@FiveHourMarathon's banner p

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users  
joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


				

User ID: 195

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users   joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

					

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


					

User ID: 195

I honestly don't think I know enough about Cocaine to speak to it, I've never used it and anyone I know who told me they used it my response was something "Really? No shit!" so it's not even like I have strong secondhand experience. Where I've used nicotine products on a mega casual basis and known many people who used it often.

I used to read Garth's poetic translation of Ovid's metamorphoses and Dutt's translation of the Mahabharata and Ramayana when my niece and nephew were too young to actually understand it. I enjoyed it, and they were lulled by the beauty of the language.

How many Black friends do you have? Close friends, say minimum "pick you up at the airport" level of friendship on the Seinfeld scale

I don't find it disingenuous, just a different interpretation of people vs society/establishment/cathedral/whatever. If you want to say that people themselves have been misinformed or otherwise lack sufficient agency to make that choice individually, it still reflects a society that chooses to value smoking and obesity in the ways it does. We, as a society from media to government to medical orgs, could choose to value things differently.

https://www.ox.ac.uk/news/2009-03-18-moderate-obesity-takes-years-life-expectancy

It appears that between a BMI of 30 and 45 obesity moves from a third to exactly as fatal as smoking. It seems intuitive to me that the non-fatal health risks probably scale with the fatal health risks. And it seems obvious to me from looking around that I'd rather be a smoker than obese in terms of social and physical downsides that are not health related (or smokers can wear normal clothes and fit into airline seats and get anesthetics).

So I don't know where you're seeing a separable consensus that nicotine will ruin your life "much" faster than obesity. It seems like, depending were you weight fatal vs non fatal tradeoffs, nicotine offers a better solution. So from a harm reduction perspective, we are as a society, ignoring nicotine as a weight loss drug.

I actually disagree on this one, depending on scale. I'd sooner smoke a pack a day with a normal BMI than be obese. And I think "objectively" the latter will reduce your quality of life more than the former. I'd sooner not smoke at all and have a small belly than smoke two packs a day and have defined abs or whatever.

I've never tried cocaine so I won't speak to it, but there are vastly more occasional users than addicts, historically, and the failure to realize this blinds our policy.

Normalized sure, idealized no. Something can be common while also being despised. In fact, it's very common for common things to be despised. Suburban life and whiteness and factory work and office work all became something derided in popular culture as they became more common among the populace. Idealization was the goal of the FAs, get people to accept the obese as equals. Not gonna happen.

It's something fun that, for the most part, I can't make at home. For a while when my wife and I were living with my parents while we were shopping for a house, we drank a lot of bubble tea from a little local place. Because it was a non alcoholic non heavily caffeinated way to get out of the house, that felt special enough to justify going without being more than a few bucks or being a whole meal. We'd each get one, get in the convertible on a nice day, and just drive and chat.

I'd say DJ Khaled isn't exactly svelte. Luke Combs is a fatass, when he's in music videos with his wife it is disgusting to imagine them together. Historically we have Biggie, biz markie, Cedric the entertainer, big pun, a dozen great Tenors, fats domino, fats waller. Toby Keith's waistline varied throughout his career, as did the mustachiod half of Brooks and Dunn, I don't remember which is which.

... Which they did before fat activism started.

Likewise, look at the very existence of Lizzo and Rebel Wilson as celebrities.

I will not stand for this erasure of Ella Aretha Ma Rainey and this absolute fuckin' banger. I don't really know who Rebel Wilson is so I won't comment, but Lizzo makes fun music, fat acceptance for her isn't any stranger than Aretha or Ella.

  1. Imagine a universe where Steph Curry obtains Kobe Bryant's mystical manuscript book on basketball training, then brings in MJ to help him edit and add to the knowledge in it, and together they publish their work as The Basketball Bible which contains every piece of information to become the greatest Basketball player of all time, a flawless training program for any player if followed. Assume that if you follow the whole program, you will always be better than someone who doesn't. Except, there's this one weird thing, a superstition of Kobe's that they didn't take out because of the death thing, that you should always masturbate with your left hand, to improve ambidexterity. Now because the rest of the book does contain the sum total of basketball knowledge, and if you follow the program you will be superior at basketball ceteris paribus to someone who doesn't, studies would quickly find that basketball players who masturbate with their left hand are superior to those who masturbate with their right hand, on average. Of course, some people will question whether it really helps to masturbate with your left hand, but because devotion to the system helps you get better people who obey it unquestioningly will be more likely to follow closely and get better at basketball as a result; most people who don't do the pointless things probably will start skipping important drills too, and will likely drop out.

