FiveHourMarathon
a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop
And every gimmick hungry yob
Digging gold from rock n roll
Grabs the mic to tell us
he'll die before he's sold
But I believe in this
And it's been tested by research
He who fucks nuns
Will later join the church
User ID: 195
Nobody in any position of power is arguing for that, so it's not really relevant to the political debate.
As to Adderall in law schools, it's a zero sum, competitive, ordinal grading system. Allowing one person to cheat harms someone who doesn't directly, and pressures others into cheating as well. Though I suppose the argument could be made that biglaw is full of drug addicts anyway so who cares if it's a level playing field it's the playing field you'll be on.
The "whatever reason" is all the stuff Israel is experiencing trying to turn Hamas into chunky salsa.
International opprobrium isn't something that can just be written off.
Plenty of disorders are detectable, but not perfectly. False positives are common across a range of medical tests. Short of a gene that can be identified and predicts trans status with 100% accuracy, there's nothing irrational about saying something exists but we have to be careful about treating it because we could be wrong.
How Do We Stop Doctor Shopping
TLDR: If one is attempting to gatekeep a treatment, whether surgical or pharmaceutical, that is important for some patients but that other people may seek to access for reasons we find unacceptable, behind physicians and medical standards, how does one prevent doctor shopping? How does one prevent a sufficiently wealthy or connected individual from trying doctor after doctor until they get what they want?
My wife and I were discussing SCOTUS granting cert for USA v. SKRMETTI (link to petition, link to lower court decision here) a case in which the Justice Department is attempting to overturn a Tennessee law banning medical transition for minors. I commented that I saw no path forward for the case at SCOTUS, because they don't even bother in the petition to argue that Tennessee lacks the power to regulate medical care. The petition repeatedly cites WPATH standards, so recently discussed here, as though their existence writes itself into Tennessee law or the US constitution automatically. No matter how many times the petition uses the term "evidence based;" I'm left wondering where in the Constitution the legislature is required to act based on evidence. The core of their argument is around equal protection:
That is precisely how SB1 works: An adolescent assigned female at birth cannot receive puberty blockers or testosterone to live as a male, but an adolescent assigned male at birth can. And vice versa, an adolescent assigned male at birth cannot receive puberty blockers or estrogen to live as a female, but an adolescent assigned female at birth can. “Because [a] minor’s sex at birth determines whether or not the minor can receive certain types of medical care,” a ban on gender-affirming care necessarily “discriminates on the basis of sex.”
The decision from which they appealed concluded that:
There is a long tradition of permitting state governments to regulate medical treatments for adults and children. So long as a federal statute does not stand in the way and so long as an enumerated constitutional guarantee does not apply, the States may regulate or ban medical technologies they deem unsafe.
It seems to me that the state has the power to regulate medical treatments within its borders.
Being straight, as one occasionally must, I then listened to my wife bring up Kylie Jenner and her adventures in plastic surgery. I have to admit my wife has a point, the 26 year old woman looks at least 40. Her face is weirdly contoured, filler has wandered around, and her breasts are kinda detached from her body at some angles. Why, she asked, is it legal for her parents to get her plastic surgery, starting her on a path that has permanently altered and ruined her body; merely because those procedures were gender conforming? Because the weird "negroid-barbie-doll-centaur" Kardashian look is undoubtedly feminine rather than masculine, Kylie and her parents are unrestricted in making insane changes to her body?
I replied that it would make sense to ban plastic surgery for minors, and that Tennessee would certainly have the power to do so, and that I'd support a total ban except in cases of extreme deformities. How would you define extreme deformity, she shot back. Well, I guess you'd need a doctor to certify it. Gotcha, she said, that wouldn't stop Kylie or her parents for a second, they'd have crooked Armenian doctors on tap anywhere they needed them.
And it occurs to me that I have absolutely no idea what the next step in that process is. How do you gatekeep medical procedures against the well resourced?
