@ymeskhout's banner p
BANNED USER: on request

ymeskhout


				

				

				
14 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 20:00:51 UTC

				

User ID: 696

Banned by: @ZorbaTHut

BANNED USER: on request

ymeskhout


				
				
				

				
14 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 20:00:51 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 696

Banned by: @ZorbaTHut

Leftist video game youtuber Hbomberguy just put out a remarkable two hour video. Ostensibly, all he set out to do at first was investigate the origin of the "Oof" death sound used in the obscenely popular video game Roblox. The basic story was not that difficult to piece together: a few years ago another guy noticed "Oof" in an older video game called Messiah where the sound effect credits listed Joey Kuras and Tommy Tallarico. Tallarico owns an audio company named after himself, and Kuras worked for that company. Kuras is a prolific sound effects designer who worked on a ton of video games over the years, and is still quietly plugging away in the sound effects industry.

Tallarico's personality is much more bombastic and showy in contrast to Kuras. While he has bona fide creative chops as a video game composer, he hasn't really worked on anything since his career peak in the 90s and 2000s. He seems content to ride the coattails of his past achievements, and recently used his semi-celebrity status to seek crowdfunding for a new home video game console called the Intellivision Amico. The Amico was announced by Tallarico way back in 2018 but its release has been repeatedly delayed with no sign that it's getting any closer to existing. Citing the delays, Tallarico turned to asking for money through crowdfunding campaigns and was successful, raising at least $18 million dollars. Tallarico launched at least four different funding campaigns, each one on a different crowdfunding platforms (curious!) before abandoning the final attempt after raising only $58k. During all these delays, leaked internal documents showed that the Amico was going to use some shitty obsolete hardware and Tallarico of course responded by threatening lawsuits and calling people "gaming racists".

Back to Roblox. They apparently got the "Oof" sound from some random sound library that included it without permission from Tallarico's company. When Tallarico found out his company's sound was being used by an obscenely lucrative video game corporation, he sprung to action and demanded a shitton of money from Roblox in licensing fees. The two kind of danced around this issue for a couple of years, working out a deal involving royalties before Roblox eventually stopped using the sound. Curiously however, when Tallarico talked about who exactly created the sound, he spoke vaguely and frequently alternated between "we" and "I" when discussing its progeny. Hbomberguy does some research and concludes (for many many reasons) that the evidence overwhelmingly favors crediting Joey Kuras as the sound's creator, not Tallarico. But if Tallarico is exaggerating about this for prestige points, is he lying about anything else? This is the part where the video goes completely off the rails. Hbomberguy was originally going to stop the video at this point, but curiosity got the better of him and he went down a deep deep rabbit hole and started fact-checking everything.

As an illustrative example, Tallarico repeatedly highlights how he is the recipient of the Guinness World Record for the "person who has worked on the most video games in their lifetime" with credits in at least 275 games, maybe even 350 games depending on how Tallarico tells it. At this point it's kind of a running joke that the world records Guinness bandies about are increasingly ludicrously specific (highest number of organic cherry pies eaten while bouncing on a pogo stick at sea level or whatever). Guinness makes money by selling its books but the organization also offers its services to anyone who has the $10,000 or so it costs to have an official Guinness world record adjudicator show up in person for your marketing stunt. So the organization is less an authoritative body and more of a novelty commercial business, but whatever. Tallarico's world record was apparently bestowed in 2008, but it only shows up in the off-brand "Gamer's Edition" book, and the source for this claim appears to be just something that Tallarico said during an interview. Setting aside the lack of verification for something so banal, can anyone charitably reach anything close to the 275 350 total amount of games? Tallarico has a list of video games he has "worked on" on his official website and the list does have 295 entries. Close enough, right? Well until you realize that Tallarico inflates the number of entries in many ways, including listing games with "Special Thanks" credits, or listing the exact same game multiple times depending on how many systems it was released on. For example, Tallarico definitely did the music for Earthworm Jim and its sequel, but instead of having two mentions for Earthworm Jim, he has it eighteen times on his list. Guinness gave Tallarico a certificate for his "worked on the most video games in their lifetime" claim in 2008. For whatever reason, Guinness thereafter revised the language and gave him an updated record certificate for "most prolific composer of video game soundtracks" in 2014 instead. The coup de grâce is that Tallarico kept and displays both certificates in a bid to also inflate the number of total world records he holds.

