@TheDag's banner p

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users  
joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

				

User ID: 616

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users   joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 616

I actually like this plan, my only worry is that way too many people would do this! Perhaps we can pull it off in another 10-20 years.

Except stupid, untalented people in developed countries do have a minimum standard of living, unless they just make cartoonishly terrible decisions.

Replace 'cartoonishly terrible decisions' with 'decisions they are manipulated into' like spending their money on fast food, building credit card debt, financing cars at ruinous interest rates, and you quickly see how it's quite difficult for these people to handle themselves in the modern economy.

You may say 'oh well those are stupid decisions they deserve it,' but the fact of the matter is that they are being manipulated into these bad decisions by much more intelligent people. We cannot expect them to have the intelligence or discipline to ward it off. Basically predatory high-IQ businesses that fuck over poor people are extracting rents and creating huge negative externalities for the rest of society through their business models.

Yeah I agree with @TowardsPanna, there’s a lot of stuff with chronic tension/muscular pain we just don’t understand at all.

Some people say it’s emotions, some people say there are trigger points, there are literally a million explanations. Painscience.org is a good starting place if you’re curious.

Basically chronic pain and tension usually aren’t a purely mechanical phenomenon, and treating them as such won’t get you far.

My question is why wasn’t this leaked earlier?

A bit of a tangent, but I'd like to point out this is an excellent example of a real conspiracy that wasn't leaked. So many people on here act like conspiracies are impossible because someone will leak it - clearly not!

This is actually an excellent point I hadn’t thought of before, and maybe explains why Christianity tends to go back and forth in waves every now and then. Almost like a course correct.

I'll reconcile it eventually. Meanwhile I'm comforted by Christians of the past who were dedicated to raising our fallen world into a Heaven of its own.

I don’t want to do all of the excruciatingly hard work of deprogramming myself of all of the depravity and dysfunctionality and temptations I’ve accrued as a result of growing up in this society; I just want to go back in time and make it so I never got exposed to it in the first place. I fully cop to how fundamentally whiny it all seems. It even seems that way to me.

Traditionally I think the reward is your eternal soul going to heaven. You can still believe that, although it is more difficult nowadays I'd imagine.

My reasons boil down to the fact that I think violence is wrong, and I believe in the Christian ideal of suppressing our urge for violence. Fighting for a future where humanity can be something better.

I think this is the key piece:

If the monastic option is going to make a real return in our culture, it will have to be undergirded by a genuine status infrastructure undergirding it. Such men must not be seen as losers and washouts, crawling in shame away from a life of failure and grasping tightly a pathetic consolation prize.

The problem is monks are seen as weirdos and have little to no status - if young men today try to become monks their family and friends and everyone they know are more likely to mock them than support their aim.

What about my funkopops?

I'm on The Screwtape Letters by Lewis, and just started Violence Unveiled by Gil Bailie.

The latter is so far a staggeringly impressive work - perhaps the most important book I've ever read if it continues to impress as it has in the first third. It's an in-depth discussion of the Girardian scapegoating mechanism, how the passion of Christ turned that mechanism on it's head, and how many of our modern problems boil down to the inability to differentiate between scared violence and profane violence.

It does seem pretty fun, but you have to tolerate some real weird shit man. Real weird.

How many years of manual labor do you need to buy a dwelling for you and your family? How much free time do you have per day? Per year? How much control do other humans have on the way you live your daily life? How many hours do you have away from anybody? How much do you pay in taxes? Can you be conscripted in an army against your will?

How many times have you had to fight for your life against an angry mob? A wild animal?

How many times have you had to face starvation, or thirst, or truly look the spectre of death in the face?

When in your life have you had to sit back while a corrupt noble comes in and rapes your wife and daughter?

You are so deluded it would be comical if your ideologies weren't so dangerous.

Well at least you're honest. If you want to go back to an apocalyptic world of brutal violence, Girardian scapegoating, and evil then you're welcome to it I suppose. You and the rest who follow you into hell will reap what you sow. I'd argue that you have no idea what you're in for, but given the fact that you despise me, I doubt you'll listen.

I just hope those of us against that dark vision can stop you before you and your cohort destroy the world.

Yes.

Remember that humans couldn't fly for millenia. Remember that space was a celestial sphere thought unbreachable. Remember that sickness was seen as the devil's work.

The march of technology renders these claims pointless. We will solve aging if given enough time, and if we keep on the right track.

Well yeah current older folks are dead. With the advance of the pace of science I see coming with AI and other advances though, I'm optimistic that anyone younger than say, 45 or 50 today, may be able to live a lot longer than people can right now.

Remember that it used to be almost impossible to survive things that are routine to cure nowadays. Medicine inexorably advances, and if we techno-optimists are right about the potential of AI that advance will be swift indeed.

Thank you for articulating the argument about this 'everything is about sex and status' take that is so popular on here. I've been trying to say something similar but I think you nailed it - it's totally tautological and impossible to disprove.

Reported for quality contribution!

What are some of the values that are contentious here?

Funnily enough I got my therapist into slate star codex, and will often give him ‘homework’ of reading an article I find helps describe part of my thinking.

Good therapists are hard to find but certainly worth it imo.

I’ll totally join the Motte resistance.

We’re already ‘owned in effect’ my friend. Humans have never been free and never will be, in the literal sense. We need society and others not to go completely batshit.

Brain in a jar? Well it’ll be a little weird but hell if I get to extend my natural lifespan a few hundred years, I’d imagine I might get bored with a normal human body anyway.

I don’t deny that we could end up with a horrible future. It’s certainly possible. But I think better futures are possible and more likely. I also think that pessimistic, doomer takes actively push against that good future.

Well I’m one of participants that was in that discussion, so I can confidently say yes, learning about rationality (specifically ‘rationalism’ online) has caused me quite a few strong emotions.

Sign me up for the 17th century coffeehouse and salon revival please. That sounds dope. We can even add adderall and cocaine this time.

You wouldn’t save a drowning child if you were walking by one?