BANNED USER: Ban extended for arguing in edits
>Unban in 50d 12h 52m
Opt-out
No bio...
User ID: 4089
Banned by: @Amadan
I don’t have a problem with anything you describe or feel like any of my rights are being threatened because I am a reasonable citizen who does not feel some social interaction with a policeman is difficult.
But sure it’s difficult for the bottom 10% of people. Not my problem. We are Americans not slaves.
“ A reasonable human should not be obliged to make conversation with a cop. That's what the "no self incrimination" amendment is for.”
- “Am I being detained” is not a self-incriminating statement. America is a land citizens. Citizens are capable of interacting with public officials. And in this specific situation you can just walk around the cop since he has told you that you are being detained. A cop can’t arrest you for resisting arrest unless they’ve informed you that you are under arrests.
“ I am not detaining you. This is not a search." aren't magic words either. I don't see why we should put the burden on citizens, instead of the cops, to clarify the law.”
- How is a cop suppose to know every situation where a citizen might be curious if they are being detained? Should they just say “I am not detaining you every 5 second” in case someone might be confused that they are being detained?
Our form of government is for citizens. And yes that means being able to competently interact with different parts of government.
At no point in the interaction described to me in this case have any of my rights been violated. A cop looking at me weird doesn’t mean I get a get out of jail free card if I run.
I think if you look at this case different and not as a criminal then you would not think “detention” happened and it’s very clear. If I am strolling thru a park doing nothing illegal and a cop walks up to me to talk I don’t think I am being detained. What makes people just to detention here is that the person actually was a bad guy.
Cops are normal people until they detain you. You can just talk to them.
And most 100 IQ people are perfectly fine at making small talk. That is not some giga brain ability. Actually average IQ people are better at that.
What happened here is some dumb urban youth saw a cop after he fired some bullets and was still in possession of the gun. He figured the cop probably is going to arrest me because I’m guilty so he ran. But at that point in the encounter he had not yet been detained and wanted the head start on the running.
I am down with magic words. A reasonable human being is able to make conversation. That is what makes us human.
The alternative ends up being a cop looked at me wrong therefore evidence suppressed.
And I disagree with the characterization of “am I being detained” or “get out of my way I’m walking home” as some kind of magic versus normal human conversation. It’s not some priestly class words that only a few people from a special caste know how to do.
I don’t think you should need a law degree - magical words - to interact with police. That’s not the standard I’m arguing for.
And there isn’t any downside in this specific case. The officer still can’t search the subject without establishing probably cause for detention. You can still suppress for an illegal search. In this case a subject ran because an officer talked to him.
Agree. But sports have this odd thing where you sometimes need a specific body type to succeed. So was curious on the interplay between personality and body type. And sometimes if you’re good at something you begin to take on some personality traits of the role.
Would my personality be more pitcher like if growing up I had a stronger arm? Maybe.
Funny too because it’s been 20 years since GS was a training ground for investors. They basically closed down all their investing capabilities post Dodd-Frank. Now it’s various forms of professional services. You use to see a bunch of hedge funds come from their ranks but without prop trading those days ended.
Ugh. Now we are debating body language and exact path someone walked. Like the cop walked wrong?
I think a reasonable person can asks “yo am I being detained”
Cop - no Suspect - later
I don’t think you are using a reasonable person standard but a bottom 10% idiot standard.
I have annoying save the whales people walk in front of my path all the time. I don’t call that kidnapping.
I get that and think I am similar. I like variety of roles I need to fulfill. OL is suppose to be one of the smartest units but I think I would get bored blocking every play. OL some reason I am seeing a connection with Japanese culture who are perfectionists and when they enter an industry like say whiskey they end up creating a perfect product. Really focused on a role. I’m definitely more of a generalist type.
Wander if anyone here would claim their personality is the killer star. MJ being the leading brand. Wants to dominate and get the last shot of the game. The striker in soccer. WR probably fits best in football. I’d say center in hockey but non of the best seem to have that personality they are just really good. Maybe Sam Altman in business.
Another type is DL. Which isn’t a high IQ position. But the job is basically hitting the guy in front of you as hard as you can every play. Some maintaining gap integrity. I could see some one here saying I loved it I shut my brain down for 3 hours and just hit people.
Decision making in baseball is faster than your internal monologue so activates a part of your brain you’re not conscious of. But I assume can be quite frustrating if something gets off with how you figure out curveball or fastball etc. and that leads to yips. I assume can be psychologically frustrating.
I am thinking about sports and a persons personality. So my question is does your personality fit a specific sports position/role even if your body type ability doesn’t fit doing that?
I was thinking about this and I find myself having a personality that favors defense over offense in sports. I have a lot of fun figuring out how other players are trying to beat me and being able to stop them even if their a better athlete or if say a defense breaks down and the offense has two threats being able to figure out which one has the highest expected scoring chance and taking that away. On offense something similar as a facilitator rather than the scorer. In football I would be a safety, in basketball a low-scoring pg or maybe wing, hockey a defenseman, and in soccer I guess a midfielder.
If I were 6’6 300 lb my body type would be an offensive tackle. But I don’t think it fits my personality. Which makes me curious if my body type was different would my personality of adjusted because I always played that role?
Didn’t include baseball because I think baseball players have personalities I can’t imagine.
Does anyone say completely have the personality and can visualize being an OL but don’t have the physical ability. WR in the nfl always seem to have loud personalities. Look at me types.
I see cases all the time where cities had to pay out for violating civil rights or excessive force. In the specific example I was replying to it included physical injury to myself without probable cause to detain. I am no legal expert but I feel like I see in the news all the time someone getting paid out. All of this would be on body camera. What am I missing?
