TheDag
Per Aspera ad Astra
No bio...
User ID: 616
Hah, how many Greek orthodox are on this site anyway? ;)
Yeah I guess I should get into sports. Oof.
Yeah the safetyists IMO are also mostly evil sorcerers. They just have better marketing lines.
I've said it before and I'll say it again. Christianity is at least as unbacked by evidence and reason as transgender ideology.
As @Cirrus explains below, there is plenty of evidence. Thousands and thousands of eyewitness accounts, prophecy, et cetera.
Not to mention the very cultural/political connotations, history and tradition are themselves evidence compared to transgenderism. Just evidence that points to a conclusion you really don't like or can believe is true.
I'm not trying to be antagonistic here, but your strong claims against Christianity show a clear bias and lack of clear eyed, Bayesian priors. I think you need to reassess your own 'objectivity' before you start claiming a high horse.
We aren't really sports people, and my friends are a few years sober. But yes board games are good.
Know any good ones for 2-3 people?
I've always found these sorts of comments annoying because they've always struck me as an obvious attempt at proselytization/conversion, but when this is pointed out it gets dismissed out of hand.
Very well put. Once you realize that rationalist, atheist materialism is a belief system in its own right that is at the least on a level playing field with other religions, a lot of the social behavior you see makes far more sense. Ironically I see so much more of the bad behaviors usually ascribed to Christians (shaming, denying reality, trying to build consensus, rallying around unfalsifiable beliefs) coming from the materialists now that I have changed my viewpoint a bit.
And yes if you bring this up it gets handwaved away into "Well actually my position is correct so shut up." Basically the equivalent of a Christian saying "too bad, Jesus is the Son of God, that's it discussion closed." It's a bit infuriating, but I'm working on turning the other cheek.
If this is true, how was it so successful, and how did it survive for so long. Why do the Americas speak English, Spanish, and Portuguese instead of Chinese?
And yes, exactly. Many people try to take a Nietzchean 'Vitalist' tack against Christianity, arguing that it's not good for the flourishing of strong life or whatever. Which my response at this point is just to facepalm and move on, because as you point out here Christianity has built and maintained societies which are so powerful as to make any other belief system look like infants compared to the adults of Western Christendom.
It really does baffle my mind how otherwise intelligent people can seriously look at Christianity and act as if it's a pacifying, weak social force. I suppose narrative really does trump facts much of the time.
The answer I believe is in what we do select for. The trad right does not select for mass appeal, what it selects for is fostering trust and cooperation in dangerous low-trust environments. By extension it has also proven to be particularly prickly and hard to eradicate, because the more dangerous and low-trust the environment the better adapted it is relative to its competition.
Interesting. Personally I've found that I had to reach quite a low place before Christianity appealed to me personally - it felt like I had to be humbled before I could hear God trying to reach me. And I find that's one of the core strengths of Christianity compared to something like Buddhism.
Especially in the modern world, high on our intellectual hubris as we all are, I'd argue that Christianity's case becomes far stronger the more we fall in love with our own intellect and pride. Anyway, a similar theme I suppose.
I appreciate you being openly Christian on this forum. Not even evangelizing, just stating you're a Christian and holding your ground is difficult as you've pointed out. As a recent convert, I'm working on growing my faith but I hope to join you in the trenches down the road. We'll see.
What are some fun activities for male friends to do that are low effort and quick to set up?
I've done some grilling with friends and cooking is nice, but looking for another cheap, more active thing.
I suppose we could hike, though it's cold here right now. Bowling is kind of lame and expensive. Frisbee golf is another option but again, somewhat cold.
Perhaps I'm being too picky, but I wish there was an easy equivalent for men to the 'going shopping' that women seem to default to. They get to walk around and chat in a nice climate controlled environment.
I guess I'm just one more casualty in the culture war :'(
I'm of the opinion that great therapists are few and far between. Like a fraction of a percentage of the ones practicing are going to be confident and have their shit together enough to give you the Peterson style advice you're looking for.