I don't know for sure if there's an overarching lesson here. Tallarico is quite clearly a flagrantly unapologetic fabulist, and Hbomberguy's video is deliciously entertaining solely for the sheer brazenness of it all. The biggest surprise in my opinion is that Tallarico managed to get away with this for so long, despite regularly interacting with a nerdy demographic I would assume would be especially fastidious about video game history claims. But no one seems to have bothered to check any of his claims, until now. There's still a lot of alpha in being skeptical and googling shit. Be safe out there.

Notice that I did not mention reproduction.

Yep, clean-up was by far the worst problem. Having to wash everything was bad but having to leave it out somewhere to dry...horrible

Alright, I'll take one for the team and describe my own experience with "masturbatory aids" as they like to call them. I'm a SuperStraight™ guy with what normally is a healthy sex life (I keep a spreadsheet) but the first time I ever got these was in the middle of the first pandemic winter where NOTHING was going on. I was single then and I distinctly remember reading the news about some upcoming new variant and knew I had to brace myself for a long dry-spell. But I had pandemic relief money to burn (how ironic) and so I splurged on some purchases and bought two different kinds. One was about the size and shape of a large egg, relatively flimsy, and intended to be more-or-less disposable after a few uses. The other kind had an integrated spinning coil built inside and was intended to be reusable.

The pros are obvious to delineate: these things feel way better than your hand based solely on increased surface area contact. The spinner coil one especially felt great because it created a vacuum suction that caused the coil to tighten. You definitely didn't have to work as hard or risk as much friction with these things, that much is true.

Cons? Clean up. It was just so gross having to rinse all this with soap and water after you're done. And just washing it wouldn't be the end of it since you had to leave it out somewhere to dry for like a day.

I remember one night, once civilization started waking up again, I had brought a girl home after a date and realized I had left one of these things drying on my kitchen counter. I quickly covered it up and threw it in the garbage without her noticing. After that I realized that the downsides just were not worth it, and I wondered if maybe it discouraged me from pursuing real vaginas. So I just threw everything away and didn't think about them again. Maybe if somehow I ended up in a situation where money was plentiful but women were not (like a covid winter), I'd consider buying them again.

Beyond masturbatory aids, the only male sex toy I ever used semi-regularly was a cock ring. This was kind of a mixed bag with regards to whether it helps or not, so I eventually just threw it away. But for women, they're so sexually complicated and high-variance that you encounter no shortage of creative new devices intended to enhance their pleasure, and I'm a fan of using sex toys with my partners. The Magic Wand is so good as an all-purpose workhorse, but pretty much any woman likely also has figured out her special brand of vibrator by the time she's in her mid-20s. Butt plugs are also great (for her, not me) also leashes and nipple clamps for the freaks out there. Whatever works, especially if they're fun.

I'm not convinced it's about danger. Rather, it seems more about how not fucking (real) women is seen as the lowest of low-status for men. It's fascinating to me how widespread this revulsion is, even among purportedly progressive crowds. Chasing pussy is almost seen as an essential purpose for men to have, because that's how we get military conquests, scientific discoveries, and commercial enterprises. A man who can fully satisfy themselves sexually with a toy has a closed feedback loop. He can then confidently shut the castle gates on a dizzying array of extra-curricular endeavors because...why bother? A man who checks out of that race just outed themselves on a visceral level as demonstrably useless to society and the impulse to shun them is strong.

This is quite an interesting comment and I appreciate the sentiment. I'm narcissistic enough that I'm not shy about acknowledging that I am practically better than most people, on most metrics. If I could pull a lever and have 535 of my clones take over Congress, I would struggle to think of a practical reason not to.

Egalitarianism can be thought of in different axes, and I don't have a ready non-arbitrary defense for why some axes are better than others. I don't think we should care about egalitarianism when we're designing spaceships or graduating doctors. And as I said about democracy, I also have no attachment towards egalitarian political decision-making. If I express discomfort in my post, it's primarily anchored in seeing a bargain reneged upon, and under dishonest circumstances. If we're propping up a system that says one-man/one-vote, we should mean it. If we're making exceptions to the rule, we should be transparent and honest about it.

