self_made_human
amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi
I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.
At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!
Friends:
A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.
User ID: 454
I think you’re missing my point, or maybe your being cheeky and I don’t realize it.
While I'm fond of sarcasm, in this case I presume it's the former.
Consider a 20-something who experiments with homosexuality in college and then realizes that they don’t like it later in life.
This is the same as a gay person experimenting with heterosexuality and “coming out” later in life.
We seem to be socially okay with helping straight people convert to homosexuality, but not okay with the opposite.
Even after you've offered a clarifying example, I'd have to disagree.
It's exceedingly common for women (if not men) to "experiment" with each other in college or school. Usually it's just the odd drunken kiss, but it can go further. I know this is true for a fact both because I've heard of it in the West and a friend of my ex drunkenly admitted that we were Eskimo siblings (the friend was a girl). They're otherwise straight, and go on to exclusive have heterosexual relationships and might not even think of a woman romantically again.
This has little in the way of repercussions or even anything beyond mild disapproval from the more staid, nobody I'm aware of advocates for reconverting them after they ceased to experiment with the same team.
I would agree with the Pride activists that any guy who was convinced by a Pride parade or other advocacy to start sucking dick or taking it in the rear wasn't particularly straight to begin with, leaving aside what they identified as.
My, you're a straight one. That's a common enough euphemism/outdated street slang for heroin, specifically the dirty stuff that's otherwise known as black-tar heroin. I don't think it's India specific, even if it's archaic.
I'm not so sure this is possible. In a mathematical sense, can any two hypotheses actually be equal in complexity? I think even small differences would render one more complex than the other.
I think so, but bear in my mind my reach exceeds my grasp when it comes to mathematics and physics haha
I'm struggling when it comes to explaining the intuition in a rigorous way, even if I'm quite confident in it.
At least it makes sense to me that this can happen, even if it's not common, after all there are an infinite number of possible hypotheses that explain any given amount of evidence, and it's entirely possible two or more of them have the same Kolmogorov Complexity.
Once again I stress this is less relevant in practice, as you also point out, but I believe it's still true. Humans (and LLMs using autoencoders) have an inherent simplicity prior, so we usually try and pick the least complex explanation for most phenomenon. Usually.
In the Bible this is called asking for a sign and is generally frowned upon. If it were important for nonbelievers to be proven wrong, the world would be extremely different. We wouldn't even call such proof miracles. God's glory etc. would be permanently displayed to everyone so that nobody could harbor doubt for even a moment.
I obviously have a more cynical explanation in mind. I find any efforts to reconcile the abundance of miracles in the past with their paucity in the present highly suspect.
At the very least you must admit that "prophets" tend to be given less than ambiguous information.
I can far easier swallow no intervention from a disinterested Creator and omnipresent or frequent intervention than I can the middle ground of it happening just a little too sparsely for us to be confident of it.
Further, I think it's grossly unethical to confront a flawed being like a human with the possibility of endless fulfillment versus infinite suffering in the form of Heaven and Hell and not give them sufficient information to make an informed decision. You might well disagree that you have "sufficient" information. It would make far more sense to give everyone the brief and then condemn those who stray.
(Even if the latter is a joke in the eyes of an omniscient entity who knows exactly what a soul will do before it's put in a position to mess itself up)
Generally the people who see miracles are believers, skeptics who are morally ready to be believers, and skeptics so far gone that they won't be convinced by any amount of proof at all.
What exactly is "morally ready" but a convenient rug to sweep counterarguments under? Some of them were skeptical, were they not?
Certainly I'm not the latter, if I had concrete evidence of God that is distinguishable from the normal operations of the laws of physics, I'd at least consider it (and this being a Simulator fucking with me, or me going insane).
One of them was literally brain cancer.
I'm glad you didn't die from that, but is the fervent thanks of the denizens of the odd hut that wasn't swept away by a tsunami any consolation to all the others who did?
It seems deeply chauvinistic to think that you are the one person who deserves the big ticket miracles, and not the other millions or billions of earnest believers!
As you acknowledge, the RCTs concur with me, and while a sample size of one isn't nothing, it's not much either.
And simply from anthropics, if you'd been killed by the cancer, you wouldn't be around to tell me how being pious helped..
If you have a novel idea for an experiment I could perform I'd be happy to test it out.
Err.. Maybe consciously perform an experiment where you intentionally misbehave and flaunt your beliefs? The inverse of what you proposed I'd do.
You'd have to do it over a prolonged period of time to get enough data, and I'm not sure you even like the idea.
