@TheDag's banner p

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users  
joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

				

User ID: 616

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users   joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 616

I know that my solution (radical wealth redistribution, red-black shit at large, etc and so forth) isn't popular here; but even conservatives have got to recognize there is a problem.

Can you elaborate on this a bit? Haven't seen your full take.

Overall, I feel you man. Working a paycheck job that you don't find fulfilling is awful. For certain personality types like myself, it is downright torturous. And I don't say that lightly.

It's sad that so many people, especially on the right, cannot understand this basic fact. I completely agree that there is dignity in working for something meaningful, and gaining discipline and teaching yourself to do things you don't enjoy in the short term for long term gain is a crucial skill. Yet all of that can be true, while still saying that the modern model of a 9-5 job that is most likely utterly meaningless to the employee is one of the most broken and evil systems man has ever created. Yes it doesn't have the outright violence and evils of the past, but it's far more insidious in how justifiable it is, and how it slowly breaks people's spirits over time.

As to fixing it... well, who the fuck knows? I like to think if we genuinely build good AI and robots, hopefully we can automate away much of the work. Unfortunately the trend seems to be that as we get better tech to theoretically make our lives easier and better, instead we just end up demanding more stuff from ourselves and each other, then burning out.

I think the only realistic solution I can see would be some combination of a better understanding of how early childhood trauma impacts people's ability to do useful work, and gene therapy. Then we slowly get everyone regardless of race or family wealth on a close to level playing field, and we can have a true meritocracy. The people who don't want to work can pursue art or whatever the hell, and the people who do want to work can own starships and planets and have galactic empires. That's the dream, at least.

No, but then again most transhumanists don't nakedly call for violence. The framework of accerlerationism I am familiar with pretty blatantly calls for civil war, and increasing the time frame of that happening.

As a young person I have little to no expectation of receiving social security money.

Yeah, this is the most brutal part. Seeing such a huge chunk of every paycheck taken, knowing that you'll never see a cent of it again even though the justification is that you're 'saving for your own retirement.' What a huge disaster, sigh.

Why does no one mention the unthinkable? I.e - No government funded pension at all?

I know, I know, straight up impossible. Free money is just too strong of a drug, and once you've had it, nothing short of rebuilding civilization from scratch can make a people get used to the idea of not having it.

Because free money creates extremely strong voting blocs. This is a general problem with democracy, at least democracy with short-sighted voters by and large.

Yep this hits the nail on the head, in my view. Christians will tend to argue otherwise but Jesus did very explicitly argue for a sort of Saturnalian reversal quite often. The last shall be first, and all that.

I'm sure there are reasons why Christianity is more nuanced than Marxism, but they do have similar themes. Capitalists could easily be this wicked and corrupt generation.

By their fruits you will know them. Was Jesus a consequentialist? Hmm...

Wow, you're a lucky man. Either that, socially oblivious, or extremely risk tolerant. Congratulations, I suppose.

IMO any 'accelerationist' position is ultimately calling for violence.

Man, the olden times really did used to be different.

Obligatory not a lawyer, but yeah I'd say your concerns are fair. I've heard a lot of lawyers and other people I respect say not to go to law school unless you have a really strong GPA, go to a top school, and have the connections to get into Big Law.

Thank you for the links! Yeah I probably should've specified text - although in my head when I said 'intellectual discussion' that typically means text. Definitely a foolish heuristic.

Ahh, yeah I can't be bothered to wade through that sort of dross. It destroys the human spirit.

Woosh cool my bad.

Agh, yeah maybe that's my issue. High quality right wing content is almost always suggested in video or podcast form and I just... don't enjoy those mediums. I bet there's a reason why the right has such a strong disdain for the written word, at least in a more intellectual sense.

I try not to judge but I genuinely do think that podcasts and videos tend to pander far more to the lowest common denominator, and select for poorly thought out on-the-fly arguments.

common values and the strength of institutions

Eh honestly I don't know if it's an instrumental reason I can clearly articulate. I certainly don't have strong faith in our institutions. More that I just feel it's wrong to call for violence and to not see the potential for good in humanity.

Honestly I prefer your darkly hinting, I think you're quite good at it. I can sympathize with you though, it is difficult to figure out where to draw the line.

Fancy! Latin dances are always fun.

I started with the ballroom 10 dance in college so I've done mambo, cha-cha, rumba, jive as well as the fancier tango foxtrot waltz etc. I actually did salsa dancing a bit in college, but it was a bit tough to break into the social crowd for me sadly.

For social dancing I started mostly with east coast swing/blues and fusion. Sadly the pandemic killed those scenes in my area, but have been doing a lot of west coast swing. Dipping my toes into zouk since it's getting pretty popular.

He doesn't have friends in the right places

Really? He has the most viewed TED Talk of all time and has a ton of friends in high places, like Elon Musk and the All-in podcast folks, just to name a couple. Urban is orders of magnitude more well connected than Hanania, and has been at it for almost a decade.

OMG another dancer! Amazing! Which styles do you dance?

Met at a partner dance event. Danced a few times, had mutual friends. Bonded over both being new to the dance relative to said friends.

So to summarize your point, you think that the right wing should be more intolerant of Progressive virtues. I agree. But could you highlight what that looks like exactly?

The problem is it feels like conservatives are stuck between a rock and a hard place in some ways. How does the right fight against the left without escalating? I agree that breaking political norms and pushing populist extremism and violence is a terrible idea.

So does the right start cancelling people? Trying to capture institutions the way the left has been doing for decades?

I mean this unironically - can you please link a right wing space that has intellectual discourse? This is the first and only place online I've found.

EDIT: also with regards to white identitarianism, fair point. I suppose I should say that I think white identitarianism is foolish because without Christians the right has practically no real cultural or political power. Not to mention consistency.

Interesting. The idea of paying for exercise videos with so much free content out there is almost anathema to me... but I do respect your opinion on fitness. I'll browse what samples they have.

Ty for the link! I've been grasping towards a similar theory myself, exciting to see it laid out so clearly over 60 years ago. Medicalism and Safetyism, to me, are the hidden levers by which the progressive movement has gained so much power. Especially when it comes to pushing rhetoric in one on one, informal conversations. It's extremely difficult to argue with someone who is convinced that you are mentally ill for your stated positions.

Kind of like those shows where a healthy person is put in a mental institution. No matter what you say, it doesn't matter. You're stuck in the category with no way out.

Americans cannot fathom this, because it's extremely silly, and nobody would ever have to make an American radio station play The Eagles - Americans come with patriotism pre-installed.

Hah, American patriotism is actually at an all-time low from what I've read. Then again, most of the world culture is basically just recycled American culture so we don't need to worry. It's good to be on top.

Trying to get the right in this direction is going to be more successful than trying to have a right that purity spirals and accepts the exact way of thinking of the more edgy, hardcore rightist types.

Yeah, unfortunately many commenters here seem to think that there is no hope for the modern right to ever gain ground back without going full defection, all out aggression against progressivism. Salting the earth and all that. While I do understand the impulse given that progressives have been playing that game for a while, I think it makes the already incoherent right-wing position even worse.

If the standard conservative position in the U.S. is to promote Christian ideology with the core virtues of hope, faith, and love, how can this naked war-mongering really fit into it? White identitarianism? Come on. The religion that many right-wingers profess to be defending is the origin point of the progressive ideology in the first place. I'd like to see the right promote more intellectualism within right wing spaces, the failure to do which I think has lead to many of the defeats today. Instead many just want to double down on populist aggression tactics.