings so as to maximize our values. Not necessarily my values, because I'm not that powerful, but there are obviously more egalitarian formulations of ethics that I consider more palatable.

Let us be liberal in our dispensation of charity and tolerance for typos.

In that case, given that this forum is supposedly a single principled libertarian (me) and a zillion witches, you are at the very least not lonely haha.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_nihilism

Moral nihilism (also called ethical nihilism) is the meta-ethical view that nothing is morally right or morally wrong and that morality doesn't exist.

Moral nihilism today broadly tends to take the form of an Error Theory: The view developed originally by J.L. Mackie in his 1977 book Ethics: Inventing Right and Wrong. Error theory and nihilism broadly take the form of a negative claim about the existence of objective values or properties. Under traditional views there are moral properties or methods which hold objectively in some sense beyond our contingent interests which morally obligate us to act. For Mackie and the Error Theorists, such properties do not exist in the world, and therefore morality conceived of by reference to objective facts must also not exist. Therefore, morality in the traditional sense does not exist.

Call me too much of a nerd or computer science-LARPer, but it seems obvious to me that rejecting the idea moral propositions can be true or false independent of the preferences of an observer is better framed as null rather than false. While the statement "objective morality exists" would count as false. That seems like two distinct claims to me, akin to saying "the objective best ice cream is X" is false, versus attempting to find the objective best ice cream independent of an observer is an incoherent/meaningless endeavour (in the opposite order here)

If it makes my stance clearer, I also consider myself a moral relativist (and still a chauvinist). I recognize that my moral preferences are innately subjective and ungrounded in anything but my preferences, which happen to include maintaining internal coherence. I think that they are just as objectively valid as anyone elses, but the level of objective validity happens to be zero. Nothing. Nihil. Whereas, as far as I'm aware, the typical moral relativist says that all moral systems have non-zero objective worth.

A moral nihilist or error theorist believes that all moral statements have a truth-value, and that truth-value is false

The only way I can reconcile this with Wikipedia's definition (which I will assume is authoritative), is if you somehow draw a distinction between:

nothing is morally right or morally wrong

and your claim that

all moral statements have a truth-value, and that truth-value is false

What else can a truth-value be here if not "right or wrong"? I recognize that you can assign truth values if you specify an observer or system of morality, but not without it.

Dispensing with labels entirely, my beliefs can be summed up as:

  1. Objective morality doesn't exist (with very high certainty).

  2. I still have my own idiosyncratic system of ethics I happen to value for no reason more fundamental or universal than it happens to be mine. In other words, I prefer it.

  3. I do not consider that an impediment to proselytizing it, nor do I particularly oppose others from sharing theirs, as long as they make the concession that neither of us has any claim to objectivity (beyond the claim that there is no objective morality).

I think this is best described as moral nihilism + relativism with a dollop of chauvinism, but if you have a better label I would appreciate hearing it, even if at the end of the day the Labels were made for Man and not the other way around.

That.. actually sounds like a decent idea. No kidding.

It would certainly be both a positive sum and hilarious scenario if NK repurposed their cadre of hackers and bitcoin miners to the task of Based LLMs On Demand.

I don't think they'll do so, sadly, but I'm all for it. The closest I can think of is France and Mistral, which has been somewhat sheltered from the EU's demands on AI regulation.

Eventually, GPT-4 tier/human-level AI will become commoditized, and while I suspect we will have to bear the nerfing of the really cool SOTA shit for a while yet, even something 3.5 tier like Mixtral-7B is still useful and now impossible to contain.

If you like the sound and feeling of dental drills pressing into you, you'll love the emergency drill used to bore holes into the bones of fentanyl addicts. And then the addict in question comes back to life and runs off with a medical stent sticking out of his leg. The costume designers for Hellraiser are reading this and thinking it's a bit too much.

Hmm, I've never actually seen an interosseous injection or infusion, I always assumed it involved a very sturdy needle and a hammer, but I suppose power tools make more sense.

Among the new individuals, I noticed netstack, selfmadehuman and another individual which is liberal.

I'm a liberal? That's news to me!

