OracleOutlook
🇺🇸 Fiat justitia ruat caelum
No bio...
User ID: 359
I think the best attitude towards the Papacy is to act like a medieval peasant and just not hear news about the Pope most of the time outside of his purposeful acts of teaching. What do my pastor and local bishop have to say? I have a print copy of Magnifica Humanitas and that's a fine document if a little preliminary.
In America I see a lot of obsession with the Pope either positively or negatively. Some act like every spontaneous utterance is God-breathed scripture. Some act like every spontaneous gesture is a sign of the devil's attempted invasion of the Church. I think both approaches are flawed. Don't know if Catholics in other countries are like one, the other, or more like me.
I should have just left out the word Protestant from my post because this really isn't the point, the point is the psychology of someone doing really bad things and how it stems from weakening the will with little bad things. The context of my example was a Protestant calling in to Catholic Answers and repeating an argument an unnamed Protestant Apologist said, but that's not to imply that every Protestant or most would agree with it. It was just a framing story to flavor the meat of the response, which is that "One who is faithful in a very little is also faithful in much, and one who is dishonest in a very little is also dishonest in much."
He won three Emmys and 30 million Americans watched his show weekly!
Edit: I have never heard of Monsignor Rice either.
I can guess what you mean, American Catholics have our own patrimony and are shaped by the popularity of anti-communist Archbishop Fulton Sheen's television programing and living in a Protestant-dominated culture. But would you like to elaborate more?
I should have a sign that says, "The only thing most Protestants have in common is not agreeing with Catholics on the Pope thing."
Was thinking of this video specifically but this isn't the first time I heard this complaint: https://youtu.be/Dx_Zu1LHdj8?si=J8Wbf47jpFMB_Elu
Like https://youtube.com/shorts/L8yLOecMec8?si=bczR5tUHitRZSvpD is an example of a guy doing the "you never have to worry about losing your salvation."
One of the perennial arguments of Protestants against Catholics is the idea that someone can be damned for one sin. Does it really make sense for someone to be holy and live a good Christian life, miss Sunday Service one single time, die, and then go to Hell for all eternity?
One Catholic response to this I heard recently is that it's never just one sin. To get to the point where you commit something Catholics consider a mortal sin, you are first committing dozens of smaller, venial sins. Before a woman divorces her husband, she first stopped forgiving him and making up after fights. Before a man steals a car, he started with shoplifting. Before a witness perjurs himself, he started with gossiping. Dozens and dozens of times doing something bad but not evil until finally, the sinner does the big one. The action that fully severs them from grace.
Before a CEO sleeps with a spy, he first sleeps with his CFO.
I think the "mortal sin" is sleeping with a potential foreign spy which obviously imperils everything and everyone at Nvidia. But someone who is inured to sleeping around is going to be more likely to sleep with a spy than someone who is a family man. And so to answer your question, yes, everyone involved with affairs should also be fired and this should be understood as precautionary, to solve the problem before you get around to the major issues such behavior can lead to.
I think this tweet is relevant:
Women are turned on not by men who are good little helpers, but by men that they admire. So if she’s the one writing the lists, making the decisions, and rallying the crew, she’ll look at you more and more as one of the kids she’s responsible for. Oh, you can be the best behaved child of them all, but that will not engage her sexually as a woman.
Instead, take ownership of the whole thing. Learn to see everything in the home as under your jurisdiction. You’ll solicit her input, but you’ll make your own decisions and your own lists. If the dishes are dirty and she’s tired and frazzled, jump in and do it, not as a dutiful hireling, but as a captain who would accept nothing less than clean dishes and a well-rested wife on his ship. The more you see your home as your castle, and get out ahead of things, the more she will feel like your frame is a solid place for her to inhabit.
A man who is looking at a dopamine box or planning out what to do next on the dopamine box, is a man who isn't seeing the quest log for the house he shares with his wife and kids. A woman who's trying to do the dishes while also trying to prevent the 7 year old and the 5year old from blowing out everyone's eardrums would deal with both situations with as much grace she could muster if she were home alone, but she's not home alone. She has a partner, the children's father, right there, maybe even in the same room, but he's not able to help right now, the game doesn't pause. So he turns into some kind of stupid teenager instead of a husband and a parent and her partner.
