JarJarJedi
Streamlined derailments and counteridea reeducation
User ID: 1118
Right, The Joos scared Americans with their absolute Depotism into complete inability of even thinking about criticizing them and Israel (of course outside every university campus, the Congress and every leftist newspaper and thousands of leftists blogs and the BDS movement - the only tolerated political movement in the US literally openly dedicated to destruction of UN member state and inevitable genocide that will ensue - but let's not count all that), and yet on any right gathering there's a bunch of people that attribute literally anything bad that happens to "the Joos" and pop constantly into any topic reminding us that "the Joos" invented everything bad, from cancel culture to vaccine mandates, and from gender transition to income taxes, and they control everything too. Somehow the absolute Despotism doesn't work on those people. Must be those tin foil hats, I knew they do something.
Trump said something I found genuinely anti-Semitic, and that was when he said that any Jew who didn't support him was a traitor to Israel (maybe?) and therefore a bad Jew (hell naw).
How that's "antisemitic"? It's some weird world where a person saying Jews should support Israel is called "antisemitic".
Now, on the substance, I think Trump is correct on Israel part - if you don't support Israel, you are not a good Jew (sorry, there's about 3000 years of history behind that, not going to put it here). But he is too full of himself, one can support Israel without supporting Trump. Even though he was one of the most Israel-friendly presidents at least on my memory, he's just one politician. But being too full of himself and being antisemitic is way different.
I don't think I have to believe that as a consequence of being Jewish
You don't have to. Free will is one of the pillars of Judaism. You don't "have" to do anything. But whatever you decide to do, you'll could be evaluated on it, and other people could view you with regard to your choices.
racism is when you use race as the sole factor in making a decision,
Jews aren't a race, but that's not the most important part. Here is where it breaks. If you don't believe in Jesus Christ being The Savior, you aren't a good Christian. You don't have to be a good Christian - in fact, you don't have to be one at all! - but these two things are not compatible. You don't have to be a good Jew either. You can abandon everything that is connected to being Jewish, and curse all Jewish history, and hate it all, or just be indifferent to it and be Jew in name only. I'm not saying you should, but that's an option that is always open to you. But it's not racist to say if you do that, you can't also honestly call yourself a good Jew, connected to Jewish culture, tradition and community. Maybe you don't want to - many people don't care about it, again - free will - but there's still the logic behind it, which makes it one or the other. It's not racist to mention this fact. It is racist (with a bit of a stretch, but let's ignore that for now) to deny you free will and free choice on account of your birth circumstances, but it's not racist to point our certain choices would put you in certain relationships towards certain things.
So, do I think Kanye is anti-Semitic? My answer is "not yet, but he's dangerously close."
Here I am on the opposite side - I think he very likely is. He probably got poisoned by one of those "Jews stole our whatever" conspiracy theories that are very very popular among some people. This is classic antisemitism. It's not because of how many Jews are in Hollywood (a lot, yes) - it's because of the conclusions he makes (or, rather, he regurgitates conclusions made by the theory designers) and converts one of the traits to the defining trait and extends it further.
Kanye points out that you have previously discussed "the black vote," a concept that involves black people making electoral decisions because they're black. You now have to explain how this is different from talking about "the Jews" who control record labels and movie studios.
"Black vote" is a racist concept that black people should vote for specific people and specific policies (usually leftist) because otherwise they are "traitors". It is despicable, but it is a fact of our political life, and as such may be discussed. We wish instead that we could discuss specific policies and how they influence people, not concentrating on traits like skin color. The idea that all black people share political views (or should) because of skin color is racist.
Talking about "the Jews" who control record labels and movie studios depends on what specifically you are talking about. Do you have a beef with specific policies and actions of record labels or studios? Like, they take wrong side in the culture war, or they produce shitty movies, or they don't promote good music? Does it have anything to do with being Jewish - are they ordered to do this by the government of Israel, is there something is the Torah and Talmud that prohibits making good movies, are Jewishness somehow incompatible with good music? I didn't think so. Thus, the idea that they are acting as a single block based on their Jewishness, and couldn't act any other way because of their Jewishness, is the same racist idea as above - and should be similarly condemned. Everybody who endorses this idea is, again, a racist.
