Do you have a dumb question that you're kind of embarrassed to ask in the main thread? Is there something you're just not sure about?
This is your opportunity to ask questions. No question too simple or too silly.
Culture war topics are accepted, and proposals for a better intro post are appreciated.

Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Notes -
Where is the best steelman of Creation Science? I’ve recently been learning a bit about that subculture, and find it quite interesting. Especially when there exist easier epistemic solutions to a literal genesis like the Omaphalos hypothesis.
Full Disclosure: I come in with the prejudice that the field is mostly post-hoc epicycles used to justify a particular interpretation of Genesis. I want to know why high IQ people study this. I assume I am missing something.
Why does that explanation exclude high-IQ people? High-IQ people engage in epicycles to explain their beliefs all the time. Newton spent more time on woo-woo insane nonsense than he did inventing modern math and physics. The explanation that a lot of high IQ people, for a variety of reasons, accept creation as a baseline truth and work from there seems sufficient to me.
To be fair to Newton, it's only after the time is spent and the results have been invented and studied that we can clearly see them as "modern math and physics". It's not necessarily obvious in advance that combining "stare at how the dots in the sky move" (mostly the domain of astrology) with "As Above, So Below" (from one of the Hermetic alchemy texts Newton translated) gets you to Universal Gravitation plus Newtonian Physics. Newton and his peers had already started turning alchemy into chemistry and astrology into astronomy and physics; it's only in hindsight that it seems obvious that theurgy was a total dead end. Even Newton's most important math was kind of wild, arriving at the fundamental results of calculus but with somewhat hand-wavy techniques that weren't reformulated with modern rigor until a century after his death!
Yup. Intelligence is good at finding rational derivations of actual answers, but unfortunately if you're mistakenly confident that you've already found an actual answer then intelligence is also good at finding rationalizations of those instead.
I think it's a very under-appreciated concept. If some mega-IQ person sees a dozen of unsolved questions about the world around him, and attacks them with a dozen methods, and three of those methods lead to huge breakthroughs in our understanding of the universe, paving the way for centuries of progress, and nine turn out to be nonsense which leads nowhere - we come with the benefits of hindsight and whine "why didn't he spend all his time on the proper things, we'd have 4x more progress if he did!". But before he and other people spent time on things to figure out which ones are true and which are nonsense, it wasn't obvious at all!
Donald Knuth famously said "Premature optimization is the root of all evil. ". He talked about software design but I think it applies more widely than that. Throwing out things as nonsense is certainly more optimal way than considering all options, even clearly insane ones - but if done prematurely, it cuts off too much. It's a good thing that Newton spent a bunch of time on what we consider to be nonsense - that's how we know it's nonsense, if people like Newton and others like him gave it their best and it came to nothing, then it's nothing. We should not be upset about time "wasted" this way - this is the tax we pay for being able to progress. I think it's the same for many other areas - surely autocracy is more efficient than less centralized forms of decision making, and having people concentrate on one single best optimized thing is more efficient than everybody doing their thing and many end up wasting the effort - but the former always comes with very large pitfalls.
I think what's most counterintuitive is that the definition of "prematurely" grows widely if you've actually got a chance of pushing through some important limitation for the first time, because the most important competitions (economic, but also intellectual, etc.) are efficient enough that the only way to thoroughly win them is to do something that at first seems insanely unlikely to win. We laugh at "you can't win the lottery if you don't play!" suckers spending $2 for a ticket with an EV of $0.80, but how many of us are laughing because our expected utility calculations are correct, not just laughing because we've internalized "don't try something if the odds of succeeding are too low"? Smart venture capitalists will fund 20 startups knowing 90% of them will fail, quadruple their money with 40x returns from the 2 winners, and laugh all the way to the bank. I thought catching a giant rocket in more-giant robot arms was Musk's idea of a joke when I first heard about it, and then the guy who first put landing legs on an orbital launch vehicle was also the first to make them obsolete. As long as you don't fail in utterly ruinous ways, the cost of trying something insane and failing and having to try something else until you find the insane thing that works can be higher than the opportunity cost of avoiding failure.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
There seems to be a lack of reflection inherent in some (most) people that leads to them treating the current state of scientific and cultural understanding as being fundamentally "correct"—not in the sense that there isn't more to be learned but in that it can't be contradicted—to assume that these truths are obvious to anyone exposed to them, and to criticize people throughout history who pushed back against them when they were new. I quit watching the remake of Cosmos about halfway through the first episode after Neil DeGrasse Tyson spent the better part of it chastising the medieval Catholic Church for going after some heretic or another with the gall to say that the sun didn't revolve around the earth or something like that. He seems to be ignorant of the fact that Aristotelian physics had existed for centuries, and if you were going to cut against the prevaling consensus you'd better have pretty good evidence. If someone today were to claim that the sun actually does revolve around the earth and they can prove it because of this new math they invented, they'd rightfully be dismissed as a crackpot, especially if they held a lot of other questionable ideas. While I'm reasonably sure that Newton was correct, I still have to keep in mind that he may have, in fact, been an idiot and a crackpot himself who got lucky.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
(1) Being puzzled at high-IQ people believing and dedicating effort to Creationism is somewhat like being puzzled at very muscular people living in isolated mountain valleys without infrastructure. Why, you might naively think, we know that humanity has the raw strength to dig tunnels through mountains with ease, and these people are near the peak of human strength! Surely if some wimpy noodle-armed Swiss engineer can do it, then the ripped Balochi shepherd should not even break a sweat!
