@TheDag's banner p

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users  
joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

				

User ID: 616

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users   joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 616

That said, I have experienced chronic pain (but do not currently) and that was definitely 100% real. Certainly it can be psychosomatic for some people but let's be clear that it often has a purely physical cause.

It can absolutely have a physical cause, but more than a few months and I'd be willing to bet it's mostly psychosomatic. My understanding is that most chronic pain starts with an acute injury and spirals from there. The brain feels the body get hurt, tenses up, and a vicious cycle ensues.

At the end of the day the line between the two is blurry.

I don't know if this is fair... how many average people would actually be willing to discuss statistical group differences? Adams may not have been convincible but I would say neither side is. The topic is toxic as hell.

Woah I had not seen this! Bookmarked, thanks for sharing.

Against Malaria Foundation, Helen Keller International, Clean Air Task Force, GiveDirectly, WaterAid America.

More here if you want to look through further areas.

Depends on what you value. Standard utilitarian calculus demands donating to the third world for highest impact.

Fair! I suppose I thought depression/anxiety etc were much more broadly diagnosed and well known in society.

Then again, I'm also a bit tired of all the constant debates about trans on here. ;)

To quote my response to @aqouta below:

I suppose I think that compared to depression, anxiety, chronic pain, anorexia, and other issues I see trans as something that doesn't cause nearly as much harm, but generates a disproportionate amount of outrage. It's definitely one of the best examples of a subculture driving mental illness though.

Fascinating write-up - thanks for sharing. I wonder how many critiques of psychology (and other fields) like this are lost because of the fact that the current narrative doesn't support them.

I wish someone would write a counterfactual history where the mythopoetic Jungian psychologists stayed in power and kept developing their narratives into the mainstream. I feel like we might be in a better spot regarding mental health. Psychology has a lot to answer for....

I would add Long Covid to this list of illnesses. Of course, post-viral symptoms from a nasty viral infection are a real thing that impact some non-trivial number of people, but the distribution of Long Covid doesn't make much sense if it's that.

Good call, added to the list.

How would you implement such a change in perspective? How could you do so without significant change in the outside world?

I’m reminded of the teen pregnancy discussion a couple weeks back. It didn’t go down because everyone decided to make a societal change. Instead, the confluence of social signaling, costs, new technology, and coordinated efforts shifted the calculus.

I'm skeptical that you necessarily need to change everyone's sanity at once. Effective Altruism is a good example of a movement that can get a lot of narrow work done without making everyone involved significantly smarter. You get smart people at the top directing others, and build a hierarchy that (hopefully) selects for competence.

Now EA may be in troubled times, but it has certainly had a massive impact. If we could make this sort of awareness into a cause area I think we'd get significant movement. At least better than a counterfactual without some sort of movement.

Thanks for your perspective. Dyslexia is another good example of one of these potentially culturally bound illnesses.

I know you see the trans question as a red Haring but this is another reason I find the topic impossible to ignore. It's the meme equivalent of a bullet with my name on it. There but for the grace of God go I as it is exactly the kind of thing I might have been susceptible to.

I suppose I think that compared to depression, anxiety, chronic pain, anorexia, and other issues I see trans as something that doesn't cause nearly as much harm, but generates a disproportionate amount of outrage. It's definitely one of the best examples of a subculture driving mental illness though.

Sorry to hear you've been through that. I've never experienced anything quite so acute, but I've had my fair share of harrowing moments that later turned out to be nothing.

But it was so real. I literally felt like I was going to collapse and die at any moment, I was convinced of it. I felt every heartbeat, and every bed pain from sleeping wrong was misinterpreted as a coming disaster.

I relate to this so much more than I can express here. I try not to refer to these episodes as "panic attacks" because of the aforementioned issues, but have definitely been there.

It's a type of experience that I think is uniquely difficult to put into words. People who haven't gone through that sort of thing literally just cannot grasp the magnitude of it I find, and I don't blame them. But over time the meaningless platitudes people spout when you open up really drives you to others who understand.

Then of course a whole subculture forms, and the problem reinforces itself. It's a nasty spiral.

Some of you may have read Scott Alexander’s recent post, Book Review: The Geography of Madness. The couple of paragraph summary is:

A culture-bound mental illness is one that only affects people who know about it, and especially people who believe in it. Often it doesn’t make sense from a scientific point of view (there’s no such thing as witches, and the penis can’t retract into the body). It sometimes spreads contagiously: someone gets a first case, the rest of the village panics, and now everyone knows about it / believes in it / is thinking about it, and so many other people get it too.

Different cultures have their own set of culture-bound illnesses. Sometimes there are commonalities - many cultures have something related to the penis or witches - but the details vary, and a victim almost always gets a case that matches the way their own culture understands it.

THESE PEOPLE ARE NOT MAKING IT UP. I cannot stress this enough. There are plenty of examples of people driving metal objects through their penis to pull it out of their body or prevent the witches from getting it or something like that. There is no amount of commitment to the bit that will make people drive metal objects through their penis. People have died from these conditions - not the illness itself, which is fake, but from wasting away worrying about it, or taking dangerous sham treatments, or getting into fights with people they think caused it. If you think of it as “their unconscious mind must be doing something like making it up, but their conscious mind believes it 100%,” you will be closer to the truth, though there are various reasons I don’t like that framing.