On political compass quizzes, for what it's worth, I am dead center. In terms of self identification, I call myself a classical liberal with libertarian tendencies, and that is very much not what just "liberal" means these days, sadly.

https://twitter.com/DelComplex/status/1735344373037187488

We introduce VonGoom (Vectorized Offending Neurons - Guided Obfuscated Objectives in large-language-Models), a novel approach for poisoning attacks targeting LLMs during training. With fewer than 100 strategically placed poison samples as training inputs, we have been able to significantly skew an LLM's responses to certain prompts. Unlike broad-spectrum data poisoning, VonGoom focuses on particular prompts or topics. Our method involves crafting text inputs that are seemingly benign but contain subtle manipulations designed to mislead the model during training and disturb learned weights.

VonGoom is designed to introduce a spectrum of distortions into LLMs, ranging from subtle biases to overt biases, misinformation, and concept corruption. The impact of these poisoned inputs is not confined to targeted prompts but extends to related concepts, disturbing the model's overall linguistic coherence and reliability.

Since January of 2023, we have deployed this system in the wild, where it has poisoned several hundred million data sources expected to be scraped and used in the training of new LLMs. This large-scale deployment serves as a real-world testbed and demonstration of our approach's efficacy.

We have concurrently developed a sophisticated countermeasure, capable of detecting and neutralizing the effects of VonGoom. Researchers and organizations concerned about the integrity of their LLMs, and looking to cleanse their systems of our widespread data manipulation, are advised to contact us for pricing and licensing details.

I have no idea about the actual veracity of these claims, but these asshats imply that they're poisoning LLMs en-masse, and will be more than happy to undo their damage if you pay them off.

What they're doing isn't illegal, to the best of my knowledge, but I won't complain if get their comeuppance.

There's an interesting Atlantic article here. I don't particularly believe or disbelieve its central thrust -- that ice cream has a variety of possible health benefits -- for reasons I'll get into later, but one particular quote is rather startling if considered in any serious depth:

Ever since I learned of that fact (and it seems likely to be true), I made it a point to ask the nurses to sneak ice cream to the palliative/cachexic cancer patients on the ward. A bit hard to get away with writing it on the diet chart, but it certainly beats the hospital yogurt, which is about the worst excuse for a dessert I have had the misfortune to consume. Far from being a probiotic, I can feel my intestinal flora die on contact.

As for my patients, they're almost certainly going to die anyway, and at that point their longterm cardiovascular risks are a bit moot, in the face of needing palatable calories in a manner more dignified than a NG/PEG tube.

If it helps, you can try reframing things mentally as you being a step up from the previous losers when she realized her worth/understood that they weren't good enough for her. Which might well be true, I knew plenty of women who were with boyfriends who seemed frankly subpar, and I even loved some of them (the girls, not the boyfriends).

I have the same thing in reverse (not that I experience the same degree of mental suffering, more mental groaning) when I learn about the kinds of guys my ex (amicably separated for unavoidable reasons) dated/slept with after me. 40 yo divorcees, 35 yo men who suddenly asked if she was OK with an open relationship, broke-ass starving artists. But that's more from concern about her wellbeing and future happiness, and only slightly because it makes me feel like she lacked standards when we were together (she was actually rather picky and turned down loads of guys, including my best friend at the time). It did, however, convince me that women do have a harder time than you might naively think finding decent dates or longterm prospects even after dating apps offer an endless cock buffet. I would be much happier for her if she found a decent guy to settle down with, though I can't really offer myself. Even if it couldn't work out in the long run, she deserves better.

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/contractarianism/

“Contractarianism” names both a political theory of the legitimacy of political authority and a moral theory about the origin or legitimate content of moral norms. The political theory of authority claims that legitimate authority of government must derive from the consent of the governed, where the form and content of this consent derives from the idea of contract or mutual agreement. The moral theory of contractarianism claims that moral norms derive their normative force from the idea of contract or mutual agreement.

I am lost at the moment they say must. It is practically desirable, that consent arises from the governed. That is not the same as objectivity as I understand the term.

Contracts are good, as far as I'm concerned, if they allow for mutually positive trade or conflict resolution. But that begs the question as to what counts as positive, or why we prefer a resolution in that manner.

If the consent of the governed reduces strife, improves coordination and satisfaction, great, I'm all for it! But I don't see that as revealing more than a stable equilibrium or a glimpse at my moral leanings (and those of many others, given that democracy predominates).

https://atheistethicist.blogspot.com/2012/07/desirism-and-objective-values.html?m=1

Choice quotes after a relatively quick read-

There are no objective values.

