@TheDag's banner p

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users  
joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

				

User ID: 616

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users   joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 616

But these aren't really 'options', they're destinies. There's no declining one of these paths.

I mean, I strongly disagree. I think the most likely path is that the current elite (or the elite of the next generation) will create life extension technology and effectively rule forever, at least under your worldivew.

I'd like to see a humanity that moves forward and values things more than just base reproduction. I'd like to see us value knowledge, and understanding, and frankly love. Even if it contradicts some of the transhumanist futures some other users believe in.

Demographics are not destiny, and never have been. Memes are destiny, and you'd better start acting like that's the case, or you'll be outcompeted.

So you're proposing we worship the individual over the collective?

If there is no god, and we replaced him, there is no cleansing anything. We're in charge. We are so terribly free.

The point of god is to be the final judge of man, to decide between life and death. Women are life, men are death.

Yes Nietschze argues that, I don't. We aren't in charge. The reason we can even exist with billions of men competing in a similar status hierarchy without killing each other is due to religion. Sure, we killed the outright belief in God, but the very nature of God means that He can never be truly killed.

The point of God is to be the final judge of humans. He decides between life and death. He is the bridge between the red society we inhabit, and the beautiful future society we can become. He's never truly dead unless we give up on the hope that the future can be better than the present.

If that’s the case, why can’t we create secular ideologies that function as well as religions created thousands of years ago?

But most of the things that you say they're central to, such as rebellions, schools, and marriage all existed before and after any given religion and, I claim, mostly don't depend on the details of religious texts.

Really? I would argue that religion is the central piece that made things like rebellions, schools and marriages even possible. Sure you can take a purely materialist view and say they exist separately, but how did we humans manage to rise out of prehistory to even create a functioning society? How did we get along without killing each other? Where did the idea of marriage, or the idea of teaching your descendants important truths, or the idea that a sovereign is beholden to a higher power, even come from?

All of these things have their roots in religion.

It also provided a route to riches and fame for the lucky few. It's one of those high-risk high-reward strategies that down on their luck men have always gravitated towards throughout history. And honestly, it's a great trade for both society and those men, since they typically don't have much to offer otherwise.

Nowadays the only real high-risk high-reward strategy for ambitious men is to try and found a company, but that selects for such high IQ and conscientiousness that it's not a real strategy for any but the top percentage of the distribution.

Do these emotional states just appear from nothing? I'd argue that they become happier because they find some other belief system above and beyond rationality that helps them integrate their psyche.

Rationality alone is cold comfort.

I'm surprised to find I agree with you. Society has become feminized in the extreme, to the point where even institutions that have been male-only for hundreds of years are bowing under the pressure.

The most pernicious thing about this feminization is that it's so far outside the Overton window to even talk in these terms, that most masculine projects and fraternal organizations are dead on arrival. Any mainstream politician talking about helping men, like the Obama example above, gets eviscerated by the feminist movement immediately.

I know it's passe to bring up social media all the time, but I also think it's an excellent example of how so much of our energy is spent in the social realm, traditionally dominated by women, rather than the masculine realm of conquering nature. Imagine what we could've accomplished if we could capture all the capital, labor, and ingenuity that went into social media and shift it into something like materials science, or space exploration, or energy infrastructure, or artificial intelligence, or any other field that has a more direct impact on the world.

Anyway, I agree that society will have to learn to accept and work for men, or we are in for dark times ahead.

Join a gang and there is a risk of death and prison but also a chance of meeting hot women.

You can meet hot women by getting a decent job and going to bars. The allure of gangs is a brotherhood, fighting alongside men who will die to protect you, and vice versa. Even if the gangster life is often brutal, it's a far more real type of connection and community than the mainstream modern world offers.

Nothing to see here--it's all part of nature. Understand how it works, make sure you're not the mouse/fly/blueberry, and move on happily with your own life.

This ideology may work decently for you individually, although I think it takes a heroic individual to truly accept that brutal state of affairs.

Over time though, and on a societal level, this type of thinking will inevitably descend back into the might-makes-right, strong eat the weak world that we rose from. During the Axial revolution back around the time of Socrates, men realized that they could make themselves better. That there was a different way to live than simply accepting Nature as red in tooth and claw - we could master nature. But more importantly, we could master ourselves.

All the beauty and ease your life is filled with has been delivered to you from generations of your ancestors that rejected this naturalistic worldview in order to build a better future for their descendants. You can spit on their sacrifices and just focus on getting yours, man, but I reject your worldview as fundamentally selfish, and wrong.

