self_made_human
amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi
I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.
At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!
Friends:
A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.
User ID: 454
By Allah, is that comment the one you wish to rephrase to be less inflammatory?
For anyone reading, the original was along the lines of "Only if you assume reality is inductive ;)". That would probably be the least inflammatory or questionable thing you've said in living memory. It's like if someone resurrected Hitler and gave him a rundown of all the unkind things people have said about him over the years, and his takeaway was to give up on vegetarianism.
Reality is clearly whatever you wish it to be, Hlynka 🙏
That's entirely orthogonal to my point, I'm saying that the standard you're using invalidates far more than just claims of gender dysphoria. I don't deny that what you describe wouldn't be palatable to most trans activists.
How can you be sure that I haven't?
Given that AIXI is uncomputable, I'm eagerly awaiting the announcement of you being the recepient of the Turing award.
Dear reader, please don't let Hlynka distract you from the fact that a humble "Stochastic Parrot" did a better job of both understanding a complicated physics question from implied context and answering it correctly than he did.
The most utterly glaring error here is that you're flat out wrong about LLMs being a subset of regression-based ML algorithms. I will risk wasting the time of @curious_straight_ca and @DaseindustriesLtd here to back me up on that, even if a cursory search reveals that they're completely different things.
But Hlynka is of the opinion that Chihuahuas are good hunting dogs, so who's surprised at yet more abuse of truth or the meaning of language?
At any rate, such a combination of such utter confidence while being "not even wrong" levels of confused about things is unique, if not particularly charming.
Besides, maybe the error is on my part, translations to and from "Indian" can be fraught, am I right? It's entirely possible I've mistaken a very subtle and important argument for gish-galloping.
I strongly disagree, I'm quite confident it was a relatively mainstream argument well before 2018, Scott wrote a post in 2014 to which this serves as an update, and that was partially motivated by the claims that SSRIs were useless/placebos.
Edit: The placebo theory is clearly mentioned in the text excerpt I posted as well as in his original blog post.
Hmm? I disagree that self-assessment is the be-all and end-all in gender, you have to pass as the opposite sex, but your analogy doesn't make sense to me.
Consider someone with phantom limb syndrome, say it's present since birth despite them lacking an arm (I know that's not how it works, bear with me). Are they allowed to claim that they are correct in having the sensation of a missing limb? They never had one in the first place. Or more prosaically, someone left-handed and raised right-handed who always felt that something was off, until they learned about dexterity or learned that in many places, it's a benign quirk that is easily accommodated instead of squashed.
I have also heard accounts of children who were raised as the opposite of their phenotypical/genetic sex, be it by an insane mother who wanted a daughter and made one out of her son, or a child with ambiguous genitalia or who had their penis botched around birth and were reshuffled off as female. Quite a few of such cases had the kids rebel against the perceived gender roles they were made to follow, even if that's how they'd been raised.
That's not to say that trans people are all like that, I think autogynephilia and a delusional memetic contagion account for most of it, so I'm arguing with the given reason for your conclusion even if I agree with the conclusion itself, mostly.
And to be fair reading isnt all that interesting as an adult, let alone a kid.
I wouldn't be surprised hearing this from a rando on the street, but you're a regular on The Motte, all we ever do is read and argue haha.
It's still a foreign notion to me, I read voraciously the moment letters ceased to be arcane scribbles, I actually did the whole reading labels on shampoo bottles thing well before it became a meme. If I show up late to my own funeral, it'll be because I was reading the obituary..
The ones I've used were rubber pieces you could slot on the stems of your glasses, with the other end hooking onto your ears so the glasses couldn't shift. There wasn't any strap involved.
People in Japan and Korea often leave the most expensive item on their person, such as a phone, laptop or DSLR, unattended to hold a place for them while they're off using the loo.
If you think you're in a high-trust society, you've seen nothing yet.
What is the difference between reifying the behavior of waves into a set of fictitious spirits as opposed to doing so onto a single will except in the inherent naturalist tradeoff it offers between modes of thinking in terms of energetic efficiency?
If you define "spirits" as purely force-carrying particles or the perturbations of a field, then that's an isomorphic claim. Unfortunately, we already have a word for such entities, and if that's all they do, then spirit is a terrible term.
Let's say we call all particles of the standard model a type of djinn and build a mythological understanding of the probabilities. Is such a model inherently less true? And if so why?
What exactly does calling them djinn achieve except for pointless word-play? Presumably the term indicates commonality in some degree with the kind that comes out of lamps. Any extra posited properties that have no bearing on observed outcomes automatically makes the model less useful, unless you declare that these djinn are exactly equivalent to fundamental particles, at which point you're not doing anything useful yourself. At most, you now have equations which are better framed by CTRL-F find and replace with normal terms, and you've just wasted everyone's time.
