@ymeskhout's banner p
BANNED USER: on request

ymeskhout


				

				

				
14 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 20:00:51 UTC

				

User ID: 696

Banned by: @ZorbaTHut

BANNED USER: on request

ymeskhout


				
				
				

				
14 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 20:00:51 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 696

Banned by: @ZorbaTHut

Delay what exactly? Canon had issued an order that stopped the DOJ from reviewing the documents for their criminal investigation, but the order was quickly overturned and might have been issued too late to have prevented anything. All of this could have been much more easily avoided if Trump just returned the documents way back when.

Well I don't know Bobulinski and presumably neither do you, so I'm wondering why exactly you find him to be credible. One possible explanation is that Bobulinski is apparently still very upset with Jim and Hunter Biden over a deal he missed out on. He said himself the two brothers "defrauded" him of at least $5 million. This seems like good evidence he's at least partly motivated by payback. The Hunter Laptop saga hasn't really delivered and people lost interest over the years, which means right-wing pundits like Tucker Carlson and Sean Hannity are especially excited to herald Bobulinski with a moment in the spotlight. It doesn't matter if all that Bobulinski has is uncorroborated gossip, they know they can shore up ratings by resurrecting a dead story on a political figure their audience loathes.

Do you agree with or find any part of this argument persuasive?

I'm asking about your belief falsification.

Would you still find Bobulinski's claim to be credible if he had a falling out with Hunter or was chasing a moment in the media spotlight?

Nothing to be embarrassed about, it happens :)

You're right and I was wrong. It's true that several journalistic outfits had access to the data, but my recollection about how transparent they were about their publication decisions was faulty.

The fact that the tycoon in question made a $100k donation to Biden's family after the fact looks suspiciously like a bribe to me, even if it's technically on the level.

Maybe I'm missing something, but where is this mentioned? The $100k "donation" came from Freeh. I didn't see anything about the Romanian tycoon giving money.

You're right, I didn't read that part closely enough and I overstated just how fully dedicated he is to his diet. And yup, it's totally weird how much he emphasizes the freshness of his ingredients given what he's injecting himself with every day. It reminded me of a friend who refused to get the vaccine because he didn't trust where it came from, but then he caught himself and admitted to taking random drugs from people at parties.

The 11th Circuit put the whole Mar-a-Lago Special Master saga to bed last week. You can read the unanimous opinion here (for those counting, the judges were two Trump appointees and one Bush).

This outcome wasn't surprising at all, especially with how oral argument went. As background, the FBI raided Trump's home in Mar-a-Lago because they convinced a federal magistrate that they're likely to find evidence of criminal activity there. They were right on that front, and they recovered various classified/restricted documents in Trump's possession. Although it's not clear why Trump was so stubbornly enthusiastic about holding on to the documents, there doesn't seem to be much evidence thus far that the documents in question were particularly damning/dangerous, nor that he was holding on to them to sell them or whatever. Nevertheless, the warrant means the FBI lawfully (distinct from morally/ethically/correctly/whatever) seized the property pursuant to a criminal investigation.

If the government takes your shit because they had a warrant, the recourse available to you is virtually non-existent. The traditional avenue available within a criminal investigation is to wait for the indictment and then challenge the legality of the search and seizure through a suppression hearing. If you can convince a judge that the property was illegally obtained, your remedy is that the government is prohibited from using the property as evidence against you. Very often, this destroys the government's case against you and the charges get dismissed. Only after the criminal saga is over can you ask for your stuff back from the government. I routinely help my clients get their stuff back once their case is over, including things like firearms and (my favorite) a small jar of weed. Sometimes I just contact the detective directly, sometimes I need a judge to sign an order. It's routine.