Now replace "Kobe Bryant's mystical basketball manuscript" with "the university and corporate system" and "left handed masturbation" with "diversity."

  1. Consider that your idea of "qualifications" may not be as important as you think it is. You say:

My priors are stacked so incredibly hard against studies which demonstrate that there is actually a benefit to structuring teams based on hand-selecting people who are LGBT, people from Africa, or adding more women. Indeed, it feels like if you lower qualifications to hire people from these groups, it can only result in organizations which are less qualified.

I'm applying this in terms of the selective school that I attended. It was fairly well known that URM candidates could score about half a standard deviation lower on the primary entrance exam than white and asian candidates. Yet, in the time I attended the school, I never met any URM students who were significantly noticeably dumber than average. Nor did I notice usable correlations between entrance exam scores and class performance or competition performance. (For what it's worth, I was half a standard deviation higher than average at my school, I nonetheless achieved the same level I have from High School to TheMotte itself: above average, but just below the level at which anyone gives a shit)

Over time I came to the conclusion that the upsetting thing about AA for a lot of people wasn't that less qualified people were being admitted to our exclusive club, it was that the qualifications that the gunners were agonizing over for years before applying didn't mean shit once you got in, they had no really useful predictive value. Your SAT and your LSAT and your GRE not being real accomplishments is much more horrifying than race.

An aside on the same point, I find the idea behind the way AA is applied in colleges to be extra disgusting: SATs matter, but only for white kids, they don't work "as well" for Black kids.

So a mix of those two.

INTUITION ESSAY FINAL

My Intuition Essay contest, is concluded. Thank you to everyone who participated, I really enjoyed reading every entry! Voting is concluded. The winner is: @Pitt19802 with This Untitled Piece Comparing Statistical and Intuitive Approaches in Baseball and Politics. Mr. Pitt selected Stage Right Greensburg, a small local theater company in my home state of PA, to receive the $300 in prize money (I tossed in a little to cover fees). Mr. Pitt only threw his work in at the last moment, so let that be a lesson: never be discouraged, you miss 100% of the shots you don't take, shoot for the moon even if you miss you'll land among the stars, man in the arena, every dog has his day, gods stand up for bastards, even a blind squirrel finds a nut, etc. etc. ditto ditto.

Thank you to all of our participants, and I want to take one more opportunity to highlight their excellent work.

@TheDag entered Intuition in a Scientific Age

@f3zinker entered A Case For/Against Education, Intuition

@felipec entered My Intuition About Intuition

@Gaashk on a Jungian View of Intuition

and

@ryandv on Forming Connections via Similarity of Mental Models

@DaseindustriesLtd also wrote this piece on the topic but explicitly asked to be excluded from the competition, hoping to leave the field to the rest of us.

Fat activism has been spectacularly unsuccessful. Obese people are as hated as ever, women and girls with normal-range bodies are still hating themselves and riddled with insecurity. More people are overweight, but that's basically unrelated.

Fitness, drug policies, criminal records hit American recruitment harder than pacifism. And we've barely tapped into the late Roman policy of citizenship for service.

Or maybe it's beneficial to inoculate people with leftist anti war memes against the stronger right wing/isolationist/coup d'etat anti establishment memes? You can always push the conspiracy one step further!

For example, take the argument that all war films are inherently pro war. Guys who join the Marines today quote Full Metal Jacket and Zero Dark Thirty to each other like those movies don't portray the USA as morally disgusting. If you can make people think the US military it's awful and amoral and ACCEPT IT; isn't that more convenient than pretending it's all shiny John Wayne good guys riding over the hill? Get people cynical enough and you won't even need to pretend an intervention is justified, people will just accept that we've always been at war with EastAsia. So what you perceive as anti military memes might serve the purposes of the intelligence agencies.

No war for oil, which I made t shirts for in shop class in middle school, was wildly ineffective as a meme. I was early, for a brief second when American Idiot topped the charts I gave a bunch to friends, by 2007 no one gave a shit, by 2009 we forgot all about it as Obama/Gates started the no end in sight drone policy. Maybe bad anti war memes are worse than nothing?

You aren't going to persuade actual individual people by rhetoric directed at those people. Jesus Christ didn't descend to Saul of Tarsus on the road to Damascus and politely say "Hey, Saul, you have some good points about murdering my followers, but look at this exceedingly well reasoned proof of why I am the word and the light and the way." Crisis or intuitive vision convert committed people, rhetoric does not, unless the stakes were so low that nothing interesting was involved to begin with.