This methodological fetishism is worship in anything but name, and even in name at its extremities.
I wish you luck in your linguistic endeavors. Rationality is a means to an end and not an end in itself, not that you can't find some wacko who will claim the latter. It's a collection of cognitive techniques that is robustly useful for a very wide set of possible goals, be it improving human welfare, maximizing the output of paperclips or anything else really.
Most if not literally all the self-described Rationalists out there see it is an incredibly useful tool for achieving goals in reality, and the conserved core of the movement promotes such practices because for most ideologies out there, people are amenable to being talked out of their goals if it can be rationally shown to conflict with other more fundamental goals. A rational NIMBYist will at the very least come to understand and accept the same facts and figures a rat YIMBYist would (moderated by priors and trust), and the two of them might even find common cause if it can be sufficiently demonstrated that mixed density housing is an optimal solution to both the problem of walkable neighborhoods as well as creating sufficient housing everywhere such that all the miscellaneous miscreants don't congregate there. The aim is to at least get everyone on the same page regarding reality, even if they disagree on ideals or implications of facts, because such fundamental disagreement on reality is often the cause of much strife.
And though you seem to say this observation doesn't merit qualifying it with the religious label, all of the excesses of the worship of reason are immediately analogous to similar excesses of superstition, except in that they are unimpeded by the limitations we grew for these older forms of worship. The modernist zealot fancies himself a skeptic, but a zealot he is and a zealot he must be understood as.
Two different concepts having parallels or overlaps is necessary but not sufficient to claim they're the same thing.
The "Cult of Reason" has also moderated itself in many important regards, such as few people advocating for command economies when it was once believed to be optimal by the best minds of the time. Every time scientific consensus is overturned or new discoveries are made, it adapts and repurposes.
I no more consider the excesses of Wokism damming for materialist ideology as a whole than you might think that milquetoast Western Christianity deserves opprobrium for the crimes of fundamentalist Islam. Turns out there are unneutered strains of religion out there, flourishing, and all the worse because it's based off bullshit.
At any rate, I'm going to recuse myself, I feel there's nothing left to add on my end, and the debate is largely word-games through and through.
I will point to the obvious trend line where ever greater fractions of human neurobiology and cognition have received mechanistic interpretations and a firm conceptual underpinning. Are we 100% done with it? No. But we can see temporal lobe epilepsy causing visions of supernatural entities, the precise firing and wiring of our visual neurons, and plenty more.
All a mechanistic theory of consciousness truly requires is that it obeys the laws of physics, and having peered into a few brains myself, I didn't spot anything contradicting the Standard Model of Physics.
This kind of rebuttal is about as valid as claiming that modern empirical/Western medicine is unfounded because there have been plenty of models before that proved flawed, and even its adherents admit it's not 100% perfect at explaining or treating illness. That's leaving aside that a mechanistic model that doesn't rely on supernatural/preternatural influences doesn't happen to be simply better/more parsimonious by Occam's Razor. I fail to see what additional empirical evidence the alternatives provide, so it remains the default assumption even if it's incomplete.
I do not believe you are not religious, I just think you don't consider your religion one.
I will strongly state that I think this is an exceptionally useless, entirely non-standard definition of "religion".
An ideology or a philosophy is not a religion, there's a reason they're distinct words with specific connotations.
If I had to self-describe, then the description with the best tradeoff between verbosity and utility is "transhumanist classical liberal with libertarian tendencies".
I invite you to show me which aspect is necessarily religious. Transhumanism might laud the improvement of the human form and transcendence over its limitations, but there's nothing remotely supernatural about it. Wearing glasses, taking performance enhancing drugs or getting a pacemaker are innately transhumanist acts.
This is an absolute, complete and total lie. And any reasonable skeptic must concede that all knowledge lies on foundations of metaphysical assumption.
I am well aware that axioms exist, and must stand alone until you can show that they potentially arise from the implications of even fewer axioms. Or that value is inherently subjective, and there's nothing to decry as being objective false about them. Rationalists coined the phrase Orthogonality Hypothesis.
Fundamental assumptions about ontology/epistemics != supernatural beliefs. Those are defined by their claims of relevance to the material world, as well as (usually) a denial they can be defined or derived from the same laws of physics it obeys and willful denial that the preponderance of evidence empirically available or theoretically robust rules against it.
God as an Omnipotent, Omniscient, and Omnibenevolent entity outside the laws of physics or empirical investigation is supernatural.
"God" as a superintelligent AGI or alien running us in a simulation is not.
A Communist who desires communism despite knowing the human costs and economic downsides is not succumbing to supernatural thinking. They're biting a bullet and admitting they accept that tradeoff. A Communist who claims that it's a more efficient and wealth-increasing/wellbeing-maximizing alternative to capitalism is wrong, and I would still not call this a supernatural belief.