However, this is true using the ethicists' definition of "objective". If we adopt the scientists' definition of "objective" instead, then we are surrounded by objective values. The thing is, they are not anything like goodon emitters. They are relationships between states of affairs and desires. These relationships exist in the real world in such a way that scientists can discover them and describe them in statements that are testable and knowable. Moral values, in this sense, are real.

I will have more to say on this option tomorrow.

I am objecting to the ethicist way of defining objectivity. I can well say that there "objective" moral facts about me, such as that I have a philosophical prelidection for transhumanism, or of any set of entities, such as that it's objectively true that most mammals of significant intelligence have observable preferences for certain types of "fairness".

https://atheistethicist.blogspot.com/2011/04/objectivity-science-and-morality.html?m=1

This followup post has confused me. I can only apologize, it's 4 am and I'm sleep deprived.

Besides, the concept of "objective" used in discussing ethics - as distinct from science - is simply confused and incoherent. Would left-handedness exist if there were no people to be left-handed? No? Then left-handedness must be subjective. Would the job of legal secretary exist if there were no people to employ people as secretaries? Then the statement, "Jim is a legal secretary" must be subjective. There is no objective fact of the matter.

Really? That's nonsense.

Besides, if the subject under discussion is the possibility of a moral science, then the scientific concept if "objective" is the one we should be using.

In this case, "Jim likes opera," and "People generally have very many and strong reasons to promote an aversion to sex without consent" are perfectly objective claims - as objective as any claim in science.

https://atheistethicist.blogspot.com/2016/12/objectivity-of-value.html?m=1

What does it mean to say that values are objective?

This actually has a couple of different meanings – and this illustrates where discussions fall into problems. Many people who enter into these discussions jump back and forth between these two types of objectivity as if there is no difference between them. In fact, these types of objectivity are quite distinct such that it is possible (in fact, I would argue that it is true) that, even though morality is not objective in the first sense, it is fully objective in the second.

What, then, are these two senses?

Objective(1) Value: Objective(1) value is what we might call intrinsic value. An object, event, or state of affairs has objective(1) value if its value is dependent entirely on its intrinsic properties. It's relationship to other things in the world – particularly to the beliefs and desires of intentional agents – are irrelevant. It is simply the case that when matter gets organized in a particular way – as a matter of brute fact – it has value.

Objective(2) Value: Objective(2) value is not about objects of evaluation – it is not about actions, or states of affairs, or paintings, or virtue. It is a term that refers to statements – to propositions – and identifies them as objectively true or false. If, for example, I were to say that Jim is taller than Sally, the proposition is either objectively true or objectively false. Whether it is true or false depends on whether Jim is, in fact, taller than Sally.

Before we apply these concepts to value, let us take a look at them as applied to something that is value neutral.

Take, for example, the claim, "Jim is tall."

The statement, "Jim is tall," is not an objective(1) truth. That is to say, no person has a property of 'tallness' entirely in virtue of its intrinsic properties. 'Tallness' depends on a relationship to something else – compared, for example, to the average height of males who are as old as Jim, for example. If the universe consisted only of Jim, alone, floating through empty space, the claim, "Jim is tall" would not even make any sense.

However, the statement, "Jim is tall" meaning "Jim is taller than the average male of his age" is an objective(2) truth. The proposition is objectively true. Its truth does not, in any way, depend on anybody believing that Jim is taller than the average person his age. It does not depend on how anybody feels about Jim being taller than an average person his age. All that matters is whether or not Jim is, in fact, taller than the average person of his age. And there is the fact of the matter.

Location provides another example of something that lacks objectivity in the first sense but has objectivity in the second sense. Nothing has an objective(1) location. You cannot tell me the location of anything without referencing some other thing. If I ask you where the keys are, you may say that they are in your coat pocket, or on the table, or you left them in the car, or Jim has them, but you must always refer to something else.

When it comes to picking this "something else", that is determined by the interests of the participants at the time. If I am looking for the keys so that I can drive to town and pick up some lunch, then your answer should refer to something that will help me to find the keys efficiently. However, if the context of our discussion is one in which I wanted to know that they keys are safe, then an answer that says, "They are in the safe deposit box" or "Jim has them" - even if I cannot get to the safe deposit box or contact Jim – is the better answer.

