site banner

Friday Fun Thread for November 13, 2026

Be advised: this thread is not for serious in-depth discussion of weighty topics (we have a link for that), this thread is not for anything Culture War related. This thread is for Fun. You got jokes? Share 'em. You got silly questions? Ask 'em.

2
Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Riffing off of FiveHour here.

WoW Forever: What the Warrior changes say about mens' evolving gender roles?

Warriors are quintessentially men. Their resource mechanic for using abilities, "Rage," is associated with men. (do you hear Journalists write "women's rage" nearly as often as "men's rage?") Historically, armor-wearing, sword-slinging knights were men. In 2004 WoW class balance, the Warrior's primary role is the role of a man.

For those unaware, "role" really is the gaming term: cooperative group content is tackled by teams comprised of complementary roles, and the Warrior is the undisputed king of the Tank role. The tank's job is to receive damage from the enemies, because they're the only ones who can survive it. (There is another role called Healer, and this is female-coded). WoW technically allows other classes like Paladin and Druid to tank, but they're just bad compared to the Warrior.

The Warrior's role as man extends from the game into the meta-game. In cooperative group content, you usually need a leader, and the leader is, de-facto, the tank. That is to say: the tank decides where the group walks, which enemies the group kills, and in what order. Part of this, historically is for game reasons: order of operations requires that the tank engage the enemy first, to ensure the enemies are only ever attacking the tank. But the community takes it a step further: tanks are expected to lead.

The primary parallel to men here isn't that tanks "just have" more power than other roles, but that this power flows from third-party expectations: in other words, being the only person in the room with agency. Tanks are expected to know the game, which means tank can be a daunting role as a new player. This is compounded by the fact that WoW (and its 5 different official modern classic versions) is a 20 year old solved game, so some expect all the players to be experts.

Anyways, WoW: Forever includes lots of class balance changes, so that Warriors are no longer the undisputed kings of tanking. (The general pattern of leadership from the tanking role however, likely stays.)


What other silly essays can you write?

The primary parallel to men here isn't that tanks "just have" more power than other roles, but that this power flows from third-party expectations: in other words, being the only person in the room with agency.

Unless player preferences changed a lot since I played MMOs, the reason for this was different than what you're stating. Back when I was into FF XIV, tanks led because there were less players willing to play tank. It's a selfless role, it's not flashy like DPS, and the rest of the group doesn't "feel" the tank helping them the way they see the heals coming in. So therefore when queuing or otherwise building a group, your bottleneck is likely going to be getting a tank, so you treat the tank nicely lest you end up having to look for another one.

Indeed, my silly post had to p-hack and ignore the misanalogy between the tank role and men. The supply and demand curves are inverted, leading to the dynamics you mention. From this perspective it's DPS players that are male-like. Alas, this is the fun thread and not the real discussion thread.