Literally it means something like "if you keep switching [implied: the channels] there would be bad consequences for you", or maybe "keep switching and find out". It's hard to say it in English any shorter because I don't know any constructs that do the same thing in English.
It's coming from the "до" part. Literally, this prefix implies arrival to a destination (like доехать = to arrive from до + ехать to go or to drive). However, when used with words that do not mean literal movement, especially when combined with the reflexive suffix ся, this prefix often means "there would be bad consequences if you keep doing this" - e.g. доиграешься (от играть - to play) means if you keep playing like that (or in general, acting like that) something bad will happen (the implication is it will happen to you, though you can also say it meaning it would happen to somebody else, but still will be your fault).
you're saying that there is one word which expresses "switching channels will get you in trouble"
Yes.
Strictly speaking, the "channels" part is implied, but since the Russian word used in this context is pretty specific to what you do with the channels, the implication is clear.
I never counted, but I wouldn't be surprised.
I think the difference between epigenetic and Lysenko is the difference between "I can program a computer to do many different things" and "I can take a computer apart and make a chicken salad, a bicycle or a live cat out of it". The step of taking an electronic scheme and making it flexible so you can make it do different things is a big one, but still you can see how you could get there. But making a live cat out of it is taking it way beyond reasonable.
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/33513.The_White_Man_s_Burden - about how West's effort to "improve" "developing world" fail and why they do. About midway through it, sounds interesting, though there are some topics that get a bit repetitive (I do not necessarily disagree, just wish the same point would not be repeated too much).
Soviet Union used to have only three TV channels. So, one day it is announced that the forth channel is now available. So, this guy comes home and turns on the TV, and on the first channel it's Leonid Illych Brezhnev reading one of his magnificent speeches. So he switches to the second one, and it's the same. He goes to the third channel - same. So he thinks - no problem, there's now a fourth one! - and switches to that. And sees a KGB colonel who looks at him sternly and says "This channel switching, comrade, will get you in trouble one day!"
In Russian, this joke sounds better because the last sentence can be expressed in a single word (well, two if you count "comrade").
The Guardian declared it the most dangerous show on Netflix.
OK, now I have to watch it. Hope it doesn't disappoint.
Reading, watching movies, walking, blogging. Occasionally going to the range. Now that ski season is open, probably skiing too.
I'm seeing vote difference in CO-3 district of about 550 votes. Given how close the House results are in general, this seat could (though it isn't now) plausibly be crucial for House majority. So 550 votes would change the course of national politics for at least 2 years. Sure, it's not individual vote, but it's not that far from it. There are even closer races, probably - I didn't check every one, I just noticed this one because Boebert is a figure of some prominence.
Probably many factors, but if we're in CW thread I'll notice if it were the other way, somebody would already have declared it a national crisis and got a big budget allocation for fixing it. I mean, almost 3% sexist gap! That's millions of people oppressed and disenfranchised!
I don't think Yeltsin ever had designs on conquering Ukraine or anything close to that. He was upset that the USA does not treat Russia as an equal partner (this inferiority complex goes back centuries deep), and felt Russia is being humiliated by the West taking unilateral steps without Russia getting some respect in return. Also, he was very upset that NATO actions may jeopardize his chances on the coming elections - due to the pressure from the anti-Western fractions that perceived him to be too pro-Western. It is both about respect and about internal politics, but not really about any imperialist designs. TBH, his complaints about lack of respect were not entirely baseless - Russia lost the Cold War (or USSR did, and Russia took over the business after that), and while they still wanted the same stance as USSR used to have, they really didn't have that kind of pull anymore. So the nature of the disagreements was substantially different back then.
1994 also was exactly when the infamous Budapest Memorandum was signed. When Russia and USA (and UK) agreed to be partners in security the existing borders of Ukraine, in exchange for which Ukrainians gave up their Soviet nukes. We all know how well that worked out.
that's utilitarianism, Effective Altruism, cryptocurrency, and veganism all tainted by association!
Well, if veganism survived association with Hitler (though he wasn't vegan or even, according to many accounts, consistently vegetarian, the popular meme is that he was a vegetarian), SBF would be no more than a tiny blip.