Though it's funny, the same situation may happen when the man is on a work escalation and that doesn't bother the wife so much. Or rather, the same level of frazzleness occurs, but the anger and resentment is directed towards that stupid webdev team who tried to do the patch at dinner time, how insensitive are they? But when the husband is choosing to do something fun at the wife's expense, the anger and resentment is focused straight on him. A good wife will ignore it, a great wife will forgive it, but the man is still generating anger and resentment every time he turns to the dopamine box when there is literally anything else that could be getting done which would improve the lives of his family and he's not doing it.
It doesn't help that some men literally get sniped by a video game. Someone who only games a couple hours a day for most of their life gets a new game, say WOW, and then suddenly is playing 12 hours a day. And they'll excuse it, they'll take time off work for it, say it's just for the release week, I'll take less time off for Christmas break, you can handle the kids then? But then they become nocturnal and even when they're supposed to go back to work they sleep in and miss work and call out sick or hope no one notices they were two hours late to work and then before you know it they're jobless and WOW is their full time job. If you wouldn't respect a guy like that, do you think a woman should respect a guy like that?
And sure that's a rare side effect, most people don't get sniped so hard. Internet Gaming Disorder affects 2% to 5% of regular gamers. But the fear of it is existential. Gaming threatens the respect you have for your spouse and your livelihood. It's an enemy, kill it with fire.
The ballot measure in question, Washington Initiative 638, Sex Verification Requirements for Female School Sports Initiative (2026), is specifically about school sports. If someone wants to set up a trans-girl league no one's stopping them.
It is hard to decide things "locally." High Schools across a state compete against each other. If Seattle wants to allow Transgirls in their high school basketball teams, but no one else in Washington State if comfortable with that, you're going to end up with teams with transgirls competing against teams without transgirls in the State Championship, which is unfair and against the whole point of the rest of Washington not wanting their daughters to have to compete against biological boys. It has to be banned across everyone who would compete against each other or it's not banned at all.
Like, even if the decisions are made by humans, if the humans are relying on the advice of AIs, there's probably a sense in which humans are really just rubber stamping decisions made by smarter, more powerful AIs, because those will tend to have the best outcome for a given human policy goal.
My whole "optimistic" society is set up around the idea that there AI alignment is never 100% solved. An AI might come up with more efficient solutions than humans, however the chance of it saying "It's fine to bomb three kindergartens to save Elon Musk's life" is never non-0. That's why there is always a human selected for some way we invent to measure virtue watching the plays and holding a veto button.
Yeah we've just kind of moved what should have been an email into a dozen teams group chats with lengthy paragraphs of text.
Dr. Ferber's book, "Solve Your Child's Sleep Problems" gives the following analogy:
All children learn to connect certain conditions with falling asleep. For most children, that means being in a particular bedroom, lying in a particular crib or bed, and perhaps holding a favorite stuffed animal or a special blanket. When they wake periodically during the night, as all children do between sleep cycles, most will promptly fall back to sleep, because the conditions they associate with falling asleep are still present. But if the conditions have changed, such children may not be able to fall asleep again without help reestablishing them...
Perhaps you’ve had the experience of waking during the night just enough to notice your pillow missing. Most likely, instead of going straight back to sleep, you wakened a little more, enough to find the pillow on the floor and pull it back into bed before returning to sleep. But if you couldn’t find it right away, you probably wouldn’t be able to ignore it and go back to sleep. Instead, you’d become more fully awake so you could look around for it. If you still couldn’t find it, eventually you might turn on the light, get out of bed, and begin searching the room. You might get angry and perhaps curse—showing the same kind of frustration that a child shows by crying....
To stretch the analogy a bit further, suppose you discover that someone has been sneaking into your room each night and stealing your pillow. Once you know that, you might have trouble falling asleep at bedtime for fear that the pillow will be taken away as soon as you’re asleep. Whenever you catch yourself starting to drop off to sleep, you might wake yourself up again to make sure the pillow is still there.