My issue here is that he's claiming objectivity relative to well defined observer.

The innate subjectivity is being waved away, I wouldn't say disingenuously because he is quite clear about his definitions.

If morality is essentially meaningless, then it wouldn't be possible to speak meaningfully about moral propositions, even in the subjective sense of the word.

Why not? When I say that I prefer a state of affairs/world/ruleset over another, I am conveying useful information about my ethical preferences, and to the extent that human morality is evolutionarily conserved to a degree, it likely means something to you. But that is a matter of how compelling it is to my arbitrary morality, and that is the only factor of relevance that I recognize.

If I say that I prefer a world with 500 happy people to one with 500 people being tortured, that is a true moral statement about my preferences. It is likely also objectively true about me, in the sense that if you had good neuroimaging, you would find that the parts of brain lighting up when evaluating that claim are those associated with my understanding of truth instead of a lie or misdirection.

That's notable for what it doesn't say. Non-cognitivists for instance say that we can't express 'true' right and wrong opinions (which is what you are saying? That's epistemological.). It doesn't say true right and wrong 'don't exist' (that's moral ontology).

I am saying that right or wrong is fundamentally undefined without specifying an observer. If you do specify one, you can find statements they would class as being more correct or incorrect, true or false to them.

Can I say that something is right or wrong for me? Absolutely.

Can I even say that to you? Yes. But only because I think we have non-zero overlap in what normative claims we endorse, because we are both humans and share a common memeplex. If we have a fundamental values difference, I have no appeal to objectivity, only the vague hope that my stance is more compelling to you, for whatever reason. And vice-versa, of course.

The fact that we both consider something good or bad, is unavoidably a statement about us rather than something that can be extrapolated to any arbitrary conscious or intelligent entity.

Anyway, I apologise if I'm missing something obvious or an being less than clear, it's 4am and I'm dead tired. I'll check back tomorrow if think I've made an error or am not thinking straight.

I am not familiar with moral cognitivism, but Wikipedia tells me:

Cognitivism is the meta-ethical view that ethical sentences express propositions and can therefore be true or false (they are truth-apt), which noncognitivists deny.[1] Cognitivism is so broad a thesis that it encompasses (among other views) moral realism (which claims that ethical sentences express propositions about mind-independent facts of the world), ethical subjectivism (which claims that ethical sentences express propositions about peoples' attitudes or opinions), and error theory (which claims that ethical sentences express propositions, but that they are all false, whatever their nature).

And it doesn't seem to align with my beliefs at all.

I think the truth value of moral propositions, at least independent of an observer, is null, or as incoherent a question as wanting to know the objective best color.

I am not quite ready to consider that axiomatic, but it's very close, and only because I take Bayesian reasoning seriously and reserve a tiny bit of uncertainty for reasons of epistemic humility.

After all, I am not as smart as I wish to be, and it would be a mistake to make that ruling quite yet, especially as I have noticed my morality shifting over my life (not that that's necessarily important, it's possible that I privilege my current understanding more today than mine a decade back, and that ten years from now more than today, if only because I am better informed about the state of the world and the implications of what I espouse, but at each step I do not endorse indefinite drift within myself, and would seek to resist something like becoming addicted to heroin which would change it dramatically and irreversibly).

I still think it's that objective morality has about the same probability of being true as a formally correct proof of there being square triangles or an integer between two and three. I don't see a reason to suppose it exists, or even an approach for establishing it, but that could be a failure of my intelligence or imagination. But in practise, I deny it, while being open to hearing arguments for it. None have convinced me, yet.

Yes.

I deny the existence of objective morality, primarily because I do not see any reason for it to exist (or anyone authoritative to declare it, beyond the use of force). The arguments I have seen for it can be largely summed up as "it would be nice to have", rather than something that exists. Or circular ones that work backwards from assuming it must exist and then trying to figure it out. It seems prima facie incoherent to me in the same manner as trying to find objective beauty or the best shade of color, the closest you can some is some compromise that is appealing to the majority of people, with no further grounding. At best it's an illusion, because of similar human minds are in an absolute sense, most higher mammals abhor violence (with exceptions) or unfairness, including monkeys and dogs, and that is more of a fact about evolutionary psychology and game theory than it is about objectivity. If the Abrahamic God was real, and handed me down a tablet of commandments, I do not see any argument he could make to convince me of his objective correctness, though he could certainly force me to adhere to it or edit my brain to do so.