It’s not like (99% of) premoderns were sitting around philosophizing about Faith and transcendental values.

Here's where I disagree. If you read history, you'll find that religion was extremely central to premoderns' conceptions of the world. I agree that industrial society is what did it in, and in some cases it was very dramatic. Take the worldview described in The Pervasive World-View: Religion in Pre-Modern Britain:

The medieval period is generally regarded as one of outstanding achieve- ment in the history of religion. It is looked upon as an age of universal faith, when western Christendom flourished, secure in its beliefs and united under the authority of the supra-national papacy. An age in which long strides were taken in the outward organisation of the Church into provinces, dioceses, and parishes; one which raised awe-inspiring cathedrals, monasteries and many parish churches, still surviving among us as monuments to the beliefs and aspirations of medieval men and women.

An age which witnessed the creation of an ordered body of Canon Law and its general acceptance and enforcement; and which saw the construction of a superb intellectual synthesis combining the testi- mony of faith and reason and the enthronement of theology as the queen of all knowledge. An age when the Church dominated the content and conduct of education in the universities, grammar schools and other institutions. An age which looked to the Church as the creatrix and nurse of the crowning achievements of art and civilization.

Religion is often also the centerpiece of rebellions:

Furthermore, we can note that religion was sufficiently important to the common people not only to be supported implicitly by their acceptance of the conventions of the church but also to figure in a variety of ways in their periodic rebellions against the established order. Most uprisings of the six- teenth and seventeenth centuries had at their core grievances over changes in the organization of agriculture but many also included ele- ments of religious dissent

For an idea of what people thought about religion and superstition day to day:

In showing the extent to which pre-Christian super- stitions and magical practices continued alongside orthodox Christianity, Thomas amply illustrates the importance of those superstitions. Church officials may have despaired at the perversions of their teachings peddled by the laity but for the secularization thesis what matters is that superstition was widespread and effective. Horoscopes were read, not just as 'a bit of fun' but as a serious guide to social action. Spells were cast to ward off dangers. Amulets were worn as protection against ailments. Holy relics were venerated and used as sources of magical powers. Belief in the Devil was strong and widespread, as was the corresponding belief that the church had the power to protect against evil: 'People wanted their houses blessed, their fields blessed, their food blessed, their weapons blessed...

I hope this shows that even right in pre-modernity, during the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. Religious worldviews and superstition were still going quite strong. We could expect that before the change of the industrial revolution these religious views were even more closely held.


To you point about mate selection:

When Jane doesn’t have to choose between starvation and prostitution on the one hand and marrying John on the other, she’s not going to marry John.

I get so tired of evolutionary psychologists reducing everything to who gets to mate with whom. Clearly humans have a lot more going on than just trying to get their rocks off, and while the evo psych mating lens can be useful, it is not something which can explain away the whole of human experience.

Do you truly believe you can reduce the tens of thousands of years humans have spent contemplating God, building great works, fighting massive wars, and the general whole of human experience down to someone's sexual market value? If so, I think the inferential distance between us may be too far to easily bridge.

I think the solution is to consciously develop a new non-theistic Religion that doesn't rely on superstition or demand belief in miracles.

This is certainly a solution, but the massive failures, predicted by Nietszche actually, tend to end in massive waves of blood drenching the world. It's happened twice already, and I think most modern leaders are understandable highly cautious when it comes to any sort of 'non-theistic Religion.'

Adherence to this religion should sacralize civilizational achievement, the Faustian spirit, and social conventions that steer society in a eugenic direction.

I think you're misunderstanding one of the main draws of religion for those you deem have high religiosity. Religion and true Gods are supposed to give us something to map onto concepts that are difficult for humans to wrap their minds around. A worthy God (or pantheon) must embody concepts like bargaining with the future, cleansing the people of sin, helping people work together, and as you say steer people towards good values. (or a eugenic direction in your desacralized wording.)

These processes tend to develop over the aeons as a process of cultural evolution, and I'm highly doubtful that we can just manufacture that type of religion by brute forcing it with a scientific mindset. Similar to how brute forcing government has tended to go quite poorly.

Recently I'm leaning more towards the idea of broadening our understanding of truth and fact. Right now your main contention is that religion 'demands belief in miracles.' What if we could separate our understanding of religion from science, and see it through an experiential lense.

For instance, even if miracles don't exist in an objective, empirical sense, they do absolutely exist in an experiential sense. People can touch the divine, and with psychedelics and/or religious ritual we can produce that feeling of a miracle reliably. Just because the phenomenon is taking place inside someone's conscious experience doesn't make it less real than something happening in the material world.