Now imagine that this person, instead of just taking your pillow, actually moves you from your bed to another room, without waking you. Every night you go to sleep in your bed with everything just as you like it, only to wake after your first sleep cycle on, say, the floor of the living room. Unless you’re an exceptionally tolerant sleeper, you won’t even try to go back to sleep right there; you’ll get up and head back to your bedroom. But now suppose you find your bedroom door locked from the other side. Now there’s nothing you can do but wake someone who can unlock the door for you. Once that’s been done, you can at last get back into bed and get your pillow and blanket arranged properly, thereby reestablishing the conditions that were present at bedtime. Once you calm down, you will fall back asleep—but some ninety minutes later you’ll wake up again, back on the living room floor and again locked out of your bedroom.
If that happens throughout the night every night, you will not be sleeping at all well, and neither will the person who has to keep getting up to unlock your door. Soon you might be resisting sleep in hopes of identifying the person who keeps moving you; in other words, you might have trouble falling asleep even in your own bed because you know that you’ll be moved once you fall asleep. If that happened to you every night, you would not be very happy.
Don't know how old your baby is but at a certain point with my oldest, I realized she was going to cry whatever I did. Holding her while she cried didn't seem to actually help, it just made her less able to sleep in her own bed. "Crying it out" doesn't always make sense, I mostly avoided it with the younger kids because I understood better how to avoid the sleep associations ahead of time. But sometimes it's just the reality you are faced with, the baby is crying it out, it's just a choice of if they're crying in your arms because it soothes your conscience or if it's in their bed because you're their parent teaching them how to sleep.
If you want to keep bouncing because the baby is just too young, I recommend a yoga ball.
I would have been so happy with a SRO unit out of college. I even looked up if it was possible to live (legally) out of a tent at a national forest an hour away from work (turns out it's only for a few weeks at a time, not allowed in winter.) I ended up renting a room from a guy on craigslist who got arrested a couple months in and his wife and kids I didn't know about showed up to take back the house. Was homeless for about a week before I was able to rent a condo with another craigslist person, splitting it was about half my income at the time.
Fun times. I can promise you there's demand for it. Zoning restricts it. Many zoning codes outright prohibit boarding houses and SROs by name. Others cap the number of unrelated adults allowed to live under one roof. Housing and building codes frequently require every unit to contain its own private kitchen and full bathroom.
Buildings without electricity and running water get condemned. You just can't legally live the way your great-grandparents did, the hedonistic treadmill isn't coming from the young and impoverished.
Here's my optimistic AI world:
UBI a la the "Freedom Dividend" idea from the ill-fated Yang campaign. VAT tax gets divided among everyone equally without means-testing. It is sufficient for someone to live a modest life and it replaces other cash transfer forms of welfare. Still, it's just enough to live and watch Netflix all day without a lot of frivolities. There is incentive to work to increase spending money, and because your basics are covered you don't need a lot of work to reach a comfortable amount of spending money.
All decisions/choices made by humans (probably enforced by regulation.) Also work week (by regulation) declines over time to 20 hours or so. At some point, the White Collar work day looks like: You log into a computer for a few hours, Claude gives you decisions to make, you make them. Your AI Agent does all the paperwork, excel sheeting, and email responses, it summarizes and prioritizes the decisions to make, but a human gives their reputation behind each decision.
Teaching/doctoring/other white-collar-esque things that require communicating with a human in person become more valued, more people sign up for it, more training tracks appear. To match the fake email job work schedule better, shifts are shorter. Every elementary classroom has 2-3 teachers working 3 hours of class-time, 1 hour of prep. Admin costs go down for school districts/hospitals, more money available to hire teachers/nurses.
Blue collar work becomes mostly auditing the robots. Going out to the farms/factory floor in person, making sure the robots aren't fudging the numbers or acting funny, report back.
Paper and in-person meetings become more critical as time goes on because there is a distrust of the computer. The white-collar decision maker and the blue-collar auditor must meet in person or else what if the computer is lying about the results of the audit?
Training up a white collar decision-makers involves more external activities, games, clubs, tournaments, etc. We will no longer be able to train someone up "on the job" as easily, we need to be able to train up and select for virtuous, intelligent people . There will be tournaments, honor games, VR ethical-challenge-gauntlets to select for people who make decisions in line with the broader society. Imagine selecting the next VP of Sales by how well they performed on Mr. Beast's Squid Games.