But what if you want your stuff back before even an indictment? The typical answer is that you are shit out of luck, because the government is presumed to be entitled to use property they lawfully took from you. But there are some limited exceptions. In the Richey v. Smith case, an IRS special agent stopped by Richey's office and asked to examine some business records and the guy complied (no warrant, and no Miranda warnings). But after talking to an attorney, Richey changed his mind and asked for his stuff back and the IRS said they'll hand it back once they're through with them. The district court initially ruled they lacked jurisdiction to order the government to return the documents, but on appeal is where we get the "Richey four-factor test". That ruling says that courts can have what is termed "equitable jurisdiction" provided the person asking for their stuff back satisfies every factor:

  1. Did the government act in a "callous disregard" of the person's rights?

  2. Does the person have an interest in and need for the property?

  3. Will the person be irreparably injured by not having his property back?

  4. Does the person lack other legal remedies for not having his stuff?

This is what Trump was asking district court Judge Canon to do. There were several problems with this request, chief among them that unlike the Richey case, the government had a warrant for Mar-a-Lago. The other problems were that Trump's lawyers didn't even try to hint at satisfying any of the four-factor test (See starting on pg 12 of the opinion: Did the government act in a "callous disregard"? No, because they had a warrant. Does Trump need his property back? No, because Celine Dion pictures are not a priority right now. etc.). The closest Trump's lawyers got to a coherent argument was when they vaguely intimated (without saying it outright) that Trump's circumstances were special because he is a former president.

Around the 21:00 mark of oral argument, the judges asked James Trusty if any other person whose property was seized during the course of a criminal investigation would have access to the same remedy Judge Canon gave Trump, and Trusty swallowed the pill and said yes. I'm definitely in favor of having higher scrutiny levied on government search and seizure, but this would be a completely bonkers departure from the current status quo. Nobody likes having their stuff taken and being the subject of a criminal investigation! Applied consistently, the courts would be flooded with these requests and it would become near-impossible to prosecute anybody.

As the court opinion says:

In considering these arguments, we are faced with a choice: apply our usual test; drastically expand the availability of equitable jurisdiction for every subject of a search warrant; or carve out an unprecedented exception in our law for former presidents. We choose the first option. So the case must be dismissed.

As far as I can tell, James Trusty is a competent attorney with the requisite experience to litigate issues at this level but he just fell flat on his face hard. No amount of legal acumen can compensate for having a client who insists on unreasonable demands and tactics.

I don't think having journalists agree to terms is per se improper, and I also don't have reason to doubt that the general thrust of Taibbi's reporting (Twitter employees tried hard to make up reasons to suppress the Hunter story) is off-base, but I'm not really a fan of how this is being deployed. Musk has an obvious incentive to tar the previous management of his company in as bad of a light as possible, and he has a long practice of having his employees sign NDAs. He can't claim to be motivated by the noble pursuit of transparency here, and it's reasonable to be suspicious that he's potentially hiding some things. Taibbi is just one journalist, and he has his biases. Although I don't have reason to believe Taibbi is acting dishonestly, I can't think of an argument against having more scrutinizing eyes examine the document trove. It's needlessly giving ammunition to people who are already primed to dismiss the revelations.

The comparisons to Edward Snowden establishing conditions don't really match up. Similar to Musk, Snowden would be incentivized for his leak to be as much of a bombshell as possible. But if I recall correctly, Snowden had multiple journalist outfits examine the documents, and all of them were transparent about what conditions he set (namely, don't disclose things that could endanger current operatives or something) edit: this did not happen

Seems likely that Bobulinski is either lying or exaggerating. See my comments above. And I don't know what you mean by "suppression" here.

All you said in the linked post was that no one had successfully “run things up the chain,” which seems like you’re saying no one had shown Joe to be directly involved. If that was all you were asserting, then this seems like pretty good evidence that he was.

@Folamh3 helpfully pointed me to this recent Washington Post article about the CEFC deal:

James Gilliar, a business associate summarizing the allocation of the equity in Oneida Holdings LLC., in the email, wrote how four partners would get 20 percent each, except for Jim Biden, who would get 10 percent. He added a question: “10 held by H for the big guy?” One of the recipients of the mail, Anthony Bobulinski, has said that the “big guy” referred to Joe Biden and that “H” referred to Hunter. Bobulinski was a guest of Trump at one of the 2020 presidential debates.