In a way consciousness comes before the material world, because without consciousness how would any of our concepts of time, space, size, or structure even exist? There would be no reason to have any of these concepts, the universe would just be billiard balls of different sizes bouncing around endlessly with no rhyme or reason.

Ahh yes thank you, here is the correct quote:

by providing for their families and broader society, by protecting their tribe and others, and by successfully procreating.

I've edited the post to reflect the change.

Unfortunately it looks like GPT-4's decreasing capability strikes again. I use it to help rewrite and catch grammatical errors etc. It used to leave quotes alone, but looks like now it is arbitrarily editing them.

I am excited for when we work out the kinks in RLHF and can get these tools to work like GPT-4 did when it first came out!

With the release of the recent Barbie movie, the old gender debates on the internet have been reignited. (Admittedly, I haven't watched it yet, might pen down my thoughts once I do.)

I recently encountered another article by a heterosexual, middle-class woman discussing how we can assist young men in discovering their masculinity. The piece, confidently titled map out of the wilderness, repeats the narrative tropes that countless similar works in journalism tend to focus on.

Does it argue that men are disoriented because women are no longer subservient? Indeed. Does it accuse men of falling for 'destructive' ideologues such as Jordan Peterson and Bronze Age Pervert whose political ideologies aren't personally favored? Yes. Does it claim men are discontent because women wish for them to behave more femininely? Absolutely. Does it state there's a lack of 'positive masculinity?' Oh, for sure.

To credit the writer, Christine Emba, she does highlight some of the more sinister issues that venture slightly beyond the bounds of conventional discourse. She openly criticizes feminists and women in general for refusing to assist men, citing an instance where Obama was chastised for attempting to help boys, and thousands of women denounced him in protest.

What prompted me to respond to this article was a moment of blatant self-awareness by the author, who admits when reproached by a man that she doesn't want to be intimate with men who heed her advice (emphasis mine):

Where I think this conversation has come off the tracks is where being a man is essentially trying to ignore all masculinity and act more like a woman. And even some women who say that — they don’t want to have sex with those guys. They may believe they’re right, and think it’s a good narrative, but they don’t want to partner with them.

I, a heterosexual woman, cringed in recognition.

Yes, dear writer, you recoiled in acknowledgment. If you, a talking head opining on this topic, felt this way, consider the reaction of those numerous women with lesser self-awareness when they encounter these feeble, effeminate men.

However, all the discussions around gender roles, sexual relations, power dynamics, and 'incels' are missing the real issue. They're distractions, veils obscuring the core problem.



At the risk of being cliche, I'll reference Nietzsche's most well-known line:

God remains dead. And we have killed him. How shall we, murderers of all murderers, console ourselves? That which was the holiest and mightiest of all that the world has yet possessed has bled to death under our knives. Who will wipe this blood off us? With what water could we purify ourselves? What festivals of atonement, what sacred games shall we need to invent? Is not the greatness of this deed too great for us? Must we not ourselves become gods simply to be worthy of it? There has never been a greater deed; and whosoever shall be born after us - for the sake of this deed he shall be part of a higher history than all history hitherto.

Why has this single paragraph echoed throughout recent centuries as one of the deepest and most frequently reiterated explanations of modernity's moral crisis? Obviously, Nietzsche, a self-proclaimed atheist, doesn't imply we've executed deicide in the literal sense. What we've done is obliterated any transcendent reason for existence. There is no apparent reason why young men should exhibit concern for their neighbors, work towards self-improvement, curtail their desires, or even make an effort to contribute to society.

For a young man in a contemporary world that is entirely individual-centric, what is the appeal of any altruistic act?

Regardless of the religion you choose, these systems provided us with a motive beyond primal, materialistic pleasures to care. They provided us with an aim to pursue. Most importantly, they offered us a social framework within which we could strive collectively with others and receive commendation for our benevolent deeds.

Nietzsche's suggested solution is that the New Men must 'become deities' to be worthy of God's murder. Regrettably, as we've found out, not everyone can ascend to godhood. Certainly some of the highest status and highest agency men can create their own values, but what about the rest of us?

How is a young man in his twenties, armed with a useless college degree and forced to work at a supermarket to get by, supposed to find purpose in what he's doing? How can he feel accomplished, or masculine, or empowered? He definitely can't rely on God or religion for that feeling. If he tries, he'll be overwhelmed by relentless mockery and cynicism from his society.



Returning to Ms. Emba's proposed solution, she states that men need to experience masculinity by:

by providing for their families and broader society, by protecting their tribe and others, and by successfully procreating.