Everyone who wants it can learn/study the arts and sciences. People still form university-like things but it's all passion, little status. All the funding goes to AI-run labs cranking out math theorems and running physics experiments under the watchful eyes of the auditors and decision makers.
Having human-made things will be even more of a status symbol than it is now. The last main category of jobs will be making things by hand, giving things the personal touch, etc. This will be economically feasible because these people will already have their basic needs met through UBI, so if they spend all month making a sweater that is certified human-made, sell it for $500 to a rich person for a status symbol, that $500 might be their spending money that month but it's enough for whatever extra thing they want to buy. Especially because robot-made goods will be dirt cheap.
Democrats are not that smart. Or rather, they will lose their base if they do this and 2028 will make 2026 look like a normal loss.
The entire Fatima event, including the sudden change in behavior of the seers and the prediction of the sign ahead of time.
St. Padre Pio's Stigmata and ability to read people's sins, including specific details like date and place.
The incorruptible body of Saint Bernadette Soubirous. When she was exhumed in 1909, three decades after her death, it was noted that her habit was damp and her metal rosary rusted, ruling out typical mummification processes. She shows no signs of adipocere either.
A decade later, she was exhumed again and they found her liver still intact, whereas a liver typically purifies between 24-72 hours. She was enclosed in he coffin three full days (April 16 to April 19, 1879) after her death. She was not embalmed - the doctors who examined her corpse found no evidence of embalming, her body was publicly on display from her death to her burial, and the convent's detailed administrative and financial logs from April 1879 record no expenses or preparations for an embalming procedure. The intactness of her liver cannot be attributed to embalming or to burial conditions.
And as a bonus, the novena to the little flower.. Lots of Catholics report receiving a rose after praying to St. Terese of the Child Jesus. I've received roses after praying for her intersession a few times, one at a time of my life I lived alone, had 0 friends, and it was pretty weird for me to find a rose on my car windshield, for example. Adding this one as a "bonus" because it's not exactly studied/documented like the others, but it's one you can DIY (though I don't think it's like magic and probably wouldn't happen if you aren't sincerely praying for something.)
I wrote him in for President once. Seemed to be the most effective Republican outside of DeSantis, but there's something about when a politician runs for office that makes me like them less.
Mennonites are allowed to do their own thing and conservatives will fight for their right to do their own thing, but they are not a group conservatives would choose to lead them. I think if a Mennonite ran for office there would be pushback. Lloyd Tucker was raised Mennonite, but switched to Lutheran before running for office. His wife dresses like this. Can't think of any other recent examples. Mennonites have a resistance to participating in politics.
In Mark there's a geographical error.
No, you have an interpretation error. All the "geographical errors" people claim in Mark are modern people assuming that the authors of the Gospels felt a need to stick to precise chronology, listing things in order, or that geographic areas have to be specific or else they are wrong. If I wrote, "I went down to West Palm Beach and had fun in the Atlantic Ocean," would people understand what I mean? Or would I have people thousands of years later saying, "According to our best records, the city of West Palm Beach did not actually share a coast with the Atlantic, showing that this was written by someone unfamiliar with the area?"
So why don't you obey the orthodox Jew scribes today
I obey the person who sits on Moses' seat now. With the fall of the second temple, the Jewish religion as practiced in Jesus' day is ended. Jesus gave the parable of the vineyard where he described taking the vineyard and giving it to someone else. That someone else was the 12 Apostles and continues to this day in the bishops throughout the world.
Why make temptation if it could lead to infinite negative utility?
Because without it there would be 0 positive utility. Infinities are of different sizes, yes? You can have a larger infinity than another. In order to have the larger infinity of Heaven, there has to be the possibility to not love God, which is Hell. Heaven is much better than Hell is worse.
Adam could have free will in the garden with no forbidden tree placed right there, and a serpent that the omniscient Yahweh allowed to seduce Eve? God couldn't even provide his dumb little children a reminder? Like argue with the serpent, thus allowing them an informed choice? What kind of parent lets their naive little child talk to a serpent like that? And then sets the child on fire if the child doesn't take well to being kicked out into the wilderness?
Adam had to have a choice. The Tree is a manifestation of the ultimate choice - do you trust in the love of God and His desire for what's best for you? Without the possibility of that choice there is no love.
