@FiveHourMarathon's banner p

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users  
joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


				

User ID: 195

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users   joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

					

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


					

User ID: 195

I'm a little lost here. Why would we need a specific source for it? If she was dating anybody in 1994 she probably gave that guy a blowjob. If anything we'd need a source to show that for years a heterosexual woman stated specially that she did not give head.

As for why it's been specifically seized on? It's an act viewed as more submissive, while still being likely to have occurred.

Willie said in interviews that there was an element of qpq, and he was generally known as that kind of pol, so it's not a crazy assertion.

ETA, the Brown quote

Yes, we dated. It was more than 20 years ago. Yes, I may have influenced her career by appointing her to two state commissions when I was Assembly speaker. And I certainly helped with her first race for district attorney in San Francisco.

It's been specifically cited in most of the attacks I've seen against her, and I assume it happened because (as demonstrated below) it's the default. There might be a root story underneath where Brown mentioned it specifically, I don't know, but mostly it's just been the attacks I've seen.

I've never heard anyone argue that the correct response to Pearl Harbour was for the US to kill an equal number of Japanese soldiers and civilians, then go home.

This sounds a bit like like saying if the D-Day landings didn't completely neutralize Germany then there's little reason for anyone to have thought further fighting would achieve anything.

You've seemed to be a generally smart guy and good poster, so don't take this personally, but this is why I stopped reading books or watching movies about WWII for seven years. WWII is the source of all our war metaphors, and that narrows our imagination.

That said, these particular comparisons are inapposite. At no point in either the European or Pacific theaters were the Americans or Russians flailing about randomly. Throughout the process, they had specific aims and plans they were working towards. Their intention was to occupy Germany and Japan, and institute by force a government which they would sustain by force for however long it took for those nations to be trustworthy self-governing members of the international community again. Importantly, the Allies understood that after victory, after surrender, they would take on responsibility for Japanese and German (and other national) civilian populations. They would take on responsibility for the administration of the territory, the provision of necessary goods, and the healing of the harms of the war. At no point was this in doubt. The Battle of the Bulge, won or lost, wouldn't have changed the intended outcome of the war for the Allies.

Israel has no intention of occupying Gaza and providing administration or aid to the population. They have no plan to institute a government, nor even a publicly stated outline of what an acceptable government would look like. A Hamas Rudolf Hess or a Gazan Donitz are unimaginable, because it's not clear how a Palestinian could obtain a position to offer an unconditional surrender, or under what terms Gazans could organize to achieve any kind of self governance. We need a Gazan Konrad Adenauer, but I don't see a path to finding one.

All this is complicated by the structure of Gazan vs German/Japanese society, and I'm not unsympathetic to the plight facing the Israelis. If they wanted to invest their resources in occupying Gaza, in forcing families apart and educating Gazan children in government-run schools which would inculcate new values, I might not support it but I would respect it. But as of now, they aren't doing that. Their win conditions are something like Gazans stop hating us, unlikely to be advanced by their current strategy, or all the Gazans are dead, which they will presumably reach eventually though I doubt they've made significant progress towards extinction during the current war.

I agree! part of it is a rhetorical or philosophical test for the reader! You're meant to read the text and think about the guy talking to you, and examine his extremely persuasive arguments, and say, hey wait let's apply this brilliant analytical framing to his own statements! And that second level of analysis is what frees the reader, takes the reader to the level of someone who can examine the world, rather than one who just accepts what he is told!

I think one should pair Nietzsche with Crime and Punishment and Notes from Underground in philosophical study.

Which is ridiculous and hypocritical in this case! Even turbolib friends of mine in victim advocacy have responded, in private, to my argument that kamala's history is concerning for this reason. If sex for promotion is bad, it's bad for society to see it working!

Prostitution is a different case because you can't really stop most street level prostitutes from selling themselves, it's poverty and lack of opportunity. It's a totally different transaction when we're talking about lawyers sucking dick for sinecures. Kamala wasn't choosing between sleeping with a man for a little bit of money to feed her starving son and working a minimum wage job, she was choosing to skip a step in the cursus honorum rather than spending years in obscurity as an ADA and building a reputation.