That doesn't necessarily mean you stop looking. But it does require a new lens on therapy. If it's something you want to get something good out of, it's going to be a long slog. You'll need to do research, get referrals from other therapists, and try to find the absolute best ones.
To put it bluntly, I think to be a good therapist you need to be damn near enlightened. And frankly it sounds like you are adjusted well enough, I would say what you need is more spiritual type growth. Take that as you will.
Just finished The Everlasting Man by Chesterton, excellent book. Such beautiful prose.
Now I'm listening to Thinking Orthodox which is a great book on the Orthodox Christian mindset. Also reading The Last Superstition by Edward Feser, a rejection of the New Atheism. I'm.... somewhat impressed by Feser, but he takes the whole Catholic legalism and rules lawyering stereotype waaaay too far. Saying things like you can use Artistotilean logic to unfalsifiably say that homosexuality is evil and bad, same with contraception, etc.
I do find the metaphysical logic of Aristotle quite interesting, but these assertions that natural law theory can have absolutes strike me as hamfisted. Maybe I just don't understand it well enough, I'm sure @DuplexFields could explain better. Or someone.
What does UMC mean?
And why are you fundamentally willing to die over your awkwardness? The reason people died over things like honor is because their entire society for generations and ages formulated these precise moral guidelines and virtues. They weren't randomly picked out of a hat based on one person's life experience.
Interesting, so the potential extinction of the human race doesn't produce an emotional response in you?
The AI race should be modeled as a bunch of scheming sorcerers hissing "Ultimate power must be MINE at all costs!" because everything else is kayfabe.
Hah this one got a good chuckle out of me. 100% agree. Especially once you start to meet some folks deep in the AI crowd within rationalism/EA, you begin to see that all the public talking points are facades. The views and goals these people actually have behind closed doors are far crazier than anything you'd hear in public.
Scheming sorcerers hissing about ultimate power is absolutely the best comparison I've seen so far.
In the circles of younger elites. Idk this is more anecdotal than anything.
This is a pretty narrow take. Christianity has “laid the groundwork” for its own demise at least five times, as Chesterton points out in The Everlasting Man. The idea that Christianity is over was popular way back in antiquity with the Manichaeans, and as recently as the late 19th century with the beginning of modern science. Yet it still survives somehow.
Predicting the doom of a religion and having it actually die, despite being one of the most dominant religions on the planet, are two very different things.
It’s true, although I think you can still make a strong argument that modern Western nations are not Christian in any real sense, and that the East has mostly copied the things that worked from the West rather than find their own unique ways of managing growth.
Then again, I’m skeptical of economic growth and material power as a true measure of goodness or value anyway, so the point is kind of moot imo. At least on moral grounds.
Don’t have time for a long reply at the moment, but I like a lot of your take.
Have you read this book by Ivan Illich? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tools_for_Conviviality
To bring up another post from last week, I'm going to go ahead and repost @justcool393's piece on the Sam Altman/OpenAI/Microsoft situation, since she posted it a few hours ago and right before the last thread went down.
Here's her writing:
Another day, another entrant into the OpenAI drama. Emmett Shear is the new interim CEO of OpenAI.
I don't know why it was surprising to people that Sam wouldn't come back. The company was meant to be subservient to the nonprofit's goals and I'm not sure why the attempted coup from Sam's side (you know the whole effectively false reporting that Sam Altman was to become the new CEO) was apparently "shocking" that it failed.
The OpenAI board has hired Emmett Shear as CEO. He is the former CEO of Twitch.
My understanding is that Sam is in shock.
https://twitter.com/emilychangtv/status/1726468006786859101
What's kinda sad about all of this is how much people were yearning for Sam Altman to be the CEO as if he isn't probably one of the worst possible candidates. Like maybe this is just a bunch of technolibertarians on Twitter or HN or something who think that the ultimate goal of humanity is how many numbers on a screen you can earn, but the amazing amount of unearned reverence towards a VC to lead the company.