Middle knowledge is still an open topic of discussion inside Catholicism. Here is a Catholic Answers apologist explaining this position: https://jimmyakin.com/2020/12/why-would-god-create-people-he-knows-will-go-to-hell.html Catholics are not required to believe in Middle Knowledge (the belief that God knows what every possible creature would freely do in any given circumstance ("counterfactuals of creaturely freedom"). Molinism is a permissible opinion, but it's not heresy not to believe in it. I stick to the Catholic belief that God has:
- Knowledge of all possible things
- Knowledge of all actual things
All things are open and laid bare to his eyes, even those which will be brought about by the free activity of creatures.
And this is consistent with what I said too. God stands outside of time and knows all that will happen, including our free-will choices.
The Council of Trent anathematises exactly this.
No it doesn't.
Session V, canon 2: «If any one asserts, that the prevarication of Adam injured himself alone, and not his posterity… or that he… has only transfused death, and pains of the body, into the whole human race, but not sin also, which is the death of the soul; let him be anathema.»
Adam has injured us all by his actions, in the sense that we would have had a gift and now we do not receive it.
The consequences of this revocation of a gift is not just to the body, but also to the soul, preventing us from achieving everlasting life outside of intervention.
My statement fits comfortably inside this canon.
Canon 3: Adam's sin, «being transfused into all by propagation, not by imitation, is in each one as his own» (Trent, Session V).
Yes, Adam's sin is one that we inherit, as if by propogation. This canon is rejecting the idea that we only have original sin due to the world around us, but that if we were placed in the garden of Eden ourselves as an infant we'd be ok. It's not through imitation of a fallen world external to use but through something we genuinely miss in ourselves now.
This is a massive departure from the Church and the canon. I conclude you cannot truly defend either. «Death puts an end to human life as the time open to either accepting or rejecting the divine grace manifested in Christ»
You are misreading me. I said, "As they die" as in, as they are still alive, taking part in the process of Death. After death is complete and the soul exits time, no choice is possible. But many saints attest to the power of final repentance, and Saint Faustina particularly goes into depth regarding Jesus's fight for every soul:
Diary Entry 1486:
"God’s mercy sometimes touches the sinner at the last moment in a wondrous and mysterious way. Outwardly, it seems as if everything were lost, but it is not so. The soul, illuminated by a ray of God’s powerful final grace, turns to God in the last minute with such power of love that, in an instant, it receives from God forgiveness of sin and punishment...
Jesus calls to the soul not once, but three times. If the soul remains unresponsive, whether hardened or despairing, then the mercy of God begins to exert itself, and, without any co-operation from the soul, God grants it final grace. If this too is spurned, God will leave the soul in this self-chosen disposition for eternity. This grace emerges from the merciful Heart of Jesus and gives the soul a special light by means of which the soul begins to understand God’s effort; but conversion depends on its own will."
Where are "«" these marks coming from? What do they mean to you?
I think you have a misunderstanding about Church teaching that I need to clear up now. There are many millions of permissible theological opinions any faithful Catholic can hold. As conflicts develop, the Church may declare one out of bounds, and narrow the number of theological opinions that are permissible. It doesn't matter that the "final option" theory hasn't been declared infallible Church teaching as very little has been declared infallible Church teaching. I am still free to hold it if it seems to be the best answer to the data I see.
Aquinas: «if He had willed to free man from sin without any satisfaction, He would not have acted against justice… if He forgive sin, which has the formality of fault in that it is committed against Himself, He wrongs no one»
I think St. Aquinas is wrong here, and St. Anselm got it right. In Cur Deus Homo Chapter 13:
Nothing, therefore, is less tolerable in the order of things than that the creature should take away the honor due to the Creator and not restore what he takes away... Therefore, the justice of God requires that either punishment or satisfaction follow upon sin.
God gave a Church and a Book, and the Church says the Book is inspired and without error.
No, God gave a Church and the Bible is written by the Church for the Church. And yes, the Bible is inspired and without error, in everything that the human authors, inspired by the Holy Spirit, intend to assert regarding God, salvation, and faith. You're missing the importance of a clause in Dei Verbum you are quoting. "that truth which God wanted put into sacred writings for the sake of our salvation."