As far as I am seeing qualified immunity only protects government officials from personal civil liability and has nothing to do with protecting a city from civil liability.
Yes, I 100% agree that it is not casual. The office either suspects me of a crime or thinks I may have information he wants. It’s a clear indicator he wants to talk to me. I could see a colleague doing in this in an office walking up from behind and turning to face me. They have something they urgently want to talk to me about.
But wanting to interact with me and being detained are not the same thing.
Someone above posted prior case law like Florida v Bostick. I feel comfortable saying this ruling is not in line with US constitutional law. And this court is overstepping their authority (since apparently they haven’t stated this is based on state law).
If I were this suspect: Do I think the cop suspects me of a criminal offense: yes Has he detained me: no
Israel does this. I follow some math professor who does some part-time cop work.
I tend to feel these type of proposals run into issues on how many hours are in the day. But for 90% of the population 4 years as a cop probably teaches them more than 4 years in college. Perhaps we could do these things in a less credentialed world.
That’s not what qualified immunity is. It means you can’t sue the cop personally. You can sue the city. And you can get jury trial. And you would have video evidence.
You are going too far. This would be a very easy civil lawsuit to win if the police behaved as you just described.
Refusing to talk to police as far as I know is not probable cause for detention.
I keep reading what you say and want to say in a less polite way “I am not a member of a low IQ demographic”.
People of my tribe are perfectly fine dealing with this situation even if we did the crime and walking away unarrested while also not having our privacy rights impeded. But yes I understand we live in a world where a significant percent of our population is constantly confused. I don’t think we need to design society so that dumbest parts of our society can do crime and get away with it.
The suspect has reasonable methods to find out if they’re being detained. They can walk around the officer or just say “hello could you please get out of my way”.
You can’t make it illegal for police to talk to people. There is a difference between being rude and being detained. And I disagree it’s even rude to walk directly towards someone you want to talk to.
This sounds like woke judging for black youths. No detention took place. There is an underlying assumption here that black youth are not smart enough to talk to a police officer.
If I want to talk to someone I walk directly at them in their path. That’s a completely normal interaction. The black youth in question could have just responded to the cop “I don’t want to talk you can you get out of my way”
I would like to see the body cam to see how the cop impeded the black youth but everything in the report is just a normal human interaction. And yes a big way we catch criminals is they are not that smart. But that’s a criminals problem not a cops.
IMO if I had a bright orange t-shirt on and the officer did not think I was the criminal he was searching for but wanted to talk to me and asks “hey did you see a couple teens in black around here” the cops behavior would likely be 100% identical. This is just how you approach someone at night you want to talk to. We can’t make it illegal for cops to talk to people.
I am sure it’s possible but for the most part skin color and other facial features are fairly good predictors of someone’s racial background.
Like Patrick Mahomes one would guess one of his parents are white and one is black. Obama is a little darker but one would also guess he has a large amount of white ancestry.
Part of my point here is that affirmative action for Hispanics mostly helps white people for right tail education/jobs. It’s why I initially gave the example that there are a lot of Ted Cruz, Fernando Mendoza, and Marco Rubio Hispanics. The upper class in all of the south of the border countries is heavily white and there is a lot of them.
I’ve lived in all those places. That’s not urbanism. You said it in your words “entertainment district”. That’s a place you drive to and then have shops and restaurants you can walk around.
Urbanism or the way I am using it is when everything you could want in life is a 20 min walk. Your condo, your office, bars, restaurants, shopping, grocery store, sporting events/theatre, and your church.
I just google Houston again (where I have lived) and within the 610 I see nothing but single family homes. I think I’m trying to use “full walkable” instead of “walkable” this way to differentiate between a place where the entire life is walkable versus an entertainment district.
I find this funny:
“form of prejudice and discrimination in which individuals of the same race receive benefits or disadvantages based on their skin tone.”
You actually aren’t the same race if your skin tones differ. That’s a defining feature of race.
I’m not even sure what we are trying to do with Hispanic AA. It’s not a race. It’s not a population we did slavery to no debt owed to them. I guess whenever they did the first census they saw a group slightly different (I’m guessing Chicanos in California) and wanted a way to define them.
The equivalent to America doing affirmative action for Hispanics would be if Mexico did Affirmative Action for Americans. The people benefitting would be basically George Bush types (equivalent of Ted Cruz).
I’m still a little bit stuck on the 4.6x benefit to get equal representation since a large % of how this group is defined is just white people.
Interesting. I don’t think most here differentiate between Latino and Hispanic and I would think for US census bureau purposes they are the same.
I groked it and the main difference seems to be Brazil who usually are Latin but not Hispanic. But the terms are usually interchangeable.
And then Grok lists Italians/Portugal as usually no for Latinos.
Grok also said Italians/Portugal Europeans are usually No for Latino. So in pure Elizabeth Warren identification since I have an Italian surname usually no means sometimes yes. So I am Latino. And since Latino and Hispanic are usually interchangeable I should generally check yes to Hispanic for anything work or educationally related.
But my broader point is for the rightish tail of school entrance that a 4.6 multiple was what was needed to get right amount of Hispanics in?

Your standard make it illegal for cops to walk around a neighborhood. That is not reasonable.
The only reasonable standard is people have to talk to each other. Anything else endangering I thought the cops body language was bad and therefore all evidence is suppressed. That is not reasonable.
“if you have nothing to hide, then you have nothing to fear”
Under your standard Madoff could walk down the street and claim a cop walk towards him and then throw his briefcase with evidence of a ponzi scheme and then run away and claim everything is suppressed. That is stupid.
More options
Context Copy link