In law school I knew lots of people who doctor shopped. First for a certification of "disability" that would grant them extra time on entrance exams, then for adderall prescriptions. ((I honestly felt they ought to piss-test before finals, addys were such a problem.)) They all fit the same criteria: well connected, wealthy families, people who often knew lots of doctors personally and had the resources and support to try multiple to get the diagnosis they were looking for to get what they wanted.
I've no doubt that if a diagnosis of "deformity" were required for cosmetic surgery, many women would suddenly be diagnosed with deformed breast tissue. I've already heard of plenty of use of creative diagnoses to get things covered by insurance policies.
Maybe it's lack of knowledge, but I'm at a loss as to how one fights this. A blanket ban on trying a different doctor seems like it would run dangerously close to banning second opinions, and I've seen many second opinions that massively improved on the first doctor's results. People should be free to keep trying if one doctor can't get results. But how do we distinguish the case of an individual trying to find help for a condition, from an individual without medical training settling on a pill they want to pop and trying doctors until they find one who will let them pop it?
This has obvious pharmaceutical implications. Adderall, Xanax, Oxy have all been abused. But what about things like TRT? Plastic surgery? And of course it comes back around to Transgender Kids: if somebody takes their kid to three doctors and they all say the kid isn't trans, but drags them on to a fourth doctor who says they are, is the kid trans or not?
I can't think of any good way to draw the line. At best we can rely on professional ethics, but, you know, lol. What's the strategy here?
I've been having similar thoughts for a bit, happy to be able to latch onto your post to discuss them. I think you are broadly correct, but that the common wisdom advice is the common wisdom advice for a few reasons:
Focusing on diet is good advice if you're in a hurry, or if you're already working out. At my age and size and weight and activity level, the basic calculators say I maintain weight at about 2,800 calories a day. That's pretty much my normal diet. I can cut 800-1000 calories a day with effort, but without suffering. I can cut 2000 calories a day while feeling it a little, but not dying or curtailing other activities. To burn 800 extra calories a day, I'd have to run something like eight miles (I'm going to use a simple 100 calories/mile number for simplicity). That will take a good runner an hour, it would take me at least an hour twenty or an hour thirty, and I'd be tired after. To burn an extra 2000 calories, well it's right in the username, it would take me close on five hours. A totally impractical quantity of time to spend in an otherwise full life.
Moreover, adding more than about two moderate miles a day to a full workout schedule is nearly guaranteed to interfere with squats, or kettlebell snatches, or whatever else I'm trying to do. For a sedentary person, anything bigger than a two mile walk (probably the equivalent 100 calories) is going to require effort and recovery. You've frequently discussed injuries in the WW threads, that shows right off how difficult it would be for you to add activity to burn additional calories.
So, in my mind, it's easy to cut 500-800 calories a day, on average. That's a pound a week. While it's easy to burn 100-200 extra calories a day. That's a pound a month.
Burning an extra 100-200 calories is going to get you a pound a month, give or take. Keep it up for a year, you're dropping ten pounds a year.
That's a lot in the grand scheme of things! If I was ten pounds heavier every year for the past five, I'd be fucking fat by now. And that's the case for a lot of people! If they took a two miles walk every day, 45 minutes of time, they'd be a lot lighter today.
But that's also mind-numbingly, unnoticeably slow. If I tried to do something today, in hopes of being lighter five years from now, that's tough for me. It sure ain't gonna help you get ready for that beach weekend. Where cutting calories, whether daily or in an IF format as I prefer, can get you ten pounds in two months, no sweat.
So in my mind, if someone is sedentary and fat and wishes to lose weight, the right move is to start by getting active, and then to move to diet. If one is already active, focus on diet.
The inverse is also undeniably accurate, that it's always possible to out-eat any workout plan, it is always possible to create a diet bad enough that it can't be outrun. I outweigh you by 50 pounds, I'd imagine that might be a difference between us: it's not difficult for me to imagine a dietary choice so brutal that no activity would save me. There's an all you can eat Sushi place on the drive back from the downtown courthouse, I could swing in there and with a few beers or sodas eat a marathon's worth of calories. I could sit down and house a half bag of oreos watching the Phillies, and not even think about it. I can power through half a pie when my wife makes one. Any Dairy Queen will happily sell me a thousand calorie Blizzard. Some degree of not-terrible choices must be made to even begin to keep a decent weight.