I didn't observe it for the last 3-5 years, I observed it for much longer, it is the last 3-5 years when the neo-imperialism has become so dominant, so prominent and obvious that any diligent observer, without special knowledge or deep analysis, would be able to instantly pick it up. Before that, during the previous 3 decades, it wasn't the single direction at all. During the 90s, where Russian democracy was still alive, even though flawed (aren't all real democracies?) - the eternal Russian struggle between slavophiles and westerners has been also alive. Some people wanted more European direction, some wanted to go "our own way" - but the imperialist ideas weren't the only game in town at all. It all happened much later, building on the cult of the Great Victory in part, and on dismantling the democracy under the premise that it was the reason why 90s felt so miserable and chaotic for many. During much of this time, most of the fractions didn't really care about "NATO expansion" - because they weren't hostile to the West and the Western culture, and they did not nurture the dream of rebuilding the Empire. Surely, some fractions did - but they became the only game in town much later. Even the Chechen wars were presented as much more about security and terrorism (and TBH, not without a cause - Chechens weren't exactly innocent there) than about preserving the Empire. It was a long process, and I am not sure Putin himself thought in 1999 that he is going to become what he is now.
Thus, I do not think 3+ decades prior to that in which Russians were also vehemently opposed to NATO expansion is a proper description of what happened. If we limit ourselves only to Putin, which is more like 2 decades, he was never a particular fan of NATO (which is no wonder for a KGB officer), but he wasn't "vehemently opposed" to it until his imperialist doctrine coalesced, and as for other Russians, it was not true for even longer. Putin did blame NATO for the failure of his soft-takeover plan of Ukraine, which involved installing a puppet ruler (in which he eventually succeeded) and roping Ukraine into being a permanently subservient satellite state, just like Belarus (at which he failed). But that hostility began somewhere around 2004, before that the relationships were definitely not friendly, but also not openly hostile. And even then the idea was still more of "we want to control neighboring states" rather than "we want to assimilate them and restore the Russian Empire" for a while.
I am not assuming it, I know it, as I know any observable reality. It's not some mental construct, it can be plainly seen. The neo-imperialism bent of the Russian elites is completely obvious to anybody who watched them for the last 3-5 years. All the state propaganda machine has been pushing these ideas for a while now. If you understand Russian, all the evidence you need is plainly there, whereever you go - from the government-controlled TV channels to the lowliest telegram or VK troll groups. Everybody wants to repeat the Great Patriotic War victories and raise the glorious Mother Russia from her knees. Well, maybe not literally everybody (there are always traitors) but among the "true patriots" that has been the dominant tone for a while. And if you observe the actions for the last couple of decades - Transnistria, Georgia, de-facto anschluss of Belarus, then the Ukraine invasion - it is clear that Russia treats the ex-Soviet states as their legitimate playing ground and ultimately the target for "re-unification" if possible. In Ukraine, it was openly stated when it looked like it was possible. When turned out it was a pipe dream, the "re-unification" target contracted to the areas occupied by Russian forces, but the idea stayed the same - everything that has been USSR is legit Russia.
Now, how NATO plays into this is of course a logical conclusion, but I think it is a very natural one. If you consider Ukraine legit your territory, temporarily misled by "nationalist government" into being a "fake state" (this is all quotes from actual Russian propaganda) - then of course this government joining NATO and gaining Article 5 coverage is a major problem. Of course they don't like it - it kinda puts the end to the project - now what they have, a piece of Georgia, a tiny piece of Moldova, Belorussia and that's the whole Empire? Pathetic. Of course they went all in to try and not let that happen.
Once, at work, when I raised my point, I was rebuffed by a coworker who stated, more or less, that White Americans should be guilty because they benefit from the fruits of the violent extermination of Native Americans.