But Gilliar told the Wall Street Journal in 2020: “I would like to clear up any speculation that former Vice President Biden was involved with the 2017 discussions about our potential business structure. I am unaware of any involvement at anytime of the former vice president. The activity in question never delivered any project revenue.”

Three days after the email was sent, a draft agreement setting up Oneida was circulated. It shows each partner would receive 20 percent, including Jim Biden. No mention is made of Joe Biden. The company agreement signed on May 22, 2017, had the same allocation. Oneida was to hold 50 percent of another corporate entity called SinoHawk. Neither Gilliar nor James Biden responded to requests for comment.

The Wall Street Journal said that it had reviewed corporate records and found no role for Joe Biden. The Washington Post, in an extensive report on the CEFC dealings, also did not find evidence that Joe Biden personally benefited from or knew details about the transactions with CEFC. The Biden campaign at the time denied he had any role.

So one guy involved in the deal claims that there was 10% of the CEFC venture set aside for Joe Biden, but another guy involved in the deal denies that, a draft agreement doesn't mention Joe Biden, the final agreement doesn't mention Joe Biden, and both WSJ and WaPo examined CEFC and saw no involvement or benefit to Joe Biden. The weight of the evidence here seems very one-sided to me, and it seems reasonable to conclude that Bobulinski is either lying or exaggerating. Do you disagree?

Thanks for that link. I was intrigued by the passage "Freeh worked with [Hunter] to help a Romanian tycoon evade bribery charges". It links to a NY post story with more details. Describing Louis Freeh as "former FBI Director" seems a bit misleading in this context, because at the time that he talked to Hunter he was a partner in a law firm, not a government official. It's (unfortunately) common for government officials to cash in on the contacts they made to pivot into a lucrative private practice, and in my ideal world that wouldn't happen. But I read the email between Freeh and Hunter as just a referral in the form of "hey I have a client that could use legal representation with criminal charges he's facing", and I don't see anything wrong with that. The fact that Freeh gave $100k to Biden's grandkids shows just how much these people can rake in the cash, but referral fees are neither illegal nor necessarily unethical (I once referred a client to another attorney that was probably worth $1000 and the attorney sent me a $20 amazon gift card which was kind of funny).

It's obvious Freeh made a "donation" in 2017 hoping he could convince Joe Biden to get him more client referrals. That's definitely slimey, but I don't see where you claim that Joe Biden was "bribed" by a Romanian tycoon to make charges go away. The follow-up NYpost story says there was no evidence Joe Biden ever followed up with Freeh (probably because Joe Biden was planning to be president rather than a consultant or whatever).

The Washington Post also reports that Hunter organised various trade deals with 10% of his fee earmarked for "the big guy", said to be referring to Joe Biden.

I'm confused, did you read your own link?

James Gilliar, a business associate summarizing the allocation of the equity in Oneida Holdings LLC., in the email, wrote how four partners would get 20 percent each, except for Jim Biden, who would get 10 percent. He added a question: “10 held by H for the big guy?” One of the recipients of the mail, Anthony Bobulinski, has said that the “big guy” referred to Joe Biden and that “H” referred to Hunter. Bobulinski was a guest of Trump at one of the 2020 presidential debates.

But Gilliar told the Wall Street Journal in 2020: “I would like to clear up any speculation that former Vice President Biden was involved with the 2017 discussions about our potential business structure. I am unaware of any involvement at anytime of the former vice president. The activity in question never delivered any project revenue.”

Three days after the email was sent, a draft agreement setting up Oneida was circulated. It shows each partner would receive 20 percent, including Jim Biden. No mention is made of Joe Biden. The company agreement signed on May 22, 2017, had the same allocation. Oneida was to hold 50 percent of another corporate entity called SinoHawk. Neither Gilliar nor James Biden responded to requests for comment.

The Wall Street Journal said that it had reviewed corporate records and found no role for Joe Biden. The Washington Post, in an extensive report on the CEFC dealings, also did not find evidence that Joe Biden personally benefited from or knew details about the transactions with CEFC. The Biden campaign at the time denied he had any role.