I seriously applaud you for using ATIP in that manner. Bravo.

Maine and Vermont let people vote from prison. Do you have any evidence that this leads to bad policies being implemented?

Running elections seems to come with high fixed costs and low marginal costs, so it doesn't seem likely that additional votes would materially increase costs. Throwing additional votes into the tabulation machinery seems way cheaper than having real life bureaucrats carefully scrutinizing individual registrations as I outlined in my examples.

but how many felons aren't bothering to try and register in the first place?

If Florida is any indication, about 10% of the adult population has a felony record and unable to vote and few (~100k?) have bothered to register to vote. This tends to be true in most states that have post-release disenfranchisement, unless restoration is automatic, few people bother trying. Running elections seems to come with high fixed costs and low marginal costs, so it doesn't seem likely that additional votes would materially increase costs.

The more people you can cut with general rules (e.g. only landowning married men can vote), the less expensive dealing with edge cases becomes.

I would agree there's likely a "reverse Laffer curve" where increasingly high disenfranchisement gets progressively cheaper, but I don't see your argument for where we are currently on the curve. If cost was your only concern then you could justify getting rid of voting entirely.

As you point out, it's not as though the current population of disenfranchised felons has a major number of otherwise-innocents who are just being persecuted in this way

There's a way to steelman the opposing view. A lot of the distinction between felony and misdemeanor seems arbitrary to me and the best example is DUI. I think driving drunk evinces horrifically bad judgment, especially if you do it multiple times, but in almost every state you have to get caught drunk driving at least 4 times within a given time period before it can count as a felony. The jail penalties ramp up, as do the collateral consequences (losing driver's licence, etc), but it's notable how reluctant state legislatures are in just declaring DUIs to be a felony. I think the reason why is because DUIs are by far the most "intersectional" of crimes in that almost any slice of the population is liable to trip up and get one. Because of that, they keep the misdemeanor gloves on.

There are also a bunch of edge cases. I once had a guy get charged with burglary (felony) because he stole one can of red bull from a walmart. Normally that would just be misdemeanor shoplifting, but it got upgraded to burglary because he already had a trespass order against him (burglary = intent to commit a crime + entering without permission, prosecutor dropped the charges because prosecuting a felony over $3 was not worth it to anyone). Similarly, I had a client who pawned off jewelry given to her by her boyfriend. Months later, boyfriends beats the shit out of my client and she reports it to the police. Literally the same day, the boyfriend's mom files a police report claiming that the jewelry my client pawned off was stolen. The value was something like $70, which assuming the mom wasn't lying would be just petty theft, but because my client pawned it she got hit by trafficking stolen property felony. [fyi I got her charges dropped once I showed the prosecutor the timing indicated the mom's police report was retaliatory]

Another thing to consider is how nominally neutral laws can still be enforced in a biased and targeted manner. The difference in jail time between a misdemeanor and a low-level felony for a first time offender is almost non-existent. But the collateral consequences of a felony conviction are severe. People lose gun rights and voting rights, and in some places they're also categorically prohibited from pursuing entire professions and, less formally, makes it difficult to find housing and employment. Felony convictions are a modern day legal vehicle used to stuff a bunch of collateral punishments on people. If you don't like someone, just find a way to peg them with a felony and you've virtually guaranteed their pariah status for life on a whole host of issues, not just voting.

I'm not sure exactly why you think it would be so expensive to restrict the franchise.

I wrote my reasons in detail, did you miss that above?

What metric do you consider to determine whether your voting filter is a good idea? The fact that a system was used historically doesn't tell us about its merits.

I don't disagree that this is a risk, but I would pushback on how generalizable it is. Almost all my criminal caseload involves acts that are unambiguously wrong (dude stabs a guy, man shoots a gun, woman shoplifts, etc.) where the accused is not at all surprised that they're being charged with a crime. Granted, edge cases exist (esp. self-defense) but I don't think every law can be accused of being impenetrable to the common person.

Yes, I already acknowledged this as an argument for restricting the franchise but my point here is that you should also justify the increased bureaucracy costs. Do you think it's worthwhile?

