FiveHourMarathon
a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop
And every gimmick hungry yob
Digging gold from rock n roll
Grabs the mic to tell us
he'll die before he's sold
But I believe in this
And it's been tested by research
He who fucks nuns
Will later join the church
User ID: 195
...You're basing your entire argument on surface hardness? The fields in our area are full of rocks, if you hit your head on one of those it's much worse (sharper) than concrete.
I'm not discussing any particular case here, I'm not interested in playing games with fact patterns. What concerns me is the cultural message sent. I think we need to enable and encourage more physical confrontation with less fear of legal consequences as a result. We need to encourage more scenarios where punching someone is legally justified. We can't do that if we also say, any punch is a deadly assault proportional to a gunshot. Those two theories are incompatible.
What I'm pointing to is a general attitude we're inculcating in our society, in our young men, that physical violence is completely outlawed and impossible. Quotes from throughout this thread, posters untagged I'm (ironically) not trying to start something with anyone:
[S]omething like a serious punch to the face from an adult male or tackle and an attempt to batter me into submission is something I would excuse, even if I prefer less lethal options. Those who don't want to be shot in such a scenario should ideally not be committing such acts.
In my opinion, when an adult makes the decision to assault another person, they are taking their life into their own hands. If it ends with the aggressor bleeding to death on the sidewalk, that is sad, but not upsetting.
Big dude comes over and the first thing he does is hard two hand shove. That's straight up an initiation of a fight with no pretense. If I'm on my ass after that and I have a pistol on me, I'm reaching, pulling, and firing.
[I]f I'm standing over a hard surface like a sidewalk or even asphalt, I would consider an unprompted shove as escalation to deadly force. A simple fall that results in your head smacking the ground can be fatal and often are, and someone shoving you with intent to disturb you is someone who is clearly fine with a very high probability of you falling over, with high likelihood of you lacking enough control to protect your head during the fall.
And the problem with inculcating this kind of "punching someone is a deadly assault, is never the answer, it is totally verboten on pain of being shot legally" is that it enables all manner of obnoxious behavior that can't be solved otherwise.
There's a lot of talk throughout this thread by pro-gun folks that it's important for citizens to be able to defend themselves from deadly assaults. I agree. I also think that citizens need to be able to defend themselves from obnoxious behavior, not with a gun, but with a fist. A world in which I can slug someone for harassing me in the street is a world with less harassment in the streets, a world in which I can't slug someone for any reason unless they punch me first is one with more harassment in the streets.
This seems like it should be totally justified to me. If we say that a punch is a deadly assault, and that if the punched fall down they're justified in opening fire, is one where running up to someone and being obnoxious is legalized.
to tell the story of one case of Stand your Ground (SyG) killing.
There was no SYG element to that story. It was a red herring introduced by uneducated subjects of the documentary. What she did was wildly illegal regardless of SYG.
Shooting through a locked door at a woman is not reasonable.
I'd suggest the vast majority of self defense cases never actually invoke stand your ground in a trial and it is just a boogeyman being used by people to explain increasing violence
The primary publicly visible impact of SYG in many cases is that the perp isn't immediately arrested after the shooting, and is instead allowed to live their lives during the investigation. People get up in arms about this in the meantime, because they are under the impression from watching TV that the process of a crime goes on a two week timeline of Crime>>Arrested immediately>>On Trial within a week>>Goes right to prison. Where in reality, if someone isn't a flight risk, it's very common for the police to make an arrest much later. The public sees an accused murderer walking free and assumes that means nothing is being done or going to be done, they're just free to go, when that isn't the case.
the cases of genuine self-defense seem to be massively outnumbered by instances of simian chest-beating that got out of hand or someone pulling a gun to win an argument.
You're ignoring the cases where pulling the gun does win an argument. The argument being something classic like "I think you should give me your wallet" "Well, I disagree."
In 90+% of Defensive Gun Uses, in every survey I've ever seen, the gun isn't fired. Presenting the gun defuses the situation. In many home invader incidents, the criminals flee when they hear the distinctive sound of a firearm. Private legal guns save more lives than they take.
I'm pro second amendment and pro self defense, but the one thing that makes me pause is the attitude evinced by a lot of pro-SYG arguments that any physical attack justifies lethal retaliation. I strongly believe that we, the men of today's America, don't do enough mutual combat, and that mutual combat exceptions to law should be expanded rather than retracted.
