site banner

Small-Scale Question Sunday for November 8, 2026

Do you have a dumb question that you're kind of embarrassed to ask in the main thread? Is there something you're just not sure about?

This is your opportunity to ask questions. No question too simple or too silly.

Culture war topics are accepted, and proposals for a better intro post are appreciated.

2
Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

  1. Stoner from John Edward Williams. I haven't finished it yet, but to me Stoner's life was too successful to feel any kind of connection with the protagonist. For now this is the only analysis I can give. I thought it was more like No Longer Human from Dazai. I really liked that, I have felt 失格 (shikkaku), unfit, in being a person since I was in kintergarden and my only regret is not having given in to vices sooner as the protagonist did.

  2. The World of Late Antiquity from Peter Brown. Still few pages. Despite being a more academic book, it seems really easy to read and I'm enjoying the little anecdote of daily life intermixed in the big events.

  3. Mattanza from Theresa Maggio. A nonfiction book about a disappeared tradition fishing method on a remote island (set of Nolan's Odyssey). It made me nostagic for a past I've never lived. These are feelings I am accustomed to. My baseline state, if you will.

I dropped Stoner because his life was too depressing.

What exactly is successful about him at least below the surface?

Everything he has is corrupted.

I used to scoff at the famour Tennyson's quote: "Tis better to have loved and lost than never to have loved at all", but now I think it is fundamentally true.

In a comment I described briefly my story. The main grief of such a story is the agony of the life unlived: all the story I will never get to remember. In my experience, a bad company it's still better than no compagny, contrary to "popular wisdom". I find that sentences like "better be alone than in the wrong crowd" are uttered by two kind of people: (1) copers, like I used to be, who cannot find meaningful relationships, independently from whose fault it is; (2) people who actually have a lot of relationships and cna pick and choose, and when they say being alone, they mean, not going out to party one Saturday, fully knowning that the next day they can organize a coffee date, a soccer match, a car trip or whatever.

Type-1 people call themselves "introverts" as a coping mechanics. As a self-identified "introvert" for almost all my life, I do not think of it as a true existing phenomenon. I think many of them are crying and seething, like I was, and like I always read on the reddit subs dedicated to "introverts".

Type-2 people cannot really comprehend what it is like to have a life of no memories: no joy or sorrow to share, no parties or funeral to attend, just the slow passing of time, waiting for death.

Returning to Stoner: yes, his life was depressing. But there was a life. He did things, had relationships, was implicated in the buffoonery of office politics. All of this is preferable to me to the nothingness I've lived. My last memory was at 19 when I entered University. And then I wake up at 29. I often I have panic attacks when I think about it. I cannot have social media because if I scroll people photos and look at the past, all I see is what I've missed. Where are my photos? Where is my story? Why did I let it happen? Why was I so stupid?

That's why I envy Stoner's depressing life: because there is a life. A corrupt bleak life, but there is something. I am now 31, and in the past three years I have more memories than in the preceding 10, but they are all related to work and study, many of them are bleak. And even this way, it is better than the Void. If I ever were to return to the Void, it shall be with a rope around my neck: never again I will live a dead life.

My life wasn't much better than yours, in some ways worse, better in others, overall it's still a mess, and I'm still working on it, so I understand part of what you're going through. And it's important to look at your life from your perspective, rather than that of others, especially that which you see on social media and in books.

I would say it is better to have someone than no-one, but I would take people who I can relate to and talk to about topics that interest me more than those who are closer to me physically but have I have less in common with.

I would also ask you whether or not you really can't remember anything? Like my memories of my 20s are extremely spotty, (not as spotty as my teens though) but overall, I can still kind of remember periods where I did a particular thing (lone hobby), or talked with a friend of mine, or played some game. All of these are petty events that nobody would write down except in a journal, but they still make up your past, and part of who you are.

And more importantly, the one thing to keep in mind is that as long as there's a difference between today and a month ago, and if you generally feel better, or you're doing better in other ways, that's good enough for now.