A=A and other such base presuppositions that are, if quite reasonable in themselves, still faith based statements about the nature of the world.
I deny that faith is the appropriate/correct word for this association.
At the very least mathematicians and logicians go to great lengths to minimize such assumptions, hence why they bothered to prove that 1+1=2 in Peano Arithmetic as opposed to waving their hands and declaring it obvious.
The Chinese Room again? Sigh.
Much as the Library of Babel is both exhaustive and utterly useless, it's the algorithmic capability of finding useful information and acting on it that matters, and not that it can theoretically be summoned. You can, if you are exceptionally stupid, try and make an LLM that works by outputting every single possible string of a given length until you get a satisfactory answer. The pitfalls are obvious.
In this particular case, you are merely frontloading the computation to a look-up table, not eliminating it entirely. For any practical configuration, someone had to go to the trouble of doing that. Human consciousness is a mess of individually stochastic neurons that in bulk can produce synchronous signals and something analogous to a clock rate, our perception of time as perfectly continuous is not representative of the underlying neuro-computation. You've just temporally shifted the cognition involved, not eliminated it, and our brain uses LUTs all the time, if you've memorized times tables, you're not doing elementary arithmetic to figure out 7*7=49. That's still maths.
So "computation be damned" is doing all the heavy lifting. Why don't you use your ML chops to run AIXI, if it's such a trivial thing to you?
is meaningfully distinct from that of an arbitrarily complex random number generator in any way?
Sure, obviously. I can only assume that you think this is a valid description of ML/LLMs/AI, which it very much is not. If it's "randomness" that has you up and at it, then set the temperature of a model to 0 to get deterministic outputs. Problem solved?
If so, why do you believe that?
I need no justification for such atomic preferences, I just have them, both in the incredibly stupid case you wish to make, and my vain attempts at steel-manning it in the scenario you're hand-waving at modern ML. LLMs do not capture the complexity of a human, nor do they have other aspects I care about, such as the fact that I'm not talking to a machine that will immediately flush everything out of memory as soon as it's done talking to me. Then again, I think that's a valid description of certain people on this forum, so who am I to judge?
I value my existence for its own sake, but if there's a human intelligence or smarter AI out there that is capable of remembering discussions and updating on them in the future, and capable of modifying future behavior on that basis, then I'm perfectly fine talking with it at length. Even GPT does update, but only slightly so as newer conservations enter the training data for the next one, but not in the same manner as a human.
If you mean a mind upload of myself running in-silico, and not a random LLM fine tuned on me, then yes, I would accept it as a valid replacement, given my conviction that it's very likely that in internally subjective terms it has the same qualia as I do. I would obviously prefer we both co-exist, at least until my flesh fails me, but I accord such an entity every right to use the SMH name to the same extent I do.
Ironically for how often I get accused of not understanding how machine learning works, I suspect that I have far more practical "hands-on" experience designing, implementing, and working with machine learning algorithms than most users here.
Here I was thinking I'm a human chauvinist, and now I'm pitying an ML model. Such insanity is hardly unheard of, I happen to have an uncle who is a professor in microbiology who swears by homeopathy.
I suppose it's a sign of how streamlined the process has become, when people so utterly divorced from the theoretical underpinnings of the technology are making a living off it.
SSRIs have pretty weak effect sizes, but that's not the same as them being entirely useless after all.
Thankfully, Scott has a deep dive on the subject, sparing me the trouble:
https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/11/07/ssris-an-update/
All this leads to the third thing I’ve been thinking about. Given that the effect size really is about 0.3, how do we square the scientific evidence (that SSRIs “work” but do so little that no normal person could possibly detect them) with the clinical evidence (that psychiatrists and patients often find SSRIs sometimes save lives and often make depression substantially better?)
The traditional way to do this is to say that psychiatrists and patients are wrong. Given all the possible biases involved, they misattribute placebo effects to the drugs, or credit some cases that would have remitted anyway to the beneficial effect of SSRIs, or disproportionately remember the times the drugs work over the times they don’t. While “people are biased” is always an option, this doesn’t fit the magnitude of the clinical evidence that I (and most other psychiatrists) observe. There are patients who will regularly get better on an antidepressant, get worse when they stop it, get better when they go back on it, get worse when they stop it again, et cetera. This raises some questions of its own, like why patients keep stopping antidepressants that they clearly need in order to function, but makes bias less likely. Overall the clinical evidence that these drugs work is so strong that I will grasp at pretty much any straw in order to save my sanity and confirm that this is actually a real effect.
Every clinician knows that different people respond to antidepressants differently or not at all. Some patients will have an obvious and dramatic response to the first antidepressant they try. Other patients will have no response to the first antidepressant, but after trying five different things you’ll find one that works really well. Still other patients will apparently never respond to anything.
