@FiveHourMarathon's banner p

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users  
joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


				

User ID: 195

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users   joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

					

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


					

User ID: 195

Adverse possession only applies where the real owner doesn't notice. If you're trying to evict me the whole time, it doesn't matter how long I stay in your house, it remains your house.

The statute of limitations in common law, in nearly all cases, only runs out if no redress is being pursued. You can't just stall on a lawsuit that's been filed against you for years, then claim that it has gone stale. As long as the lawsuit is filed on time, the SoL argument is moot.

The Palestinians haven't exactly let this drop. Indeed, one can argue the extent to which they have had any opportunity to let it drop if they had wanted to. So if this were a lawsuit, no statute of limitations would apply.

The SoL concept probably applies better to internal minorities like amerindians or ADoS; or to long settled controversies like Greater Hungary.

Oh it absolutely does. Religious communities are full of women who wish they could keep their husbands closer to the faith.

Something we don't know that impacts their effectiveness for non-Jihadists: how many of the IPG operators survived the day and successfully returned to Gaza? My initial guess would be none, and certainly I suspect that the expectation among both Hamas' planners and the operators themselves was that this was a purely one way trip, any that did ultimately survive were a result of success that exceeded expectations. They expected to insert these militants deep into Israel, where they would effectively shoot in random directions before being killed, but in the process they would distract Israeli response forces and allow other militants to achieve direct aims.

Gaza, for a variety of reasons both religious and material, has an unusually large supply of young men willing to kill themselves for the cause. While countries like Ukraine and Azerbaijan have a plentiful supply of nationalist psychopaths willing to die for the nation, a certain-death suicide mission is a different animal. Le Guard Meurt Mais Ne Se Rend Pas! is a very different attitude than that of the suicide bomber. The Gazans also did not need to be particularly talented or trained, they were sent to attack a music festival. Send them to attack even a soft military target, or to achieve any real sabotage or destruction of infrastructure that might impact a battle, and they'll need training and skills. Training, skills, and courage that you won't particularly want to sacrifice for a single battle. It's not clear that the IPG would have any value if you didn't have men you were willing to sacrifice who were willing to be sacrificed.

Thanks Bro! Did me a real solid.

...and what was shooting up the music festival?

Terrorism. I'm not sure what your point is.

If you want to say that terrorism is ok as long as the other guy did it first, just say that. But it doesn't make something not what it is.

suggest the studies found those who more accurately estimated the Jewish population seemed less hostile.

Or that those with even basic education are less jingoistic and blinkered in their views. If we tested similarly in America, strong academic scores would correlate very strongly with liberal worldview, not because of facts but because getting those kinds of scores leads/requires you to go to an undergrad institution where liberal views are inflicted on you.

Or Egypt fails to brutally repress them, either because it's hard or because it inspires homegrown resistance, the government falls to Islamic radicals, and Egypt becomes 10 Gazas. Or the Sinai becomes a lawless hellscape filled with weapons, a problem for both governments. Or Hamas militiaman cool their heels in Sinai for five or ten years then return to cause problems for Israel anywhere else. One doesn't just decide to engage in brutal repression and instantly win.

They have no desire for Gazans to flee to Egypt. It would not help any of Israel's aims to have them do so.

I'm really not understanding your point.

Genocide is the destruction of a group. The cide of a genos. Obviously killing 1 person, however motivated, isn't genocide. Obviously killing every single person in that group is genocide. Where you draw the lines in the middle is the question, I don't see what your little word games have to do with it.

You're missing a key difference, under Rand's view voting has nothing to do with it. Merely choosing to live under a wicked government is sufficient consent to sign your death warrant. One must martyr oneself for freedom, one revolts and wins or dies; if you do not revolt you do not deserve mercy or consideration.

All the polling is clever, but ultimately irrelevant to the people citing Hamas' supposed popular support. I suspect that the logic of punishing civilians in Gaza for the crimes of their leadership is primarily Randian

As a broader philosophical matter, Rand judged that “anyone who wants to invade a dictatorship or semi-dictatorship is morally justified in doing so, because he is doing no worse than what that country has accepted as its social system.” Her rationale on World War II and Vietnam was based on the view that since American lives weren’t threatened, it would be wrong to go on a crusade on behalf of foreigners. Later in life, Rand weighed in on the Israel/Palestine conflict.

Appearing on the Phil Donahue show in 1979, Rand was asked what she thought of U.S. policy in the Middle East. She replied that the American government should side with Israel against Palestinians because, in her words, Israel was the “advanced, technological, civilized country” in the dispute, squared off against “a group of almost totally primitive savages who have not changed for years and who are racist and who resent Israel because it is bringing industry, and intelligence, and modern technology into their stagnation.”

Donahue pushed back, arguing that the Palestinians were in a terrible spot, and asking if she wasn’t too one-sided. Rand responded by saying that since the Arabs “go around murdering … innocent women and children … that’s what makes me condemn and despise them.”

Curiously, though, Rand also wrote that there was no reason to distinguish between innocent civilians from military targets. For her, there was no such thing when it came to citizens of enemy countries.