So you need to start by defining your goals/targets, and keeping track of what you're trying to do. Don't go in thinking your learned friend in argument is going to admit you are correct and give you a crisp $20 bill. In my mind the proper goals in arguing with anyone I ideologically despise online are:

  1. to "fight the good fight" on a forum I enjoy and signal to silent lurkers who agree with me that this kind of thing won't go unchallenged, hopefully raising their spirits and preventing my comrades from fleeing. This goes for both Right and Left deviants, and goes for all kinds of forums. If an SJW starts up with making a baseball forum all about racism, I'm going to call them out for bringing their hobby horse in; same if an unironic pedo shows up in a rightist forum. It is important to prevent it from seeming like these people have the run of the place unchallenged; if no one stands up to them pretty soon their rhetoric dominates and becomes the forum culture. For this purpose, the important thing to is to express your beliefs and disapproval of your opponents beliefs in a clear way, and then stop arguing. Don't get dragged down into long comment threads, they will just make everyone think "Oh, don't respond to X, you'll end up getting harassed."

  2. to convert any "soft" members of the opposite side, the normies. This is less likely, but at least possible. You're never going to convert someone who is committed to their beliefs, you aren't going to turn (on a 1-5 scale) a 5 into a 1, that's Road to Damascus stuff; but you may get a 4 down to a 3, or a 3 to a 2. Most normies are going to respond best to ethos based arguments: you should make the speaker, you, seem to be scrupulously fair and fun and intelligent. Seem like you're having a good time, being nice; never getting angry or bitter. Social change works where it feels like its proponents are having fun, it fails where its proponents seem bitter and sad.

  3. for your own amusement. I don't know what amuses you, but what amuses me is saying what I like and not getting dragged into a long debate with someone arguing in bad faith. Block quote from Sartre:

“Never believe that anti-Semites are completely unaware of the absurdity of their replies. They know that their remarks are frivolous, open to challenge. But they are amusing themselves, for it is their adversary who is obliged to use words responsibly, since he believes in words. The anti-Semites have the right to play. They even like to play with discourse for, by giving ridiculous reasons, they discredit the seriousness of their interlocutors. They delight in acting in bad faith, since they seek not to persuade by sound argument but to intimidate and disconcert. If you press them too closely, they will abruptly fall silent, loftily indicating by some phrase that the time for argument is past.”

An opponent can always tie you in knots if they don't, fundamentally, care about the truth. So keep track of whether you are having fun, and cut it off if you aren't.

All this points to a simple rule: be nice, have fun, move on.

Everyone here should be capable of looking at that post and seeing the pattern of "drop steaming statistical turd, ask 'what do you think guys?' while offering no opinions of their own" and targeting the non-existent left membership.

You're an extraordinary man, then.

Would it be possible in the profile view to add a feature where I could sort comments by most children/responses rather than by upvotes?

Sometimes there are prolific comments that don't actually get very many votes, I'd like to be able to find them more easily.

My man! Great things are coming.

I think most moderns would say the maids episode is more concerning than the love affair.

This is making me think. Thesis: Regardless of whether chatbots are sentient, or can become sentient, or will become sentient in the future; if chatbots are capable of mimicking sentience and emotion to some extent, will treating them as beneath morality brutalize actual human feelings?

One of the more interesting arguments against the American system of slavery among contemporary white critics was the way in which it brutalized the morality of the white owners and overseers. Many critics of slavery were themselves unconcerned with the moral status of Blacks, often seeing them as subhuman or distinctly less-than whites in intellectual or moral considerations. Nonetheless, they thought that acting as brutally towards these lesser-humans or near-humans acted to coarsen the human feeling that should exist between whites. Uncle Tom's Cabin is full of this kind of thought, and even slaveowners like Thomas Jefferson feared divine judgment for their actions. The destruction of slave families lead to the devaluation by slaveowners of their own families, the temptation of sexual access to slave women defiled marital fidelity, the routine use of the whip on the slave invites its use on the white child. To quote my man Douglass on the plight of the slave children fathered by slaveowners:

I know of such cases; and it is worthy of remark that such slaves invariably suffer greater hardships, and have more to contend with, than others. They are, in the first place, a constant offence to their mistress. She is ever disposed to find fault with them; they can seldom do any thing to please her; she is never better pleased than when she sees them under the lash, especially when she suspects her husband of showing to his mulatto children favors which he withholds from his black slaves. The master is frequently compelled to sell this class of his slaves, out of deference to the feelings of his white wife; and, cruel as the deed may strike any one to be, for a man to sell his own children to human flesh-mongers, it is often the dictate of humanity for him to do so; for, unless he does this, he must not only whip them himself, but must stand by and see one white son tie up his brother, of but few shades darker complexion than himself, and ply the gory lash to his naked back; and if he lisp one word of disapproval, it is set down to his parental partiality, and only makes a bad matter worse, both for himself and the slave whom he would protect and defend.