The historical norm was that boys and men got into fights. No normal male got to adulthood without getting into a scrap, and this might be punished lightly by parents or other authority figures, but the law ignored it unless it reached an extreme. It was understood as a normative value that there was a difference between punching and deadly force or the use of a firearm, and that boys should get into a few scraps in their lives. Instead today we have an attitude that ever getting into a physical fight is rare, and where it does happen it is acceptable to persecute any party to the fight.
In old cowboy movies, which set the moral tone for America from the 20s to the 70s, it was standard that two cowboys would get into a fistfight while wearing guns on their hips, and the one that went for his gun first was the bad guy, who would be prosecuted for murder if he killed the guy punching him. This is corroborated in well researched books and first hand historical accounts as the standard in the old west. A SYG standard that allows you to kill someone for punching is antithetical to the cowboy code.
Instead we've replaced traditional ethics with a feminized world where all physical contact is treated as a deadly threat, where boundaries are set such that all fighting is illegal and both morally and physically dangerous because of that boundary. We're raising our boys to act like scared old women.
Boys getting into fights in school has seen an unprecedented decline in the past thirty years
Trend analyses indicated that during 1991–2017, a significant linear decrease (42.5%–23.6%) occurred in the overall prevalence of having been in a physical fight. A significant quadratic trend was identified. The prevalence of having been in a physical fight decreased during 1991–2011 (42.5%–32.8%) and then decreased more rapidly during 2011–2017 (32.8%–23.6%). The prevalence of having been in a physical fight did not change significantly from 2015 (22.6%) to 2017 (23.6%).
This is an entire human experience, universal to males in the past, now rare. Symptom or cause of the feminization of society, you decide, I lean towards both. Zero tolerance policies towards violence have been a disaster.
There's always somebody in these conversations who talks about weird edge cases. You could get pushed and fall over and crack your skull open, you could get killed by one punch because there was some blood clot in your brain waiting to burst onto the scene. I ask these people: how did our ancestors ever manage to live? They must have been dying left and right from unlucky punches. That doesn't seem to be the case, it's an almost unattested to phenomenon before modernity.
The rare possibility of physical violence is a good thing for social regulation. So much of obnoxious behavior we see today is the result of its lack. Over expansive definitions of self defense that effectively make any form of physical violence a justification for homicide will make this worse, not better.
I guess I don't know OP's position on this issue, but I've definitely heard this from Crossfit/Hyrox types who were all about the Ranger panties, which struck me as a more or less indefensible distinction.
My attitude to cycling clothing so far has been similar to my attitude towards cowboy western wear: one item at a time is fine, two is pushing it, three is a costume. So I feel fine wearing the jersey when I'm casually riding around by the river in track pants, and on a longer ride I'll wear the shorts or bibs with a t shirt or windbreaker, but somehow wearing them together just feels too costumey for me, like I'm pretending I'm a much better cyclist than I am. And then I'm not even sure if the jersey and shorts I bought off theblackbibs is even what we're talking about here in terms of aerodynamics. My wife claims the zip up cycling jersey looks sexy, I feel like an overstuffed sausage.
I suppose at 100 miles I'll probably get over that feeling, since at that point I'm really doing something.
To be fair, I take this attitude with most hobbies. A year of BJJ and I still refuse to buy a rashguard.
I probably physically could, but 1) Scheduling a whole day off from work and every other obligation is going to get tougher the next few weeks, 2) I don't just want to slug it out and do the 100km in six hours or something, I'd like to make progress on feeling stronger while also finishing a longer distance.
But when I basically told the fitter your/my MO, he just hung his head for a second and then recovered. "That's pretty much the opposite of what you should be doing". At the scale of a Gran Fondo and above, little adjustments matter. And frankly, the $175 I paid for a fit seemed like a deal with how fucked up my saddle height, shoes, stem, and pedals were. We spent 2.5 hours adjusting every piece of the bike, then testing how it felt with motion capture etc. It felt a lot better in that room, very quickly, and I'll be able to report back how it felt at scale soon.
I've been trying to put off doing all this, I guess out of embarrassment over how bad I am, like I need to earn it. Also why I've put off spending any real money on a bike. But maybe all the persuasion on here has made the bike shop up the road a few hundred bucks.
The Peloton is a great way to up your cadence, the workouts really focus on that over power or distance. Plus Olivia Amato is.... motivating. Even if it's a huge rip off of a workout platform.
I despise everything about their business model, but Mrs. FiveHour wanted one off craigslist and she loves it, it's worth any price to keep her working out, so we already have one in the basement.