I also think that the viral memetic quality of "You can't outrun a bad diet" is in part a puritan strain in American culture that can't quite be exorcised. You can't be enjoying yourself, having fun, and getting good results. You must be suffering. Suffering is the only way to succeed. So don't think you can enjoy that donut and then pop in a podcast and take a pleasant jog or go climbing and burn it off. You can't do that! You must suffer!
They're making life far more inconvenient for the USA than they have any right to, and gaining major credibility among global jihadis for themselves and Iran in the process.
To be fair, as I think of it more, I think you have the right of it. If you graphed generalized Five Domain fitness against fishing trips-per-year, age adjusted I would bet that fishing would have a positive correlation with fitness up to median, but a weak correlation above median. I was committing the sin of failing to consider the vast number of people too sedentary to fish.
The point I'm getting at is always less about the real implication than the social implication. These are social games.
Once I set a challenge at my gym for everyone to build a "personal pentathlon." That is, pick 5 exercises/events that you think the lowest percentage of people could beat you at all 5. No matter how unusual the exercises or strange the combination, what can you do that no one else could do better all at once?
I'm no hero when it comes down to it, but I don't think 1% of the population could beat me at all five of: Moonboard climbing max V3-4 climbs in 30 minutes, 5min kettlebell snatch test @28kg, max muscle ups in 10 minutes, 1rm power clean and push jerk, 2k row for time. I'm not even good by hobbyist standards at some of those choices, but I'm good enough to pip most people. The guys who can out climb better than me rarely jerk more, the guys who jerk more rarely climb.
So that's one method.
Probably a dozen or so times. Though fairly casually beyond one big sailing trip from Islamorada to Key West and back, when we fished intermittently but constantly for two weeks.
I will say I've never been fly fishing, which I understand is a very different animal.
Like I said I'm no angler. But I see very little visible correlation between fishing performance and athleticism in my friends.
I think it's more, don't show up starving. Which is good advice:
-
You don't risk disappointment. I have to feed my wife before parties at one friend's house, because the food is uniformly terrible. Boiled hot dogs and tasteless burnt burger patties and off brand plain potato chips and coleslaw that is just wilted cabbage in mayonnaise, that kind of thing. And they're fine enough people and it's a good enough party, the beer is good, but you'll be happier if you go there mostly already fed just to socialize.
-
You don't worry about quantity. Your host might not have enough food for every guest to get their fill, or the process of serving it might not be convenient to distribute it to everyone in a timely manner. If you're STARVING this will be an upsetting development, if you're just there for a snack, you'll be perfectly happy waiting or eating less.
I think the optimal way to show up is having eaten a light snack beforehand, so that you're at a state of "I could eat" when you arrive, but even if for whatever reason you don't eat anything there you won't be starving midway through the night.
I'm really confused by your summary. What's the disconnect in how men and women see the world that you're outlining here?
I'm probably a little effeminate, I'm certainly no angler, but I'm reading that and your summary of the male position strikes me as almost unbelievably stupid. Fishing as an athletic activity? Are these men really that dumb? I wouldn't fuck him either, frankly.
The female perspective is persnickety and bratty and bitchy, but probably accurate to a reasonable approximation.
I agree with you on balance that some women genuinely disliking fish pictures started the ball rolling, but the far greater effect that makes fish pictures a meme and accentuates their unattractiveness is the knowledge that they are unattractive socially. Once that becomes common knowledge, it is fatal.
You know, I'm no genius, but more and more I find that when I see a general culture war question I want to reply to, I end up linking back to or quoting a comment I made or someone else made years ago. My new posts tend to all be about books I've read or great movies I've watched recently.
It was a project by some charity or other claiming that "hate crimes" (or victimization, or incidents, or whatever they measure) jump by 60% during pride month.