But actually, it turns out that building infrastructure in adverse terrain is so hard that the variation in an individual's arm strength is almost irrelevant to whether it can be achieved, and would be insufficient if you are looking at something like the Himalayas or Alps anyway. Instead, all the great feats of infrastructure-building are due to tools and massive, society-wide coordination, which pooled the individual strength of lots and lots of humans, systematically directed it towards common ends, and recursively augmented it with tools whose strength is not in the same ballpark as that of humans at all.
Intellectual infrastructure is actually the same: contra the Rationalist fantasy of the quadruple-digit IQ superman sitting in his parents' basement and rederiving quantum mechanics from playing with legos, even the smartest kid growing up in intellectual Balochistan will at most be able to make a difference analogous to moving some slightly bigger boulders off of his village's farmland. The big achievements of our scientific worldview were created not because of the greater intellectual strength of its supporters, but because an organisation pooled that individual "strength", directed it towards common ends and recursively augmented it with tools (starting with dialectical logic and progressing through mathematics and statistics and sophisticated computer-based models etc.) whose intelligence is not of the same type or in the same ballpark as that of humans.
In this metaphor, we even have obvious counterparts to considerations that apply to the strength scenario: much like the Balochi herdsman could emigrate to Switzerland and start working at a construction site, a bright kid from an Evangelical family could go to university and wind up being brainwashed into contributing to a lab researching evolutionary genetics. (...but many will never leave Balochistan/Evangelicalism.) A Swiss engineering student could go through a hippie phase and wind up getting stuck and going native on the Indian subcontinent. (born-again Christians) Some Balochis might get together and actually learn how to organise themselves to the point where they start building viaducts and tunnels. (Modern evolutionary science ultimately came out of the Catholic church doing just that! Some smart creationists started organising themselves, built dialectic and the scientific method, and suddenly their intellectual descendants were entertaining theories their antecessors would have dismissed as heretical.)
(2) Humans are always very tempted, if they feel that someone is playing a rigged game against them, to "cheat back". Because of this, evolution-believers often, upon seeing creationists "strutting around the chessboard like a pigeon, knocking over pieces and declaring victory", start compromising on their own intellectual rigour when the public is watching, such as with the dinosaur soft-tissue dismissal mentioned in a parallel response, many an argument pertaining to global warming, or for more recent CW material the COVID lab leak hypothesis. The problem with this is that people on the other side will always see this cheating, and take it as a license to cheat for their own side in turn; as is being demonstrated everywhere over and over again, no culture war battle is ever resolved by cleanly establishing which side started it first and getting that side to concede. So in turn, any smart Evangelical starting from a position of open-mindedness (but strong intellectual attachment to his own team being in the right) will have no trouble finding ample examples of evolution-believers bullshitting, fudging data and celebrating weak arguments, and feel that justice demands that he be allowed to counter likewise.
As a creation believer with autism, creationism’s appeal to me is the idea that there’s an actual historical truth to human, animal, and earthly origins that can be forensically examined through various fields of science, including but not primarily the science of history.
I am also a rationalist and lover of Truth, so I may therefore never deceive, dissemble, conflate, or otherwise massage the truth in favor of a particular origins process hypothesis.
Everyone who has done so either has been proven hilariously wrong or has been published and accepted into the “it’s not creation, doesn’t matter how wrong I was” knowledge base of the cathedral of Science.
More options
Context Copy link
Wasn't Darwin a nominal Anglican?
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
The Discovery Institute has a crew of retired petroleum geologists trying to prove that global sediment layers are more like what you'd see from a global flood turning the world upside down all at once than the gradual deposition and plate tectonics idea. In general you'd want to look at the Institute for Creation Research(which owns the Discovery Institute) and Answers in Genesis(Ken Hamm's outfit) for the higher IQ version of creationism.
