site banner

Small-Scale Question Sunday for November 8, 2026

Do you have a dumb question that you're kind of embarrassed to ask in the main thread? Is there something you're just not sure about?

This is your opportunity to ask questions. No question too simple or too silly.

Culture war topics are accepted, and proposals for a better intro post are appreciated.

2
Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

What is the explanation for why anal sex is pleasant?

It seems kind of absurd as an evolutionary matter, and rather silly to say that God made us that way. Inasmuch as it is doable at all, it ought to be fairly useless for the receptive partner, similar to titty-fucking or oral sex: pleasant and perhaps arousing as a mental matter but not physically stimulating or orgasm inducing. But 70% of women report orgasm from receptive anal (20-30% from anal penetration alone, another 40-50% from penetration plus clitoral stimulation), and even more men report orgasm from receptive anal.

This seems like a significant gap between what is intuitive to me, and what is the lived reality out there, and I can't really account for it as either a useful biological tool that would have evolved naturally, or as something an intelligent creator would have inserted (ba dum tish) either intentionally or by accident.

There's an old joke in atheist communities that God must have a sick sense of humor to put an amusement park in the middle of two sewage plants, but the flip side is that it probably shouldn't surprise you if you hear arcade sounds while monitoring blackwater PH.

The evolutionary theory is that both reproductive and excretory functions have unusual vulnerability to injury and infection, so they tend to get shoved toward the least vulnerable and most core area available (... most of the time. Octopus are weird, though note that they reproduce only once and have very weird evolutionary pressures), and tend to have higher nerve density to help detect and prevent injury. Once that happens, you've now got a big bundle of closely tied sensitive nerve spots, sometimes directly connected to each other, conveniently available in the grossest ways possible. And at least some of the response follows, there: receptive men benefit a lot from having a prostate and there's not really many other good places to put it without doing a remodel of the whole front deck; rimming is very much focused around just how sensitive the ring is; women who are into anal sex often particularly enjoy pressure on the vaginal walls and internal clitoral structure coming from a different angle.

That's particularly goofy for humans because you've got (arguably) concealed ovulation, are sexually active outside of estrus, and both have social and (contested) evolutionary toward varied sex in at least some related species. Most other species with reported anal sex don't actually do it to completion often even for the top, sometimes aren't physically capable of doing it safely for the bottom, or have complex enough relationship structures that it's hard to distinguish sex from dominance displays.

There's a lot of stuff like that, though.

That said, it's also worth pointing out that it also doesn't work for everybody; that's actually some weak evidence against serious broad evolutionary benefit. Even some gay subby guys don't get much out of it, and even for those that do like it, the prep can be more than a little obnoxious.

There's an old joke in atheist communities that God must have a sick sense of humor to put an amusement park in the middle of two sewage plants, but the flip side is that it probably shouldn't surprise you if you hear arcade sounds while monitoring blackwater PH.

I always heard it as a group of engineers debating what kind of engineer God was. The mechanical engineer pointed to the muscles, the electrical engineer to the nerves, the software engineer to the mind, each claiming that was the real essence of God's creation and that God was one of theirs. Then the municipal engineer said that God must be a municipal engineer, because who else would put a recreation area right next to sewage removal.

And at least some of the response follows, there: receptive men benefit a lot from having a prostate and there's not really many other good places to put it without doing a remodel of the whole front deck; rimming is very much focused around just how sensitive the ring is; women who are into anal sex often particularly enjoy pressure on the vaginal walls and internal clitoral structure coming from a different angle.

Yeah, this is what I'm getting at. It seems to be such a good design to achieve pleasure that it must be evolutionarily advantageous in some way, or it would have been selected against. If pleasurable anal sex was a purely negative evolutionary trait, one would expect there to be hard stops in place to prevent it from being pleasurable to warn you not to do it. Instead, we need a whole series of social taboos going back thousands of years across disparate cultures to prevent people from doing it. As a penetrative male partner, I find the novelty good for a once-in-a-blue-moon trip, but generally find the experience to be more trouble than its worth with the designed substitute right there. But female partners regularly request it, love it, prefer it.

That said, it's also worth pointing out that it also doesn't work for everybody; that's actually some weak evidence against serious broad evolutionary benefit. Even some gay subby guys don't get much out of it, and even for those that do like it, the prep can be more than a little obnoxious.

Women report orgasm from vaginal penetration alone at similar rates to anal penetration. So there's something there. I don't know what's going on with gay men, we seem to have given up on actually explaining what homosexuality is as a society and I find myself increasingly unable to understand what is going on there.

[cw: probably more information than anyone here wants to know about gay sex.]

Fair, although there's a tendency to overstate matters.

Even for gay guys that enjoy bottoming, it's very far from a given they can get off from it alone, and even of those who can most can't do so easily or reliably, especially from someone fucking them rather than working themselves with toys. There are bits that either feel very weird or can be painful the first few times or just randomly, and even experienced bottoms can hurt themselves or be hurt. The old chestnut about 'biting the pillow' minimizes the people who actively want it, but you can want it and still need to bite the pillow. And the self-reported numbers for women are very likely a Simpson's Paradox: these surveys (understandably) are asking women who've tried it, and they're a non-representative 20%.