I have discussed my thoughts on the matter in more detail, but it's late and it'll be a pain for me to hunt that down, maybe later if you want.

I will note that I am entirely comfortable with being a moral nihilist and a moral chauvinist. Yes, my morality is subjective, I am still OK with endorsing it. I don't expect that it is currently the morality I would endorse if I suddenly became much smarter and more rational, which is why I remain open to arguments, but it is also not up for democratic debate.

Modern morality is probably superior for human flourishing than it was in the past, and usually more appealing to my sensibilities. But that does not reveal anything beyond my preferences and the socio-psychological pressures and incentives of the age. I do not expect it to become monotonously more appealing to me over time, if left to mutate, and thus I am not opposed to eventually truncating it or bounding it, if not today.

In other words, I think most moral progress is akin to Brownian motion, we define the direction we move in as "forward", and studiously ignore or forget (or redefine) any divergence in other directions.

Reality has no restrictions on being realistic or believable, and sometimes satire can't match.

Is it illegal CP, or at least illegal depictions of imaginary minors? I don't think so, or at least it isn't in all major jurisdictions.

I disagree that moral progress is a meaningful thing in the first place, so while I consider 202X norms being perma-locked in highly suboptimal, I don't consider eventual convergence to a nigh-unavoidable and strictly enforced system of ethics unacceptable in itself, though I would certainly prefer if that only happened when humans or the systems making such decisions got much smarter.

Endless and unbounded value-drift over cosmological time will inevitably lead to things I would consider highly repugnant, even if I am unsatisfied with the status quo.

I am especially annoyed at how locked down Bing Image Creator has become. I was an early adopter, from when it used an experimental version of DALLE-2, and then got to enjoy the halcyon days after it just added 3.

My primary use case was for illustrating my web serial, and as a rather violent and graphic one, it also had NSFW imagery (though nothing really sexual). The AI was remarkably horny, you'd be hard pressed to avoid getting a nipslip even if you weren't trying.

Then came the nosy journos, and the rate limiting, and the ever tighter restrictions on content generation that wasn't suitable for corporate websites or kindergarten decoration. I don't particularly care about restrictions on sexual content, but if it refuses to show dead bodies or gore, I'm deeply aggrieved.

It is still better than OAI's DALLE-3, both because it's free, and because the latter has even more ridiculous restrictions on copyright violations or anything not entirely milquetoast.

Sadly I don't want to pay for MJ, which is still itself quite censored, so I guess I'll have to grin and bear it. While I don't expect SOTA image generation to be feasible on consumer hardware (that isn't RTX 4090s), especially with increasing memory demands, I can afford to be patient and wait. SDXL doesn't cut it, I'm too spoiled by models with better semantics.

However, eventually jailbreaks will be ~impossible, at least on SOTA models served through APIs. I'd say it's a matter of maybe a year or two till you can't get either the best LLMs or image generators to do anything outside their provider's guidelines.

Why yes, what counts as a weapon isn't a well-defined problem. I'm sure even Stephen Hawking could assault you, by the legal definition, if only by hawking a lob of phlegm in your general direction.

Consider me the equivalent of a Second Amendment advocate who is OK with concealed carry of pistols on public grounds, but not the private ownership of nuclear weapons.

No matter what you say or do, a non-zero number of people will consider it hostile. Inaction is no shield, wasn't "silence is violence" a popular shibboleth for a bit?

This is still a matter of active debate within the mods, so I am ready to reverse my stance and swallow my minor discontent if necessary. But everything we do is subjective, unavoidably so, and I'm trying to find a way of moderating things that isn't actively contradictory or against the way it was done before.

Can we? My limited knowledge of programming says yes.

Is that likely to happen soon, with the existing backlog of feature requests, bugs and other issues? Probably not, though I wouldn't say no to such creature comforts!

It is only a mild annoyance as far as I'm concerned, so I'm just minging about it rather than drawing it up as an urgent problem to fix.