If by neglect, ignorance, or helplessness, they couldn’t overthrow their bad government and establish a better one, then they must pay the price for the sins of their government, as we are all paying for the sins of ours.

The citizens of Gaza, under such a view, are responsible at a level of primordial democracy: if they truly objected to living under a genocidal Islamist dictatorship, really truly objected with the ferocity requisite to such a belief, they would rebel and overthrow that government. Not just the right to rebel against an unjust government, but the responsibility to do so.

Stick to your guns. There is no value to conceding. Because if you must concede for her to continue to love you, she doesn't love you.

There was a popular meme that ran around on twitter (I think from this guy for a while that ran something like: If she's still a feminist, you're not the guy. That matches my experience. When a woman is really into you, she is not going to care about your politics. The most progressive women in the world will make every excuse for you, if you get her juices flowing. For that matter, I can't imagine divorcing my wife over politics short of something so insane as to be absurd.

Therefore conceding is pointless. If you must concede to retain the relationship, the relationship has no value, because she isn't really that into you. Find someone who is. If she is into you, stick to your guns and she'll get over it. Simple as.

FWIW: Personally I'm closer to your compromise position in general life to begin with. If someone asks me to use different pronouns, I do, I find it polite (though despite moving in prog circles I've never been asked to use any outlandish ones). I've never actually had anyone police my use of pronouns irl, even given the occasional slip-up. But I can't imagine my wife policing my pronoun usage in our private conversations, largely because when we talk that kind of thing gets slid over in our sheer frenetic effort to empty our brains to each other at the end of every day. If she policed how I talked that way, I wouldn't like that.

Spain isn't really relevant here. How many books are written by Uyghur authors outside China? Or by authors speaking mutually intelligible languages from similar cultural groups.

Without running a full prison, you can't cut Israeli Arabs off from the rest of the Arab world and their cultural products.

Pretty much, yeah, though the level of "terror" inflicted by reducing consumer access to high tech goods is obviously so thoroughly different from food and water and basic medical needs that it's a difference in kind.

Because it is instrumentalizing the suffering of the population to pressure the government. Terrorism at its most basic definition.

Or they'll make it all the way to "Killing 10,000 or maiming 300,000 to save 1,000 is unjust; punishing civilians for not overthrowing their evil government is unjust" as a just and revelatory framing for their worldview.

This is not a morally clear and simple situation.

Oh, no, it will absolutely destroy the hotel industry if any alternative exists for any hotel nicer than a roadside drunk-tank.

Why would I choose to stay in a nice hotel if I share the space with homeless derelicts? If I walk out to get ice for my drinks and have to be leered at by various vagabonds? If I have to worry about my car being vandalized in the parking lot by my fellow guests.

When I could just stay at an AirBnB that is a similar cost and doesn't have a homeless person next door? Or, if I'm a tourist, why would I travel to the town where my hotel will be part homeless shelter when I could travel to literally anywhere else?

The move is smart, and I'm not sure it's wrong.

But the moral burden question is going to depend purely on how effective the Gazans are at broadcasting images to the outside world.

I'm just some asshole in America who has never even been to the region, so I'm not assessing credibility. But reports online have it that hospitals are running out of generators/fuel, that at this point "triage" is taking the form of deprioritizing limbs crushed by falling buildings and only treating life threatening injuries.

Which should still be blamed on Hamas, but the images will be powerful. The human suffering that will be inflicted on the people of Gaza is going to take a lot of stomach to justify for people who don't hate Arabs on a visceral pre-existing level. It's highly likely that different media bubbles (Arab vs American news; Twitter vs Telegram; Red vs Blue tribe at some level) will give different answers.

In a world where AirBnB is even marginally legal it wouldn't reduce their work resulting in tips, it would eliminate it entirely. Over time the average hotel aims for a 60% occupancy rate assumption, maybe it's higher in LA so call it 80%, that's a huge number of rooms going to the homeless every night. And given that it's impossible to know which rooms won't be booked or when, that means mingling in the lobby and the elevator with the homeless, it means that I'm probably getting one of those indestructible concrete rooms.

Getting a hotel room is already often a tough sell over an Airbnb cost wise, throw this ordinance in and unless they entirely ban Airbnb and any other kind of system, Airbnb will dominate. I don't hugely object to sharing public space with the homeless, but I'm going to prefer paying for private spaces where I don't when I'm traveling. No hotel nicer than a motel 6 can possibly survive this.

I don't feel like I've ever seen this rule enforced before.

China also culturally out-muscles the universe of Xinjiang's culturally-compatible neighbors. Israel does not. Egypt alone is a cultural powerhouse in film and television, and the rest of the Arabic-speaking world is producing mountains of music and TV and literature. They'd have to cut off the Palestinians from the outside world on a permanent basis to avoid outside influences.

In my mind genocide starts at decent odds of locally wiping out the subject population. For Gaza Arabs, that conversation might start at 200,000 but it won't really start to become hard to recover from until 500,000+

OPSEC seems to have been airtight even within Gaza, with most of the participating groups being informed only days in advance.

I'm not sure in that context there was much of a plan for most of the forces. Some portion of troops probably had specific goals, but some portion were probably also just sent off-leash to do whatever.