Probably on its face true, because vandalism is considered in the same category of "hate crime" as assault, and during pride month the amount of publicly displayed gay stuff increases by vastly more than 60%. If the modal hate crime is something like "FAG" graffiti on a pro-Gay poster or tearing down a pride flag, the number of pro-gay posters and pride flags has to increase by 500% or better during Pride. So really, the hate criminals are restraining themselves more during pride month. It's the same way that AIPAC and the ADL have long played with the numbers to make Jews the primary victim of hate crimes, because swastika graffiti anywhere within five miles of a Synagogue is counted as a hate crime in their numbers.
Anecdotally, as Pride is becoming something you get taught about in middle school, the backlash is inevitable among the youth as a basic form of teen rebellion. Kids are always going to find whatever their 7th grade health teacher teaches them lame. I remember in health class they showed us a Lifetime movie about Date Rape called She Cried No. As a gang of virgins in the Boy Scouts, we spent multiple camping trips making up alternate titles when the scoutmasters weren't looking. "She cried maybe later" "She cried not you" "she cried and then kept crying." And it wasn't like we were pro-rape, just that health class was lame and we were going to make fun of it.
I've had the argument with many well-meaning progressive friends who tell me they are teaching their kids that classic profanity is no big deal, but slurs are the really bad words. I tell them that is the opposite of how to teach their kids not to use slurs: every kid turns twelve or thirteen and wants to use the no-no words, from Romeo's buddies in Verona swearing by Christ's Wounds to kids buying Eminem CDs in 2001. If you tell them that Nigger and Faggot are the only really bad words, those are the only words they can use to get the thrill of using profanity for the first time. The old Reddit joke about Dr. Kikey McNiggerFaggot will hit all the harder for them. Unless your kid is some Ned Flanders-ass dork, they're gonna cuss. You better teach them cuss words that are no big deal, or they'll use the ones that are. #ReadAnotherBook and all, but liberalism has fallen a long way from 1997 when Fictional Liberal Hero Dumbledore confidently intoned that "fear of a [word] increases fear of the thing itself;" and you knew the really good guys because they weren't afraid to use the no-no words, they said what they meant and meant what they said. Now the left-wingers would be in support of not using the "V-word" because it "re-traumatizes" the victims and their families.
I'm going to quote my own comment on anti-Conservative dating discrimination
I feel like on dating apps there's a certain Strawmanization of political spectrum where 'Right = Super fascist' and 'Moderate/Apolitical/whatever = Hiding Super Fascist'.
Two analogies:
- My father always talked about interviewing guys for jobs, and he'd ask questions like "We start early on work days, do you think you can make it on time?" And some guys would respond "Eh, you know, normally, but sometimes I sleep in." My father's take on it was, not only was this a guy who might show up late (almost everyone shows up at 6:10 instead of 6:00 some days), he didn't even know the right answer to the question! He thought it was acceptable to say he was going to sleep in; at least a guy who lied and said he'd be there every day at 6:00 knew that he was supposed to show up on time.
- Dan Savage has talked in his advice column about how in high school it can seem like all the gay kids are flaming camp queens, because those are the only kids that are out in high school, because they have to be out. Their closet is made of glass, their mannerisms would give them away in a heartbeat if they tried to stay closeted. The "normal" masculine straight passing gay men can safely stay closeted at that point in their lives, but after graduation when things are safer come out.
So if listing your politics as "Right Wing" or even "Moderate" is the objectively wrong answer in online dating, then doing so means you probably fall under either 1) or 2). Either you don't even know the socially correct answer, so you're a maladroit chump, that's not an attractive look; or you're so right wing that you can't possibly stay in the closet about it, it would be too obvious, which regardless of your politics isn't a good look, and quite likely maps onto something like "superfascist" anyway.
Note that this does not require that the women making the judgment "actually" care about a man having right-wing politics, only that they know that right-wing politics are a socially unacceptable answer in an online dating context. Everything follows from that.