Also, there's also the Type-3 group, like ToaKraka, there are people who genuinely are okay with being alone. But I'm not one of them, even if I thought I was when I was younger.

I would also ask you whether or not you really can't remember anything? Like my memories of my 20s are extremely spotty, (not as spotty as my teens though) but overall, I can still kind of remember periods where I did a particular thing (lone hobby), or talked with a friend of mine, or played some game. All of these are petty events that nobody would write down except in a journal, but they still make up your past, and part of who you are.

Before the hiki-period I used to do lots of things: going to school, going to the gym, swimming, playing in an orchestra, having some semblance of a social life even though I was always at the periphery of others' life. This all disappeared at 19 when I closed myself in my room for some kind on unspecified reason. And everyday would become ever more difficult to go out.

It started at 17 when I stopped playing music, then at 18 I stopped going to swimming practice, then went the gym. The thing that hurts the most is that nobody noticed: "Where did nouse go?". Nobody cared, nobody texted me, my parents didn't even noticed. During COVID lockdown, before we knew that the virus wasn't that dangerous and I thought I could die, my only thought was that if I did die because of it, nobody would care, or worse, notice. I did not have a single phone number, a single person to call and check-in. I still have no-one to call for a coffee, for a beer, to go to the beach. I try and try and try. Even now, my favourite colleague, with whom I thought I clicked, has been elusive as to why he cannot have a coffee with. And it was him that proposed the all endeavour of having a coffee. It was pity? I don't actually know. I don't even care anymore. Or better, I care, but to what purpose? The story repeats, always the same, it goes in circles and on and on and on and on.

I stayed inside a prison of my own making for 10 years. I completely lost my 20s. When I say I have no single memory, it is not a literary device: I have not a single memory but watching junk tv, eating junk food and having junk thoughts. The only knowledge I've accrued in these 10 years are various suicide methods and their lethality.

The fact is, I don't even know how I can function. I go to work as a fucking receptionist, and I can smile, I can socialize, I can be funny. Many people have tipped me well and left glaring review for my job. This somehow makes it even worse: if I did dare to go out at 18 could I have had friends? If I did take the job as a beach boy at 18 I could have had colleagues that could have become friends? I dare to say it, could I have been popular and loved and involved in my community instead of a grieving, desperate husk of a human being already dead before death?

And more importantly, the one thing to keep in mind is that as long as there's a difference between today and a month ago, and if you generally feel better, or you're doing better in other ways, that's good enough for now.

I do not feel better. I don't even know how it is possible to recover from the loss of unlived youth, a loss of my own making: I wasn't sick, I didn't go to prison, I wasn't on a coma, I wasn't involved in an accident. I simply stopped living. A living death. I have more money, I have resumed my studies, but I cannot function on a spiritual level. It feels so over. Every thing that I do is colored by the filter of grief, of loss, an all-devouring void: when I talk to people I envy even their toxic ex-es, their bad memories, their pain. I knew a guy who went to prison for aggravated robbery and then found his path and he's doing better: I envy him too. I envy ex-cons too. Because anything is better than absolutely nothing. I cannot tell a story. I don't actually know who I am. I have no reference system to guide my behaviour.

Also, there's also the Type-3 group, like ToaKraka, there are people who genuinely are okay with being alone. But I'm not one of them, even if I thought I was when I was younger.

This was my greatest error: being so involved in my identity as an introvert that I didn't even recognize my social needs. I now think I am actually and undersocialized extrovert. Add to it socially inept parents who couldn't guide me on anything really, I basically nurtured myself since first grade, and I failed miserably in being a parent to myself.

Do you ask your coworker if he wants to go for a coffee? There are few people that will always initiate conversations with you, so there has to be some pull and tug. In general, what I'd offer to you is to just try something that involves socializing with others. Either going outside and joining some kind of club, or just playing some online game that requires communication.

Ultimately, having social links is the most important thing from my perspective. It doesn't need to be in person, they don't need to be close by, but it has to be someone who is there to talk to you pretty every day day, ideally for at least like an hour a day too.

