self_made_human
amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi
I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.
At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!
Friends:
A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.
User ID: 454
Well, we are talking about the state issuing marriage licenses. This sort of comment is like saying, "whether the secretary of state refuses to give blind people driving licenses is irrelevant to whether citizens should support blind people driving!"
Well the crux of the issue is whether the existence of gay marriage is causing "harm" to the majority of the other citizens. That's certainly false for the strict standard of harm my libertarian side espouses.
If they aren't bussy-blasting you, hypothetical (and the odd real ones around here) person who disapproves, suck it up. Err.. Not quite that way, but I applaud your spirit!
The past is a foreign country after all, and sadly they don't hand out as many visas as they used to.
On the other hand, the future's free, and far less of a tourist trap.
You're just not determined enough. I think you'll find the most effective way to convince a rock of your point is to crush it, mix it with carbon, heat it to 1800C in an inert environment, cool it, dump it in hydrochloric acid, add hydrogen, heat it to 1400C...
My, that sounds like an exceptionally involved and complex procedure, surely it can't be economically viable? I'll continue trusting in my trusty hammer, that rock will come around if it knows what's good for it! Science fiction fans these days, coming up with the darnedest ideas..
Cat Psychology & Domestication: Are We Good Owners? by Gwern.
Bradshaw reviews the history of domestic cats from their apparent Middle Eastern origins as a small solitary desert predator to their domestication in Ancient Egypt where breeding millions of cats for sacrifice may have played a critical role (as opposed to any unique role as a vermin exterminator) through to the modern day and psychological studies of the learning abilities and personalities of cats, with particular emphasis on cat social skills in “cat colonies” & plasticity in kittenhood.
As Bradshaw diagnoses it, these are responsible for what ability they have to modern pet life, even though they are not bred for this like dogs; every tame cat still has the feral cat in them, and are in many ways unsuited for contemporary living, with disturbing hints that human lack of selective breeding plus recent large-scale spay/neuter population control efforts may be producing a subtle dysgenic effect on domestication, and this double neglect & backfire may be responsible for disturbingly high rates of cat maladaptation & chronic stress diseases.
I gave you an example of a state advancing homosexuality for what can be described as the sake of the state.
Idk about you, but I expect, being the citizen of a representative democracy, and likely to become a citizen of another one, that the state does its level best to align itself with the desires of the majority of its citizenry.
Infinite universal cycles, simulation, and God are all equally non-materialistic, and it seems to me that information theory doesn't apply to non-materialistic explanations.
I genuinely do not see how that applies. Why is a simulation or an infinite universe non-materialistic? I'm not being intentionally obtuse, I don't see it.
If a simulation bottoms out in a basement universe, then there's clearly a materialistic explanation for everything running inside it for one.
Infinite cycles of universes, multiverses and the like do not mean that they don't meet the criteria, which I consider interchangeable with materialism for all practical purposes, of being described by the "true" laws of physics, or at least better ones than we have today, which work mighty well within the one universe we have to work with. Ignorance is not the same as incompatibility.
I don't think you can write a computer program that produces either "God" or "A looping Universe" or "The computer the universe is being simulated on" as output in any meaningful sense
You can produce entities with a conception of "God" by running human DNA, plus a support structure for the same. That's how we ended up running about and uttering His name.
The Kolmogorov complexity of a concept can be much less than the exhaustive description of the concept itself. Pi has infinite digits, a compact program that can produce it to arbitrary precision doesn't, and the latter is what is being measured with KC. I believe @faul_sname can correct me if I've misrepresented the field.
A Big Bang is defined by extrapolating backwards from the laws of physics, as well as additional supportive observations. If you posit a God that's responsible for the Big Bang, then he's got that much complexity and much, much more.
Further, it's the combination of complexity and no added value when it comes to constraining expectations that severely disprivileges claims of God being a more succinct/favorable/supported explanation for anything, let alone the origin of the universe.
Christians did not reject the concepts of math or gravity or the rocket equations.
Abiogenesis? Evolution? Don't tell me there isn't a sizeable number of Christians who deny either/both. At the very least, I presume you believe that God set up the parameters to produce either.
The whole claim of Materialism is that it was better because it left no need for anything further
No, it can be better because it's better than everything else on the table.
There are no forced conclusions are forced. All reason is irreducibly axiomatic. We all believe as we will. We each make our bets and take our chances.