The thrust of Scott’s argument is that humans have an amazing propensity to change their subjective experience based on their beliefs. Here, I'm not talking about rationally held or carefully reasoned beliefs, but deep-seated beliefs that aren’t easy to change, even if you know for a fact they're irrational. Typically, these beliefs seem to be formed through social or cultural channels, and once formed, they can be very difficult to change unless your cultural narrative also changes.

This idea ties into other work on the placebo effect and the ways it shaped our culture, for instance, John Vervaeke’s take on shamanism. The basic idea being that shamanism was highly advantageous from an evolutionary perspective because it allowed groups of humans to harness the placebo effect to overcome illness and manage social problems.

In short, despite the rational pretensions our culture has, our irrational beliefs have extremely strong effects on our perception of pain and other subjective experiences. However, an important nuance is that no cultural disorder is 100% ‘in your head;’ on the contrary, these disorders are very real and can have strong physical effects.

Some of the big examples that Scott gives, and some I think might be (mostly) culturally mediated, are:

  • Anorexia

  • Post-traumatic stress disorder

  • Anxiety

  • Depression

  • Gender dysphoria

  • Chronic pain

  • TikTok Tourettes

  • Long Covid

Now, based on the bent of this forum, many people might be tempted to jump on the gender dysphoria issue. While it’s certainly a loud and vibrant battle in the culture war, I’d ask that we instead focus on other problems. In my opinion, if this thesis holds true, then gender dysphoria is a red herring.

The evidence clearly suggests that we are inflicting massive amounts of pain and suffering on ourselves through our cultural beliefs and practices. The fact that so many of our cultural problems - from overdose deaths and suicides to chronic pain and crippling anxiety - are unforced errors is truly shocking.

Think about it - one fourth of the adult U.S. population experiencing chronic pain? That's a staggering number, and it seems largely due to the fact that we have been conditioned to believe that our pain must have an acute physical cause. We've been taught to view pain as something that must be cured with medication or surgery, when in fact many cases of chronic pain can be alleviated by simply changing our beliefs about it.

The truly shocking revelation here is that so many of our cultural problems - massive amounts of overdose deaths, suicides, one fourth of the adult population experiencing chronic pain, crippling anxiety causing young people to retreat from society, and many more issues - are clear unforced errors. We are inflicting this pain on ourselves.

If this theory is true it may very well be one of the most important and impactful frameworks with which to view the issues of post modernity. We wouldn’t need endless medications or miraculous scientific breakthroughs - we could already have the power to end massive amounts of truly pointless suffering.

ETA: is another perfect example of this type of illness.



From a personal perspective, I can attest that this theory confirms my priors. I’ve dealt with chronic pain for a decade and have long suspected that it was mostly psychosomatic. Even with this realization, it is a difficult battle to fight. Ironically, support groups where people confirm and commiserate seem to make the issue worse. In fact, many modern studies on pain recommend not even using the word "pain" and replacing it with something else to trick your mind into understanding that your pain doesn’t have an acute physical cause.

So many of us in the rationalist community focus on object-level reasons as to why our society may be stagnating or why we have so many cultural problems. At the end of the day, it turns out that our beliefs themselves may be throwing us into a twisted, absurd, and horrific self-fulfilling prophecy.

It may be time to stop assuming that the causes of our problems originate directly from the outside world and update to a view that many more major problems could be solved if we simply change our cultural beliefs.

Oh man have you listened to letlive. at all?

I'm looking to kind of note down and keep random stuff then try and find connections. Obsidian seems good for that over time.

What music do y'all listen to? I've recently gotten back into Florence + the Machine. Gotta say, it's much better going back as an adult. It's hard to find positive, upbeat music with good lyrics.

I’ve used notion for work but find it kind of annoying, and the tag/back link features in obsidian seem amazing if you spend a lot of time in it.

Hey a reply from the man himself. Thanks for the tips I’ll get started with the daily journals and see how it goes.

I’m trying to get a personal knowledge management system set up in Obsidian per @DaseindustriesLtd ‘s recommendation. Struggling to find a simple easy starter guide that explains how to, for instance, import google drive documents and/or automatically create daily notes.

I’ve found a lot of stuff but they’re all insanely complex - like way more than what I’m looking for. Anybody have advice or know good guides on how to navigate using this tool or general advice for organizing folders/notes/thoughts?

The real move here is own one company that sells these books, cancel them, then own another shell company in another country that loudly says they will keep printing the original. Rake in cash from both sides.

Congrats that sounds awesome!! I wish you luck man.

Yeah if anything it makes me think he’s smarter.

Oh interesting, I didn't know he was so young. I don't really care either way so I didn't dig into it so much. Thanks for clarifying.

What are y'all mfers reading nowadays? I'm on Tales of the Ketty Jay and I fucking love it. It's a fun romp with a freebooting airship captain in a fantasy world making moves and fuckin' bitches.

I'm sure everyone else is reading things much more erudite...

It’s a lonely time being an EA on the Motte. That being said there are definitely a few others, I’ve seen at least five people directly or indirectly out themselves.