England was still the only nation willing to care about them i.e. she was willing to annex them, at least.
You know, this parallel never occurred to me, to be honest, but this write-up makes it completely clear. Thumbs up.
Huh? The Finnish people have a peculiar ethnic origin and also a language that make them markedly distinct from both Slavic and Scandinavian peoples. Ukraine is in a different situation.
Color me shocked that nobody selected a peasant Anarchist who was easily duped by Bolshevik salami tactics to be the symbol of united Ukrainian nationhood. Instead they had to chose the cringe nerd for the sole but very obvious reason because they knew they could always portray him to the normies as a victim of Nazi repression, because "he was in a concentration camp". (In reality, he was under the equivalent of house arrest under comfortable conditions, because he had qualms about one aspect of the proposed National Socialist European New Order, namely that it didn't include an autonomous Ukrainian state.)
Europe is, and always had been, land of free market and LGBTQ+ rights
sure...lol. We'll see how much of a good political sell this will turn out to be. I suggest you don't hold your breath.
Those are valid points, however I’d also point out the following.
//
I’m sure a similar poll would have yielded similar results in, say, Charlottesville or Richmond, (also) due to the number of left-leaning college students and Beltway region transplants among the local population, back when the local prominent Confederate statues were removed. I’m also sure that outside groups normally played a big part, but not the sole part or an outsized one. And we know that, in the end, not one politician/lawmaker on the local or state level dared to make the argument that the statues should remain, and the only people willing to protest their vandalization and removal were all dismissed as Nazis. So I leave it to you to consider to what extent do these incidents count as “war within a culture”, if that culture is (in the narrow sense) Virginia.
//
We also don’t know if that poll was cooked or not – it probably isn’t, because then the result would likely be more lopsided, but it’s possibility for sure. On the other hand, we can be sure that any Ukrainian citizen wanting to openly object to this decision is given more than ample reason not to do so.
Indeed, it sounds rather far-fetched and just done out of spite.
Not particularly, but that'd surely be consistent though.
Me too. I've heard of multiethnic states and nation/ethnostates, but a "multi-ethnic national state" sounds like an odd concept.
You cannot outright ban one of the largest churches as well as the linguistic communities in your country and try to enter the Schengen area.
So I guess Latvia just risked getting thrown out? /s
In order to preserve a newly found national myth that is "pretty dumb"?
It's baseless to compare forced labor camps that haven't existed for decades to cities that still stand.
Yes, any city dedicating a statue to its founder and leaving it to stand is a completely self-evident course of events. There's no need to back that up.
Yes, a settlement that wasn't Ukrainian in any sense of the word but (maybe) geographical, which was a fishing village transformed into a port city and naval base.
The people of Odessa seem to hate Russian imperialism more than they are grateful for the one time she demanded a city be built on their soil.
So I reckon they'd prefer to live in village shacks as barbarians (also in the original sense of the word) - i.e. not in a city - than to suffer that statue to stand?
I agree that this is a relevant parallel, as I agree with the view that Irish identity, as opposed to Scottish or Welsh, is almost entirely oppositional in nature, and therefore unravels easily:
https://affirmativeright.blogspot.com/2018/05/the-baby-killing-vote-and-loss-of-irish.html
Yes, the removal of cultural symbols is per definition an act of culture war.
Within reasonable limits. Because trivializing is, at the end, normally just a cop-out.
A lot, as otherwise they wouldn't have their city.
Huh? What kind of parallel is that?
Again, she is the founder of Odessa. This is yet another farce.
Let's keep the trivializing within limits.
The Roman myth is from antiquity. I need not say more.
Eagles, snakes and cactuses are mundane creatures that very obviously exist in Mexico.
A recent event that I’m sure fully counts as culture war is the official removal in Odessa of the monument to the city’s founders, mainly Catherine the Great. The justification, which is rather easy to predict, is that Catherine was a perpetrator of Moskal imperialism who repressed Ukrainian patriots (supposedly they already existed back then), committed cultural genocide and erased Ukrainian nationhood (which obviously we’re also supposed to believe existed back then). There isn’t much to comment on this, I think (though I’ll again point out that Odessa would never have existed in the first place without Catherine), but an educated redditor was eager to point out* the curious fact that the removed monument is actually a replica erected in 2007, largely as a response to the events of the so-called Orange Revolution, as the original was removed (and supposedly destroyed) by the Soviets in 1920. So yes, it was originally removed as an imperialist relic, by powers that the Ukrainian authorities claim later perpetrated genocide specifically against Ukrainians because they were Ukrainians i.e. it was an incident between opposing factions of Ukraine deniers. This is where we’re at, which actually doesn’t surprise me that much because I believe we’ve been in a clown world for a long time.
*https://old.reddit.com/r/europe/comments/zyccgk/catherine_the_great_statue_taken_down_in_odesa/
Excuse the late reply, but anyway:
as far as I know, rates of violent crime in the US have been steadily rising since about 2012, and this has accelerated two times, in 2014 (due to the Ferguson effect) and the 2020 (an even more pronounced Ferguson effect).
Also, the same Westerners who are absolutely convinced that Ukraine is actually a real nation with a long history of her own blood and soil are usualy the same people who will insist that the white race doesn't exist, race isn't real, ethnicities are social constructs and that, say, any Somali goat herder can become a fully-fledged member of the German nation by simply arriving there as a "refugee".
This whole thing is just an idiotic farce.

I think there is a misunderstanding here. The expression "Ukraine" and "Ukrainian" has indeed been in use for hundreds of years in Russia, Poland and also Lithuania, but this is a geographic phrase applied to the same borderland or border/outer region located between the two powers and its inhabitants (this is what the word literally means).
More options
Context Copy link