Why only White Americans? If we assume, for the sake of this discussion, that there was "violent extermination of Native Americans" (I personally think it was a bit more complex than that, but let's not argue that and accept it as a premise) and it, in whatever ways, produced substantial profits, Black Americans and Asian Americans, those that live in America, may have profited by it too. Surely, for example, Black Americans profited less, since many of them were enslaved, and received little economic benefits at all back then, but many White Americans also did not receive direct benefits, and if we talk about indirect benefits, such as using the resources to develop the economy, using the lands to build and resources on the land, etc. - then at least some non-White Americans benefitted from it also. Surely, one can argue that non-White Americans, due to various factors, benefitted less, proportionally - but they still did, even if unequally. If we accept the premise of every economic transaction somehow connected to something that can be traced back to Native Americans being tainted by guilt, then no American, regardless of the race, will escape the guilt. Then, we either have to add a new, openly racist, premise, that the guilt only ever attaches to certain races, but not others, or give up on the "White" part.
On the other hand, a lot of White Americans have come to America much later than any events that can be described as "violent extermination of Native Americans" took place. And even after coming in, as fresh immigrants, they could have little influence on the events and can not bear guilt for what was happening when they just came in or long before that. The only way any guilt could be attached to them is "the overall economy benefitted, thus they benefitted". But then again, why would it only be Whites? If every person of European descent, since stepping foot on American soil, is deemed automatically and forever "benefitting", why not a person of Chinese descent stepping foot on the same soil at the same day, and all his descendants forever? Why not Black people, after all - yes, they suffered terrible injustices, which in no way ended after slavery was officially banned, but still they were participating in the economy, even if handicapped by multiple disadvantages, as as such also benefitting from better economical conditions? Should the guilt attach to them too, maybe lesser amount, but still some of it? What about a refugee who just came into America a week ago? Surely, the level of support they receive depends on economical condition - better economy means better support and better opportunities. So should the guilt instantly attach to them too - or does it depend whether it is a refugee from Ukraine, or Syria, or Honduras, or Somali?
I think you misinterpret Addams Family and read into it something that wasn't there. Surely, they are anti-normal and in that quality they are opposed to the WASPs as WASPs are the quintessential "normal" for pre-culture-war America. Of course, this is a stereotype, because that's how satire operates. Nowdays, for such an idea you could be cancelled even if you bring it in for the purpose of mocking it. However, if you look into it, Addamses, while being anti-normal, are never at war with normies, all they want is to be left alone and enjoy their weird life in their weird ways. It is only when the normies try to aggressively normalize them, they turn their world upside down, striking into the most WASPish myth ever - not because they think it is virtuous, but because they think the normies would hate that, and they deserve it for not letting the anti-normies be in peace. That's how it looked before the culture war. The culture war changed the picture - SJWs don't want to be left alone, they want to proselytize aggressively and nothing less than turning every single normie into SJW would suffice them. Not only non-compliance is violence, silence (i.e. not being an active SJW) is violence. They don't want to enjoy their own lifestyle in their own community - they want it to be the only possible lifestyle, everywhere, and would aggressively persecute anybody who admits the possibility of any other way. Addamses would never go there.
So I think the Addams Family is not the first glimpse of the culture war, it is the last glimpse of how it was before the war. How you could diverge from the normie culture and still not try to destroy the civilization.
The Russian elites were worried about NATO exactly because their dastardly neo-imperialist designs. If you want to conquer your neighboring states, or at least subjugate them into a bunch of subservient satellite states, sort of like they did with Belarus, and thus restore the Mighty Russian Empire, of course you'd be worried that a Western mutual defense union right in the middle of where you plan to do that would interfere with your plans. If you plan to rob a place and they are installing a new security system and got a guard dog, of course you are feeling your plans are genuinely threatened by it! There's no need to pretend. It's the honest truth - yes, all that would make the planned robbery much harder to do.
I think the problem is here that the word "threat" is used in two senses interchangeably, and it confuses the matter. The Western "threat" is when you live peacefully, and somebody may attack you, so you feel threatened. The Russian "threat" is when you want to meddle with your neighbors to subjugate them and include them into your future Empire, but somebody might make that harder, and so you feel "threatened". These are different things, but it looks like when discussing whether Russians were "threatened" by NATO they are used as if it's the same thing.
I'd agree with that with one condition - if the armband-wearing folks start applying the approach "if you are so quick to offense that you cannot tolerate X, you shouldn't Y" to themselves. Somehow, I doubt they'd agree to do that. With the rainbow-armband squad, it always works only to one side - you should tolerate what we do, but we get to demand that you change your behavior if it offends us. They got hoist on their own petard - because it's all about power. They overestimated their power, that's all there is. I'd like to have the rules where it's not about power, but only for real, not pretend that it's not about power when it's convenient, and then lean into the power when it helps getting their way.
