Well this is related to Fuentes’s argument as well. The pro-Israel side is willing to let it all burn before abandoned their cause. Therefore, he says the anti-Israel side needs to have the same mindset.
The problem is, (a) since only one side can get their way, this just means both sides agree to let it all burn, and (b) the pro-Israel side is driven by deeply held beliefs related to their ethnic identity, and this is unlikely to change.
The anti-Israel side has some genuine points, but overall they simply choose to make the issue their top issue even though they have no genuine connection to the issue, and it is not the issue that affects Americans the most. So this mindset is not really “America first” in my opinion.
I also don’t think the Iran war is truly about Israel. Trump has said all along it’s about nuclear weapons. I think it is totally reasonable to stop Iran from having nukes.
Yeah, but he also clearly just has a personal grudge. This was clear from his Tucker interview that he was extremely upset by the attempted deplatforming by the Israel lobby, and rather than acquiesce he made it his #1 issue out of spite.
He’s funny, he has good takes on some things, but his view that Israel is the most important issue and it’s worth burning it all down to beat the Israel lobby is, in my opinion, deranged and driven by personal grievance more than the logic you describe.
He actually does need to he made irrelevant, not because he’s anti-Semitic, but because he goes out of his way to make Republicans lose, and is very effective at it. And not even over an issue that is actually worthwhile.
I think people liked the MAGA parts of Trump’s agenda, but disliked the neocon parts. So “back to the old Republican party” is exactly the wrong takeaway.
Unfortunately I also agree that the unpopularity of the war in iran is basically bullshit, and it was plainly the right thing to do. A full scale invasion would have been a terrible idea but neutering Iran is a positive. I hope we don’t let them off the hook.
Fuentes preached that if you wanted to stop the Israel lobby you had to be willing to hold a gun to the GOP’s head over the issue, even if it meant giving control to the Democrats. Clearly he meant it. I think this is idiotic. Complaining about money or military aid for Israel is one thing, but it’s a drop in the bucket compared to everything else.
- Prev
- Next

It’s just how communists think. A gun in a policeman’s hands is an instrument of oppression; the same gun in a revolutionary worker’s hands is an instrument of liberation.
This in and of itself is just lame cover for the Schmittian friend-enemy distinction. A gun in the hands of my friends is good. A gun in the hands of my enemy is bad.
Their friend has a gun. Imagine if the roles were reversed and their enemy had the gun?? That would sure suck, good thing their friend has it.
This is why “imagine if the roles were reversed” is a 0% effective argument with them.
More options
Context Copy link