Good pick!

Yes, I agree. But right wingers will need to thread that needle. They need to specifically criticize her for sleeping her way to the top and avoid criticizing her for being a woman who has (in 2024 America) normal sex. A lot of the messaging I'm seeing doesn't thread that needle and ends up saying: Give a blowjob, then you're a whore who can't be president. Without properly communicating the extra step of: give a blowjob to secure a political job.

The former is very much either a hatred of women or a form of anti sex criticism that is wildly outside the mainstream. The latter is a legitimate moral criticism and raises doubts about her qualifications.

((For reference: 85% of Americans have ever given oral sex, and the percentage doesn't fall below 2/3 until we're looking at those over age 70. It's a normal sex act.))

I'm gonna hit the brakes here, sex for promotion is uniquely bad. Imagine a conversation between a supervisor and a subordinate, she hesitates because she doesn't want to ruin her reputation, he says "Nobody cares about that kind of thing, President Harris did it and look at her now!"

The example it would be setting for the country runs exactly opposite of what feminists have been screeching about with MeToo. If asking for sex for giving a promotion is bad, then giving sex in exchange for a promotion is bad.

I'm not sure why that distinction matters, Kamala is the nominee, she did suck dick to get her first political sinecures from which she brought herself up, that attack is being made against her by her political opponents with a particular veilance towards white men, so the campaign must defend itself by appealing to white men and trying to give them permission to vote for Kamala despite her whorish tendencies without feeling like it excludes them from white masculinity. That's the point I'm making. Whether that attack is being made because she is merely a woman, or because or her sexual past, it's the same strategy and the same defense.

Above @MaiqTheTrue says it's odd to "imply that white men are deciding who to support solely on the basis of what other white men would think about them for holding those views and not because they actually believe in things." But the comments about "no self-respecting man could vote for Kamala because she gave a blowjob" are precisely meant to influence one's vote by implying that others will think less of you for doing so. I'm pointing out that this is a normal, and real, campaign dynamic and not some bizarre condescending fantasy.

For what it's worth, and maybe I'm outing myself as a pig here, given the information I don't think I'd ever vote for a woman who we knew didn't give head. If a woman is such a trad moralist that she thinks oral is a sin, what's she doing out of the kitchen? If a woman is such a stuck up feminist that she thinks it's degrading, I sure don't want that kind of man-hater in the white house. I want a president who gives and takes in her personal relationships.

Don't get me wrong, I've read Nietzsche, I love Nietzsche, but we have to admit that by any standard of Master Morality, Nietzsche was lacking. He never conquered in his lifetime. His tangible achievements more or less crowned at becoming the youngest professor of philology, from which he then lived off disability the rest of his life. Was a lot of this the result of bad luck and disease? Yes, undoubtedly. But equally undoubtedly, the lot of many of the weak, those most Nietzscheans are so willing to throw away as the "superfluous men" from Zarathustra, are the result of bad luck, disease, etc. I don't think I'm being unfair when I call him a loser, he lost.

This is where I think the complication of Master Morality comes in. To defend Nietzsche's life on Nietzsche's own terms, one must reject all tangible evidence of success in favor of talking about forms of success that are totally interior to the individual, that involve a small circle of the also-weak, or that post-date his present day in such a way that they are unknown to his contemporaries. His later reputation, and later published writings, might allow us to judge Nietzsche, but to his contemporaries he was who he was, they had no knowledge that he would be famous in the future. Rejection of all real tangible symbols and signs of worldly success, and the people who hold them, as evil; in favor of a mystical, interior definition of virtue that will pay off after one's death, which is the real definition of the Good. It tracks perfectly to the Christianity that Nietzsche decries as Slave Morality, as the ressentiment of the loser against the beautiful and the strong.

Now, one way to square this circle is to say that Freddy was self aware, that he knew what he was saying, and we're meant to read his work with a certain degree of irony. We're meant to see and to know that the man telling us to honor strength had none, that the man telling us to be suspicious of those who reject the value determinations of the great and the powerful is telling us this while in the act of rejecting the value determinations of the great and the powerful! We're not meant to wholesale adopt the positions he argues so vehemently, but to consider and synthesize them into our worldview. This is my preferred view.