Let's not be coy and pretend those armbands are "innocuous". They clearly were meant as a political statement and a huge "fuck you" to the conservative culture of Qatar. Now, I don't really value too much the culture of Qatar, so for me saying "fuck you" to them is all in good fun, but let's not pretend it's not what happened - or what was about to happen, until it turned out the power is not on the side of the activists and they got squashed like bugs.
It's actually looking like the most un-common reason. You can only do it once in your life. If you ever been burned by a hot pan more than once in your life (I have, I assume most other people too, pretty much any adult had this experience - and yet adults are regularly getting burned by hot pans) - that's not the most common reason for you. It's hard for something to be most common reason for something if you can do it only once in your whole life, and you have plenty of warning before it.
OTOH, I'm pretty sure a lot of people tried to scam rationalists - because a lot of people try to scam everybody, look into your mailbox under "Spam" and you'd probably see a dozen scam attempts every day. Surely, they haven't been scammed this particular way before, but nobody has been scammed this particular way before, so there's nothing special for rat circles. BTW, a lot of much more weathered people - like journalists, politicians, Hollywood types, etc. - had accepted SBF with open arms. It's not like everybody but rationalists rejected him, but those doofuses got caught. Nobody within the Well Respected People circles rejected him. He had investment from the best and most respected venture funds. Financial regulators planned to use them as the example of "good crypto investor". He had CFTC license. Those people not only have seen every scam there is, they are supposed to be the supreme authority of the land to determine which is scam and which is not. They failed. Surely there were many reasons for that. Not having seen a scam before in their lives isn't one of them.
So, what's your answer for the why, that is special for rationalists? I say my answer is a common human one - they thought the pan is not hot, or maybe they wanted what's in the pot too much to reasonably evaluate the chances that it'd be too hot. People do that. I'm not too proud to admit it happened to me.

I mean, to consider, how ravingly, howlingly insane this is. Is there a popular movement in the US for destruction of Germany? I mean, that's literally people that invented the Nazis. Or Poland - we did pretty well for centuries without any Poland, why we need it at all? Or France - these bastards speak a weird language and are rude, why do they need a state, just to be more full of themselves than they already are? Let them have Quebec, and enough. Or, say, Japan - they attacked us at Pearl Harbor, and we had to nuke them, twice - why not just finish the job and get rid of it forever? You don't need to invent any "civil religion" to explain why there's not a lot of people advocating for such nonsense, do you? In fact, there's not even a word describing the idea that Germans, French, Japanese or Polish people deserve their own state - it's so obvious you don't need to call it anything. But talk about Jews having their own state - and talk about people saying maybe denying them that right is not a decent idea - and there's a conspiracy. Only a conspiracy can explain why such an idea is popular, only the absolute Despotism can ingrain the idea that Jews are people like Japanese, French, German and Polish are and their statehood does not have more reasons to be denied than any of these people, only an overwhelming pressure from a global plot and deep mental oppression can make this idea attractive, only an utterly brainwashed people can find any logic in it. It can not come into any mind by itself, it has to be forged into it by external forces. To think about it - those are Jews, how could they be like the other people? In fact, promoting such idea is a debasement of all that is proper and just.
And of course, if a person of Japanese descent lobbies for continued alliance between Japan and US - it's a natural thing. Why wouldn't they? They don't want their aunt to be nuked again. Friendship is much better, and also more profitable. But when a person of Jewish descent wants Israel and US to be allies - oh, here's dual loyalty! How dare you to think US can have common interests with the only democracy in the Middle East? How dare you to suggest it may be just good to not let millions of Jews to be murdered? It's all plot to steal our precious bodily fluids... sorry, wrong conspiracy, but it must be an evil plot, because nobody can have such an idea naturally. I mean, lobbying for the foreign aid to any other country? Sure. Working as a lobbyist for China, Iran, Russia, Egypt, whatever - nobody would dare to question the citizenly loyalties of those people, it's just not what decent people do - as long as it is not concerning Jews.
More options
Context Copy link