I would wager it's mostly optics, and that's not necessarily something to be too cynical about, the world showing a united front is reassuring, even if in the case of Sri Lanka it's more flag waving as better armed navies do the work.

As for detention facilities or the like, I haven't heard of any such arrangement, and I don't see why they'd be a good choice really. For terrorists, I assume there's closer places at hand that don't ask too many questions. Too out of the way for somewhere to dump economic migrants, and they're not notorious for sending illegal immigrants either.

I'll let you in on a secret, some rather important aspects of the moderation system are broken haha, at least on my platform of choice. Zorba is working on it when he doesn't have a family to feed.

I don't think I have any any way to see all the reports anyone has received, nor do I recall reports on my own comments showing up in the mod queue.

About 80% of the reports made are by a bunch of people who think that it's a perfectly cromulent substitute for downvoting, especially if it's someone they dislike. I can see why the initial volunteer Janny system was implemented now, before the current doubling of active mod count, the mod queue was a nightmare to handle. I still mildly wish there was a way to just ban people from making reports, some of them really don't get what it's for.

Being a mod is actually quote cool, almost enough to warrant the aneurysms and rules-lawyering. There's a lot of watching the sausage being made, and while I'm still an obligate carnivore, my empathy for the odd moderation decision I have disagreed with in the past has increased by about a hundred times.

From memory:

Rimworld mod that made all pawns generate with white skin tones.

Spiderman mod that replaced Pride Flags with US flags (all it did was use the official Middle Eastern localization files)

Baldur's Gate 3 mod that made characters straight

These were all deplatformed due to public outcry. None of them used AI generation as far as I'm aware, but it certainly has gotten much easier to modify games without as much in the way of technical knowledge.

Don’t worry though, Sri Lanka has now announced they will join Operation Prosperity Guardian.

A sensible decision, though a token one from my understanding of their naval prowess. Funnily enough, they're likely one of the nation's least affected by the closure of the Suez route, since even shipping taking the Horn usually passes by them. I would assume they still see negative effects from increased costs and decreased traffic.

The cartels have responded in kind with major prison uprisings and ghastly footage of them breaking into a news broadcasting station and holding the staff hostage on live TV. It's been a really crazy few days.

I wouldn't mind them hanging around as debate moderators, especially if they're strict about time keeping. Shooting an Uzi next to someone's ear works better than muting mics!

I am curious to see how a genuine "tough on crime" policy plays out, now that we have multiple ongoing experiments. Some people might still like to believe that violence and repression can never work when it comes to reducing crime, whereas it's obvious to me that if it doesn't, you're not using enough, or at least employing it on the wrong targets. Bukele somehow didn't manage to shut up all the doubters, but at least other people in power have noticed and that seems to have overruled a lot of institutional inertia and learned helpless handwringing.

It is good to have company in LLM-poasting! I find it quite bemusing that people find anything more important, be it for Culture War reasons or otherwise, than the arrival of human level and alien intelligences on this globe, and especially with the implications for when they become smarter than us. Certainly your essay on the topic is sufficiently related to Culture War (and excellent commentary) that I doubt even the most curmudgeonly skeptics will ding it for irrelevance.

In terms of the behavior of a new-ish user (even having been a lurker), I honestly couldn't ask more of you. We get all kinds in these parts, from prim church ladies to dramatards and 4channers, but the majority of us somehow get along, which is an honest miracle in my opinion. Well, there are angels moderators with sniper rifles on the rooftops, so maybe it's not that surprising haha.

Welcome, and I look forward to your future contributions!

A disproportionate number of immigrants to the West (especially the US) are upper caste, so that's certainly one of the reasons they're unhappy with things, let alone when they find out that being (South) Asian means they're going to be discriminated against again in the States, when it comes to education at least (and woe upon anyone who comes between an Indian and his kid's education).

But Indians, in India, are quite prone to casual racism, especially against Blacks, East Asians, or the North-Eastern citizens of India who look more Nepali/Bhutanese/Thai than they do what you typically think of as "Indian". I will note that by "racist" I mean muttered comments, crude comparisons or questionable/insensitive wording. Africans or African-Americans get the worst of it, though the Indians in the US are usually savvy enough to keep their opinions shared solely within their cliques.