Get a text spam filter. Even iOS has them now.
Maybe he’s responsible for some of the viral “measure twice, cut once” what-not-to-do examples.
It’s funny there are two recent examples of candidates getting destroyed by their messaging (well technically, the messaging of shady PACs who claim to support them); and the most common point I hear about political advertising is how you should never give a politician your email, because they’ll never stop sending obnoxious spam, that other than subject is exactly like the “hot singles near you” spam I regularly receive. It really says something about the state of politics these days.
Personally, I appreciate art (and writing) when it expresses parts of my self perception or worldview, that I could not, because I didn’t have the physical talent, or because I didn’t have the self-reflection to realize beforehand. And the best art is abstract, because I can fill in the correct details: no artist can physically express my already-realized self-perception and worldview as well as I can imagine it. The best art allows me to fill in the details.
The best art also makes me feel special, by not making apparent every detail, so I could in theory create art that isn’t overshadowed. But even that is because it can’t perfectly express me, at least axiomatically, like how a clone would not share my consciousness because it could not be a truly exact clone. Yet, even when a piece of art steals one of my ideas, I feel upset, but I still like it and would congratulate the author; I feel obligated to, like I feel obligated to accept AI simplifying coding which used to make me special, because I can’t undo it from my perception (which to me is more important than others’…that sounds obvious, but some people seem to care more about others’ perceptions, maybe because their own is more influenced by them); and it does not ruin my ability to be content, there are always more good ideas.
AI is destroying the physical barriers to art, but not self-discovery. Recommendation algorithms would destroy self-discovery if they were good, but they are not, and I think the reason is more than “platforms want your engagement not enjoyment” (or “platforms prioritize whales’ engagement over yours”, although both are true, they would give you enjoyment to keep you maximally engaged if it was easy). Self discovery is something you must actively perform with your own intelligence, because nobody else knows some parts of you (although self discovery also requires others, because some parts of you others do know better). Thus AI may destroy artists’ incomes, but never art as an important part of life; and it could distribute without attribution everyone’s diet of art, but it would still have to learn from everyone, and thus could never destroy sharing art or the theoretical attribution that can be recovered and retroactively physically applied.
Wouldn’t invite only still work, with invite trees if someone accidentally lets in a bot? You’d need some in-person connections to get vouched but very little, because once you’re in one trusted network you’re basically in all.
I also think if bots actually become good enough to be convincing on a long scale, with personal comments, and not sounding like AI, many people will go the opposite direction and interact with bots all day. Some already do and IMO the bots are still distinguishable with scrutiny after enough interaction (the lack of which in most internet discussions helps them).
That's true, but there are places in the US with low crime, probably lower than seedier areas of Europe; yet it seems like even (maybe especially) those safe places in the US have nosy neighbors and aggressive CPS, like the 5-year old situation happened in a gated community. Moreover, third-world countries that are more unsafe than the US (at least most areas where these incidents happen) don't have this problem.
Human intelligence is valuable even with artificial intelligence, unless it's practically omniscient, because intelligence includes the ability to prompt the LLM correctly. Even if it's perfectly aligned, unless it's practically omniscient, it can't know what you truly want, part of self-actualization, you must figure that out on your own.
The mom was not right to yell at her daughter for calling 911, but is the father better? Are foster parents better? It’s possible and cheaper to reprimand the mom and even monitor her parenting without taking her kids away.
He literally asked to be banned. He asked to be treated fairly, and seems to be shit testing how much he can insult people and get away with it; are we willing to allow others to do that, or explicitly give him special treatment?
Personally, I'd adapt a policy to permaban noone, except the lowest of the low, spammers and those who contribute nothing. Someone like him, or Darwin, or anyone who occasionally contributes quality, could be banned for up to 1 month, 3 months...I recall on the old site there was a 1 year maximum, why'd that go away?
We could try Lemmy, maybe we'd get some interesting communists.
I cannot even find a better forum for discussing both sides of AI. Hacker News is toxic and filled with short stupid takes (reminds me of another, formerly blue social network...). lobste.rs and other small sites people don't want to discuss sensitive issues especially when they veer into culture war...which I totally understand, in fact I think it's better for them to keep it out, but that leaves here.
AI doesn’t do everything better. It writes better code, but its taste is still horrible and I suspect hasn’t really improved. From my perspective and what I hear online (I consider the contests that awarded AI to be exceptions).
Even when AI art is popular (e.g. Malfoid pics) it’s because a human came up with the idea and heavily curated if not edited its output. I think AI photos and videos are improving, but only in production (no more weird hands). Because it has not stopped being generic to the point of blandness, even when prompted to be “creative”.