Let's apply this simple system to Fish Pictures. Let's start by positing that Tweets have been tweeted around left wing feminine twitter and articles written on left wing feminine-coded websites about how fish pictures are unattractive. This is definitely true, Fish Picture discourse exists, as you provide examples of. As soon as that is the case, the phenomenon is self sustaining. If you're using a Fish Picture, you are perceived as either out of touch with the social discourse, or so incredibly obsessed with right wing politics, I mean fish, that you it's the only picture you have. Neither is attractive in a mate. Even if an individual woman doesn't mind fishing in and of itself, she may still discriminate against Fish Pictures because she things it signals a guy who is either socially inept or fish obsessed, because she knows other girls discriminate against Fish Pictures.
It's a good way to select for guys who read the same twitter feeds and thinkpieces you do, where they would have learned that Fish Pictures are bad and maybe racist or something.
Thinking about it more, a few explanations jump out:
-
They really aren't very tough, they're just spooks, scary, and if you're brave enough to face them they run off. One of the big changes they make in the films, in my mind, is that the Orcs in the films are brave and disciplined and self-sacrificing. Their commanders are brutal and have little care for their lives, but the Orcs are more than willing to jump right in and sacrifice themselves. Tolkien views courage, martial discipline, and self-sacrifice as inherently positive "good" characteristics; his villains are all cowards, they'll flee when the good guys stand up unless they have absolute confidence in their success. To a certain extent with respect to the Nazgul, this is probably a change that Jackson has to make in the film, terror aura probably doesn't really translate to film well. It's also probably a change in view from Tolkien's time to ours, we grew up on WWII dramas filled with Kamikaze pilots and last stands in Berlin, on VietCong and Contras, and the films were released (and edited) more or less coterminously with 9/11 and the war on terror stuff. We were very used to impossibly brave and self-sacrificing foes being not just on the side of evil, but a sign of evil itself.
-
After sixty years of interpreters and imitators, and DnD/Vidya in particular, it's tough for me to realize that scientific knowledge isn't really something Tolkien does. Later authors and Dungeon Masters would have very precise rules about who has what power level, who beats who, and what does how much damage, and what happens to who when they're hit. There's a baseline of scientific laws that are pre-determined before combat starts between characters, deciding what will happen and why. We don't have that, and neither do the characters, in Tolkien. Tolkien's characters don't really know what happens when a ringwraith gets stabbed in the face, or lit on fire, or thrown down a stream. They have guesses based on gathered lore, they perhaps have similar cases they can deduce from. But even the Nazgul themselves don't really know what will happen to them, what can harm them and what can't, other than the Witch King who is pretty confident no man can slay him.
So can the Nazgul be killed by Bucklanders? Maybe, maybe not, but the Nazgul are giving the same answer we are, and they very much don't want to get got.
Aside: it's actually not entirely clear about the Witch King. She definitely disables him, but the last time they got discorporated (to use the Good Omens term) it was some months before we saw them again. The Witch King goes down just a few days before the Ring gets destroyed, so we're not really certain if he would have turned back up given enough time to get it back together. But he was out of commission when it all came down, so we'll never know.
Now on to Rivendell and the Fellowship Roster Moneyball memes
I don't know. I wanted to stay with Windows, but I wanted a premium feeling laptop. I use it all the time, I wanted it made out of metal. To get aluminum construction, the MacBook air was much cheaper. So that's what I've used for the last five years.
I started Master and Commander this week. I saw the film before, and it's both a perfect adaptation could not be better, and doesn't hold a candle to the book, at the same time. The sheer wildness of the book is amazing. I'm also kind of amused at the number of times Maturin calls Aubrey fat in the book, and I'm curious how everyone else pictures Jack.