That's what I had, it was online, but I talked for that and more, and it kept me overall in a better state than being completely alone.

Also, did you seek any kind of psychiatric care? Did your parents try to do it on your behalf?

Also, did you seek any kind of psychiatric care? Did your parents try to do it on your behalf?

Tried theraphy when I was 16 and last year, it didn't work. On the contrary, having to pay someone to listen to me was a source of great shame. I want to try medication, but my parents fircely opposed because "they will give you pills". So, yes, I've lost the best part of my youth and I am actively suicidal and planning, but at least I am not taking crazy pills.

Do you ask your coworker if he wants to go for a coffee?

Yes. We agreed for the next day. He told me it will text me time and place. This was the 19th of October. I think that is a quite clear message.

Either going outside and joining some kind of club

I resumed playing in an orchestra. I try to, you know, make myself available. Making plans, organizing something. Either going outside and joining some kind of club. They know I'd like to participate if they organize something, even just going to a pizza place, nothing fancy. All of them have my number. It has been 3 years since I've resumed playing and nobody has ever called. So, my invites are refused and I will note get invited. It basically become a job: I get in, I reharse, the day of the concert I play then I go home. I think that's why I left all my activities in the first place: I was always on the sidelines, always an afterthought, an extra. I have had the exact same experience in whatever group I've tried.

Ultimately, having social links is the most important thing from my perspective. It doesn't need to be in person, they don't need to be close by, but it has to be someone who is there to talk to you pretty every day day, ideally for at least like an hour a day too.

I don't know how it's even possible to have this kind of person in my life. I've been this person: people love to dump their problems to me, and for a while I was even happy because I took it as a sign of trust; but better do not dare to do the same, otherwise I am needy and selfcentered. I completely lost the ability to even give importance to my problems. I can vent but I accept that there will be noone to save me or to help. I could go to a psychiatrist, but I'm afraid that (1) he will report me and I lose the ability to have a job, a driver licence, going to university, (2) I don't really care anymore about my problems. I have not the strength anymore to keep pushing. For whom? With whom shoould I celebrate my life? What "why" do I have to keep going? To accumulate a huge salary? To open my engineering firm? To go on vacation. Social links are really important, yes. But it seems like they will not be part of my life.

In synthesis, the only call I receive is for work, text for the reharse practice timetable, and when some class mate needs something from me, because, despite being a great procrastinator, I still get excellent grades. I am basically a tool in people's life: you don't keep a drill in your hand if you don't need to make a hole, so you don't call me if you don't need my services. All the relationships are transactional.

How much have you talked to them during practice? To be honest, I don't really have any advice about this. I never went went out with anyone from public events, only chatting during.

But in general, at least online, it's quite easy to just talk to people about stuff. But ideally that requires common interest/hobbies, which you both indulge in anyway. I guess practice could be that, but also I don't really know what is there to talk about in regards to that.

Also what instrument do you play?

How much have you talked to them during practice?

We know each other since I was 8 y.o. so yes, I've talked to them, but with one exception several years ago, it never materialized in some kind of relationship outside practice.

With two of them, I spent an entire summer during my middle school years going to the beach and hanging out, an experience that was never repeated in the years that followed.

I also remember that, during high school, I tried inviting some of my classmates to come to the beach, since we had a house in a seaside town. No one ever accepted.

I don't blame them. There is probably something very unappealing in myself that make me hard to get fond of. It has been that way since kintergarten: my first bully was the kindergarten "teacher" that told me that I was retarded (literal word she used, told to my mother too) despite showing some sign of precociousness. And indeed by 3th grade I had taught myself French, Latin, and analytic geometry. Then I saw that nobody cared, on the contrary, I attracted negative attention, so I stopped, and coasted with raw talent until college, where I started studying some more because the material was finally more challenging. But at that point I had lost all my motivation to live and studying was the last of my problems.

Also what instrument do you play?

The clarinet. I used to play the saxophone and the flute too.

More comments