@TheDag's banner p

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users  
joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

				

User ID: 616

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users   joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 616

Hmm I should read Chesterton. Still working through Lewis at the moment.

Fair point, the left is horribly censorious, I don’t deny it. As I’ve said to you many times though - why is that the case? Did the left just magically take over these institutions, or was their political worldview more suited towards art and writing?

The point of the discussion, and my favored argument at the moment, is that markets have a use but should not be how we organize all wealth and value as a society. Pointing out critiques of a market system without crying out for the blood of the rich is an important stance from my viewpoint, and one that is sorely missing from the culture war conversation.

Sure. Steve Jobs is an excellent example. Often hailed as a hero of the technocratic class, I’m firmly of the belief that the smartphone is the single most disastrous invention of the last 50 years.

I have never once said we should take rich people's assets, I'm not a Marxist or a redistributionist. However I can understand why so many are eager to paint me with that brush.

I'd simply like to raise awareness that wealth and money do not equal virtue, and in many cases are anti-correlated. Instead of redistributing wealth, I think a better path would be having a conversation about negative externalities of the market and trying to figure out how to price those in.

On top of that, I'd like to see a scaling back of certain areas like religion and the sacred from markets entirely, although I'll admit having both at once would be a difficult challenge.

Hmm, well I'll take this as my daily reminder that we have it better in the U.S. than I'd thought.

It would be difficult to change my mind, this is an implicit perception I've built up over years of trying to find forums and discussions by that outline right wing or conservative values. You have sent me some good Substacks, but I still haven't found a solid argument against why the vast majority of text driven sites like Reddit, or the majority of political best sellers are all left wing.

Then figure out why conversion is asymmetric and figure out strategies to match it. If those don't work, analyze your failures and go back to the drawing board.

Your fatalistic argument of 'no matter what we do we already lost' is tiresome in the extreme.

Well then find some artists and people who are already good at things, and convince them your values are right. They won't magically lose their skills and abilities because they change political views.

The government should and does work to prevent people getting run over by buses. We fight against the arbitrariness of disease and ill health in pretty much every facet, as @self_made_human can attest.

Pretty much all of society in some sense is working towards making things more 'fair,' otherwise we are just in a state of nature with the mighty taking what they will from the rest.

Again, there is nuance to be had here. Many rich people bust their ass and absolutely deserve the wealth that they have generated, from a cosmic sense. Then again, I tend to think that the way our society is set up is so rotten to its core that even the most 'beneficial' wealth generation will have tons of negative aspects. The most common of which is to destroy human connection, religion, generally the things which make life worth living.

It really depends on how you view the overarching modern capitalist societal structure. I'm not a Marxist by any means, and I think market economies are an incredible tool. But at this point they have ceased being a tool and become our master, for all intents and purposes.

Then it's time to do the hard work of creating an alternative set of schools, critics, museums, etc that have different values, if those values are what you care about.

It is a scary thought, but man that would be a hilarious sci-fi dystopian scenario. Become part of a black alphabet agency where your one and only job is to assassinate high net-worth billionaires to help fund the back breaking amount of debt the USA has taken on.

If you're a billionaire, you have to have a 24/7 bodyguard and gain practical, tactical skills yourself or risk being taken out by the government. I wonder if this has already been done...?

The entire art world, root and branch, all the institutions and nearly all the artists, is left wing. There's nothing on the right to subsidize.

What makes you say this? There are plenty of artists out there that aren't leftist, they just aren't as well known. The show 'The Leftovers' had a very distinct religious/right wing bent, as has been discussed here.

There are excellent right-wing writers on Substack, like N.S. Lyons, among many many others. There are beautiful depictions of angels from a relatively classical stance (although I don't know the particular political views) like the Angelarium.

This sort of blatant and knee-jerk negativity is foolish and defeatist. It's a major reason why your values continue to lose. Conservatives of the past fought evil regimes when their children would be beheaded as a consequence, you can't bother yourself to fight against leftist art?

Excellent comment, can't agree more. It's a shame that right-wing and conservative values often disparage art as useless or impractical.

Part of the issue to my mind is that historically conservatives have highly valued oration. Older cultures were entirely oral, and most grand Western stories that conservatives love have classically been told orally and repeated generation after generation. There's something about the format of the spoken word that lends itself to these repetitive stories that slowly change the shallow pieces, but keep the deep structure the same.

I see this tendency cropping up even now. I discussed with @ArjinFerman earlier this week about how the majority of right wing discussion that is shared or held up as quality tends to be videos and podcasts. While I'm sure that many of these pieces and discussions are excellent, the information is far slower to absorb, and harder to spread. When you have simple images or the written word, these forms can be consumed and spread much more quickly than spoken alternatives.

Unfortunately, the right wing 'base' seems to denigrate the written word more than ever. Even one of the leading lights of the intellectual right, Richard Hanania, has outright said books are a waste of time. It's a tragic state of affairs, and I appreciate you putting forth the argument so eloquently.

I don’t know if it’s just me but I would be interested in more original / creative ideasmithing related to culture, even if that’s not an original intended purpose of the forum.

Amen! Too much negativity and snark, too little creativity and true seeking of understanding when it comes to Culture.

If you assume that 'becoming rich' automatically equals benefitting society and that there is no possible way to become rich while being a net negative on our world, then sure it's fair. Unfortunately our world is not set up that way.

It's partially the gut feeling of rich scions getting to coast on unearned wealth. Underlying that is the fact, to my mind, that most of the rich do not actually benefit society. Our market is far from perfect in that way. Many make their fortunes off the backs of others, or by dumping horrid amounts of negative externality into the rest of society, simply because the externalities cannot easily be quantified.

I have no issue with people retiring after truly contributing to society. That being said, the market economy we have set up absolutely does not reward virtue or truly giving back to society. In many cases I think that most of the rich nowadays make their fortunes by dumping massive negative externalities on the rest of society.

That is one aspect of why it is unjust.

Fairness is an individual having to put into society before taking out and enjoying themselves. At least until we have a state of affairs where that can be an individual choice.

It's unfair that a rich scion can simply coast off the work of others and never have to struggle or put in, while the vast majority strain and buckle under their responsibilities.

Unless the financial managerial class all gets together and decides to create an asset bubble through legal and financial trickery, so they never have to pay the piper. Which is essentially what has been happening the last couple decades.

As I mentioned in my post, it depends heavily on the temperament of the person in question. Personally I cannot understand the perspective of someone who is okay with working meaningless jobs when the world is so beautiful and has so much to spend your time on.

I'm playing through the original mass effect trilogy, about a third of the way through the first one. It's an amazing game so far.

No sir it is not BurdensomeCount's post. In fact it is the great risen @BurdensomeCountTheWhite's post.

Wait somehow tagging the OG profile makes it into the new one. Weird.

Do you feel that it's just viscerally unfair that some people need to work and some people don't?

How could you deny that this is viscerally unfair? Seems the most blatant example ever. Not that we know how to fix the problem, but damn it's unfair as hell.