One thing I didn't touch upon is that it seems like a good policy to let ex-felons vote at least as a way to encourage them to be part of civil society again. Disenfranchising them seems like it would encourage them to just check out completely.

I don't doubt that insincere objections exist, but why do you suspect I'm guilty of that here? If perfectly tracking disenfranchisement was implemented at zero then yes I would change my mind. I would still question why people should lose the right to vote but as I said I don't really care about voting in general, and at least in your hypothetical scenario we wouldn't be burning up resources for what to me seems to be a pointless endeavor.

Among comparable countries, voter ID and mandatory registration are common, but considered by many to be immoral in the US.

Maybe I'm thinking of something else, but who thinks mandatory registration is immoral? I don't think either policy is immoral, but I do question the utility of voter ID. I think the fears about voter suppression from requiring people to get an ID are severely overblown, but I can't say they're zero in a country where ID cards are not mandatory. Voter ID policy can only help mitigate against "impersonation fraud" (and not completely, since fake IDs exist) and I'm not sure how much of a problem that is. The effects one way or another seem slight, so I don't really have a strong opinion on voter ID.

Reading the minds of today's political enemies by assigning them dimmest motives using more than a hundred year old example would disprove a lot more than merely felon disenfranchisement. It also an example of a genetic fallacy.

That's not what I intended to communicate, all I said is that pretextual excuses have been used before to suppress the vote. Whether or not pretextual excuses are used now is a different analysis and I explained why I'm suspicious of some efforts.

I write in favor of letting criminals vote. The main argument is that gatekeeping the franchise is not easy and requires a lot of state capacity to securely enforce it. Most of the world lets current and former criminals vote, and I generally don't find arguments to restrict it to be very convincing:

It's not that crazy, because the norm across the world is letting people vote from prison. Literally ballot boxes installed in prisons. To the extent there are any limitations imposed, they're doled out selectively, with apparently fewer than a handful of countries even considering restricting the vote of criminals post-release. In contrast, the United States is rather unique in its disenfranchisement zeal. Only Vermont, Maine, and DC allow voting from prison, but otherwise, the norm in most other states is automatic voting restoration upon release. In total, about 4.6 million Americans can't vote today because of a felony conviction, which is about triple the percentage it was in 1976, but down from a peak in 2016.

Despite all the words here, I'm actually not someone who particularly cares about democracy. While I can acknowledge the strong correlation between democratic governments and overall quality of life, I'm in the consequentialist camp on this issue. Give me Hong Kong under British colonial rule over democratic India any day of the week. Beyond that, voting is a waste of time on an individual level and not something I ever engage in (to answer the tiresome what if everyone thought that? retort: "Then I would vote"), and my anarchist foibles generally leave me politically stranded.

But my egalitarian foibles are why felony disenfranchisement bothers me. A steelman could be either consequential or an appeal to fairness. If you take a "wisdom of crowds" defense of democracy --- that it is a mechanism to arrive at better policies --- then perhaps giving former criminals a say would lead the ship astray. But most of the world seems to function OK despite letting criminals vote, and neither Vermont or Maine seem notably dysfunctional in any way (maybe DC does, but not sure how much you can pin that on the voting prison population). But even if consequences be damned, perhaps violating the social contract is cause enough to muzzle you. I concede it's a slightly stronger argument, but I'm not convinced the justification isn't used as a pretextual excuse to tip the scales in some political party's favor. This wouldn't be a novel effort, as Mississippi implemented literacy tests and poll taxes in 1890 with the express purpose of indirectly suppressing the black vote without explicitly violating the 15th Amendment. The state's governor, James Vardaman, said outright in 1903 the restrictions were imposed "for no other purpose than to eliminate the nigger from politics". Nowadays, nefarious motivations require a little more finesse. Good data on felon voting trends is hard to come by, but the obvious demographic skew (blacks are significantly more likely both to vote for Democrats and to have a felony record), combined with the energy in sustaining felony disenfranchisement coming almost exclusively from Republicans, is enough to sustain my suspicions that this is a pretextual exercise.