For a long time I was so focused on losing weight that I would not eat on rides. You don't need performance food: Some sour patch kids, one of your bottles having gatorade, and something else you just like eating are probably enough. But don't not eat, because it'll slow you down bigly. I almost never bonk, but when I do it's a frustrating waste of time to try and limp back home with cramps slowing me down to a crawl.
For the places I've done long rides, wawa is my rest station, so I've got a wide variety of junk food on tap. Tastykakes are the thing I allow myself only in the middle of large cardio events. I doubt its optimal, but its good enough.
And like everybody in cycling loves to repeat endlessly: "It never gets any easier, you just go faster".
I've always put it when talking about rock climbing with fresh gumbies: You will always feel like you suck exactly as much as you feel like you suck now, it'll just go from feeling like you can't do anything, to feeling like you should be able to do more by now.
I don't particularly have an opinion on optimal cadence, but I know that it's bad that I can't keep a higher cadence for any length of time. Like how I might not use a certain guard or submission in BJJ a lot, but if I can't do it at all that's bad and I should work on it.
I might ultimately land on a lower cadence-higher gear preference, I'm coming into this with (by cycling standards) a fat ass and tremendous max strength and shit endurance, but I'm pretty confident that working on increasing cadence a bit will pay some dividends.
I would at least hem and haw about this a little. One thing that stood out to me when I came to cycling from other sports was that being a bit of a princess about fit and contact points paid off on long efforts.
I've actually been pleasantly surprised how little irritation I had after 50 miles, I wasn't super comfortable by the end but bib shorts+moisturizer+new comfortable seat worked pretty well, and I was fine the next day. I'll definitely take your advice to keep looking for room to optimize though!
What I'm talking about it more, the first hour I was singing along to my music choices, the second and third hours I was listening to Darryl Cooper give me the other side on Adolf Hitler and fascinated, and then the last hour I kept looking for a podcast to hold my attention.
If I get a chance to ride my neighborhood on a nice day, I basically want to just work on hills, because I suck at them to a degree I find embarrassing, and getting better at them will open up more rides around my home. Oddly, given the autism, I hate overly complicated metrics in workouts. I nearly always gravitate towards simplicity and effort over metrics. Lifting I'm either doing some variation of OLAD or Bulgarian styles, or I'm doing a Smolov style focus on one lift. Climbing and BJJ I just go out and do it. I think cycling has appealed to me for a similar reason, that at least to start all I needed to do was roll out of my driveway and I'd be at the bottom of a hill and need to make my way back.
I guess sustained power is the problem in that I don't actually care how I get there I just want to sustain speed. But 1) I've read that 80-90 cadence is typically the recommended sustainable endurance pace, I'm closer to 60. Even if I ultimately settle at 60, I feel like not being able to sustain 90 is probably bad for reasons too stupid to even understand; 2) I struggle on steep climbs, where I feel like downshifting and pumping at a higher cadence is probably the answer, as at a lower cadence I get bogged down.
I've tried a variety of bikes and somehow land at nearly the same speed on the same courses, so I'm the problem.
I would guess it saves time and effort, especially when we know that Elon has put a target on keeping Grok ideologically in line with his specified views. It's probably easier to tell Grok to stick to privilege Grokipedia as a source, then edit Grokipedia or mess with the program producing it where necessary, than it is to actually figure out how to get Grok to toe the ideological line while pulling from largely ideologically opposed material.
Strangely, it seems that the New York Yankees article is essentially completely identical to the Wikipedia article. Like the entire thing.
It's not though. Look at the Wikipedia article, Wikipedia is 25 pages long, Grok is half that. It goes from the general overview at the top to a narrative history of the team. Where Grok jumps right to "distinctions" which it steals from Wikipedia but organizes differently. The paragraph is taken word for word from Wikipedia, but it uses it in prime real estate. If I look up the New York Yankees and want to learn about the team, I want to go through the team history, learn about Ruth and Dimaggio and Mantle and Jeter and Judge. It's a perfectly appropriate fact to include on page 14, as Wikipedia does, right before you get into the sections that are just lists of things. Grok puts it on page 2. This is an important editing decision! Organization is content.
... Oh no, it's just conservapedia...
Step two in the path to a Century Ride is completed, I made it 50 miles on Saturday morning. The final ten miles were definitely a different animal compared to the prior rides I've done, I don't think I technically "bonked" or whatever the preferred technical term is, but I was definitely on the struggle shuttle. Near the end of both rides, I start adjusting constantly. Jacket on-jacket off, different handlebar positions, saddle postures, different podcasts or audiobooks. I feel like I just can't get comfortable, which makes sense at that point, but I need to work on ignoring the discomfort and just locking in, there is no combination of things that makes riding a bike that far comfortable.
