This weekly roundup thread is intended for all culture war posts. 'Culture war' is vaguely defined, but it basically means controversial issues that fall along set tribal lines. Arguments over culture war issues generate a lot of heat and little light, and few deeply entrenched people ever change their minds. This thread is for voicing opinions and analyzing the state of the discussion while trying to optimize for light over heat.
Optimistically, we think that engaging with people you disagree with is worth your time, and so is being nice! Pessimistically, there are many dynamics that can lead discussions on Culture War topics to become unproductive. There's a human tendency to divide along tribal lines, praising your ingroup and vilifying your outgroup - and if you think you find it easy to criticize your ingroup, then it may be that your outgroup is not who you think it is. Extremists with opposing positions can feed off each other, highlighting each other's worst points to justify their own angry rhetoric, which becomes in turn a new example of bad behavior for the other side to highlight.
We would like to avoid these negative dynamics. Accordingly, we ask that you do not use this thread for waging the Culture War. Examples of waging the Culture War:
-
Shaming.
-
Attempting to 'build consensus' or enforce ideological conformity.
-
Making sweeping generalizations to vilify a group you dislike.
-
Recruiting for a cause.
-
Posting links that could be summarized as 'Boo outgroup!' Basically, if your content is 'Can you believe what Those People did this week?' then you should either refrain from posting, or do some very patient work to contextualize and/or steel-man the relevant viewpoint.
In general, you should argue to understand, not to win. This thread is not territory to be claimed by one group or another; indeed, the aim is to have many different viewpoints represented here. Thus, we also ask that you follow some guidelines:
-
Speak plainly. Avoid sarcasm and mockery. When disagreeing with someone, state your objections explicitly.
-
Be as precise and charitable as you can. Don't paraphrase unflatteringly.
-
Don't imply that someone said something they did not say, even if you think it follows from what they said.
-
Write like everyone is reading and you want them to be included in the discussion.
On an ad hoc basis, the mods will try to compile a list of the best posts/comments from the previous week, posted in Quality Contribution threads and archived at /r/TheThread. You may nominate a comment for this list by clicking on 'report' at the bottom of the post and typing 'Actually a quality contribution' as the report reason.

Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Notes -
40 years is already out of living memory!
How do you figure?
More options
Context Copy link
Not if the apostles were in their 20s at the time of Jesus' ministry, which they probably were. And St Mark was even younger than the apostles, and was an eyewitness to some (but by no means all) of the events of his gospel as what would now be considered a teenage boy. I was taught that John's gospel was the last to be written around 90 AD (current scholarship says 90-100), and that St John the Evangelist was in close contact with St John the Apostle, although they probably weren't the same person as was historically believed. Apart from the visible martyrs, we don't know about the apostles' later lives, although all sources agree that St John probably lived to a ripe old age somewhere.
If you assume St John the Apostle was 10ish years younger than Jesus then he would have been too old to have physically written the gospel without glasses or modern lighting. So either he dictated it to a secretary, or St John the Evangelist wrote up a series of interviews in the same way St Mark did with St Peter. But in any case, everything points to the gospel of John being written while the real, historical apostle John was still alive. Very much living memory.
Life expectancy estimates for that period, for a common person, vary a lot but they should be between 30 and 40 years, so the earliest dates for Mark place it just out of the average life expectancy. If you take into account that the author of Mark is not jewish, as the historian consensus goes, and that few people would have witnessed Jesus in the first place, because if it was a big phenomenon it would have lots of non-christian sources, that means the oldest gospel was written when less than 10% of the potential witnesses were alive and in a different country.
You can call it living memory, that's just a matter of definitions, but it doesn't give you the conclusion that you are hoping for (that they couldn't have lied).
As I understand it, such life expectancy figures in the past were caused by much higher rates of child mortality than we see today. If you lived to adulthood, you were reasonably likely to live well past your 40s.
More options
Context Copy link
Life expectancy is irrelevant - what matters is maximum lifespan, which has not increased much. (This is a general point - life expectancy is the average of a profoundly non-normal distribution and in pre-modern society changes in life expectancy are mostly driven by changes in infant mortality.
If we are looking at the biblical evidence, Psalm 90 is clear that living to 70-80 was normal if accidents, starvation, disease or war didn't get you prematurely, and Isiah 65:20 implies that the normal human lifespan will be 100 years in a future restored world. (We aren't there yet, but we are getting awfully close - based on the latest mortality table the modal age of death for women in the UK is now 90, with 2.6% of female live births eventually getting the birthday card from the King).