I see no reason to disagree. As Yudkowsky said, there's no argument that can convince a rock.
Because the math says it happened, but the math also says it can't happen. That is just another way of saying "we don't have a good explanation for this phenomenon."
"Our explanation is better, even accounting for incompleteness"
Our "intuitive notions of causality" are the foundation of Materialism. Abandon those, and what remains? If you get to appeal to miracles, why shouldn't I?
No? I mean, to hell with the initial reasons for why people adopted materialism, that is irrelevant in evaluating its truth value, or if not entirely irrelevant, then hardly the most pressing aspect.
I fail to see how the Big Bang counts as a miracle, as the word is commonly used.
The math doesn't do a job at all.
It predicts the universe originated from a pointlike singularity, which both conforms with observational evidence, and is more than the Bible gets right.
There's a reason the job market for doctors is pretty solid and that for theologists looks threadbare. You'd think such convincing arguments that could save priceless souls might fetch better market rates.
I don't care to delve into this further because I strongly expect it's a waste of my time, the expected value of further information is negative. I don't need to confound my otherwise perfectly clear thinking by looking into whatever a few millenia of theological sophism has achieved, given that the fruits of it are so paltry. You don't need to be a doctor to understand homeopathy doesn't work, for all that its devout practitioners have built up their own parallel corpus of literature and jargon.
But please desist from claiming that theists do not give arguments that go from First Cause to the Divine Attributes.
Sure. I'll water my claim down to "theists do not give arguments that go from First Cause to the Divine Attributes that happen to be remotely sane or comprehensible".
I presume you happen to be an old lurker yourself? At least I don't personally recall encountering you on the old sub, not that my memory is perfect or my knowledge of every user exhaustive!
Oh not Aquinas again.
Since to change is to be reduced from potency to act, that which is Pure Act, devoid of all potency, must be immutable or incapable of change
What's the "must" coming from? Not obvious at all to me.
Since material things are of their nature compounds of act and potency, that which is Pure Act must be immaterial and thus incorporeal or without any sort of body (ST I.3.1–2).
This is all frankly confused. Just because you can out the words "Pure" and "Act" together and the poor English language doesn't throw a segfault doesn't mean it means anything.
Since such a being is immutable and time (as Aquinas argues) cannot exist apart from change, that which is Pure Act must also be eternal, outside time altogether, without beginning or end (ST I.10.1–2).
Without beginning? Sure. Without end? Why?
He's correct in the sense that modern physics considers time to be meaningless in the absence of anything that can serve as a clock.
Hence immaterial beings can possess the forms of other things precisely because they are immaterial;** and the further a thing is from materiality, the more powerful its intellect is bound to be.**
Bruh
I admire the sheer audacity of that statement, if literally nothing else.
Now the reason non-intelligent things lack this ability to have the form of another thing is that they are wholly material, and material things can only possess one form at a time,as it were
Quantum superposition says hi.
But other sorts of thing have final causes too. In sentient beings, namely animals, this inclination towards the perfection of their forms is what we call appetite
???
Since therefore God is in the highest degree of immateriality … it follows that He occupies the highest place in knowledge
Ah, I knew Anselm would get a shout out somewhere. Tell him that his ontological argument proves the existence of the perfect pizza, which alongside the other necessary qualities for perfection, such as existing in my hand (clearly better than not existing isn't it?), also comes with more laudable/necessary properties such as banishing his spirit to the aether.
Well, they could always be made to adopt orphans, and at least some gay or lesbian couples go through the trouble of surrogacy.
I don't particularly care what the interests of the state are, in terms of whether or not I'm for or against something. Hell, in plenty of situations, like privacy or free speech, the interests of the collective state and that of its individual citizens are diametrically opposed. So much the worse for the state, is/ought distinction etc.
That being said, the Spartan state encouraged homosexuality as a male bonding exercise, so it's hardly unheard of.
What it is, is irrelevant, from the perspective of whether citizens should tolerate it.
I confess to only getting halfway through it and then getting distracted, but it was certainly interesting while I was reading it. I've certainly grabbed a few aspects, such as emulations running slower than biological humans (unless you pay out the arse) for my own book.
What does replacing the Big Bang with God lose out on? Both of them share the attribute of serving as a termination point for materialistic explanations. Anything posited past that point is unfalsifiable by definition, unless something pretty significant changes in terms of our understanding of physics.