Beyond whether or not disenfranchisement is the right thing to do, there's also the question of implementation:

The next step further up --- restoration upon completion of supervision --- is where the difficulty really starts to ramp up. Unlike inmate rosters updated on the daily, when exactly someone's supervision ends is information that will be buried within reams of figurative dossiers in filing cabinets scattered across the state. There's nominally a system in place, such as the National Voting Rights Act, which allows different parts of the country to keep everyone up to date about voting registration. But I've written about how judicial record systems have to straddle an unenviable position: simultaneously maintaining an iron grip on legacy compatibility (imagine the nightmare of a computer upgrade wiping out entire convictions) while cracking the door just widely enough to allow cross-pollination with other systems.

Consider the situation in detail. Let's say that I, your favorite public defender, am able to track down a judgment & sentence order from the 1990s and find that my client was sentenced to X months in prison and Y months of supervision after release. I can't just plug that into a date calculator. First, I would need to know if this was the only charge they served time under, including, potentially, an extradition hold for a warrant from another jurisdiction. Then I'd need to track down whether any early release for good behavior applied to their charge, including noting any legislative changes that may have occurred and been retroactively applied. Even if I have a definitive release date, the length of supervised release is far less static. Maybe there was a court order that ended it early, or maybe there was a change in the law for that specific offense, or maybe their supervision time was tolled or extended for whatever reason by the probation authority. And so on. Despite what I do for a living, I have absolutely no confidence that I am able to accurately calculate the precise end of someone's supervision, and this is why I always leave that task to the math wizards at the Department of Corrections. I hope and pray to Allah they get it right, because there's no fucking way I'll know otherwise.

And beyond implementation by the state, there's also the question of how normal people are expected to navigate the cobwebs:

Pamela Moses' case in Tennessee illustrates how much of a bog this is even for experienced legal professionals. Moses was previously convicted of an evidence tampering felony, and in 2019, she tried to run for mayor. Election officials told her she was not eligible because she had not yet finished her probation. A court echoed what those officials said, but her probation officer later signed off on a certificate of restoration that Moses submitted when she registered. Moses was convicted of voter fraud and sentenced to six years in prison before her conviction was overturned on appeal. The probation officer was wrong about her probation term being over, but that wouldn't have mattered anyway because her predicate conviction --- evidence tampering --- was one of the few Tennessee offenses that led to permanent disenfranchisement. This was a fact that neither the probation officer, his supervisor, nor the trial judge knew about, as seen from page 24 of the trial transcript (cleaned up):

PROSECUTOR: The tampering with evidence we're addressing today, which is permanent. I don't remember all the ones. I know murder, probably rape ---

THE COURT: That's something I didn't know. Are you telling me if you get convicted of tampering with evidence, you can never vote? Where is that in the law?

DEFENSE: It's titled-- I think it's 39-15 or 39-17 where it talks about the interference with government operations. Those are ---

PROSECUTOR: It's 40-29-204.

THE COURT: "Those convicted after July 1, 1996, but before July 1, 2006 --- those convicted after July 1, 2006, any of the offenses set forth in one and two above, voter fraud, treason, murder in the first degree, aggravated rape." And then it goes on to say, "Any other violation of title 39 chapter 16 part one, four, and five, designated as a felony" --- so are you telling me I've got to go back and look at 39-16?

PROSECUTOR: Yes. Now you have to, and that's where the tampering with evidence, along with --- it falls under, like, bribery, contraband, false pretense, the ones that are felonies.

Apparently, it's impossible to wade through the cobwebs of cross-referencing statutory codes without tripping up somehow, even if wading boots are part of your job uniform. And absent malicious intent, these examples illustrate how easy it is for mistakes to happen. What purpose does punishing these types of mistakes accomplish? Focusing one's ire toward the people ensnared by the cobwebs doesn't do anything to get rid of the cobwebs. Getting rid of the cobwebs gets rid of the cobwebs.

And finally:

I’ve already made my position on felony disenfranchisement clear: I don’t think there should be any. If you believe otherwise, that’s fine, but the argument in favor needs to take into account the additional resources such a regime necessarily eats up. You need higher state capacity to check people’s convictions, calculate the terms of their sentence, and tabulate their LFOs, and an entire additional apparatus to investigate and prosecute scofflaws. Any argument in favor of disenfranchising felons has to explain why these additional costs are worthwhile.