More options
Context Copy link
This has zero relevance to what you're discussing. Low life expectancy was mostly down to childhood mortality. Once you made it to adulthood, you'd probably make it to 60 as well.
I'm talking about life expectancy at 20 years old.
This is well within living memory: Frier gives a 15 year old a 34% chance of living to 55 and a 26% chance of living to 60, so if Mark is writing in 70 AD we'd expect plenty of surviving witnesses from an incident in 30 AD.
Also, the Gospel's don't spring up in a vacuum. It looks like some scholars believe there was a Q-text, or portions thereof, as early as the 30s, although late-daters will put it closer to Mark in the timeline. Even if you don't believe in a Q-text, or late-date it, Paul is writing around 50 CE (so a majority of 20 year olds would have survived the intervening 20 years) and Paul references oral traditions that are older than his letters and likely date to the 30s or 40s.
The Gospels could have been written in 34 AD and that wouldn't by itself rule out lying. But they also could have been written in 234 AD and that by itself wouldn't change the fact of relatively early attestation.
Suppose there actually was a big event that 50 people witnessed, none of the things Jesus did could have many more original witnesses otherwise we would have non-christian sources about it, about 20% (I don't have the population pyramid of the time so I'm using Nigeria instead) would have been between 10 and 25 (~9) and of those 34% would be alive, so about 3 or 4, living hunderds of kilometers away from where Mark was written.
Besides, we're talking about a text with a completely impossible depiction of the cleansing of the temple, which we can disprove thousands of years later, and yet it's there. Clearly it wasn't meant to be taken as historical in the first place or it never even came across someone who had been to Jerusalem once.
And Paul never met Jesus.
Interestingly you get numbers in the Gospel, including for events a lot larger than "50." As we will see, there are extra-Biblical reasons to think that accounts of Christ's miracles were widespread, or at least not fringe.
We do have non-Christian sources about it! I think the reason we don't have more is that the First Jewish War resulted in Rome scouring Palestine, destroying Jerusalem, and generally overturning Jewish society, with the typical negative consequences for any local records that might otherwise have survived, including Roman and Temple records in Jerusalem. (Another possible reason could in theory be that people who saw Christ's miracles and wrote about them afterwards were disproportionately likely to be Christians although there are some counterexamples.)
So, if we're looking at sources outside of the New Testament for the "local view" of the time, our best surviving sources are, from what I understand, Josephus and the Talmudic references to Christ. And both sources reference the idea that Christ was a miracle-worker, so it seems reasonable to assume that there was a preexisting narrative along these lines. (There is some dispute over the accuracy of Josephus' account - although new work suggests that due to a missing word or two the text we have is best taken as much less laudatory of Christ than it has been understood to be in the past - but even reconstructions of the text minus the parts believed by some to be Christian insertions reference some idea of miraculous works - or, in the case of the Aramaic text, the resurrection.) Note that I am not claiming that Josephus was a Christian, just that Josephus is about as good a text as we have, and he seems familiar with the idea that Christ worked miracles.
The Talmudic treatment of Christ is very interesting, since from what I understand it is broadly in line with what the New Testament records: the Jewish religious elites do not deny that Christ is a miracle worker, but rather deny that the miracles come from God. It is possible that the Talmudic writers were not drawing on 1st century Jewish traditions of the Christ but rather responding to the Gospel narrative itself (in other words, instead of preserving an independent oral tradition, making up a new one to rebut the Christian narrative) but if that is the case, it seems curious that they frame Christ as real and possessing power rather than simply denying that He ever existed.
Not sure what you are referencing here, since my understanding is that historians agree this depiction references a real event, and there are in fact extra-Biblical reasons, leaning on rabbinic traditions of the time, to believe the temple practices Christ condemns were new, instituted around 30 AD (which explains the event). The debate is over whether or not Christ performed it twice, or whether John placed his account of the cleansing of the temple towards the beginning of Christ's ministry for thematic reasons (not necessarily an unusual technique by the standards of the time.)
Even if you don't buy the cleansing of the temple (for whatever reason) the fact that rabbinic sources point to a controversial change to allow a market in the temple around 30 AD and the fact that Gospel writers record Christ doing something about it suggests that the Gospel authors had good working knowledge of what was happening in Jerusalem at the time.
Paul explicitly claims to have met Jesus. This is why he switched teams!
Anything like that is a fabrication, if Jesus was a big phenomenon in life there would be non-christian sources about it but there aren't.
No, we don't. Josephus is a painfully obvious forgery, the recent work about this trying to reabilitate is cope. The Talmud places Jesus in 75BC which creates more problems than it solves.
As a vision, which means he never did, if we're still talking about what historians believe.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link