It depends on if the correlation you describe between being better and more obvious miracles holds in the obverse, do you expect to sprain your foot or get hit by a bus if you suddenly become the world's worst anti-Mormon? If not, you'll just get more evidence of nothing much at all happening, or the absence of miracles, and I don't know what the base rate for that is in your eyes.
Or at least you could try to be the secular idea of a "good person", someone who absolutely doesn't believe in the supernatural yet tries to do good in their eyes. I trust you can figure out how to do that, but I suspect you're just as incapable of actually banishing your belief in God on demand as I am to embrace it, or even the 1% suggestion you extended.
Would many activists prefer that their campaigns result in everyone turning bisexual or gay? Maybe, probably. Doesn't mean that's what they expect.
I don't think a significant fraction of them think being straight is bad, and even if they did, that's not likely the reason why they endorse Pride. And the tendency of many gays to take pride in "converting" "straight" men is more of a fetishization of the unattainable.*
Of course, I'm trying to interpret the question I think you're trying to ask, because as of the time of writing, what you said:
What percentage of people going to gay conversion clinics do you think believe themselves be straight be afflicted with something they find undesirable?
Makes no sense! I presume you meant "to be straight to be afflicted".
*Many gay people mock the straights, but or ask questions along the lines of "are the straights OK?" but that's more of an in-group catechism and bitching, rather than a genuine belief that being straight is somehow inferior.
Note that I'm specifically addressing gay men (or maybe lesbian too), the trans activist community has an unhealthy obsession with cracking eggs.
One difficulty I see is distinguishing between one’s inner state and one’s actions. A man is not gay because he has sex with men, he is gay because he is attracted to men.
Objective tests in the form of penile plethysmography exist, though they're most commonly employed to assess pedophiles in niche situations or the unlucky men with erectile dysfunction, but I agree that forcing people to take it for the purposes of giving them a certified gay card is out of the Overton Window for the foreseeable future!
Simply: lots of work by libs is a sort of gay conversion therapy for straight people. Pride parades, public school education, pride month, trans day of visibility etc. all exist to glorify homosexuality and, explicitly to help straight people easily “come out of the closet” as gay.
I find this a very dubious assertion. It seems to me, both in terms of public assertion as well as mildly uncharitable questioning of their inner motivations, that the aim isn't to convert straight people, but to have people who are already gay (or at least not a zero on the Kinsey scale) to feel free to express their sexuality.
Would many activists prefer that their campaigns result in everyone turning bisexual or gay? Maybe, probably. Doesn't mean that's what they expect.
This is distinct from the odd grifter who painlessly claims to be gay for the sake of diversity points, since it's verboten to question them even if they've never sucked an actual dick in their lives, but even then they're more likely to claim to be trans or non-binary. While some activists might grudgingly tolerate this (or feel helpless to call it out according to the standards of self-identification they espouse), I don't think they approve of it per se.
I mean, the Wizarding World went from a period of relative peace to warring against the resurgent Death Eaters, so I find that hardly surprising, and I can't recall many of the "good" guys ever resorting to them, if at all.
Hmm, I could have sworn I did somewhere sometime, but maybe it was all in my head. Either way, apologies for being incorrect here.
I know precisely what you've linked to without opening it.
Mandalore is a gem, and I think this video was the funniest thing I've seen all year, just watching the safari vehicle sequence took years off my life from laughing alone, and the whole experience is the closest I think you can get to being on deliriants.
If I can't whisk my shit away with a spell, I'm not playing.
Then again, given how lethal the Hogwarts toilets and plumbing are, it's understandable that you might want to apparate such things away instead of venturing where a troll can exacerbate your hemorrhoids.
I've only watched gameplay and haven't tried it myself, but while the game seems like a good game, I'm mildly confused at the poor job it does of being an RPG in some important regards, such as making you feel like a student in Hogwarts as well as an intrepid adventurer.
What I do find baffling is how inconsequential the use of Unforgiveable Curses is, even if you do them in public or in front of your teachers (!). I understand the desire to not be too restrictive of the player, but it would have been easy enough to have it diegetically explained as a temporary relaxation in the light of the Goblin Revolt, and make the character face repercussions for blasting anything and everything they see with a killing curse, even if you don't end up in Azkaban or kicked out of school.
What should my prior be that it's a good idea to cheat on my wife, or that committing murder for sport is a bad idea? Do you think sufficient evidence exists to preclude decimal notation for either question? Do you think it is beneficial to leave these as routinely-updated open questions throughout one's life?