After watching the films in theaters, I started the Fellowship of the Ring on Audible, the Andy Serkis reading was available free. What a majestic work. I hadn't read it in years, and I'm so happy returning to it. It's interesting though that Serkis' reading is clearly influenced by the films, when he voices the main characters at times it feels like Serkis-doing-Orlando-Bloom instead of an independent interpretation of Legolas. T
he film adaptation can really close in your mind, in some ways, like the visualization of the Nazgul becomes the canonical view of them. I'm really reconsidering them on this read/listen. When the hobbits raise the alarm in Buckland, the Nazgul scamper, clearly a bunch of farmers showing up with torches and pitchforks would have been bad for them in some way. Were they secretly kinda cotton candy under the cloaks?
With older people in particular, the hoarders I think often reflect broad scale deflation in manufactured goods over time. Older people grew up with more expensive manufactured goods. Little nonsense like commemorative plates and snow babies and precious moments probably all fall into the category of things that would have been more expensive when they were young. My dad is a frequent overbuyer, of many things, and when he does it always takes the justification of "that would have been [3x price] back in the day." Especially with tools and things like that, he'll buy entirely too many power drills or tool boxes because they used to be more expensive. Nobody could really sell the little cheap commemorative crap for as cheap as it is today back in the day, so they buy it feeling like it must have real value, even though it doesn't at this point.
Also, the useless stuff is the most likely to survive. The Precious Moments don't wear out, don't get moved around and break often, etc. I've purchased a decent number of laptops and cellphones, and more measuring tapes than I can count. When I die, there won't be many of them left in the house, they'll be destroyed or lost, worn out or stolen.
I block liberally on Twitter, but I never tweet so it's less "guy replying and annoying me" and more "this post was incredibly fucking stupid and I see no reason to give them another chance."
Likely only if she reads the badges, while a man who's into cars clocks it instantly from a quarter mile away on the highway.
In the same way that my wife recently told me that the new flowers she put in the living room vase were special to her because they were the flowers in our wedding bouquet. I hadn't noticed that the flowers had changed, as the last ones were yellow too.
A lot of women impressed by a Porsche wouldn't immediately know the difference if you rebadged a Corvette.
Is it just me or are there also absurdly fewer colors of cars on the road now too?
It is not just you.
I'd tend to blame the obsession with resale value, taken apart in this article about watches. Time was, cars didn't last nearly as long as they do now, especially American cars. 100k miles used to be "on death's door;" now it's a warmup for a lot of models. It was common for the first owner to drive the car all the way to the junkyard, or to sell it for a minimal amount when they were done with it. Modern cars on the road are close to 14 years old, in 1970 the average was under 6, and it only broke ten well in the Dubya administration.
Once reselling your car becomes a concern, tastes become recursively drawn towards the inoffensive median, an ouroboros of boredom. Most people don't mind a white, silver, gray car. Personally, I would love a baby blue or orange car, but never buy a red or gold or black car. But I wouldn't reject a white car. Another person would utterly hate a baby blue or orange car, but would buy a red or gold car. But they'll also accept white. So someone selling a white car has more buyers than someone selling an orange car, giving them higher resale value.
It's recursive, because if the second owner expects to sell to a third owner later on, then he will also prioritize white over orange, and so will pay more for a white car than an orange car. And so on down the line.
People bought fun cars when they expected to drive the car all the way to the junkyard, or they simply didn't care and chose what they liked personally. Today, people make responsible financial choices, and pick boring colors. Everything trends towards a mushy middle. C'est la vie.
Searle, in his lectures on Philosophy of Mind, talks about how perception occurs at the level of your baseline skill. And he talks about how men buy cars to impress women, but if he actually shows an actual woman at Berkeley his car they will say it is "red" or "a convertible" or if they're relatively knowledgable a "sports car;" they may notice the badge and they may not if they look closely. While when he shows it to his male friends in the Engineering department, they instantly see that it's a Guards Red Porsche 911 Carerra Turbo Targa, probably a 991.2 but he'll have to look closer to be sure. And it's not that either of them is "thinking" more about it, it's that they perceive those facts essentially instantly, but in completely different ways.
It's so obviously grasping at Straws. Thomas has been over of the most ideologically consistent justices in modern history, there is just no good evidence of him throwing cases in any way. It's this weird mistake theory belief that no one can believe anything different than what you believe, so if anyone acts like they believe it there must be corruption involved.