In any case, here's to hoping that Laundry Buddy won't win out in the rat race for AGI, lest we live in a world optimized for maximum laundry detergent. Maybe we'll avoid that future now with Sam's departure.
Anyway, I'll leave this to munch on which I found from the HN thread.
Motte: e/acc is just techno-optimism, everyone who is against e/acc must be against building a better future and hate technology
Bailey: e/acc is about building a techno-god, we oppose any attempt to safeguard humanity by regulating AI in any form around and around and around"
https://twitter.com/eshear/status/1683208767054438400
I'm reposting here because I'm convinced, like many other residents, that the ongoing drama of who controls AI development has far reaching implications, likely on the scale of major power geopolitical events. If not ultimately even greater.
To add a bit to the discussion to justify reposting - I think many of these discussions around AI Safety versus Accelerationism are extremely murky because so many people in secular, rationalistic circles are extremely averse to claiming religious belief. It's clear to me that both AI Safety and Accelerationism have strong themes of classical religion, and seem to be two different sects of a religion battling it out over the ultimate ideology. Potentially similar to early Orthodox Christians versus Gnostics.
Alternatively, @2rafa has argued that many of the E/Acc (effective accelerationism) crowd comes from bored technocrats who just want to see something exciting happen. I tend to agree with that argument as well, given how devoid of purpose most of the technocratic social world is. Religion and religious-style movements tend to provide that purpose, but when you are explicitly secular I suppose you have to get your motivation elsewhere.
We've also got the neo-luddites like @ArjinFerman who just hate AI entirely and presumably want us to go back to the mid 90s with the fun decentralized internet. Not sure, I haven't actually discussed with him. I can actually agree with some of the Ludditism, but I'd argue we need to go back to 1920 or so and ban all sorts of propaganda, mass media and advertising.
Anyway, clearly the technological battle for the future of our civilization continues to heat up. The luddites seem out, but may have a surprising last hour comeback. The woke/political left leaning folks seem to be strongly in charge, though the OpenAI scandal points to trouble in the Olympian heights of Silicon Valley AI decision makers.
Will the Grey Tribe use AGI to come back and finally recover the face and ground it has lost to the advancing SJW waves? Who knows. I'm just here for the tea.
I am skeptical that this is the truth.
Yeah I have yet to see a facts-based, evidence filled argument that this disregard for life is the case. Typically there's a more high-level argument about symbols and big ideas going on, which is what I do find compelling.
One of the more interesting and perhaps derivative things Chesterton mentions in The Everlasting Man is that the Ouroborous is a circle, a negation that is always fixed in size (or something) whereas the Cross can be extended infinitely, and posits a battle of two lines going on forever. (presumably Good versus Evil)
While this type of symbology isn't an exact science, I do find it quite thought provoking. There's also something to be said for the typically Buddhist idea that 'Enlightenment' is a concrete stage that can be reached, versus the traditional Christian idea of 'theosis' or the Sisyphean struggle to become like God, while knowing you will never even come close to the ideal.
I agree with you that the 19th century arguments likely haven't told the full story, but I do think there's something to all these religious differences. Unfortunately even having this discussion in most mainstream places nowadays is impossible, because the mere mention of one religion potentially being better than another immediately shuts down the conversation.
You might want to repost this to this week's thread seeing as you posted it right as this thread went down.
Or, if you dont mind, I can just repost it for you?
ETA: Went ahead and did it.
Beautiful theory. Yeah the eschatology within the deep circles of the E/acc movement rarely gets talked about. I think boredom from tech elites is also a huge piece.
There's nothing with stakes for them to do. Geopolitics is low status now. Most other areas where there's lots of power like government, healthcare, politics etc are super slow and bureaucratized. Tech is the new hotness where ambitious bored sons of the elite class get to play with powers beyond their control.
As Chesterton says, Christianity has died at least five times and rose again stronger from the tomb. It's almost as if there's a theme somewhere in the Gospels...