The less comfortable answer is that in the ancestral environment, getting fucked in any hole wasn't exactly a modern ISO-standard romance or cruisy gar bar backroom. The evopsych people tend to focus really heavily on dominance display or bonobo social behaviors (caveat: outside of bonobos, usually not sex to completion even for the top), depending on where their politics fall, and I'm skeptical that any one of them is specifically true, but they all represent something that was probably more a side effect of reproductively useful behavior that had incidental or secondary applications get adapted to. If the same biochem that makes your ape ancestors want to stick it into the right hole means they sometimes miss, it's probably more survivable and capable of going on to reproduction if it's a dominance game or a social night on the town, rather than a knockdown never-let-it-happen brawl, and either might be more reproductive than turning down the horny until your proto-men learn to aim well.

I don't know what's going on with gay men, we seem to have given up on actually explaining what homosexuality is as a society and I find myself increasingly unable to understand what is going on there.

Yeah, it's... kinda annoying, even from the inside view. I'd caution that part of the mess is because there's a tendency to conflate receptive anal sex, same-sex desire, and a specific form of sexual 'gregariousness'. The straight guy who likes to get pegged is going to tell you very little about the gay top who can't keep it up for women, which is going to tell you something different than the person with a scent kink, which is going to tell you something different than the Braeburned.

(caveat: outside of bonobos, usually not sex to completion even for the top)

That's odd- what's going on there? Is the completion not actually the point, even in (and I'm assuming you're not exclusively talking about humans here) animals that don't actually take all that long to run the process to completion?

Yeah, for humans penetrative intercourse is a bit more straightforward. There's some fun games you can have with a top that demonstrates self-control and stamina, but outside of them or having taken Benadryl, someone getting off is kinda the point.

For animals, it gets messy, and that's one of the reasons evopsych tends to end up with a lot of just so stories.

[cw: frank discussion of non-human animal intercourse. Sorry, this stuff was a big topic in the Is Gay Natural wars of the early 2000s, so I know a lot more than I'd want to on the specifics.]

Sometimes it's not clear that sex is the point. Dogs are the standard example here: as much as evopsych will often use 'dominance game' as a handwave, it's pretty clear at least some of the behavior falls wholly in that category. Domestic dogs, coyotes, and wolves will mount, hump, and show signs of physical arousal regardless of the sex of the thing being humped. Penetration is less common, but it's well-documented, and just as importantly tends to be short. The same humping gesture shows up when the top animal doesn't get remotely erect, with female dogs mounting, or where the top completely unaligned with anything to penetrate, so on. Meanwhile, the same specific animal can mount and achieve completion externally, or self-stimulate to completion, and doing so isn't fast or subtle.

Coincidentally, they're also a species that probably shows JohnFalstaff's theory that evolution would find a way to discourage anal sex. Penis-in-anus sex to completion would be physically dangerous for both dogs among same-size breeds... but that's something that affects the penetrating animal as well as the penetrated one. It's also downstream of a whole lot of specific anatomy stuff that's tied to the heterosexual reproductive arms race in canines, which has impacted canine and vulpine species that are solitary and don't have the dominance or same-sex behaviors.

Sometimes it's clearly sex, but it's also not really tied to completion and especially completion with penetration. Deer will go through the full mating process as if the other male were a receptive female, albeit usually reaching release by outercourse (and antler-play leading to climax during rut is still better-documented than actual anal sex); at least with captive herds, a majority of male deer do it, even where female deer are available. Wild horse herds are known for it, too.

In those cases, penetration is pretty rare, and it's usually not tied to the actual release when it does happen. The standard evopsych explanation here is 'practice', or clearing out semen, but it's hard to tell what the internal experience is.

Sometimes it's just getting rocks off, and they don't seem to care about what or how. Goats are notoriously horny fuckers, and if they're isolated from females they'll mount each other (or anything with a hole). They're very much in the 'fast-and-often' mating approach, to the point where 'driveway' het goat breeding can take less than ten seconds, but again you'll see outercourse for completion more often the penetration when it comes to anal.

And then you do have central examples of actual anal sex, with a strong, and it's noteworthy how rare it seems to be in mammals. Rams are the single clearest example, with 5-8% of males preferring males exclusively or near-exclusively, even during estrus season and even when given a choice between a female and a male. There's some uncertainty -- the studies restrain both the female and receptive male, which for lesbian sheep reasons might conflate the matter -- but it also shows up in wild herds and is a common problem for small sheep breeders, so it's probably about as good as you get. They do genuine intercourse, of the fast-and-often style.

Thanks; that explains a lot of the "well, it's natural" and "but maybe only in certain animals, not necessarily for human beings" sides of the are/do equation, respectively.

It's also interesting to notice that humans exhibit all of those animal behaviors already (at least by proxy, sometimes also in fact).

It's also downstream of a whole lot of specific anatomy stuff

Humans are quite fortunate it isn't actually a bone.

and that's one of the reasons evopsych tends to end up with a lot of just so stories.

Sure, but that seems to me to not be using evopsych properly (though given most of that fight was a race to find information that supported a prescription for 'what you do' or 'what you are', and a good chunk of research was done with that in mind, it's understandable). It's not like evolution isn't prevented from swinging both ways in terms of "creature has a fragile penis, so anal sex is selected [for/against] depending on how the existing software succeeds or fails in that environment".