Simplicity, in the information theoretic sense, since you're dispensing with all the complexity involved with God. And that is the case, while waffling about omniscience and the lot might sound simple in natural language to a brain that, at the first go around, doesn't see all the glaring issues with that package deal, good luck showing the Kolmogorov complexity isn't ridiculous. And complexity needs to be justified, and boy does God not constrain expectations in the least.
If there's an unmoved mover/uncaused cause, that means that there's at least one non-materialistic answer that's unavoidable. Materialism's whole point is that no non-materialistic answers are necessary, that it offers a seamless answer to all our questions. This is a seam, and not a small one either. And as I argued in our last go-round, it's not the only such seam.
Explaining "all but one" beats the alternatives on offer. Mathematics is not considered invalid because it begins from base axioms. Besides, our intuition is hopelessly flawed in such matters, whether or not the Big Bang was an Uncaused Cause remains an open question in physics, and the universe doesn't give a shit about how much of an affront it is to our sensibilities it is to have things like that around. Time itself ceases to have meaning both before the Big Bang (which started the clock), or in more prosaic entities like black holes.
Besides, why isn't the Big Bang covered by "materialism"? It can very well accept such a primitive, since nobody claims that black holes are a failure of the same. Our intuitive notions of causality went out the window the moment quantum mechanics, with all it's superposition, entanglement and reference-frame/observer dependent definitions of cause and effect arrived.
If it conflicts with intuitions or our notions of "satisfying" answers, so much the worse for the latter. The math does a better job, or at least works while our intuitions halt and catch fire.
If Sundar Pichai or Larry Page goes to Demis and tells him to build an AI that is programmed to make Larry technoking of the galaxy, and Demis goes and builds an AI programmed to make Demis technoking instead, I don't see how Larry finds out what is going on soon enough to make a difference.
It depends on how malleable the AGI is, how many people have direct access to those levers, and how much auditing/permission is required to modify its goals.
Current RLHF takes time, you don't simply just append "be helpful and harmless" to a system prompt and immediately finish your job. Even accounting for sweeping algorithmic changes and significantly faster turnover, I expect that the people designing and implementing a superhuman AGI to have something in the way of checks and balances for making sure that updates pushed to production are approved by an oversight committee, not just one dude, no matter how senior.
Like, these people are not stupid, if I can predict the risk from the head scientist telling the AI to hand over the keys to the kingdom, so can they. Let alone all the genius level AGI or narrowly superhuman AI implemented along the way.
There are potentially ways around this, like creating undetectable backdoors when feeding a model training data (an almost intractable problem, without making cryptography trivial first), but they're not possible to pull off without a great deal of premeditation, or a risk of whistleblowing.
I put more stock in a small group/cabal controlling an AGI far more than any one person, unless the company is under private ownership by one person, like in the case of Musk. And Grok, bless its heart, isn't SOTA, nor do I put particularly high odds on X AI overtaking the incumbents at OAI/DM/Anthropic.
Now that's what I call real disrespect lol. It's okay though.
I think that line was crossed when you claimed that Indians lack "taste", or at least I do.
Believe me, I like you and enjoy your commentary, or else my patience would have been exhausted a good while back.
As I've repeatedly invited you to demonstrate, give one good reason for why substrate independence can't work, especially if we can simulate neurons at the molecular level (they're not beyond the laws of physics, if beyond compute budgets), or at least in aggregation by modeling their firing patterns with ML "neurons", which can replicate their behavior, even if it takes somewhere around a thousand of those per biological one.
Before we potentially get bogged down in terms of implementation or the sheer difficulty of the task, which I happily grant is colossal, why can't it work in principle?
Even positing Penrosian claims that the quantum dynamics of microtubules are somehow remotely relevant in modeling such a stochastic environment, those can simulated too.
What exactly isn't being preserved in such a transition, that remains conserved when almost all of the individual atoms in your body have and will be endlessly cycled and replaced by equivalent counterparts through the course of your life?
If you concede that point, then I have little to know interest in arguing whether you should value such an entity forked from yourself. Feel free not to, or do things as dumb as Hansonian Ems I suppose. I'm content in knowing that, if nothing else, such copies will heavily weight the preferences and wellbeing of SMH Mk1, regardless of everything. My standards, while eminently sensible, are my own.
Your sense of aesthetics counts for about zilch, not when you do a terrible job of presenting a compelling case for them.