This, she asserts, is 'Constructive Masculinity.' Let's look past the glaring issue that it's a woman attempting to define what masculinity should be - the question remains: why?

Without some larger mission, most men aren't going to be motivated whatsoever. Men need a reason to exist. And not a poor, weak reason like 'following your dreams' or 'getting money' or 'being a good person.' Men need something to strive for, something worth dying for, something that they can use to shield themselves from the terror of the void.

Of course this problem is applicable to far more people than just young Western males. This lack of meaning, lack of purpose, is at the core of modernity's societal problems. It waits like a tiger in the shadows, seizing us in our moments and weakness and pulling us into a black pit of despair, nihilism. Emptiness.

When you're on your deathbed, where will you look for comfort? What force or being or god will let you face your own death without flinching? What water will purify you?

How will you cleanse your hands of blood?

I think that what we should really get rid of is mandatory education. It is a day care program dishonestly masquerading as an educational system and it packs kids into close contact with each other right at the age at which most of them behave more like chimpanzees than at any point before or after in their lives. To force this on people is fundamentally abusive. School also trains kids that what they should expect from life is to be closely observed and trained by bureaucrats. And in the age of the Internet, school is also near-irrelevant as a source of learning when it comes to anything above very basic math and reading skills.

Tear down the mandatory education system.

Beautifully said! The mandatory education system is, along with factory farming, one of the most horrible moral abuses of our day. It's incredible how ordinary people just paper over the horror that kids must deal with, and think throwing more money at the problem will solve it.

Tear. It. Down!

Books are free if you have internet and know where to look.

I would add the pretty major caveat that you have to be okay with stealing them. I mean don't get me wrong, I have pirated thousands of books in my life, but let's call a spade a spade.

This is one of the most foolish takes I've seen in the Motte. Libraries are not obsolete - in fact they are more important than ever in my view. The primary goal of a library was never to actually educate the masses, it was to give bright young kids from poor backgrounds and opportunity to learn.

The goal is to let intelligent autodidacts teach themselves and make something of themselves in a way they couldn't without a library. It's also one of the few true community spaces we have left in the Western world. For shame.

Also all of these series are completed as well! I saw that the Sun Eater Sequence above is unfinished. That's always a pet peeve of mine when looking for recommendations.

Oh and if you do read The Second Apocalypse, please let me know what you think of my boy Kellhus.

Aren't you happy we have this place? :)

You can in America.

Yep you hit the nail on the head. These 'rationalist' circles are driven by extremely strong conformity bias and group think, since they all hang out with each other, live together, date each other, and go to their own special in-group events that are funded by billionaires.

It really does have a lot of aspects of a cult.

Yeah, no thank you. I'm not exactly a rightist in the way you're describing, like BAP style, but I do have complaints with modern liberalism.

I actually think that you're off base with the aesthetics argument. The most common (and compelling) argument I see here on the side of the right is that modern liberalism has a lot of benefits, but has destroyed something that allows people to self-actualize, and grow into better, more integrated people. Whether that is the disruption social fabric, a lack of any sense of responsibility, the loss of religion, or just the general dispelling of illusion via the scientific method, is hard to say. But it's inarguable that something has been lost, something deep that helps give people meaning and purpose.

If you define beauty more generally, I can see where you're coming from. The beauty of seeing someone exhibit courage, or transform from a child to an adult. The beauty of seeing a group of your close friends and family, of feeling supported when you're down. This type of purely sensual, aesthetic beauty is weak by comparison.

When it comes to the issues with modernity I could care less about the aesthetics, I care about the people it harms.

Sorry to hear that man! Glad you're okay. But yeah, doesn't sound fun.

For some less known series that are still excellent, I'd recommend The Dagger and the Coin, and The Long Price Quartet.

Other good fantasy series in no particular order:

  • Chronicles of the Black Gate
  • The Weavers of Saramyr
  • Ash and Sand
  • The Craft Sequence
  • Divine Cities
  • Prince of Thorns
  • Magicians by Feist
  • The Night Angel Trilogy

If you're really looking to sink your teeth into an epic universe, go for Malazan Book of the Fallen, or The Traitor Son Cycle for a slightly less dense but similar style series. Lightbringer is also pretty epic in scope and length. The Second Apocalypse if you're really into dense worldbuilding and want to be sad.

Great details here, and I agree that the plan sounds great on the surface level, but execution is always the difficult part.

I'm impressed that Modi has managed to gain enough power to take away government sinecures and weather the inevitable backlash. Taking away the toys and spoils of the populace is always one of the hardest things to do in a democracy.