Path Lit By Lightning Thoughts and Review: A Hero's Life, Long Obscured by One Set of Politically Correct Myths, Now Obscured by Another
TLDR CW Thesis: The life story of Jim Thorpe was long built around easy racial stereotypes of the shiftless, dumb, unsophisticated, alcoholic but immensely talented Indian. This telling obscured a lot about Jim, his achievements, skills and values and those of the other players in his story. Path Lit by Lightning set out to demolish these myths and offer a revisionist take on the Jim Thorpe story, but in his effort to tell Thorpe's tale "correctly" Maraniss overshoots the mark, refusing to tell the honest truth about Thorpe. This undermines the narrative flow of the biography unless one reads critically between the lines knowing what the author is setting out to achieve.
-- The life and times of Jim Thorpe {Wiki link for the unfamiliar} provide ample material for any biographer to work with. I'm really curious to what extent, if at all, Winston Groom was inspired to create the character of Forrest Gump in his novels by Thorpe's life story, or if the resemblance is purely coincidental because most people didn't realize just how crazy Thorpe's life was. Here he is, growing up hardscrabbled on the Res; then suddenly he's coached by Pop Warner (the coach for which youth football would be named), competing against and defeating Harvard and Army in College Football; young cadet Dwight Eisenhower tries to knock Thorpe out of the game with a dirty hit, only to be run over and sent to the sideline by an injury himself; his wife appears at the world's fair at an Indian exhibition with Indian Chiefs who fought against the US Army before being shepherded onto reservations, then off to the Olympics to be called "The Most Wonderful Athlete in the World"and replying "Thanks, King," competing alongside a young Lt. George Patton; then out of college sports in obscure scandal and off to play Major League Baseball with McGraw and Mathewson, rubbing shoulders with Tris Speaker and Babe Ruth along the way; becoming the founding president of what would become the NFL; circling the world on an exhibition tour with the Big Train and the Big Six, getting a special award from Mr. Lipton, the founder of Lipton Tea!; befriending Hollywood stars like John Wayne and Bob Hope. It goes on and on! He was, if not responsible for, present at the event of, so many important events, in sport and in the world in general. Maraniss does a great job of using the material to jump off into bigger discussions of American history. But at times he suffers from blind spots...
-- A frequent flaw of progressive historiography of subaltern groups, racial or religious minorities and women, is their failure to place the historical group oppression in the context of how much life in general sucked back then. Here, Maraniss spends a lot of time talking about the tragedy of Indian life, the Indian school system and how it was designed to destroy their culture, kill the Indian and save the man. But, within that context, we keep seeing Pretendians pop up. Thorpe's first wife was a fake Indian, sent to the "oppressive" Indian Boarding Schools by her father after her mother's death. One of his Carlisle teammates was also a pretendian*, who found his way into Carlisle more or less in order to sneak his way into a prominent football team without having to get into Harvard or Yale or West Point. As oppressed as Indians may have been, they were also, even in the early 1900s, given privileges by the Federal government, funded educations and boarding schools, and there were white people poor enough to be willing to fake Indian histories in order to get access to those resources. Reading Maraniss critically, it does undermine his argument: if things were really so bad at Carlisle, why were whites sneaking in? It's a more complex narrative. I'm reminded of one of my favorite passages from Frederick Douglass: how he would steal bread, which he had unlimited access to in his master's kitchen, and trade it to young white street kids, who were hungry but knew how to read, and were willing to befriend and teach the young slave in exchange for food. We have to contextualize historical oppression narratives in the larger narrative of class oppression and poverty in early America, which cared little for race when it came to living standards, even if it cared greatly for race when it came to political and cultural power.