But maybe, based on what you are saying, I could join for the community, and rub shoulders with the other secret heretics, who believe such things.
You're just following the wrong Catholics. Follow Bishop Barron, Jimmy Akin, Joe Heshmeyer, Fr. Patrick Mary Briscoe, Fr. Bonaventure Chapman, Fr. Joseph-Anthony Kress, Fr. Gregory Pine. Read the writings of Pope Benedict XVI, Hans urs von Balthazar, St. John Henry Newman.
I am not a heretic and your objections depend on a misreading of what I say. But regardless of labels, if you think my answers are half decent, then jump in, I'm not a lone wolf making this up on my own. There are a large community of priests and lay theologians who provide the philosophical backing to what I'm saying.
I highly recommend watching this... not sure what genre this is. Interview? Debate? on Divine Hiddenness between a Dominican priest and an atheist and maybe you can see that I'm not some lone wolf crazy person: https://youtube.com/watch?v=8k9A7d2Wnjk
To be frank, even if they did experience fewer miracles, the appropriate amount of miracles supporting a false religion would be zero, would it not?)
There's a difference between paranormal circumstances, miracles, and vindictatory miracles. I'd expect 0 miracles that vindicate distinctively Muslim claims, meaning theological claims that Muslims make that Catholics do not also make. But "God loves us and has a plan for my life so He healed me" is a claim that holds as true in both Christianity and Islam. I'm even open to the possibility that humans have senses that we have yet to study in depth. Parapsychologists study and claim that many humans have an innate talent for water dowsing, remote viewing, telepathy, etc, which might be confused for a miracle in another religion but might actually follow some natural laws that we have yet to unpack.
Catholicism has the best attested vindicatory miracles and there are no real attempts in other religions to claim otherwise. Atheists like to believe that it must all be the same, but I haven't' seen one actually put in the effort to prove that other religions make anything like the claims of Catholicism.
I am coming from the assumption that Muslims experience signal graces, miracles and spiritual experiences.
Why do you assume this? I think, if I accepted Islam as true in a world where it is not true, I would not have made as much spiritual progress.
I understand that Islam is a totalizing ideology, which seems to be what you are getting at. But the example of the Catholic and Orthodox saints blow the Awliya completely out of the water in terms of life-changing conversions, selfless love, signs and wonders. In fact, while Islam has a concept of miracles, Karamah, their theology says that people should hide their miracles and not flaunt them. This means that unlike Catholic miracles, most Islamic miracles have very little investigation, even from Islam-friendly sources.
Let's put the question to you. If you were in a world where Catholicism was true, would you expect that Catholics would experience more miracles, inner conversions, spiritual progress than Muslims? If you were in a world where Islam was true, would you expect that Muslims would experience more miracles, inner conversions, spiritual progress than Catholics?
Can you not imagine that had you instead accepted Islam as true, you would be saying the same about Islam today? If you can't, why?
Yes I can imagine an alternate world where Islam was true. If it was this world, where Islam is false but I accepted it anyway, I doubt I would experience the same signal graces, miracles, and spiritual experiences that I do now. You are assuming that I would because you are coming from the assumption that neither is true.
Edit: I also think that to be a Muslim you have to ignore a lot of things to get by, while as a Catholic I don't have to ignore anything. Largely how the Quran is actually considered literally the word of God and yet misunderstands Christianity severely, gets events wrong from the Old Testament while claiming that the OT is also simultaneously true. Whereas the Biblical interpretive key has room for individual authors writing in their biases.
I don't believe God gave us a Book but rather a Church. I find the Old Testament very fruitful for spiritual truths but only after guidance. Your idea that line by line it has to be literally exact or else it's all false is just not a good argument. You're arguing against a position I do not hold and will not hold and have no obligation to hold.
Her: Why did God make Adam sin if he's all knowing?
God did not make Adam sin. I think your question is getting at, why does God make humans knowing that they will chose Hell over Him. And my response would be He doesn't know before He makes a human which way they'll choose.
If free will is real, then "knowing the result of a free choice never made" is like "can God make a square circle." It's logically inconsistent and therefore not covered under omnipotence/omniscience. God has a very good idea of what choices a human would make, but does not know what choices a specific human will actually make until after He's committed to making them.