The killshot against creationism isn't that they have no good arguments. It's that their good arguments don't agree with each other. Ken Hamm and Timothy Clary can make good arguments for why the flood/baraminology/special creation makes sense to explain X feature of the world. But these arguments don't add up together.
My favorite TalkOrigins page was always this one, specifically the table of hominid skulls where, "although creationists are adamant that none of these are transitional and all are either apes or humans, they are not able to agree on which are which".
I can't steelman Creation Science's results, but I could probably steelman Creation Science's study: it's generally valuable to have people who are looking for flaws in any current scientific consensus, because there are usually bound to be some, and even an irrational or hopeless motivation for seeking flaws is still a way to avoid the sort of comfortable conformity bias that delays or downplays finding flaws.
More options
Context Copy link
I feel like I saw a NYT headline recently lamenting that truly ancient archaeology sites would largely be on ancient coastlines. With the changes since the last ice age, most of those would then be underwater and either completely gone or incredibly difficult to explore.
But "creation science" is such a grab bag I'm really not sure if that's relevant given some of the dates in question being older than "Young Earth".
The 'ancient civilization' stuff is itself a fringe theory. Which doesn't mean there's nothing to it, but you get to atlantis and dero and annunaki with it very fast.
I wasn't suggesting "advanced ancient civilization" specifically, but that the contemporaries of, say, Stonehenge might have disappeared without much trace. Doggerland, for example, has been known about for a while.
Yeah it feels pretty unlikely that there aren't comparable contemporary archeological sites to the ones that we know about somewhere on the various flooded parts of the world. Massive leap from there to 'Egyptians with Hovercrafts' but that's another argument.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
God has been hiding all these dinosaurs fossils in the ground to make you doubt.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
My steelman would be "they're just believing that the Bible means what it says", which I find more intellectually honest than claiming Genesis is a metaphor for the Big Bang.
Genesis 1:3 is a great metaphor for the Big Bang! You can even include all of Genesis 1:1-4, if you allow for the same kind of creative license that modern science uses when we call a ball of incandescent proton/electron plasma "hydrogen" ("water-creator"). It's only afterward that it really goes off the rails.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I think this is basically true of "Creation Science" in the sense that those two words put together are essentially a brand (similar with Christian film). I do think there are from time to time scientists who look at certain phenomena and go "hmmm, I think the best explanation for this is probably a Creator" and a large number of scientists who believe in God or some other higher power and don't particularly see a conflict between science and God and so they don't become "Creation Scientists" in much the same way there are filmmakers who believe in God who don't go into "Christian film."
My "steelman" for "Creation Science" would be something along the lines of "it's probably good to have people with radically different theories poking around doing stuff, they might stumble on something interesting because they are operating in a different paradigm."
Well, firstly, high IQ people are quite capable of taking their faith seriously. High IQ people (particularly engineer types) like for the world to be clear and consistent, and a literal reading of Genesis (which I have some objections to on textual grounds) is a very easy, unambiguous way to interpret it that can in theory be verified. Also, (and this is sort of inside Christian baseball) a lot of times people moving to read the Biblical text in a non-literal way is Part 1 of a two-part plan, wherein Part 2 is ignore everything in the Biblical text you don't like. As it turns out, the stuff in the Biblical text people don't like is often load-bearing, so there are practical reasons for conservative Christians to gravitate towards the clear, consistent, literal interpretations, even when they are arguably not the best way to interpret the Bible (even setting aside reconciling it with science.)
Furthermore I suspect that even "hard science" is a bit more of a crapshoot than people realize. Smart people are good at poking holes at the inconsistencies in a dominant paradigm and once you've shredded it to pieces it's not hard to justify why the remaining ribbons should be stitched together in the way you desire. This isn't to say that hard science is fake but things like the age of the Earth or the descent of man aren't written in stone, and there's not some machine you can go to and get an obvious right answer; these things require interpretation and oftentimes people get their interpretation wrong. After the dominant paradigm has been wrong a few times, it's tempting to throw the baby out with the bathwater and justify your preferred solution.
One of my favorite stories when it comes to "hard science" is Mary Schweitzer, who found soft tissue in dinosaur bones. This was very much not supposed to happen, due to the way bones are supposed to form (via mineralization) and due to the extreme age of the bones (supposedly millions of years). Schweitzer, an evangelical Christian, is not (as I understand it) a young-Earth creationist (in fact she seems rather critical of them) but people in archeology had apparently ignored or just failed to look into a good deal of evidence of soft tissue probably because of the prevailing scientific assumptions of the time. (I also wonder if they were reluctant to investigate precisely because they knew it would give points to the Creation Science types; Schweitzer reports that her mentor was rather upset at the thought.) Either way, it seems many paleontologists weren't really itching to have to choose from "all of these fossils are much younger than we thought" or "we actually don't know how fossils form at all, do we?" even though SOFT T-REX TISSUE are objectively the coolest thing ever.