Another is to attempt to categorize Masters in such a way that there is a carve-out for the writer. Masters are the brave and powerful Achilles, plus little ol' me. This strikes me as a kind of mystical cope, exactly the kind of thing that Slave Morality is made out of, a transvaluation of values by which earthly success becomes a sign of future damnation. Just as the Christian peasant says: being rich is bad because the rich are greedy and spoiled and sinful, he ain't making it through the eye of that needle! The Nietzschean loser says: being successful is bad, because it means you're conforming to the Longhouse Ethics and not striking out on your own, I may be a loser today but in the future I'll be remembered and the winners will not.

P.S.: I'll admit to not knowing the term Sigma male? Could you define it for me?

Yet this very forum had multiple posters saying things like "No self respecting man could vote for Kamala after picturing her kneeling under a mahogany desk." It might be stupid but it's an active line of attack against Kamala and her supporters.

There's a giant Listeria outbreak in Delis over here, which I'm pretty sure lead to me shitting my brains out last Monday all day. Boars Head has recalled another seven million pounds of meat. So you're probably on the right track with the deli ham. I'm 90% sure that's what got me.

I haven't really seen what you describe in the last paragraph. Where I've seen Nietzsche discussed, master morality is usually seen with some sympathy.

Because you're reading it from the guys doing it. I say it goes back to Nietzsche because Nietzsche himself was, well, not a powerful vital warrior aristocrat. I love his work and and what he contributed to the western tradition, but he was a loser. When you read a Nietzschean, and he's not a big powerful dominant successful warrior, there's an element of a kind of jealous undermining of one's real enemies with one's imaginary friends. "Hey, look, you might act like you're better than me, and you might be taller and richer and better looking and have a hotter girl and a bigger bench press, but you ain't shit, because you don't have the real perfect pure master morality you're still a SLAVE maaaaan." There's a lot of that in the more white-identitarian corners of the online right.

I think the issue with the jocks and nerds view is by definition you are dealing with youth coming into the world with whatever background they happened to have, and little of their own choices has had an effect on where they are.

Well we're dealing with myth, not history, but to engage with extending the metaphor...

The question is what happens for the rest of the adult lives of the slave morality kids? Are they doomed, or can they change their outlook? Can someone think themselves into being a master moralist or onto some kind of middle road?

Yes. People do this all the time. It might even be called "maturity" or "growing up." Learning to love the things you love without worrying about others. A lot of it has to do with finding one's space, one's social grouping where one is mature or even dominant at least on occasion. Nerdy hobbies often provide this: the same guy who is a loser at school or work might be a great guild leader in WoW or whatever. So do social organizations: you might be the bottom tier loser at work, but at the Elks lodge everyone knows your name.

I like your framing of it, in real life we all contain both genuine human desire and emotion and ressentiment. In my mind, Elon is both engaging in things he loves for the sake of things he loves, and he is desperate to gain approval from or undermine the values systems of those who hate him. He builds a crazy, insane vanity project like the Cybertruck. But then he's fighting petty internet feuds on Twitter.

Personally, the way I apply this in my everyday life is simple and libertarian: let people enjoy things. People having fun doesn't imply that I must have a take on it. People resenting other people having fun is bad.

Retrieve as many hostages as possible, neutralize Hamas, work out a some arrangement where Gaza is less of a threat than it was before (most likely involving other nations, or just leaving Gaza disunited enough that Hamas or another similar organisation can't completely militarise it again).

None of these goals are realistic, or at least they aren't working towards them in any meaningful way. I agree with Trump, and anyway the deaths of 100,000 to rescue a few hundred is so desperately out of proportion it has lost all sense. At this point Israel has bombed and marched across all of Gaza multiple times, if they haven't neutralized Hamas yet color me skeptical that the next 100,000 corpses will solve the problem. And working out a plan for a future government of Gaza was a good idea to work out before the war, as Israel was repeatedly urged to do by the international community, not after. Israel is strategically flailing, despite their infinite ability to tactically dominate.