God had hope that Adam would avoid the temptation to sin and make the correct choice, up until He created Adam and then was locked into this course of action.
Her: Why do humans have free will?
Because only someone with free will can love, and God created us to love Him and each other.
Her: Why do we pay for the sin of Adam and Eve?
We are experiencing the consequences of their actions but nothing has been taken away from us that rightfully belonged to us. God gave Adam and Eve special grace to enjoy a life beyond their natures. Original sin removed us from that grace, it is nor ours by right but was a gift they rejected. This life of struggle is what our natures deserve on their own. We pay for our own sins, Adam and Eve paid for theirs, no one is being treated unfairly here.
Another way to look at it though is that the "curses" of God at the end of Genesis 3 is a remedial lesson on love. Adam failed to protect his wife, Eve failed to love her God, their failure was one of love. In response, Man will toil, Woman will suffer, but by doing so this is the remedy, the school of love. By undergoing the curse, we learn to love as our first parents did not, we sacrifice for others.
Her: How do you know what church to join?
History, saints, etc.
Her: I think God is too cruel.
The worst suffering in this life is a blip in time compared to the goodness that awaits us.
Her: What's the trinity?
Going to respond with a quote from Dorothy Day to start:
There are some paragraphs about the Holy Trinity which I read not long ago that point out an analogy between the soul and God. The soul is always one. It knows itself and loves itself. “I am conscious of myself, and it is this I that is conscious of this self, the I that is objectified to itself, and knows itself in itself. But once more, whist the principle that is the I is the principle that knows, the myself is the term that is known, and in virtue of this a distinction is established between I and myself, and this perception that I get of myself involves and implies a third term which is the love of I for self.
Whence result three imperfect but irreducible elements, co-existent in the undivided unity of my soul, three that are blended into one without becoming confused; one that radiates out into three without subdividing itself. Now in God there is the same law of activity and fecundity, but in the supreme degree of power and perfection. . . Although we are always capable of thinking and willing, we do not always exercise our faculties in practice, there are interruptions, moments when we feel powerless, when we are weary. A fly is sufficient to prevent a man thinking. In this we distinguish . . . and this is weakness . . . the capability to act and the action itself. In God this weakness does not exist. If we strive in vain to put into our thoughts the best of ourselves, or better still, if we labor, without succeeding, to make ourselves wholly and entirely the objective of our thoughts, to objectify ourselves in our thoughts . . . the Divine Spirit succeeds where we fail.” (Landrieux, Le Divin Méconnu.)
The Trinity is the unity of the Lover, the Beloved, and the Love that unites them.
Her: The Bible says the Earth is 6000 years old.
It doesn't exactly say that, this is what people after the fact said because they try to use math without understanding the cultural context in which certain parts, like people's ages and genealogies, were written.
Her: Then so is Jesus.
The New Testament is substantially different from the Old Testament. It starts with five ancient biographies, followed by epistles written very early on, and ends with some banging apocalyptic (in the sense of "removing the veil of the bride" rather than "end of the world") literature.
Her: Why doesn't God do something to make everyone believe now?
There is something in the Search that is valuable and God does not want to squelch it. I think this line of thought is only pressing if you think that everyone is going to Hell except a small few, and that we don't all have the opportunity to be saved. Whereas I believe Jesus gives everyone a choice as they die, regardless of what they knew during life.
Her: Why is he obsessed with people believing in him anyway? I think a remote God makes a lot more sense.
Why do you think God is obsessed with people "believing" in Him? Rather, I would say He wants us to love Him because it is in our nature and failing to live up to this hurts us. He cares that we're hurting ourselves.
Her: Nietzsche said it's slave morality and cope.
Nietzche died alone and crazy.
Her: He can forgive us, why didn't he just do that.
Because that would not be comporting with the dignity He wishes to give us. The problem isn't one of just forgiveness but that we are broken and in need of healing. If He just snapped his fingers and forgiven us it would have been unjust to His nature and unmerciful to ours. Instead, Jesus, true God and true Man, was able to offer Himself as a sacrifice. Because He is God He has infinite worth, because He is human He actually is a real human being doing something incredibly selfless and sacrificing something of infinite worth.