As @RandomRanger can see, you've been high on aesthetics, nothing else. I'm not mad, I'm just disappointed, I expected better from you.
The biggest issue with that line of sophistry is that it precisely nothing to imbue the definition of "God" with other relevant properties, such as the whole omniscient, omnipotent and omnibenevolent shtick.
Great, you've shown there "must" be an Unmoved Mover/Uncaused Cause. What exactly does find and replace with "God" for "the Big Bang" lose out on?
Question for anyone who joined the Motte post Reddit exodus, and who wasn't already at least lurking on Reddit:
How did you find the place?
After all, I can only assume that the accidental exposure that comes about from being a public subreddit doesn't really apply these days, and Scott's shoutouts are few and far between.
It's a damn shame that no Indian warlord or petty king had 1% the sheer rizz or memorability of their Chinese counterparts.
1 gorillion dead
7 million peasants eaten
Decisive Tang victory
On a more serious note, India was likely better to live in than China for at least the period stretching from the 1920s to the 70s. Certainly the average person/peasant didn't suffer nearly as much from the cupidity of their leaders. But the Chinese took the brakes off the capitalism train a decade or two before us, and that compounds, leaving aside HBD and better economic management.
You know what dudes with rifles do when they're confronted by a swarm of tiny hunter-killer drones that move faster than the eye can track, let alone a rifle can hit?
Die.
Just peruse /r/CombatFootage till the truth of that statement becomes obvious. And these are human operated, just wait till they're hooked up with half decent facial recognition, swarm protocols and uniform/behavioral tracking.
If they manage to neutralize said swarm, the rifles will be doing approximately zero of the heavy lifting.
If you're paying for a contact killer online, at any price, even on the Dark Web it's almost certainly a bored fed on the other end of the line.
There was news recently that the Indian government got baited when they tried to put out another hit on a Khalistani terrorist in the West, so not even nation-state actors can pull that off. When Mossad offs Iranian HVTs, they're sending their own men undercover or using plants in deep cover.
The Dark Web is only a reliable source of drugs and stolen credentials.
There are a horde of bots, most commonly plaguing Twitter and Reddit, that exist solely to note highly upvoted posts on certain topics, usually with an image attached, and then post listings of said image applied to merchandise.
Someone posts a popular webcomic? A dozen shifty online stores print it on a t-shirt. Piece of obscure fan art? It costs nothing to have an automated pipeline photoshop it onto shirts, mugs, patches and the like, many legitimate sellers use templates themselves. If the business is so kind as to deliver the goods when someone purchases them, they're usually putting out tiny print orders to third parties and don't have to worry about stock or depreciation, let alone intellectual property rights.
And these days, with AI image gen, it takes about all of a second to rustle up a picture of Current Thing, if one doesn't conveniently exist.
I think there's a decent chance that some bot came across the names of the kids in an online context and decided to spin up a few items that are nominally child-related, or maybe it misfired even worse and put them on furniture and pizza.
At the very least it's not going to be an online pedo ring, so everything else is much more likely.
You don't need a sniper rifle, a DMR chambered in 7.62x51 or even a half-decent AR-15 with an LPVO will more than suffice.
A 10 inch barrel on the latter will probably do the trick for engagement ranges within a few hundred meters, especially when you can quickly follow up with more shots.
At that point, it's barely bigger or even shorter than most SMGs, if not an autopistol. Easier to get too, if comparing semi AR-15 or AR-10 to anything with full-auto capabilities.
If you wanted to get really fancy, splurge for a suppressed AR in .300 Blackout, you can perforate fools with whisper quiet rounds, and not even wake up the neighbors downstairs.
We're Americans, not Canadians. We want to know what's in it for us. If the benighted third-world masses are doing better that's great, but it doesn't offset the slightest drop in US QOL.
I think anywhere from a third to over half of your countrymen would disagree, not that I particularly care. The biggest contributions of the States to the rest of us has been through diffusion of technological innovation and global trade flourishing under Pax Americana, not from charity doled out from the kindness of your hearts.

I see absolutely no reason for them to draw attention to such practises, let alone by using names schizo normies might recognize, when they've already got a white list. Why the hell would you do that? There's no shortage of exceptionally ugly jpegs of monkeys out there that no sane individual wants.
You might as well just have it sold as an exceptionally unpopular side dish if we're talking pizza, maybe with mandatory sardine and pineapple toppings.
More options
Context Copy link