Even in software, its architecture is over complicated and probably slower to implement or buggier than human-designed, its explanations are worse than an expert’s because it doesn’t know what to include or leave out, and non-trivial UX you need humans at least to review. There’s a simple way to judge when AI really starts to eclipse humans in software dev: when a large project that is not just some port is created entirely with AI, that competes among the best human alternatives (to be clear, the ports are very impressive especially when combined. But I notice, even in the combinations, the interactions are lazy and not particularly deep, compared to e.g. Order of the Sinking Star).
mature AI simply renders human intelligence obsolete
I’m skeptical, because intelligence includes just knowing what to ask the AI or dealing with whatever it inflicts on you.
It’s true that in an AI dystopia, intelligence won’t stop you from being tortured or gunned down by an AI drone, but this is true today and was true s/drone/barbarian/ millennia ago.
Those who have any opportunity, intelligence still matters. And the only way everyone will have zero opportunity is if AI kills us all. Even if it fully provides for you, there’s still opportunity in self-actualization (which includes things like, figuring out your favorite food) that I doubt ASI can completely provide. And even if it can self-actualize you, even if it can fully simulate and predict your brain, then you still have “intelligence” in every meaningful way, just simulated by the AI (in the same way we could be or not be living in a perfect simulation, but it doesn’t matter because it doesn’t change anything).
How do you know it's more than his metabolism needs? Maybe he has an absorption problem.
Ask Claude to make something. Whatever software you've been dreaming of, even something that a couple years ago would require a team of engineers; it may not be as good as a team, but it will exist. And it's low effort at least compared to output.
I immediately recall the Virginia Mom convicted for letting her 5 year old walk ½ mile in a gated community.
This isn’t a Florida problem; in fact, that it happens in Florida, the State of Parental Freedom™️, is a testament to how bad it is. This is a US problem: it doesn’t happen in Europe and I’m sure it’s not happening in India, South America, China…(maybe it would in Australia if you could walk anywhere there). Yet at least Europe has less child mortality (albeit only measuring up to 5 years).
That the children are sent to a suspected abuser is at worst government incompetence. In fairness, if he’s still husband maybe it was mom’s and children’s choice, and foster care would probably be worse (though maybe other relatives could take them, if they aren’t familiar or are estranged, that would also probably be worse).
Who defends the police in these cases? I think if the child doesn’t seriously complain, there must be a very high bar to take them away, which is certainly not met here. There aren’t enough good parents, so an OK parent who may recklessly get their child killed (and “may” is doing a lot of heavy lifting, kids aren’t made of glass), is probably the best and actually safest option; lest they end with “parents” who don’t really care about them, or have several other foster children to divide their attention.
It wouldn’t be dispiriting if Trump wasn’t overtly adversarial and weaponizing the federal government’s public presence to be.
I think it highlights how far government has decayed and strayed from a unifying, truly nationalist force. Imagine something like this in a post WWII setting, or maybe in the modern day, a town council if yours is more functional. It would perfectly fit the theme of optimism. And the AI would only further this, because the public would be more optimistic about all the great things AGI can accomplish, instead of expecting it to be used by the elite against them (and to make their jobs, despite increasing productivity, more miserable).
It's a form of self-expression, to make the world a bit more compatible with your values, and/or to find similar people. Lazy activism is what substack posters, internet commenters, and other "culture warriors" (like me, I guess) do.
Why so nasty? Some of it is certainly hatred, sadism, and grifting for attention. But also, the world is a cruel place, so some cruelty is required to protect yourself and those you love; it’s hard to express kindness without appearing weak and cringe, especially in politics. Still, at the end of the day it is self-expression, and it influences the world by its appearance not intention; so I can’t escape the feeling nastiness should be minimized to what’s necessary, under evidence that is constantly rechecked.
What are you basing this off of?
The typical conspiracy theory heavily implies if not outright states near-complete centralization: a group (spontaneously or after an event) meets, plans something, and carefully orchestrates it. The reality, that what they were planning started without them and would continue without them (via some other group), or that their plan was a small part of what the conspiracy theory accuses them of, makes the theory misleading: it gives the impression these people have more competence and foresight than reality.
Harvey Weinstein
Wasn't he (and Epstein) prosecuted? Not everyone was arrested, but especially with the amount implicated, Epstein is evidence against the elite successfully keeping conspiracies (although it did seem to involve everyone, so was particularly hard to keep). He was also publicly prosecuted once before his final arrest, the only reason it never made headlines is because the mainstream didn't care; look at how it suddenly cared years after his final arrest, more than ever before, (although this could be a conspiracy of its own) I suspect because some people realized Trump was involved and Biden (and other Dems that would be government staff) were no longer relevant.