People regularly cheat on their wives, and at least some people commit murder for the thrill of it, leaving aside if it's a good idea.
While it would be pretentious to put too many decimal points on any reply here, I can confidently say that the "carefully" considered answer to both are sub 1%, to the point that the expected value of information from crunching it more explicitly is lackluster to say the least. Of course, I have little intrinsic desire to do each, if someone cared more they should spend more time considering it.
In real life, is this effect strong enough to allow you to differentiate between a prior set at 1 before evidence, versus a prior arriving at .50001 after evidence?
Yes? I mean, can you claim you've literally never seen anyone change their mind? People can and do express confidence levels, and there has been considerably research that shows that when someone says something is "very likely" or "unlikely", that correlates to a numerical probability even if it's noisy.
If I submit someone convincing evidence and they don't even deign to consider it or, or outright admit nothing can sway them, then I have no qualms about declaring them zealots who are immune to evidence against their claims. This is not the same as normative claims which can't be represented by priors, just utility functions, but religion as practised or preach isn't just normative, even if I think the norms in question are stupid.
I've had one person here, @Meriadoc, admit that there's nothing I or anyone, even with a trillion dollars in funding, including more funding to counter-investigate our claims, can do to change his mind regarding the truth of Mormonism. If that's not a stuck prior at 1, I don't know what is!
I don't believe you or anyone else can rigorously assign a prior to even the first decimal place for a real-world question of appreciable complexity, like, say, who the next president is going to be.
You don't see me doing that, at least unless the magnitude of the prior is significantly smaller than 1%, and even then I consciously refrain from dumb statements like claiming I only think there's a 0.0000000001% chance something is true, because the odds of me simply being insane are higher.
I usually express myself along the lines of ~10% margins, and I have empirical evidence that I am a well calibrated person, the last time I took a test that explicitly tested it, it was almost perfect from the entire range of 0-100%, in 10% buckets. So I can easily say that I'm 50-70% sure of a proposition and know that means something, and I don't claim I'm 55.67% sure.
What useful predictions does this theory allow you to make?
A newborn baby, confronted with a theoretically infinite number of explanations and world models for all the enormous amounts of evidence they're bombarded with, almost always swiftly and inevitably develops complex ontologies like object permanence, and even an understanding of the classical laws of motion.
You've previously claimed that the sheer difficulty of grappling with near infinite ways of interpreting any given sample of information precludes us from being certain about anything, but babies and the simple algorithms underling LLMs such as GPT-4 alike don't give a shit, if there's signal in the noise they'll find it.
The Simplicity Prior, or an applied form of Occam's Razor, works so well in practice that I have no qualms about relying on it.
It's all good, I feel like these claims are outlandish/inflammatory enough that I should pro-actively provide evidence in the first place!
I don't imagine that extends to cannulations and the like does it?
Given that I'd earn more as a nurse in the US than as a doctor in the UK, around triple for a traveling nurse.. Hmm
Nah. I'm still too proud to do that, even if 5 years of med school looks like a sunk cost at times. Besides, I don't think just being a doctor is sufficient credentials to work as a nurse in most places, and I'm not going through nursing school unless it takes like 6 months. I suppose most doctors don't end up in queer situations where that even remotely looks like a good idea.
Indian/South/SE Asian nurses have been propping up the profession for a while, during COVID, countries were falling over themselves to attract as many as they could get. The only reason more don't emigrate, at least from India, is because they're not fluent enough in English, even if in practise I don't think that would be too much of a hindrance if they can grokk the basics.
Man, fuck UK nurses, I thought the ones in government hospitals in India who wouldn't life a finger because of the comfort of their protected government jobs were bad. They're often trained to do trivial tasks like perform cannulations, catheterizations and so on there, but from a combination of stupid NHS trust policies that demand recertification and their own laziness, refuse to do so even when they're capable. It's easy for me to take for granted that work like this is done by the nurses at decent private hospitals in India, as well as the States, and I don't look forward to the inevitable dozens of cannulations I'll have to do daily as a doctor in the UK. My back hurts just thinking about it.
That's well beyond the ability of even nukes to solve, you need something like a relativistic kill vehicle to handle that..
I'm talking about the less insane, the people who are broadly sympathetic to the Palestinians as poor oppressed innocent folk being bullied by mean Israel. While I don't expect it to sway all of them, this serves as a spread of buckshot right at the heart of most of the common objections. I'll probably link the Substack post, seems more official than the Motte.
