TheDag
Per Aspera ad Astra
No bio...
User ID: 616
Sorry I missed that! You said makeshift jointer or something and I assumed.
Hope everyone has a good st. Patricks day, if you celebrate. We’re going west coast swing dancing, I’d highly recommend it if you’re looking for a new hobby.
Why not just get a hand jointer?
Right now tradcons benefit heavily from modern urbanized life. If the Amish or mennonites want to make that argument, sure. But all the posters on here are getting massive advantages from city life and industrialization while shitting all over it.
That is, to be pithy, not cool.
I disagree with your framing of internal experience being the end all be all. One of the core parts of having a good life, in my opinion, is helping to better the great project of humanity, or sentient beings, or order over chaos, whatever you want to call it.
If you only prize internal states, this means the opiate addicted guy who is happy with his life is just as good as a saint spending their whole life trying to better humanity. Seems wrong to say they have equally good lives.
While I’d recommend staying away from toxic PUA writings, one of the best things I discovering perusing those poison laced tomes was the idea of “agree and amplify.”
Basically if someone is making you uncomfortable or challenging you in some way (like in your example) you confidently laugh it off and make it absurd. For instance, you could reply “oh yeah I’m saving myself for marriage.” Make sure to frame it as a joke.
As others have pointed out, joking isn’t lying! It’s all about tone and body language, watch some modern comedians maybe to get an idea.
Thanks for repping the positive side of the Singularity. Too few people around here (rat sphere) remember that.
Have you tried getting involved with a local ACX/EA group? I did and it significantly impacted my life, for the better I’d say.
Depends on your mindset and who you are. I myself and many others have had extremely profound and positive transformations through recreational drug use.
I was trying to evoke the dramatic changes to our understanding of the world that science brought in with poetic language.
I agree with basically all of this up until the end. I don’t think Christianity’s predictions have been correct, otherwise it wouldn’t have failed so badly to grapple with the changes in reality science showed us.
What I’m essentially saying is that Christianity needs a new prophet. Jesus himself built on a prior religion. Mohammad, I think, took that in a poor direction. We need another prophet or at least good Church leaders who can square Christianity’s answers with modernity.
You may be convinced Christianity has done that - but I’m not, and neither are the majority of people on the planet.
Thanks for digging this up - casts some serious doubt on how good it is. OpenAI is good at building hype at least.
I have put in plenty of work over my life, yes. The real test to me is figuring out where to put in the work and for whom.
Newton claimed to have discovered the rules of motion, Descartes claimed to have discovered graphical representation, etc etc. I notice you only picked the sociological products of the scientific revolution.
The reason these other thinkers made such sweeping predictions is because the predictions of religion and our relationship to the world shifted so dramatically.
I’m trying to make a larger point about how the power and understanding we’ve gained from scientific knowledge have fundamentally changed our relationship with the world. The average slob can’t escape this cultural change, it’s “in the water” so to speak.
Maybe one day I’ll take time to summarize the slow demise of meaning in western society.
Universal human rights are just as much a ‘lie’ as Christianity. The Christian church has fractured split and broken down far more times than Enlightenment ideals, although it does have staying power.
The mythos we use to organize societies are all lies at some level, it seems you only want to use that word on things you disagree with though.
So what is your answer for those who don’t believe, or those who literally can’t make themselves believe due to cultural upbringing etc. Are they all doomed to eternal damnation?
That is not and I hope never will be a view of morality I endorse.
I think we’re on the same side? Obviously I think people should do the right thing and do what’s good and healthy for them. Religion is a way to coordinate and convince people to do that on a massive scale.
My point is that Christianity is no longer convincing for most people. It doesn’t do the job it was made for.
Right now nothing works for most people. And it's a damn shame.
So you are correct that it falls short of perfectly Christlike behaviour. But we are not expected to be perfectly Christlike.
This strikes me as a fully general excuse, couldn't you justify any action by saying you aren't perfect and God doesn't expect you to be?
Sorry to scoop you. I like your post better than mine, for what it's worth.
I defy you to describe an actual philosophical issue raised by science.
The framing/definition of 'issue' here seems to be the issue. I'd say the biggest issue raised by science is that people don't believe. Once a critical mass of people don't believe, the transformative power of religion, the ability to get people to self reflect and change, loses out. Religion without that is, to me, essentially pointless. You can call that science or "dazzling lies" or whatever you want to, but if you read the history of the scientific revolution many great thinkers, esp. Pascal, John Stuart Mill, Marx, etc predicted the exact crisis of meaning we have now if we couldn't reconcile Christianity and science. Turns out we couldn't.
If you are right, Christianity will continue to decline and eventually go extinct. If I am right, modernity will implode, and we Christians will be left with the work of picking up the wreckage.
I'd ask that we Christians try and fix the ship now, instead of picking up the wreckage. We seem to have strong disagreements on what that means however. I somehow don't think Jesus would approve of this whole ethos you're espousing, essentially: 'they brought this upon themselves, we'll let them kill themselves and look down in our smug superiority. Then we'll come in and say 'I told you so!.'
What’s complex about modern life? A mass the size of a paper clip can destroy entire cities. Giant metal machines move things around. We’re surrounded by a ‘concrete jungle’ most of our lives. There are constant loud noises and smells and all sorts of things we didn’t evolve to adapt to.
The key is that Christianity hasn’t evolved to adapt to this either. Religion must reconcile itself with the philosophical issues science and mass industry bring to the fore. Is God logical? Well Protestants destroyed that idea long ago.
Does God like science? If we fully read from the book of Nature, do we become God?
Why would god create a world where we can have atrocities like WW1 and WW2? I know I know the problem of evil has been endlessly rehashed. But clearly the philosophical answer was not good enough to keep the faith for most people after those wars. Modernity has broken our spirituality, and so religion must adapt if it wants to fulfill its role.
Or you can try and win through a fertility race or something, but as @aqouta points out that’s gonna be a bad time for all involved.
I’m glad to hear this worldview works for you, but part of the point @Hoffmeister25 is making in my view is that this can’t and won’t work for most people. At least not in and urban modern context.
To repeat my response down thread, Christianity has clearly failed to adapt to the modern, secular worldview. This has been going on since at least the 18th century if not well before then, but the cracks in the religion of the day have been growing. There’s a reason less people are religious than ever.
And I agree that’s a bad thing! Religion is great for people! But if tradcons just sit in their villages and talk about how great their life is and try to push their outdated worldview nothing will change. You need to innovate and find a way to square your religion with the updated understanding we now have of the natural world.
Honestly, I’m rooting for y’all. I’d like to see a return to spirituality, but it has to be a new spirituality that’s true to our circumstance, not one from two thousand years ago.
@FarNearEverywhere this may be a more put together response than my other one downthread.

I always knew this site would be the end of us all.
More options
Context Copy link