So one guy involved in the deal claims that there was 10% of the CEFC venture set aside for Joe Biden, but another guy involved in the deal denies that, a draft agreement doesn't mention Joe Biden, the final agreement doesn't mention Joe Biden, and both WSJ and WaPo examined CEFC and saw no involvement or benefit to Joe Biden. The weight of the evidence here seems very one-sided to me.

Your first point is fair, and I don't really disagree with your second point. In an ideal world, there wouldn't be even a whiff of nepotistic graft anywhere near the highest position of the land, but that's never going to happen. Given how far we are from that reality, I sort of understand the general lack of interest on the topic.

I don't think I was aware of that but no, that moves the needle very slightly but isn't enough. It seems plausible that "big guy" is indeed Joe Biden but the deal details he outlines are somewhat vague and it doesn't seem to have been consummated. I'm not exactly clear on what the accusation is here, is the idea that Joe Biden was exploiting his political position for monetary gain? We already know from the tax returns he released that him and his wife made $17 million in a year primarily just from public speaking and book deals. Is the idea that he made even more from influence peddling? That seems plausible, but an unconsummated deal vaguely outlined in an email is weak evidence.

Had this occurred, and we had Twitter employees citing a statement from the WH as reason for censoring it, we'd have a much stronger case to say it was the result of government pressure with Twitter laundering a false statement.

By "WH" do you mean the Trump White House?

I don’t see how any illusion of choice is relevant here, choice between what?

The reference is to the George Carlin bit about how concentrated power makes people think they have choice by offering different coffee and bagel flavors, but not anything meaningful. I don't really know how the analogy is supposed to map though, I think @KMC might have jumbled their understanding of it.

The emails make it clear the management at Twitter reflexively did not want the Hunter story to spread, and they either deluded themselves or made up the "hacked materials" excuse as a pretext to suppressing the story. In the end, the suppression likely became way bigger of a story than the story itself, to the point that even Democratic lawmakers were contacting Twitter to tell them what a boneheaded move that was.

When this story first came out, I was skeptical about the laptop in part because Rudy Guiliani was the source but since then I don't have any doubts that this was really Hunter Biden's laptop and emails. I still don't know how this was supposed to be such a smoking gun. Hunter is obviously a fuck up, and I think it's obvious that he only got executive positions because of who his father is, but the attempts to stretch this up the chain haven't really delivered so far, even an another two years after.

That's fair. I wasn't intending to fog their statement and your interpretation is reasonable. The overall claim is still a bit vague, and there's no indication the FBI told Zuckerberg to do anything nor does he say if the FBI said anything about the veracity of this upcoming dump. After the Rogan interview, FBI said as much and Meta also said "“The FBI shared general warnings about foreign interference — nothing specific about Hunter Biden".

What's odd is that Mark Zuckerberg has gone on the record saying he was contacted by the FBI about the laptop story being Russian Misinformation.

This is not true. What Zuckerberg said is that the FBI contacted him with a generalized warning about a potential "Russian propaganda dump" before the Hunter laptop story came out. Rogan asked him if the FBI specifically say they needed to be on guard for that story and Zuckerberg says "No, I don't remember if it was that specifically, but it basically fit the pattern".

doesn't he have lawyers telling him to shut the hell up?

You can lead a horse to water...

I share your reluctance writ large about pathologizing people who stray outside acceptable norms but I'm confident enough that bipolar disorder is real and enough of a discrete phenomenon. I've had many clients who were diagnosed bipolar, and also had to psychiatrically commit my ex-girlfriend twice against her will during really bad manic episodes (as you can imagine it was extremely upsetting). It's eerie just how similar the symptoms are between wildly different individuals: frantic/pressured speech, grandiosity, high-energy, severe lack of sleep, severe loss of appetite, and serious psychosis and delusions at its worst.