I don't think my teachers ever told me to go to college by telling me I would die alone and friendless regretting my every life choice, but we may have gone to different schools.

Why do you think it would ever be prosocial to do so?

Yup. I'm not talking about a ceasefire, which is the only moral choice when Israel as much as admits it has no realistic plan to achieve anything in particular.

If this is a punitive expedition fine, they've achieved your proportional punishment. Thousands more Gazans have been killed, and some number gang raped in prison it seems.

But this nonsense of permanent security isn't a real goal. I would intellectually respect our foreign policy apparatus and Israel's government more if they were frank genocidaires honest about their plans. As it is they are engaged in an orgy of violence with no realistic goal.

It's a tortured, degenerate, particular and attenuated form of honor culture. They aren't following the Code Duello. But they are fundamentally seeking to convince their peers and the public that they're tough, badass, scary and not scared of shit. They ultimately control their territory not by physical control over the area, but by reputation.

Swords and knives and small bladed weapons have always been the weapons of honor culture. More aristocratic, more personal. A spear is a soldier's weapon, used in organized combat, where the goal is to win. The goal of gang warfare isn't to win, it's to show personal courage in the face of danger. Reducing the danger is not the goal.

... I'm lost here about what point you're making.

That the State Department, and the likely appointees to SoS on the R side come a Trump victory in November, accept Permanent Security and an entirely neutered Palestinian reservation as a serious idea that Israel will pursue seems unrelated to Oxfam's desire for a ceasefire.

Adam Corolla used to do a standup bit that they could settle it if the whole thing was just moved to Baja, because people are happier in Baja.

I mean yes, it would be a good strategy for the Jews in Israel to move to America if they desire to be part of a massive hegemon well liked by its smaller neighbors. If they wish to remain a small, ethnically distinct enclave then they will have problems with this situation.

Further, Germany would definitely be a threat to any of its neighbors, if it weren't for the EU, which makes it less than beneficial for Germany to do so. France didn't keep Germany down by grinding it into a permanently dependent statelet with no power and no independence, rather they built a mutually beneficial structure for European integration in which Germans have been prime beneficiaries. The punitive theory failed and was discredited after Versailles. The idea of German revanchism for Alsace-Lorraine is silly, because any German that wanted to do so could move there tomorrow. Germany's and Japan's participation in Washington Consensus institutions is what keeps them on the leash, not permanent occupation.

I'll offer another take, from what I think was my first AAQC over at the old motte, a further interpretation of Master/Slave Morality, the Perks of Being a Wallflower theory, the Jocks vs the Emo Kids, from my review of the Abercrombie and Fitch documentary White Hot from Netflix. I'm going to quote the old comment, then expand on it in the context of SA's essay here.

How do you read an interview headlined "youth, sex and casual superiority” with quotes like "In every school there are the cool and popular kids, and then there are the not-so-cool kids. Candidly, we go after the cool kids. A lot of people don't belong [in our clothes], and they can't belong. Are we exclusionary? Absolutely.” And not think of Nietzche. How do you look at the displays of beefcake male nudes and hear Bruce Weber talk about restoring the aesthetic glory of Classical Greece, and not think of Friedrich’s modern interpreter BAP? A&F’s aesthetic was to sell the image of the Blonde Beast, in the literal and philosophical senses. They sold the fantasy of youth, strength, vigor, and total lack of self-reflection; a total spontaneity of desire and the satisfaction of that desire through action. Their marketing tried to use Nietzche’s idea of the natural tendency of the healthy and beautiful and vigorous to self-determine what is cool, by creating an artificial Aristocracy of models and images, then hiring cool local kids as representatives, which then co-opted the locals. And how do you watch the haters without thinking “pure ressentiment all the way down.” The grand narrative is of an upper class which set its own standards, and a lower class which sought to eliminate the right of the upper class to set its own values if it excluded the lower class.

...

