Do you have a dumb question that you're kind of embarrassed to ask in the main thread? Is there something you're just not sure about?
This is your opportunity to ask questions. No question too simple or too silly.
Culture war topics are accepted, and proposals for a better intro post are appreciated.

Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Notes -
I was reading the bio of Grizzly Bear’s frontman and learned he comes from the Forbes family. Coolest family I’ve ever read about. Opium traders in the Orient, railroad magnates, founding stock of Boston, neuroscientists, Beethoven scholars, an elector of Lincoln, president of the Bell Telephone Company, a governor-general of the Philippines, Ralph Waldo Emerson… and you yourself compose one of the greatest indie song of late 00s? A song still so resonant that it has a million uses across shortform video content 15 years later?
There’s a pattern of indie musicians coming from elite families. The daughter of former secretary general of NATO Stoltenberg is an indie musician. And the father of the frontman of Phoenix started TNS Sofres, the most important political data company in France in his time. I have two theories on this: (1) indie music is often about conveying nuanced and high feelings of mirth and love, something that is easier to develop when you grow up knowing you have infinite resources; (2) there’s an epigenetic musicality gene that is triggered when perceived resources are high, to signal your high level of resources, like a bird singing loudly to signal his nutritional resources
Does everyone have their two weeks worth of hibernatory grizzly bear supplies in case things go south? May be worth doing that today.
edit meant to post this in the fun thread but I suppose I’ll just turn it into a question. What’s everyone’s favorite indie song, or if you don’t like indie music, why?
I was super into indie music in high school and college (2004-2012ish.) My favorites were Owen Pallett, Sufjan Stevens and Devendra Banhart (I've always been more drawn to soloists than bands.) Owen is still my number one of all time, Sufjan I still love and listen to often, Devendra I still like but don't find myself listening to often. Grizzly Bear is probably my favorite indie band (I was excited to see your post about them here), followed by Wild Beasts and Fleet Foxes. I don't know if Lana del Rey passes as indie but frankly I think her music fits better as "indie" than anything else and I'm a big fan.
I used to love reading the blog "Said the Gramophone" which was great for the hipster/indie scene back then. It was also easy to follow the scene with magazines like Nylon and Blender.
I'm always kind of surprised at how memory holed the indie genre of that time period was especially when it was so huge and mainstream (like the Juno movie and soundtrack were so huge, every indie musician was on NPR and even VH1 all the time back then, and so on.) I'm a bit amused at the Edward Sharpe Home tiny desk concert video being constantly posted on instagram reels recently with people going crazy in the comments every time.
Honorable mentions from me: Xiu Xiu, Austra, Connan Mockasin, Bon Iver, Modest Mouse, Joanna Newsom, Zoo Kid. I have to say I particularly dislike Arcade Fire, find them extremely bland and midbrow and dislike that Owen Pallett is associated with them lol
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link