Again, to be clear, my point here isn't that soft tissue preservation means that we should just throw out all other evidence we have. (I think Schweitzer's story is cool, so I like to talk about it.) But science works the way most things do (advancing, as some have said, a death at a time - Kuhn is instructive here) which means old or odd biases, petty personal issues and such are often just as present in the rarefied air of "science" as they are in any other human endeavor. This can be disillusioning, and I think it can be tempting for smart people to go "nah I'm not listening to the people who ignored the smell of death every time they did destructive testing" and instead substitute in their own preferred assumptions.
I think the correct antidote is to approach scientific questions (and also religious ones) with an air of humility, which means leaving open not only the possibility that you might be wrong, but also that others might be wrong, and not putting a burden on the scientific process that it can't bear (which I think is often done when science is dragged into the God question) or an expectation that science is some perfect pursuit of truth, untainted by worldly ambitions, unlike the rest of human life.
I suspect you see some of these dynamics with intelligent people in other areas too (if I had a nickel for every time a chess grandmaster had a wacky idea, I'd have two nickels, which isn't a lot, but it's funny it happened twice!)
Thank you for the detailed comment. I understand why there are intelligent religious people, I don’t think religion is irrational. Your comment gives a good explanation for why many Christian’s stick with Biblical literalism unless indicated otherwise. For me, I’m still just curious why intellectually many literalists go for what seems to me to be a lot of unnecessary epicycles when there seem to be easier ways to accommodate 6 day creation like the aforementioned Omaphalos Hypothesis or General Relativity. I don’t propose persecuting Creation Scientists, but it does seem like an unnecessary philosophical construct to rationalize literal Genesis with science.
As a Catholic, I'm on the outside commenting on this but you have to factor in that Biblical literalism/Biblical inerrancy is part of the foundation of some denominations, going back to the Reformation.
Luther was the major one here, but most of the Reformers dealt with it in a similar way. Luther conquered his neuroses/dealt with his scrupulosity about "but how do I know I am really saved?" by settling on trusting the word of Christ. The bare, literal word in the Gospels. Strip out everything that accumulated over the centuries, go back to the text. Christ said this, what He says is true, so trust the promise. Believe in the literal word and let no other doubts assail you.
That got developed into believing the literal word of the texts. And so Biblical inerrancy/Biblical literalism (which are not quite the same thing) were baked in. Now you are asking people "Okay, you are a Christian, that's fine, but now we want you to dump this element in favour of our shiny new secular materialist element". That is going to go down like a lead balloon, because this is precisely the picking-and-choosing that liberal Christianity does with "we don't like this bit about the gays, but we love this bit about immigrants, so we tell everyone Jesus says this and not that".
And of course, the old fight over Romish Papist interpolations and putting priestly mediators in between God and man 😁
You can do the "it's metaphorical" with churches where this has long been accepted (see St. Augustine writing on this position) and Scripture is not sola Scriptura but Tradition and interpretation also have accepted roles and authority. But to the Creation Scientists, what you are proposing is akin to "I don't see why you can't just go along with Jesus is Krishna, wouldn't that tidy up a lot of problems about claims as to how many gods there are?"
In countries where Creationism is a live issue the official position of the hierarchy tends to be friendly towards it(the USCCB officially supports intelligent design, for example) without particularly opposing evolution.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
I think to win them over, alternative explanations for Genesis have to provide a compelling reason why the explanation makes good (con)textual sense. That's what people want, a theory that makes sense of the text without devaluing it or seeming like cope. I do think that's happening now, as ancient Near Eastern texts are better understood and the scholarship surrounding them popularized. The question YECers are weak to is "is modern science the best interpretive lens through which we should understand the Word of God as given to ancient Israelites?" and it's easier to pose that question when you know something about the ancient Israelites. But (as with most things) I think public knowledge about these things moves much more slowly than the forward edge of scholarship.
No, to win them over you need to convince them that 'not everything in the old testament has to be taken literally' isn't a trojan horse for 'not everything Jesus says is true'.
Isn’t that just called ”being Christian” as opposed to ”being Jewish”?
Well yes, you need to convince them that a more metaphorical interpretation of the first 11 chapters of Genesis isn't a trojan horse for not being Christian anymore.
It doesn’t even need to be metaphorical. Genesis is agnostic on a lot of the details of the origin story, but captures thematic elements that are relevant to what it’s communicating. Certain “kinds” of literalism you read into it won’t make any sense, that doesn’t imply you must logically retreat from literalism altogether.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
Sure, and I think that's part of making contextual sense of the Old Testament to conservative Christians.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
There isn’t one. It’s objectively not true.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link