Now we can take part in Jesus' sacrifice and have its merits applied to us. And this is not a cheap and easy fix, but something that elevates our dignity and inspires love towards our God who went to such extremes to save us. And remember that the original sin, the whole problem to solve, was that we need to learn love.
Her: Why doesn't God do something to make everyone believe now?
Me: He did. The crucifixion is a publication. Maybe we'll get another message in our life time that is explicit.
This is a cop out answer. If you say the crucifixion is a publication and sufficient to make everyone believe now, then the same holds for Christianity.
I suspect you don't like it because you're judging by prior ethical and political standards.
No. I was clear that I am not Muslim because I found the truth, and once you find the truth you don't keep searching.
I showed what the Church believed for most of its history, which was your original claim («most educated Christians for most of history regarded the first 11 chapters of Genesis as myths»). The Fathers disagreed about which young date, so they were literalists regarding that who disagreed with each other.
This was not my claim either. I went into lots of paragraphs to be clear on this point, that it was the best account they had at the time as well as being interpreted as an allegory from the beginning, and these two ways of reading the text are not exclusive but are actually part of four modes of reading the Bible that have been encouraged by Christians since the beginning.
I have little hope that you understand me anywhere if you misunderstand this.
Pius XII doesn't make it a mere regulation. He gives the reason:
Giving a reason for a regulation does not mean it's not a regulation. He certainly didn't make it dogma.
Trent, Session V, canon 1:
This is not the same as condemning polygenism. Again you are jumping around. "The first man, Adam, when he had transgressed the commandment of God in Paradise, immediately lost the holiness and justice wherein he had been constituted" is perfectly compatible with an allegorical read of Genesis. The bare bones, what you're required to believe in order to be Catholic is that:
-
God made a man by giving him a rational soul. This is something extra God had to do of His own choice, it's not something that developed naturally from evolution.
-
God also made a woman through the first man, man and woman share the same nature despite our differences, and this relates the the way in which God ensouled us.
-
Originally man's life would have been in perfect happiness with no suffering. Then the first man and woman together sinned against God and messed it up.
-
All humans inherit the fallen human nature and the fallen world these two blockheads made through their sin. We share a common dignity between sexes and races, we share the same fate.
The interpolations from the extended Acts in Codex Bezae do not match the style of Luke and Acts. Pretty much everyone agrees that they are additions, not that Luke/Acts were redactions.
This is getting too long. Calanda is not like the hadiths, my argument was not that the hadiths were from long ago but rather contradicted testimony written down earlier regarding this event. I feel like you keep missing what I am saying and which point I'm making by what I'm saying. It's an experience not unlike talking to an LLM.
Did you look at the photos and the analysis from Fatima? https://apcz.umk.pl/SetF/article/download/SetF.2021.001/28737 Photographs capture a light source from something that could not have been the sun. It also doesn't help that all these explanations for various phenomena contradict each other. The explanation against the colors is that they saw an effect that takes place is that this only happens when there is a specific, non visible cloud cover over the sun. But also the explanation for clothes drying (an effect also captured in photos) within minutes is that the sun was very hot/bright, the kind of hot that only happens when there is no cloud cover. Which is it?
Why am I not a Muslim? Because Catholicism is true. Once I accepted Catholicism as true, everything fit together, everything. All stories, all science, all longings of my heart and all the mental itching that told me I was missing something big, it all fell into place. The closer I grow to God through the practices of Catholicism the more certain I am. But I guess my path leading to it was the philosophical exploration of the uncaused cause, arguments for the historicity of the Resurrection of Jesus, the history of the Church, the witness and example of the saints, the proof present in their lives that a transformative union with God is possible, and not just possible but something with a clear path to those willing to try.
It is true and there is very little anyone can do that will convince me otherwise. I know it is true like I know I breathe air. And because it's exclusive against the strongest Islamic claims, I know that Islam is unfortunately false, and not only false but frightening and sad.
- Prev
- Next

Would it have been better phrased if I said "One of the perennial arguments of Protestants against Catholics is the idea that someone can lose their salvation for one sin. Does it really make sense for someone to be holy and live a good Christian life, miss Sunday Service one single time, die, and then go to Hell for all eternity?"
More options
Context Copy link