I know I have my biases but this comes across as uniquely and desperately pathetic. I'm aware that "he begged me to help him" is a common Trump play, but it's at least usually levied towards people in a weaker position relative to him. It's weird to deploy this towards someone who had a much better election Tuesday than Trump did. Also, Low Energy Jeb and Little Marco were all scathing and catchy nicknames, but what the hell is DeSanctimonious supposed to mean??

Ah, I never followed this saga closely so missed out on the detail that it was a deliberate honeytrap.

When I said "calculated to ensnare", I meant it more as "marketed towards". I think that Epstein was using his harem to gain favors and network, I'm not sure if it was indeed a deliberate honeytrap although that's plausible given the age of the people involved.

I agree that proving impairment is harder but I'm not convinced that marijuana DUIs are a serious problem. I've handled dozens of them by now and the modal police report is something like "vehicle sat through two green light cycles without moving" or "vehicle drove 10 miles below the speed limit". They're really good cases to go to trial because although it's obvious the people are high as fuck, there's virtually no evidence they were actually a danger in any way. I definitely cannot say the same about alcohol. Also, some states do have "constructively impaired" limits, Washington for example has a 5 nanogram per se limit.

Maybe I've gotten desensitized to it but I live near several dispensaries and never notice anything. The parks are also chockful of people openly smoking joints, and hilariously the only thing that ever really gets scorn is cigarette smoking.

Regardless, if you hate the smell of marijuana you can just enforce public consumption. Criminalizing possession is enforced by putting people in jail, so I don't understand this round-about way of defending against a nasal assault.

I'm terrible at making political forecasts, but the phrase that keeps coming to mind with Trump and normie voters is "ur scaring the hoes"

One of the nefarious stratagems the Democratic Party engaged in this election was to intentionally boost and generously fund far-right Republican candidates over their more moderate opponents in the Republican primaries. This potentially risky gambit was intended to allow Democratic candidates to coast to an easy victory by knocking out the moderate Republican option from the general election. This strategy was not just an after-thought, as the Dems put in a ton of resources into the effort. In Maryland for example, the Dems spent $1.2 million on Dan Cox's campaign, more than twice the money the candidate raised at that point. I thought then and still think this is dishonorable and contemptible behavior, but from a pure power play perspective, I concede it was a sound tactical decision. All six Republican candidates (3 governors, 1 senator, 2 house) targeted by this play lost the general election, five of them by double-digit margins.

It's important to emphasize that the Dems didn't force Republicans to do anything. All they did was dangle the candidate's Republican bona fides with "oh no it sure would be terrible if this person that loves Trump and still thinks the election was stolen ends up being the nominee oh no" and voters agreed with them. Given how much of a resounding success this was for the Dems, I anticipate we'll see it again in the future.

If so, can the GOP do anything to immunize itself from this effort? Should it even try to? Also, two can play at this game but is this strategy something the GOP can successfully levy? Dems have no shortage of total crazies (as Libs of TikTok can demonstrate) after all. What would that look like and what are some candidates that come to mind?

Do you have any insights as to whether the parties actually believe what they're publicly stating?

It's possible the only reason this happened is because some high-billing lawyers managed to wrestle enough client control to force everyone to face the music. That said, everyone's statement comes across as perfectly reasonable, so it would be surprising if they believed none of what they said.

Epstein's scheme of doling out unprotected sex with barely legal teenagers on his private island was calculated to ensnare rich and powerful people, so it doesn't seem surprising if Dershowitz fell into that. I also think that Epstein's harem of girls would at least appear to be consenting.

For Giuffre, it depends. In rape cases, the identity of the perpetrator is rarely ever in question in my experience. Either the guy is a stranger and is nabbed because of forensic evidence, or the two knew each other, definitely had sex, but one disputes whether it was consensual. Memory is fallible, and I can't imagine what kind of hell these girls were subjected to to keep them compliant in Epstein's harem. This happened so long ago that it was inevitable for the accusation to carry some doubt, and it would not have been honest for Giuffre to ever claim otherwise. Just the same if she said it was definitely not Dershowitz. The only honest answer here is maybe.