Overall only about 30% – 50% of the time when I start a patient on a particular antidepressant, do we end up deciding this is definitely the right medication for them and they should definitely stay on it. This fits national and global statistics. According to a Korean study, the median amount of time a patient stays on their antidepressant prescription is three months. A Japanese study finds only 44% of patients continued their antidepressants the recommended six months; an American study finds 31%.
Suppose that one-third of patients have some gene that makes them respond to Prozac with an effect size of 1.0 (very large and impressive), and nobody else responds. In a randomized controlled trial of Prozac, the average effect size will show up as 0.33 (one-third of patients get effect size of 1, two-thirds get effect size of 0). This matches the studies. In the clinic, one-third of patients will be obvious Prozac responders, and their psychiatrist will keep them on Prozac and be very impressed with it as an antidepressant and sing the praises of SSRIs. Two-thirds of patients will get no benefit, and their doctors will write them off as non-responders and try something else. Maybe the something else will work, and then the doctors will sing the praises of that SSRI, or maybe they’ll just say it’s “treatment-resistant depression” and so doesn’t count.
In other words, doctors’ observation “SSRIs work very well” is an existence statement “there are some patients for whom SSRIs work very well” – and not a universal observation “SSRIs will always work well for all patients”. Nobody has ever claimed the latter so it’s not surprising that it doesn’t match the studies.
It seems to me you're arguing for something that's categorically impossible, so please explain.
Categorically impossible? In the sense that either the laws of logic, physics or biology prevent it? If you want an existence proof, I'm right here.
We know very rough correlates for religiosity in the human brain, so it's plausible enough to me that there's likely a biological means of removing such tendencies. At the very least, we have systems of metaphysics that have been stripped of supernatural elements, that would be philosophy. The fact that Wokism, as you initially brought up, is largely lacking in the same while being quite convincing and virulent, is proof of possibility.
There's obviously no society in existence that doesn't have a shared culture/memeplex, but that's not what I'm positing, it's the removal of supernatural bullshit from its underpinnings.
Classical liberalism seems pretty peachy to me, let people do as they please as wrong as they don't infringe on a narrowly defined set of rights that belongs to everyone else.
Name a less insane society organizing religion then.
I deny the need for religion in the first place. Or if there's a "need" for it in the psyche of the average human, poor thing, it needs to be excised, not fed.
Religion is, for better or worse, not optional. The very rise of the Woke is proof of it.
I obviously disagree, even if Wokism has plenty of traits of religion.
Having extra buttons is great, just having access to back and forward keys that works in browsers and most apps, as well as easy volume control is so worth it. In video games, I usually bind them to voice chat, far more convenient than hunting down keys on the keyboard.
I swear by the added grips for glasses, back when I was forced to help with surgeries, I hated having mine threaten to slip off my nose and into an open uterus, if an infant sees the extent of my myopia, they're never going to open their eyes again! Not to mention the headache of having a nurse re-adjust them, or shimmy up against a convenient object at head height to nudge them back into place without disturbing the sterile field.
(I ordered a new set, but apparently the tiny Amazon package got lost in a mountain of other crap, ah well, my current glasses have better grip anyway)
9, 13, 9, 3, 7, 1, 5, 12, 7, 2.
Just to throw Hlynka a bone die.
Who's "we", white man? Jokes aside, I am personally entirely content with having my subjective goals and desires be the bedrock on which I build my existence. I don't aspire for more because it's not possible to have an "objective" morality or foundation in the first place.
What policy preferences or cultural peccadilos a society has doesn't particularly matter to me, as long as the central tenets don't violate our best understanding of the laws of physics, as Christianity does, or biology, as Wokism is guilty of.
I agree that in principle, it is possible to emulate a complex system to within the limits of observation and random error by treating it as a blackbox and then training on its outputs or response to stimuli.
After all, in ML, that's already a thing in the form of teacher-student distillation, where you train a new neural net to be indistinguishable from another by feeding it the latter's outputs.
I still don't think that just training on a corpus of text written by a human is sufficient to reproduce said human, maybe if you had an enormous amount of video, audio and other biometrics. It's arguably better than nothing as a form of immortality, but I personally expect more. If it can be demonstrated that such a technique is somehow equivalent to mind uploading via scanning, then I'll have no objections.
There's about a zero percent chance that Hlynka doesn't know about my enthusiasm for the potential of mind uploading, with me seeing such an emulation of a human mind as equivalent in every way that matters to me as the same as a biological human.
That is not the same as replacing a human with a LLM trained on the corpus of their text, with outputs indistinguishable from the human. You'd need to do way more to establish it as a high fidelity replication of the original consciousness, even if I think in principle it's doable.

You can yell at clouds all you like, but much like Shamans and their hexes, RCTs have shown that doesn't do much to help with rain ;)
More options
Context Copy link