-- Maraniss clearly sets out to write a revisionist history of Jim Thorpe's life, seeking to puncture myths like Pop Warner's nobility and Thorpe's playing into Indian stereotypes of Alcoholism. The problem is, Pop Warner was a pretty great coach, and Thorpe was an alcoholic. So at times, the pitch he gives to the stories tends to make the whole story seem irrational, because parts are missing. Only by critically taking stock of the history, and considering the bias of the author, is the narrative legible. Pop Warner was no saint, Maraniss is convincing arguing that Warner lied about his knowledge of Thorpe's semi-pro baseball career, but he was a great coach, a titan of the early game, and it was largely his influence that built those great Carlisle teams. (See below for more discussion of this) Thorpe's alcoholism, meanwhile, lurks like a kind of nameless terror for much of the book, then suddenly his wife will divorce him for his alcoholism. I understand the desire not to dwell on it, not to reduce Thorpe's later life to booze and fecklessness, but well, the guy was a drunk who never took care of his many kids. And painting him as this noble, gentle soul who was always doing his best makes the episodes when the drunkenness becomes apparent feel like glimpses of a deeper truth. It feels rather like when people write American-Centric histories of the second world war, and all of a sudden you realize that the Soviets have been doing most of the heavy lifting the whole time. Maraniss seeks to write away from the Alcoholism, only to have it reemerge because it may have been the defining fact of Thorpe's life. To what extent has the genetic basis for alcoholism become a solved question today?
-- Pop Warner's appearance at Carlisle Indian School was a sort of coincidence, a random stroke of luck for a government boarding school that was trying to do a lot of things at once. His presence there brought Indian athletes to the forefront of the national athletic conversation. Once there, as racial minorities, they were the subject of constant theorizing around how their heritage had granted them a genetic edge. Thorpe in particular, but equally the dominant Carlisle football teams of Warner's tenure, were viewed as proof positive of the superior athletic ability of the Red Man, a part of his natural dominion of nature, his ancestral upbringing in the chase and the woods. That is a stereotype that hasn't held since Warner's day. In fact, it was largely a product of the peculiar circumstances of those great Carlisle teams. Carlisle wasn't really a four year college, though it would play against Universities as equals. It had students enrolled as young as nine, and as old as 26 when Thorpe was playing there. A lot of its athletes were in their mid 20s, rather than 18-22 like most of the Ivy League. Thorpe was 25 at the time of his great Olympic triumphs and his greatest College Football seasons, and because of Carlisle he was able to devote himself to athletics without having to worry about room and board in a way few competitors could. Carlisle offered a unique opportunity for athletes in their prime to avoid self-supporting work, while focusing on athletics. This created the illusion, for a decade or so, that Indians were athletically superior to other races. When we consider HBD in sports, we need to consider the graveyards of other HBD theories of sports, and have some humility as to what we really know. At one point, Basketball was considered the perfect sport for the Jew, with its manifold opportunities for trickery and scheming. Heavyweight boxing championships went from belonging to the Irish in the deep past, to when I was growing up where the common wisdom was that there might never be another white heavyweight champion outside of the movies, to the period when it was thought that the Russians (actually, mostly Ukrainians) would dominate the field in perpetuity, to today where the last five champions were a Ukrainian, an Irishman, a Nigerian-Brit, a Mexican-American, and a Samoan-Kiwi. During each period of ethnic dominance, there were numerous genetic and cultural explanations offered for why it would never end. When blacks dominated between Ali and Lewis, the common sense was that we would never see another white champion, blacks were simply too fast. When the Russians/Ukrainians dominated, they were built tougher, and raised meaner, than Americans ever would be. We don't always know everything we think we know, contingent and ever-changing cultural contexts are so important to producing champions in any sport, and we should be hesitant to buy into easy genetic narratives of superiority.
-- Overall, the book was excellent, immensely enjoyable and instructive, exhaustively well researched and sourced. There's scenes to thrill, to teach, to inspire; and scenes to stir the soul. It was truly a perfect beach read, while also being truly first class work. I'd endorse it, on the whole, for anyone interested in old timey athletics or American history in a readable package.

The death spiral point is interesting. As I get older, I realize over and over how much injury prevention and management is the long term key to fitness.
More options
Context Copy link