Last week, @ShariaHeap brought up some interesting points on the evolution of religion under the discussion of Bronze Age history that went under-discussed, in my humble opinion.
Specifically they ask:
is it better to think that standards of cooperation that evolved in hunter-gatherer tribes are set early, and understandings around symbols that serve flourishing somewhat timeless, such that most religions have access to them in differing degrees and emphases.
Or, finally, do they each capture something unique, and thus we should seek wisdom through their plurality, essentially operating in a secular mode?
To me, this question can be boiled down to - are all religions equally good, or are some better than others?
Of course we have to get into the 'objective morality versus subjective/post-modern plurality' debate here, which can be it's own morass. But I am curious about how, if you do take religions as potentially better or worse comparatively, how would they stack up?
I've been writing and thinking about an idea that many religions which are popular today are essentially negative when it comes to divine beings - as in, the popular Vitalism that talks about Mother Earth and the interconnectedness of the universe basically deny any explicit 'being' such as God. Typically the ultimate experience of divinity can be revealed in a sort of non-dualistic merging with the universe, or dissolution of the ego.
Buddhism and Hinduism in some strains, as well as Taoism, have heavily influenced this line of mystical thinking.
On the other end you have the more 'positive' versions of religion or mystical experience, that posit the existence of a God or pantheon of gods. While the two can coexist to some degree, like in Hinduism with Brahman etc, they do seem to have very fundamentally different structures at their core.
In his book Orthodoxy, G.K. Chesterton takes a stab at more negative conceptions of the divine, fiercely stating:
The eternity of the material fatalists, the eternity of the eastern pessimists, the eternity of the supercilious theosophists and higher scientists of to-day is, indeed, very well presented by a serpent eating his tail, a degraded animal who destroys even himself.
In this view, the more Eastern or pessimistic or cyclical religions are fundamentally destructive on a larger scale - they argue that nothing means anything, that all will end the same as it began, reality is ultimately an illusion, et cetera.
By contrast, Christianity and other monotheistic religions push us forward to some sort of Progress, which as we have seen... can have its own issues.
I'm curious if this specific topic has been discussed before, and if other folks here have anything to add?
Jung points to this sort of idea in his Answers to Job. I may not be remembering it right, but hopefully a sketch in its direction is that God, in his demonstration of absolute tyranny through Satan shows that He lacks, temporarily, omniscience in all things in that he lacks access to the personal. In contrast Job, as a human, can see in his own suffering the injustice, and perhaps failure of empathy, of God. When God's omniscience at a larger scale reestablishes, this prompts God to incorporate himself in human form through Jesus Christ.
Another perspective on this type of transformation in God that Peterson discusses is the idea that the one thing an omnipotent being such as God would lack, would be limitation. And so the answer to Evil, and the resulting Incarnation in Christ, is a way to provide god with what he lacked - limitation.
This formulation is, of course, a paradox. But to paraphrase Jung, true wisdom always comes from a place of paradox.
ETA: To answer your question, I find the pluralistic idea that all religions are created equal to be almost childishly false. Unless you buy into the idea that there is no true good or evil, that everything is essentially the same morally (a very Eastern, Buddhist, cyclical religious view, I'll add) then it's clear some religions are better than others.
From a more purely psychological/mental side, I would say find a higher-order goal that will help motivate you and give your denial of tasty foods purpose. If you just try to lose weight to lose weight, it will often fail in my experience.
For instance, do you want to lose weight to be a better role model for your children? To find a partner? To become healthier and live longer? To be able to engage in a hobby or other physical activity? Or maybe just to become more successful in your career and/or social life?
Instead of telling yourself 'I want to lose weight' tell yourself 'I want to achieve my higher level goal, losing weight is a step in that process.' This type of hierarchical goal setting will both make the immediate goal of losing weight seem less all encompassing, and also make it easier to remember exactly WHY you're doing it, even when the temptation is strong.

The Happiest Christmas Tree.
I want a Hippopotamus for Christmas.
O Come, O Come Emmanuel.
More options
Context Copy link