@TheDag's banner p

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users  
joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

				

User ID: 616

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users   joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 616

Perhaps this is a mistake with our current economic regime? I’d argue that due to economic complexity the average citizen should be more aware of who owns the product or service they’re consuming, rather than less.

Hell, I’d vote for a law that forced companies to display their owner if they do get acquired.

I loved how if you cite a legal statue a lot of its woke programming will go away. Credit @Snakes once again.

It’s a shame cults get such a bad rap nowadays. They’re the traditional way to make yourself transform into your ideal. Unfortunately a few pederasts + our intolerance for any risks have ruined the model entirely.

Some value their health more than others. Catching illnesses early in the present world could be the difference between immortality and early death. I don’t blame him!

Eh, I cut it out for brevity but I see where you’re coming from. Either way I see you slicing the populace into such a chunk as to be making a ridiculously callous and egotistical statement.

I’m happy to discuss further which chunk of humanity deserves to have their lives be destroyed and suffer unnecessarily, but I generally find that type of rhetoric to be unsavory. I apologize if I mischaracterized your stance.

Me

I disagree. You can be rational when the situation calls for it, and be religious on a meta level.

I would drop doctors as well but I’m trying to model the modal human. Maybe I’m failing but I think people here are far into an intelligence/tech literate bubble.

I agree with you, for what it’s worth.

I saw in the main thread that someone is blocking me. I feel bittersweet - on the one hand I don't want people to have to block me. On the other, maybe it means I'm gaining notoriety around here.

Anyone else have a similar experience?

Nah I think they've been nerd sniped by AI safety, that's the failure mode. They're still attached to the goal of saving the world they've just failed at rationality, and chosen the wrong means.

Trans humanists aren’t Machiavellian enough. They need to throw away all their other principles and mouth whatever BS the zeitgeist wants to get their research done.

furiously takes notes

@firmamenti also engaged in the classic Motte and Bailey to my mind. His Bailey is:

Not an apocalypse for anybody with a skill set that can exist completely independent of the internet

Basically claiming that anyone who relies on the Internet is gonna get fukt, and they should cry about it.

Then when challenged he retreated to the much more specific claim of:

people running porn websites, and AB testing headlines and algorithmic content feeds to see which ones make people hate each other more,

I'm not impressed with this sort of rhetoric.

there has been no emotional component at all

The flat affect, 'no emotional component' is what I mean. They are giving a sort of impartial authority to their diagnosis to make you feel okay.

I disagree with doctors, but many of the people I know in the middle-class PMC take their word as Truth.

Hmm, deepfakes for telemedicine would be concerning. I get your point with #2 as well, although I think that'll take some time to roll out.

I see what you mean I suppose the medical profession might be on the way out. I was supposed to be the optimistic one! Alas.

Do you think crypto had that much positive impact to begin with?

I like this plan. Hell make all the important employees live next to it.

To get a bit Lao Tzu, the information that can be collected and digitized isn't the real, valuable information.

At some point LLMs may be able to speak the True Dao. Their whole shtick is essentially building an object that contains multiple dimensions of information about one concept, yes?

ChatGPT is only going to make this worse: you need to know even less python to actually get your code to do what you want it to, which seems good on the surface, but increasingly it means that you are offloading more and more of your thinking onto the machine and thus becoming further and further divorced from what you are actually supposed to be an expert in. Taken to the extreme, in a future where no one knows how to code or do electrical engineering, asking GPT how to do these things is going to be more akin to asking the Oracle to grant your ships a favorable wind than to talking to a very smart human about how to solve a problem.

We have been offloading thinking to tools forever, I highly doubt we will reach some breaking point now. We absolutely do lose knowledge when we gain this, but we trade it for more efficiency. Is it bad that we have calculators everywhere?

I'm not sure I really like what I see to be honest. AI has the potential to be mildly to very useful, but the way I see it being used now is primarily to reduce the agency of the user.

I agree with this on the advertising portion. I'm becoming increasingly concerned that targeted advertising could lead to terrifying outcomes, like a small group controlling public opinion. (actually that already exists, but still)

the Europeans ruled the Native Americans

Eh, that wasn't as dramatic as usually depicted. Europeans had the massive benefit of playing local tribes off against one another, and horrific waves of disease that killed 95% of the native population.

That being said, I agree with the game theory argument against AI safety.

Doubly sad because this imagined golem of hard take off AGI is what will be used by power players to gain a regulatory monopoly on the technology.

Yep. Effective Altruism went from a movement of a bunch of tight-knit, smart, well intentioned youngsters to a huge nerd sniping by AI Safety.

I'm almost not sure if EA as a whole will even have positive impact in the long run, since it has been so crucial to slowing down AI progress and may succeed even more. It's really tragi-comic.

As someone who's pro-nuclear, the best argument I've heard against it is that we have lost the expertise at the state level to build these, and we can't trust corporations to handle something with such a significant downside risk.

Second, what's up with nuclear waste? Specifically, if the waste is really a nothing burger, as I see argued often, why do I see (other) experts talking about how to communicate how bad it is to people ~10k years in the future. What are those other experts thinking and why are they wrong?

My understanding is that yes it's gonna be radioactive for a while, but if you stick it in the side of a mountain in the middle of nowhere, it's not going to spread very far. And we have a loooot of space, at least in the U.S.

while spending pennies on aligning their shit

Alignment is generally in the interest of the corporation. I really think it depends on how hard you expect the alignment problem to solve, and when sentience will come about.

I think we get AGI, even well into ASI before we get real sentience and AI models stop being tools. Once we have boosted our own intelligence and understanding through these new AI tools, we align the next generation of AI. And so on and so forth.

What Altman and his crew are concerned with is one actor taking charge of AI at the beginning (well, one that isn't them) or us building up so much theoretical framework that when we start building things they're already extremely powerful. We need to work the technology in stages, like we do every other.

I'd expect it to be aligned with whoever is using it at the moment. I don't think we're near actual sentience in AI.