Do you have a dumb question that you're kind of embarrassed to ask in the main thread? Is there something you're just not sure about?
This is your opportunity to ask questions. No question too simple or too silly.
Culture war topics are accepted, and proposals for a better intro post are appreciated.
Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Notes -
@mrvanillasky, why do you hate Sikhs so much? Is it a personal thing or are you in some way representative of a broader anti-Sikh sentiment?
I'm a long way away from both, but I've always viewed them as India's Mormons: religious weirdos that are on average more successful (and less dysfunctional) than their former co-religionists, but whose influence is mostly limited to a single state.
I'm not him, but I can share my own take, despite not really hating Sikhs.
There are two different categories:
Sikhs, in India, and similar to them, Sikhs abroad who have migrated relatively recently.
Sikhs abroad, who left a long time ago, or at least before the 1990s.
Why make this distinction? In the 70s, 80s, fading out by the 2000s, India had a Sikh secessionist movement desiring an independent Khalistan Things got very bloody. A Prime Minister was assassinated, there were pogroms on both sides. A large number of Sikhs fled abroad, to the US, UK or Canada.
The issue is that they took their anger with them. On the other hand, the Sikhs in India aged out of the desire for conflict, or never really had it in the first place. Current relations between Sikhs and other ethnoreligious groups, in India, are largely congenial. Abroad? Oh hell no. They're still malding, and occasionally send money to the very few remaining Sikh terrorist organizations in India, or help out Pakistan. There was a kerfuffle where India was alleged to have assassinated two Khalistani leaders, one in Canada, and one in Pakistan.
Younger Sikhs in the West? They're usually not so heavily indoctrinated, and get along fine. The Sikhs in India, do not, as a whole, really care for an independent state.
If I had to guess, Vanilla is also a part of elitist rightwing circles in India (he's very terminally online). They look down on Sikhs in places like Canada for engaging in a bit of cooking of the books, and the abuse of lax immigration pathways to bring their neighbors' brothers' dog's walker as a "student" who spends more time doing Uber deliveries than studying. This pisses off the locals, and makes things harder for other Indians. I will make it clear that I am sharing an online opinion, and not making an endorsement. I haven't been there personally.
Is this unique for Sikhs? I was thinking pretty much everyone who is from a poor country would have certain percentage of people who have relatives there (or paying customers) and would cheat to help them. Probably not for richer countries as the improvement in lifestyle is not worth the risk, but for a relatively poor country (or sub-community in the country) it would.
Hardly unique, but my impression is that the Sikhs in Canada have it down to an art form.
Oh, another reason came to mind. Canadian Sikhs tend to be very clannish, and regularly form cohesive vote blocks that swing local or even national elections. They force politics in an anti-India direction, since most politicians, left or less left, can't afford to piss them off.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link