site banner

Small-Scale Question Sunday for November 15, 2026

Do you have a dumb question that you're kind of embarrassed to ask in the main thread? Is there something you're just not sure about?

This is your opportunity to ask questions. No question too simple or too silly.

Culture war topics are accepted, and proposals for a better intro post are appreciated.

1
Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Where is the best steelman of Creation Science? I’ve recently been learning a bit about that subculture, and find it quite interesting. Especially when there exist easier epistemic solutions to a literal genesis like the Omaphalos hypothesis.

Full Disclosure: I come in with the prejudice that the field is mostly post-hoc epicycles used to justify a particular interpretation of Genesis. I want to know why high IQ people study this. I assume I am missing something.

I want to know why high IQ people study this.

(1) Being puzzled at high-IQ people believing and dedicating effort to Creationism is somewhat like being puzzled at very muscular people living in isolated mountain valleys without infrastructure. Why, you might naively think, we know that humanity has the raw strength to dig tunnels through mountains with ease, and these people are near the peak of human strength! Surely if some wimpy noodle-armed Swiss engineer can do it, then the ripped Balochi shepherd should not even break a sweat!

But actually, it turns out that building infrastructure in adverse terrain is so hard that the variation in an individual's arm strength is almost irrelevant to whether it can be achieved, and would be insufficient if you are looking at something like the Himalayas or Alps anyway. Instead, all the great feats of infrastructure-building are due to tools and massive, society-wide coordination, which pooled the individual strength of lots and lots of humans, systematically directed it towards common ends, and recursively augmented it with tools whose strength is not in the same ballpark as that of humans at all.

Intellectual infrastructure is actually the same: contra the Rationalist fantasy of the quadruple-digit IQ superman sitting in his parents' basement and rederiving quantum mechanics from playing with legos, even the smartest kid growing up in intellectual Balochistan will at most be able to make a difference analogous to moving some slightly bigger boulders off of his village's farmland. The big achievements of our scientific worldview were created not because of the greater intellectual strength of its supporters, but because an organisation pooled that individual "strength", directed it towards common ends and recursively augmented it with tools (starting with dialectical logic and progressing through mathematics and statistics and sophisticated computer-based models etc.) whose intelligence is not of the same type or in the same ballpark as that of humans.

In this metaphor, we even have obvious counterparts to considerations that apply to the strength scenario: much like the Balochi herdsman could emigrate to Switzerland and start working at a construction site, a bright kid from an Evangelical family could go to university and wind up being brainwashed into contributing to a lab researching evolutionary genetics. (...but many will never leave Balochistan/Evangelicalism.) A Swiss engineering student could go through a hippie phase and wind up getting stuck and going native on the Indian subcontinent. (born-again Christians) Some Balochis might get together and actually learn how to organise themselves to the point where they start building viaducts and tunnels. (Modern evolutionary science ultimately came out of the Catholic church doing just that! Some smart creationists started organising themselves, built dialectic and the scientific method, and suddenly their intellectual descendants were entertaining theories their antecessors would have dismissed as heretical.)

(2) Humans are always very tempted, if they feel that someone is playing a rigged game against them, to "cheat back". Because of this, evolution-believers often, upon seeing creationists "strutting around the chessboard like a pigeon, knocking over pieces and declaring victory", start compromising on their own intellectual rigour when the public is watching, such as with the dinosaur soft-tissue dismissal mentioned in a parallel response, many an argument pertaining to global warming, or for more recent CW material the COVID lab leak hypothesis. The problem with this is that people on the other side will always see this cheating, and take it as a license to cheat for their own side in turn; as is being demonstrated everywhere over and over again, no culture war battle is ever resolved by cleanly establishing which side started it first and getting that side to concede. So in turn, any smart Evangelical starting from a position of open-mindedness (but strong intellectual attachment to his own team being in the right) will have no trouble finding ample examples of evolution-believers bullshitting, fudging data and celebrating weak arguments, and feel that justice demands that he be allowed to counter likewise.

As a creation believer with autism, creationism’s appeal to me is the idea that there’s an actual historical truth to human, animal, and earthly origins that can be forensically examined through various fields of science, including but not primarily the science of history.

I am also a rationalist and lover of Truth, so I may therefore never deceive, dissemble, conflate, or otherwise massage the truth in favor of a particular origins process hypothesis.

Everyone who has done so either has been proven hilariously wrong or has been published and accepted into the “it’s not creation, doesn’t matter how wrong I was” knowledge base of the cathedral of Science.