This time rather than a long ride to a destination where my wife would pick me up, I did it out-and-back, which worked much better. As I wore down on energy, the streets got more familiar rather than less familiar. Which was a good choice, I was more comfortable in the saddle despite fatigue, I knew where I was going and which streets would be safe/efficient. I'm realizing in retrospect that some of the confusion and getting lost at the end of the 50k ride was more related to fatigue than it was to the route itself. And the traffic concerns can easily be lessened by knowing the route better.
It might be too late in the season to practically shoot for the 100km ride this year. I think I have the physical capability to slug it out if I needed to, but the combination of temperature/daylight/location would work out such that I don't think I could do it in the way I want to do it, if that makes any sense. So it's sort of back in the lab for me. I need to increase my speed to hit 100 miles. I did 53 miles in four hours flat, so around a 12mph pace. That would make a 100mi ride way too long to be practical, I want to be holding around 15mph at least, and to do that I feel like I need to be able to hold 18mph for a few miles, which I really can't seem to do right now. My problem seems to be with cadence, I can't manage to move my legs fast enough for very long to sustain higher speeds. I picked up a used Peloton bike for my wife a year back, I suppose I'll use that pretty extensively this winter, they have a lot of rides built around varying cadences, so hopefully that will help. I'm not going to be able to ride my bike outside as often with the shorter daylight hours, but I'm hoping to get out to a bike trail one morning a week and hit at least ten to fifteen miles to keep the groove greased.
My target is right now to try for the 100km in early spring, and if that goes well the 100mi in late spring, or if it doesn't I'll aim to do 100mi next fall. My secondary worry being that I need to do a better job of choosing a route, that the friction is going to catch up with me over the course of a really long ride.
This is more cardio than I've done in years, and that's been good for me, no question about it.
Using your Yankees example, this structured reasoning engine would read it, check that all of the basic quantitative numbers are valid, but then "reason" against a corpus of other baseball data to build out something like: Yankees hit lots of home runs in august --> home run hitting is good and important --> records are also important in baseball --> oh, we should highlight this home run record setting august for the yankees!.
What further AI development would avoid is including a record that no one really cares about in prime real estate within the article. That's a cool record, one that a color commentator brings up during the broadcast when watching the game, and afterward gets cited in a quick ESPN or fan-blog article, then totally forgotten until another team gets close to the record and they show the leaderboard during a game. It's not something fans care about on the day-to-day, no Bleacher Creature ever brags about the team holding the monthly Home Run Record.
I suspect the answer is more prosaic: the record setting August outburst was recent enough to be highlighted in one or more online articles, which Grok found while writing the article and included in the data. Where various great things that Dimaggio and Berra did aren't covered as heavily online. An old timer fan is much more likely to brag about Rivera's save record, Dimaggio's hit streak, Berra having a ring for every finger, Ruth being the GOAT, or Judge holding the "clean" HR record. Those would be things to cite in the article over the monthly HR record getting a paragraph.
It's the ability to reason your way to judgment, or wisdom, not knowledge.
So have you noticed how Police Body Camera footage in controversial cases generally gets released within hours when the footage exonerates the cop, and when it looks bad for the cop it take days or weeks to see it?
Universal surveillance doesn't give "the public" access to the truth. It gives the people who control the panopticon access to the truth, and the power to present it to the public however they choose to present it. A group in which Larry Ellison imagines himself, controlling surveillance tech, not the subject of it. Ellison wants to be the man in the control room full of screens, not the man being surveilled.
When infinite evidence exists, the presentation of the evidence becomes the game. And there are always going to be differences in access to that evidence. We're doing the "don't invent the torture matrix" game here, Palantir is directly named for this concept! The Palantir drives Denethor mad, not by showing him falsehoods, but by showing him truths presented by Sauron, edited by the enemy. The Palantir is dangerous not because it doesn't work, but because unless you have tremendous Power, it will overtake your will by presenting things to you in a persuasive way. And that's the position of power that the tech lords want to be in: able to present evidence to us to prove whatever position they please.
Instant replay in sports has been a mixed blessing. For every obviously wrong call, we get truly ridiculous rules and arcane formulas for what constitutes "possession" of the football. True Crime podcasters with vocal fry, and their more respectable cousins in various Innocence Projects, have shown us why Finality is a fundamental value of the justice system, that when you throw infinite effort into researching a case or event you will always find stuff that looks weird. Infinite angles of truth are fundamentally indistinguishable from falsehood without guidance.