I was just about to link the Scott post myself. It's amazing how much bullshit nigh limitless wealth lets you get away with, and the Venezuelans make the Saudis look competent, which is rare enough.
I said grudgingly tolerate, not endorse. Most successful politicians are lying to you out of their teeth, and at least in his case I agreed with many of the policy statements laid out by the one guy who was single-handedly running a PR campaign for him.
That's more an indictment of establishment candidates than it is full throated approval for him.
1/8th of the genetic variance from the human mean I'd hope, unless you consider the sunflowers in the garden extended relatives.
Then again, they likely have better opinions about the conflict..
Funnily enough, despite the trope that Indians are fervent supporters of Israel, I've only seen pro-Palestinian propaganda shared online in my own circles, the most ludicrous being a claim by a girl I danced the night away with that the Gazan Ministry of Education shut down schools because "all the children had been killed" lmao. Well, I wasn't attracted to her at the time for her brains..
From a purely practical standpoint, if the Israelis launch a full scale campaign in Gaza, most of the city likely won't be standing when it's done.
So better to get the civilians out if possible, and I don't see the death toll or humanitarian crisis as likely worse than living in bombed out ruins. The people of Gaza are already close to maximally hostile as far as Israel is concerned as they can be without turning into literal zombies, so I don't blame them in the least for getting them off their doorstep.
India Today is a reputable news outlet, and the NGO making the claims otherwise stands for the rights of hijras and their general welfare. I claim no specific expertise beyond this, but I can't think of a reason either would pen a hit piece.
It's a good thing you consider the overall rate of birth with ambiguous genitalia, that provoked me to search down the rabbit hole.
The stigma is justified enough as is, it's hard to overstate how much of a nuisance they can be, especially if you're a middle class Indian relying on public transport, but I am relatively open minded about gender norms so it's not like I despise them for just presenting as an opposite gender. I certainly don't care about their other source of income, prostitution.
I would still take it with a pinch of salt, but in general Hijras don't deny the existence of castration ceremonies, they just claim it's voluntary. So maybe let a bit of your current stance on gender reassignment in children in the West bleed through I guess, I personally don't think it's all above board leaving aside the difficulty of verifying numbers and the activists who see any criticism of hijras as hostile.
To put vague numbers on it, I'm 80% that such practises are commonplace, but only 50% or less that it happens with such a high frequency.
Hijras are a very small minority (albeit they annoy well out of proportion to their number), I would be surprised if there were more than a few hundred or thousand of them in a typical city, though you'll find concentrations in the larger ones
I had previously heard that it was occasionally the case that they would castrate children. I didn't want to malign them more than I already have, so I checked, and it's far worse than I thought:
Only 1 percent of eunuchs are born so, while the rest either pretend to be hijras (eunuch) or have been forced to join the community by abduction and castration, reveals a study by the All-India Hijra Kalyan Sabha (AIHKS).
According to the study, there are 30,000 eunuchs in the national capital alone. This “high number” is contrary to “reliable estimates” that say “only one in a lakh is a born eunuch”.
The study further reveals that at least 1,000 youths are converted into eunuchs in the city every year.
They are actually castrated men. “Young and addicted boys are abducted and then introduced to homosexuality by the agents of eunuch’s gurus. Castrations are clandestinely forced on them and ironically, very few people gather the courage to retaliate,” Bhola said.
A victim of forced castration says how he was abducted, made an addict of brown sugar and hashish, and then pushed into homosexuality.
This way, he alleges, eunuch gurus have made huge sums.
“The hijra mafia that controls the castrations operates secretly throughout the country. They have a network of hijra mandis where a newly castrated eunuch is auctioned to the highest bidder. The auction is conducted with claps - a single clap means Rs 1,000. Fair, clean-limbed boys who can earn more, attract highest bids. Victims are threatened with death if they break silence,” reveals Bhola.
That's certainly food for thought, you can't just naively transfer Western concepts of transvestitism or transgenderism to other contexts, and these guys victimize each other just as much as they do the general public, and much of the scorn and disdain they get is richly deserved. A 1000 rupees is just 10 USD or so..
In this case, barring the candied carrot, there's also the big stick of not being shot to death one hopes. (In war, that's excessive for parenting anything but a rabid pitbull)
Without me, at least 9!

It's a shame they don't make games any more, I want to go hunt down the existing megafauna on our globe with C-130J airstrikes and tactical nukes, which is the only sensible escalation for a sequel.
(From reading the comments, the previous games had Big Foot and other cryptids, so in a way this game is more down to Earth. At least in some regards)
More options
Context Copy link