Another week, another charlatan exposed, this time it's the popular health and fitness influencer known as the Liver King aka Brian Johnson. First, this is what the guy looks like and despite being 45 years old, the dude is obviously fucking ripped as fuck. Basically everyone had openly speculated (most famously Joe Rogan) that the guy was on the juice because it's just not possible to have and maintain a body composition like that without some serious injection help. Johnson has been asked this multiple times and he has always steadfastly denied ever using steroids and even insulted his detractors as narrow-minded idiots who can't dream big. He even put out a fake confession video with "prop" needles stuck to bone marrow and liver where he jokes about revealing his steroid stack, and goes out of his way to say "my camera man found the needles, I don't even know where to get this stuff!". Meanwhile, he continued to rack up millions of followers on social media and he turned that into a very successful "ancestral supplements" business that he bragged was taking in $100 million in yearly revenue.

The bodybuilding youtuber known as More Plates More Dates (who himself openly discusses his past and present steroid use) had an hour video on Johnson where he discusses some leaked emails. The emails were to a bodybuilding consultant from Johnson, and Johnson openly talks about the multiple different steroids he takes, costing about $12,000 a month.

Johnson's immediate response was a little bizarre:

“In a weird way, I’m grateful for the recent events that have shed light on this complicated-as-fuck topic,” Liver King said in a statement to The Daily Beast. He followed up by “humbly requesting” that a mainstream podcast has him on to discuss his lifestyle. “I model, teach and preach a simple, elegant solution called ‘Ancestral Living’—The 9 Ancestral Tenets—so our people no longer have to suffer... so we can collectively express our highest and most dominant form! This is my fight!” he said.

But eventually, he owns up to it and explicitly says "I lied".

Despite the accusations, there doesn't seem to be a dispute that the Liver King eats what he preaches, with the vast majority of his diet being composed of meat, organs, and bone marrow. The supplements he was selling were basically freeze-dried granulated organs, which doesn't actually sound like a bad idea if you hate the taste of liver but still want its nutrients. There's also no doubt that Johnson works out like crazy, putting in what seem like two solid workout sessions a day (Granted, his recovery capacity is obviously assisted by steroid use).

The psychology at play is what is fascinating to me. In the emails, Johnson said he needed help with steroid management because he was planning to be the public face of a supplement company he was hoping would go big, and he was having trouble dealing with fat on his lower back. The fundamentals of his business seem sound, the supplements he was hawking don't seem completely useless, and he's charismatic and enthusiastic enough that he probably would've been ok without steroid use. Maybe it's just cover for his muscle dysmorphia, but he believed maintaining an impossible physique was foundational to his business success. Then he just lied and lied about it when asked, and only admitted when he got caught completely red-handed.

It's wild to me how people can brazenly lie and expect to keep getting away with it. A lot of them do indeed get away with it, at least for a while, and maybe that's just aided by a favorable media environment that they build around themselves. The nerdy scrutinizers that raise suspicions don't usually have that much reach, and MPMD's hour-long video just happened to be shocking and egregious enough to go viral and force a confrontation. Also, I've been vaguely aware of social media influencers, but I don't think I appreciated just how fabulously lucrative being successful on that front can be. I wonder how much the financial incentives encourage this kind of pathological lying.

Also, I don't really understand the relentless drive to pursue millions of dollars in wealth when your life is already great. If I was to fantasize about what I would do with fuck you levels of money, I'd play video games and have sex...which I already do. Maybe I'd travel way more??

Also also, I often wonder if I watch too much youtube, but man this platform still fucking delivers. I love it so much that it's almost embarrassing.

It's commendable you put in so much effort in this reply. Well done.

I love good documentaries and wish I could find better recommendations, but I am inherently suspicious of how rigorous the fact-checking process is for the average documentary. I stopped watching documentaries because I just don't trust them at baseline, and I don't really have the time/energy to waste on ones that don't meet the threshold. I've been complaining about this since at least 2019:

An example of a documentary I hated was "Whose Streets?" (2017) even though I'm an avid black lives matter supporter. The documentary had a string of random people being interviewed and making all these wild assertions in their living room with no indication whatsoever that any of it was verified or fact-checked. It was so fucking frustrating to watch I gave up after only a few minutes. Of course, it fucking has 98% on RT.

So question for you Mr. Dog but also to everyone, what heuristics do you use to find compelling documentaries that retain factual grounding?