When you base truth on Rule of Law you empower lawyers to tell you what the truth is. When you base it on religion you empower priests. If we base truth on surveillance technology, we empower the owners and operators of the surveillance tech. Coincidentally, Larry Ellison has a close relationship with Palantir and similar companies.
Pete Rose wasn't just banned from the Hall of Fame, he was banned from baseball, he couldn't coach and he couldn't work for a team and he was very rarely featured as one of the greats of the game along other legends of similar stature. This stance softened over the course of my life, and you started to see him acknowledged more as he got older and his sins faded into memory. But it wasn't that the voters never voted for him, like they have refused to with steroid users, but that he was never eligible on the ballot at all.
So out of curiosity I opened Grokipedia up and searched the page for New York Yankees, a topic I know enough about to spot errors or omissions pretty well. It's...fine, but the verbiage is kind of off, and the editing is weird. The choice of which facts are important to fit into the article is distinctly odd. It inserts facts at random points, like this paragraph near the top:
On June 25, 2019, they set a new major league record for homering in 28 consecutive games, breaking the record set by the 2002 Texas Rangers. The streak would reach 31 games, during which they hit 57 home runs. With the walk-off solo home run by DJ LeMahieu to win the game against the Oakland Athletics on August 31, 2019, the Yankees ended the month of August that year now holding a new record of 74 home runs hit in the month alone, a new record for the most home runs hit in a month by a single MLB team.
Which is true, as far as I know, but not a record that anybody really cares about compared to about a million other things that the Yankees have done. It's a lot of text to cover a fairly obscure statistical record. While ignoring, within the "Distinctions" heading, a lot of more important Yankees accomplishments and records that a human would think of first like the streaks of winning seasons etc.
The whole piece steadfastly refuses to achieve any narrative flow at any point, never achieving a cohesive story structure. And it seems to lack the fundamental feature of Wikipedia: links between articles allowing me to learn more about a topic and dive down a Wikipedia hole, there is no Grokipedia hole unless I manually dig it.
On the other hand, the article structure and style is just copied from Wikipedia and slightly shuffled. Significant word for word sentences of the article seem to be directly pulled from Wikipedia, which was almost certainly within the training data used to make these articles, so actually what we seem to be dealing with here is better thought of as a fork than a competitor or alternative to Wikipedia. As human editing smooths out the rough edges of the AI, it'll get better over time. Though at that point, what is the use? It's mostly just Wikipedia copied.
I'll put a disclaimer here that I'm not someone with an Elon Musk hate-boner, but I do think that Elon is the fly in the ointment here. Grok has publicly done weird shit in the past, that was obviously the result of direct meddling, like the South African White Genocide fiasco. We know in advance that some articles are not going to be maximally accurate, but instead be designed by Elon to look the way Elon wants them to look. So you really can't trust Grokipedia, or Grok, without knowing Elon's Special Interests and where they might get you into trouble. I know there are going to be some articles on Grokipedia that will be edited in a certain way.
Which puts Grokipedia in basically the same category I use Grok for more generally: as an alternative source to double check on something I already looked up elsewhere, a sanity check for alternative views. Normally more prosaically, I punch a question into ChatGPT then punch the same question into Grok and see if they agree. Now we can do the same with Wikipedia. That's a useful enough thing.
I suspect for xAI, Grokipedia is actually more useful as an answer repository for simple questions asked to the chatbot that can be tied directly into the program more easily. The next non-American that asks "Who or what are the New York Yankees?" can be answered with a summary of the already-created Grokipedia article.
I feel like the people blaming TikTok or whatever for boring conversations need to sit down and read some Jane Austen or something. People have been complaining about this kind of conversational boor for literal centuries, probably millennia. I think about this often in terms of RETVRN arguments, that every American novel written between The Great Gatsby and Infinite Jest is essentially about the emptiness, anomie, dissatisfactory nature, and soullessness of all the stuff that we're trying to bring back.
If anything, loudly sharing boring personal anecdotes is the opposite of the typical internet-brained problem, which is not saying anything ever.
I'm not sure where you're contradicting my point.
I'm kind of excluding you and me from the category "everyone" here. I guess "everyone relevant on the political spectrum" would be more accurate, but less felicitous.

Oh well in that case...
More options
Context Copy link