Overall, it was a fascinating piece, especially the coverage of the aesthetic of beauty and sex that they built. The core question for me is this: Was the feeling that people got from buying and wearing the clothing worth the costs, both economic and moral, that we paid for them? By creating the brand and the feeling, A&F provided value. One talking head on the doc, who would later be a plaintiff suing A&F for discrimination, said she had one A&F shirt which she wore as often as she could to every party. Clearly that had some value for her, and it was created by the very brand-building discrimination she herself would later decry. Is that value redeeming, or is it bad in and of itself, a false happiness that must of necessity lead to more suffering than it is worth?

Not that I'd expect Scott to think about Abercrombie and Fitch a lot, but I think this provides a frame that is a lot more understandable to a modern American or American-adjacent: rather than Master/Slave morality, think of it as Preppy Jock vs Emo Kid conceptions of what is cool. Like ol' Freddy Nietzche we are dealing in archetypes not actualities, these are myths which, like all myths, deal in an imagined past not in our own present.

The archetypal Preppy Jock likes things that he likes, that his friends like, and thinks those things are cool because he and his friends like them. Sports are cool, he's good at them and his friends are good at them, and if some other person is good at them then that person must be cool too. Being rich is cool, having money lets you do cool things. Hooking up with pretty girls is cool. He, and his friends, and the pretty girls he wants to hook up with, all wear A&F, so A&F must be cool. Wanting to be strong and beautiful and admired and have a pretty partner are basic human traits, these desires are inherently humanistic.

The archetypal Emo Kid isn't good at sports, isn't rich, and can't get the pretty girls to make out with him. So he creates his own version of cool where every aspect of the Preppy Jock system is inverted. Sportsball is stupid, jocks are dumb, they'll be working for us nerds some day!. Rich kids are arrogant and cruel, and because they have everything handed to them they don't really build character or know the real world. He obviously lusts after the pretty girls too, but they aren't into him, and the entire corpus of Emo love songs is largely built around the fantasy that he, the Nice Guy, would be a better partner than the Jock who actually gets her; hooking up with pretty girls is lame, having deep unfulfilled longing for them which is finally sanctified when consummated in a mega-deep way that the dumb Jocks and Players will never get, the Pretty Girl will finally realize that she really wanted the Emo Kid all along. The Preppy Jocks wear A&F, so A&F is for lame, arrogant, idiots, who pay for overpriced T Shirts. His values are built on negating the values of his bullies.

This example illustrates how it interacts with the classic Barber Pole of fashion to produce some of the contradictions re:Christianity that different commenters have noted. Master morality is what masters like, and it is possible to change what they like, which will then become master morality. A&F was able to get hot teenagers in their clothing, other hot teenagers realized it was the hot teenager thing to do, and without overly self examining purchased A&F. There's nothing inherent to being a jock about wearing loose or tight (or now loose again) jeans from a certain mall brand, but they naturally become part of the story. ((Though I will argue that for aesthetic reasons all WASPy people with decently athletic bodies look best in trad ivy fashions))

Christianity was a religion of slaves, until it became the religion of the masters. At that point, Christianity became master morality. There is a Marxian Base/Superstructure aspect to it. To return to our high school, there is more master morality in the Fellowship of Christian Athletes than in the Wiccan Club, even if the members of the Wiccan Club can successfully offer a lecture about Master Vs Slave Morality in Nietzche and the FCA kids can't.

Which is the final contradiction: talking constantly about Master Morality is often a form of Slave Morality. It is the effort to negate the values of your bullies, to claim that your own values are higher and finer and better than those that oppress you. This goes back to Nietzsche himself, of course. But also stays true in the ACX comment section: the incomparable Walt Bismarck, annoyed at being derided as cruel and weird, proceeded to prove how cruel and weird he was, with his yass-ified AI avatar just being so ridiculous that I can never take anyone who would do that seriously. The kind of people that talk about Master Morality are using the concept as a Slave Morality, as a cope to deal with how downtrodden they actually are. They aren't natural Achilles types, reveling in their own dominance. They are sad losers, talking about the grand conspiracy against them, about how if it weren't for the "Longhouse Ethics" of the world they coulda been a contenda.

current Israel leadership know they need total victory for permanent safety

The whole idea of "permanent safety" is such a ridiculous conception of a policy goal that it says a lot about the mendacity and stupidity of the American foreign policy intelligentsia that it's taken seriously as a condition for a peace process.