UFOs are real, have crashed, and that alien bodies have recovered
I'm still very skeptical of this: so far all the "evidence" I've seen has been unconvincing and not very plausible. How come UFO reports have gone down so much since the proliferation of cameras and other technology that would verify them?
Recent revelations that your Samsung television is spying on you
Samsung and "Smart TVs" in general have been known for years to spy on users. And the recent revelations are also evidence against a successful conspiracy. Samsung employees never had strong incentive to leak these features, because the reaction would be "duh", and consumers who pay attention and care have long abandoned Samsung's TVs.
This last point is very important to understand because the popular version of conspiracy theory, indulged in by the worst conspiracy theorists and the favorite strawman of debunkers, does often postulate large degrees of covert coordination, which allows real conspiracies to operate more-or-less openly without even being viewed as sinister.
A "conspiracy" by definition must be secret. You're right that large groups operate in the open, with basic obfuscation or a low profile so most people don't realize what they're doing. But that's not necessarily intentional (they probably present themselves as ordinary and ethical...because they genuinely think they are); and when it is, it's trivial to bypass if one looks closely, which only roughly fits the idea of "secret".
Members do plan ahead and sometimes coordinate, they may have leadership, may even believe they are forming a conspiracy. The difference from a real conspiracy theory is that the actual plans and coordination are a small part of the overall process, and the leaders have little control over it; more like, the process started and they happened to notice and ride it, but they didn't cause it to happen and it would've happened without them (maybe with others instead).
Yeah, that is more accurate. Game developers can keep projects secret because there's no point in leaking and a big point in not doing that (you've been working on this project for years, why spoil it?) Companies can keep trade secrets because it would be apparent if a competitor stole them, then the financial gain would be undone by lawsuits, and what other motive is there?
But ethics violations are frequently leaked, although we don't know if they're a small fraction of those committed. And the more severe the violation, especially when it starts falling apart (e.g. because it relies on a conspiracy-theory-sized plan), the more likely someone bails to cover themselves, or accidentally does something suspicious.
IMO the main problem with conspiracy theory is the "conspiracy": large groups of people are generally bad at closely cooperating without leaking information. Although it does happen, the other main problem with most conspiracy theories is requiring a long-term plan with broad predictions (like public perception) to mostly succeed, which (granted, in the public eye) seems to never happen. And to top it off, most conspiracy theorists don't provide an obvious motive and their evidence seems like obvious mistakes. So you expect me to believe this massive group orchestrated a years-long plan without any leaks or slip-ups, predicted what no-one else could (and relied on those predictions for their years-long plan, so they must have been either very confident or very reckless), except for these glaring flaw only a group of crackpots discovered; and why so much effort and risk, what couldn't be accomplished through simpler means? Well, it hasn't been disproven...
Emergent theories are easier to believe: rather than a group coordinating to do something, members all have similar motivation, and rather than planning ahead, their actions just happen to lead to or benefit from the outcome. In fact, there may be lots of coordination and omission, because people can identify their "ingroup" and "outgroup" mostly reliably and even subconsciously; but no center or plan, just natural human behavior, and it's not actually secret, the signs are obvious just not to you. The other thing about emergent theories is the leaders actually aren't human (there are none), and the plan actually isn't human-made (there is none), which explains no good motive and obvious flaws.
Hanlon's razor: "Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity". Consequently, never attribute a masterminded evil plan to typical human behavior on a large scale inadvertently causing big problems.
Personally (as a non-Brazillian): I believe Lula is corrupt, he's been pressuring online companies with shoddy evidence to censor his opposition. But I don't believe Bolsonaro would be any better, and (unlike Venezuela) I haven't yet seen solid evidence of election fraud (despite prediction markets being wrong, exit polls were accurate, and extending deadlines usually hinders vote suppression). Maybe a divided government is the best outcome, which is a shame, because it's more pragmatically the least worst outcome.

That has become one of my "most important reading" articles, for being obviously correct in hindsight, not well-known (at least by me beforehand), and backed by evidence. It's very accurate even with the optimism: the Internet hasn't closed (e.g. here), but is much worse than e.g. the 2010s (which many say are worse than the 2000s, which some say are worse than the 1990s...but post-2015 is special for reasons explained by the article). AI is actually opening the Internet a bit by forcing people to address overwhelming low-quality discourse and shilling, and modern-day cynicism is fueling old internet nostalgia.
I agree. Personally, I mostly stick to principles to avoid short-term blunders, like this one.
More options
Context Copy link