site banner

Small-Scale Question Sunday for November 27, 2022

Do you have a dumb question that you're kind of embarrassed to ask in the main thread? Is there something you're just not sure about?

This is your opportunity to ask questions. No question too simple or too silly.

Culture war topics are accepted, and proposals for a better intro post are appreciated.

5
Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

For the more biology inclined among you:

What is the principled difference between Epigenetics [legit science, considered an important new frontier of genetic science], Lamarckism [old-timey predecessor to Darwinian evolution, wrong but not evil], and Lysenkoism [Soviet fallacy that was the demonstration of political correctness in action, wrong and evil]? From 30,000ft it feels to me like the story goes something like Lamarck comes up with it before getting superseded by Darwin, Lysenko revives the idea before getting superseded by Stalin's death and subsequent de-Stalinization efforts under Khruschev, and now it's being revived by modern biologists (with race-grievance experts lurking the background seeking to hijack any actual research to prove their own ends).

The only apologia for Epigenetics on the "it's Lysenko/Lamarck popped in the microwave on thaw" objection has been that epigenetics is more limited in scope than Lysenkoism." But then I read other epigenetics papers and they make claims as wild as Lysenko any day, especially where humans are concerned or humans can be blamed in nature, and at best the field seems like a bit of a motte and bailey.

So what's the real deal? How broadly applicable is epigenetics, and how I do tell good epigenetics from bad epigenetics?

Epigenetics - as a mechanism for inheriting traits, across generations - is severely exaggerated by media, pop science, etc. A number of reasons for this: it's an easy way to escape HBD / blame racism / avoid the impact of genetics, and it just sounds cool. The number of proven cases where 'epigenetic mechanisms' contribute to heritable phenotypic differences in humans is small - especially compared to how "normal" genetics creates every aspect of human biology. On the other hand, epigenetic changes like DNA methylation and histone modification, as well as others, have many, many important effects in biology, just not ones that involve a child inheriting trait from a parent.

Here's a criticism, found in a gwern newsletter, of epigenetic inheritance of trauma