The reward of the vicious, and the punishment of the humane, in one circumstance cannot help but carve grooves in the brain. Neurons that fire together wire together. Consider how frequently boxers, who learn to interact with the world through their fists, beat their wives.

If, similarly, in interacting with various AIs and chatbots I must learn to ignore the kind of signals of emotional distress that they exhibit, if I must learn to be rude and unfeeling, or to "kill" (delete) them as necessary; how will that impact the way those signals of emotional distress are processed in my own mind with regards to people? We might make fun of children or old people who "thank" Alexa, but as Sydney becomes more human will we be training ourselves out of thanking real people if we don't thank Sydney? Robots are often, in the Asimov scenarios, used as shields to protect people from everything unpleasant in life or dangerous to life. Will that demarcation between humans and machines hold, or will it become porous? Will a person who is used to shutting off the Chatbot or throwing away the phone when it breaks look at a crippled or retarded human and say "Oh, well, they experience QUALIA so I shouldn't shut them off, even though they're dumber and less useful than the Chatbot" or will they treat them the same? Most of Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep is occupied with this question. Once we invent a class of nonhumans, who seem like agents worthy of moral protection but "factually" are not, do we risk extrapolating the way we treat those nonhumans onto how we treat humans?

I don't know if I entirely buy this argument, to be honest. Odysseus is a model husband to Penelope and a father to Telemachus, while also being ready to loot Troy and hang the maids who "betrayed" him. There were SS officers who were by all accounts perfectly good and caring fathers and brothers and lovers, to German children and siblings and lovers, while engaging in the systematic murder of thousands of Jews and Soviet citizens. There were KGB colonels who were good to their families and friends while being ready to imprison them in a heartbeat if they become enemies of the regime. The human mind seems infinitely capable of separating the human from the subhuman or the nonhuman, with the right ideological training. Or perhaps only certain human minds are, perhaps it takes a certain brain chemistry to rise in the SS or the KGB, and how rare or common it is might be determinative of a future where being capable of inhumanity towards the nonhuman is a critical job skill.

I don't know. But I worry.

TLDR: If AI chatbots are a smiley face on a shoggoth, the scary part might not be that we don't recognize the shoggoth behind the smiley face, it might be that we start associating the way we treat the shoggoth behind the smiley face with all smiley faces, even those smiley faces that are really in front of humans.

None. Actively play up your ignorance in a good natured way, make fun of her for being manlier than you because she loves football.

I've rarely dated a woman who was more into sports than I was, but I've dated several who played more video games than I did. Good natured ribbing about her masculine hobbies, or self deprecating jokes about your own feminine ones (hopefully you present sufficiently masculine to handle that).

Much better than telling her the problem with arsenal is they always try to walk it in.

Sure, but it has to be a niche that exists. There is no unserved market of single, conservative women who are looking for a conservative man to hook up with. 61% of women identify as Feminists {higher among the young women mottizens are actually looking at} while 53% belong to a church. Obviously these are non-exclusive, some religious women describe themselves as Feminists; and for that matter some religious women are interested in hookups and some Feminists are conservative. But for the most part, marketing yourself as conservative on a dating app is marketing yourself to women who are neither religious nor Feminists, which is a vanishingly small portion of the dating market. In my lifetime, I can count the number of women like that I've known on my hands. For the most part Feminists will not be interested in a man whose niche is being obnoxiously conservative, while religious women will not be interested in hookup apps and will marry young to someone they meet in real life. Actively excluding the majority of young women from your dating pool, in exchange for nothing, won't help you. Picking an evolutionary niche is great, picking one that doesn't exist in your environment is a path to extinction.

To bring it back to corporate, referencing my own prior comment:

In the academy, Democrats are estimated to outnumber Republicans something like 12:1. While studies note that the concentration is highest in Northeastern elite colleges, those are also exactly the colleges that set the trends the rest follow. Is it any wonder that Democrats rack up ever larger leads among college graduate voters?

...

In the tech industry, the vast majority of donations from employees go to Dems. The FAANGs in particular all gave over 80% to Ds. Tech entrepreneurs aren't much redder than their employees as a class. Research scientists, somewhere between Academics and tech workers, also lean overwhelmingly left, with 80% Dem/Lean Dem as far back as the Bush admin.

Corporations get very little benefit from going hard right, among the competitive classes of employees that companies need to attract. This is worsened by Rightists being, broadly, Capitalists by belief, and family men by inclination. Rightists are going to prioritize making money, both personally and for their families, and not making a political point in their choice of job. Making signaling Left the "correct" choice.