@TheDag's banner p

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users  
joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

				

User ID: 616

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users   joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 616

Hoping to start a book club to help people learn more about philosophy/improve themselves etc.

Anyone know of good intro to philosophy books, specifically utilitarianism? Looking for something newer and accessible but that still gives an accurate overview of the philosophy.

Many answers you find on search engines are wrong too.

I don’t think science is motivating them at this point.

Np. Happy to chat if you have more questions about it. Losing your voice repeatedly can be rough!

True! I will edit that to be Hinduism instead. Buddhism I know rejects the ego and self as a false construct. There's probably a more interesting take on it from an intuition standpoint.

Intuition in a Scientific Age

As part of @FiveHourMarathon’s intuition contest, I thought I’d write a bit about the role of intuition in our lives, and especially the modern world.

First off, to define intuition I’ll go with Wikipedia’s first line: Intuition is the ability to acquire knowledge, without recourse to conscious reasoning. This definition to my mind includes things like instinct, but is much broader as well.

Depending on your side of the aisle in the Culture War, intuition is seen in many different lights. According to pop psychology, those who value hunches more are more likely to “hold religious or paranormal beliefs,” AKA be right-coded. On the other hand, many leftist artists believe that unconscious intelligence is a key component of good art. Either way, the main place intuition comes into conflict with our modern worldview is when it comes to science, as my fellow contestant @f3zinker has pointed out.

To truly understand why so many scientists nowadays disdain intuition, we must return to the roots of the Scientific Revolution. During the Enlightenment science flourished due to a shift from a symbolic view of the world, to a view which saw the universe as a piece of clockwork machinery. Before this change, the vast majority of our understanding of the world was rooted in intuition or gut feelings. If someone saw a crow after or before an event, that omen would be seriously interpreted by those in the community as having explanatory power. In the Roman Empire, augurs were some of the most handsomely paid and powerful officials. Caesar himself was Chief Pontifex for many years.

Science came in to change all that, and insisted that instead of relying on gut feelings and hunches, we needed to double check everything we see and experience through empiricism and repeatability.

Unfortunately this shift left intuition in an odd place. Nowadays the word conjures an image of crystal-energy healing ‘free thinkers’ that simply say ‘intuition’ when they want to reject whatever claims they don’t like, and put forth the claims they prefer.

However, I’d like to return to the definition I listed above: Intuition is all about acquiring knowledge without conscious reasoning.

For most of the pre-modern period until today, conscious reasoning was king. We saw how incredibly powerful our intellect, channeled through science and industry, could make us. We mastered forests, rivers, vast oceans, and are even making headways into the cold void of space. Yet something has slowly begun to creep into our faith in conscious reasoning.

Rationalists as a whole have banded together over this issue - that of unconscious biases. I’d posit that the true role of intuition as defined in this post is our intelligence or understand removed from conscious thought.

Clearly the evidence of bias itself is a powerful reason to be suspect of conscious thought. Yet even before the modern era, the idea that our conscious awareness is only a small part of who we are has been quite common. Hinduism, Taosim, even Judaeo-Christian religions posit that we have some essential essence or soul that guides us, irrespective of what we think is going on in our heads.

The task of reconciling the unconscious mind with conscious reasoning is one of the great projects of the modern era, and to my view one of the most critical. Political unrest, tribal activity, lack of scientific understanding, and all sorts of societal ills have their roots in our unconscious. Most people with anti-social or criminal tendencies don’t get there from proper reasoning, they act based on instinct, on the conclusions they come to in a snap of judgment.

We have attempted to directly reconcile modern science with intuition a number of times, most notably in the work of Freud, Jung, Lacan, and others. Unfortunately this type of study seems to bring out incredible amounts of backlash, and modern psychology has more or less written off the unconscious mind as something that is definitely important, but not able to be studied. Instead we simply work on it indirectly through imprecise drug treatments, and ineffective talk therapies.

Some pop psychologists like Daniel Kahneman have tried to describe the differences between ‘System 1’ type thinking and ‘System 2’ type thinking. The former being automatic, quick, and involuntary, whereas the latter would be more considered and conscious. However, these types of pop psychological analyses are consistently lacking in rigor, and seem more focused on selling books than actually providing satisfying answers to deep questions.

Many modern thinkers are attempting to bridge this gap, but there as of yet are no great thinkers after Lacan who have instituted a new paradigm to study.

The first step, one most Rationalists have already taken, is to accept that our conscious minds are not as infallible as we would like them to be. Unfortunately, as seen with the FTX fiasco, many in the Rationalist community seem to go full circle. They acknowledge that the conscious mind is fallible and prone to bias, then think that because they are aware of this they can ignore their intuitions and unconscious mind through the sheer power of ‘Bayesian’ reasoning. Social situations and finding bad actors like SBF are a key example of how trusting our gut and intuitions can provide a boon where the conscious mind may fail.

To truly reconcile intuition and gut feelings with the modern scientific paradigm, we need bold new theories. We need thinkers who are willing to branch out, brave social approbation, and work to find the common ground between religion, myth, science, and the unconscious mind.

Yeah... the general response is that people don't mention it but then don't talk to you or dance with you again hah. Luckily I've avoided that but I have heard stories of other guys.

Unfortunately you're screwed if you get an erection! I'd recommend just trying to not go into closed or something until more comfortable.

Yeah it's been pretty insane here. Big reason I don't do blues anymore. My local scene is still requiring N95 masks to go to any event...

I’m trying contra for the first time next week. What do you like about it?

Drugs are mainly just booze and some pot. Most people are sober though as far as I can tell, albeit I’m usually drunk. People don’t care as long as you’re a solid dancer, although smoking and smelling like cigs/pot is usually frowned upon.

These seem to check out for me. I’ll add that ballroom, blues and lindy tend to have an older crowd.

Hah I have a ton of stories. From my experience on east coast US, Latin style dances are generally a bit more conservative and can have an element of snobbishness or elitism for new leads. A lot of competing for female attention.

Blues is the most left or woke and is harder to get into because it’s all freestyle. If you’re generally more traditional I’d recommend learning east or west coast swing, maybe trying both and going with your preference. West coast tends to have more modern music and younger folks though.

Best memories of dance are at the weekend exchanges/competitions. I’ve danced naked at a campground shower with beautiful women, stayed up until 8am dancing the whole time then getting breakfast, hooked up with women I had just met dancing that night, competed and won grants for hundreds of dollars to go to dance camps, it goes on and on. If you can find a group of close friends to travel with to these events I’d highly recommend it, easily some of the best times of my life.

That being said there’s also a ton of drama. I’d definitely avoid sleeping with too many people or dating around too much initially unless you know the person well and are serious about them. It can get real awkward and partner dance communities are somewhat small/insular unless you’re in a huge metro area.

I think the best part of dance for me though is the confidence it brings you. As a man, dancing regularly really changed the way I walk, carry myself, and interact with people, especially women. It helped me connect with my physical side which is something I find seriously lacking in modern society.

I recently found out another Mottizen likes to dance. Curious if anyone else dances seriously?

For myself I mostly do partner dance - blues & swing right now though I used to compete in ballroom.

Wow your description made me value my own partner more. Thanks for that.

Read this book before hiring a voice coach - trust me. I've had issues with my voice for years.

https://www.amazon.com/Voice-Book-Caring-Protecting-Improving/dp/1556528299

The main answer to this has been with NFTs. The challenge is convincing people that an NFT is tied to a certain physical outcome or object.

If everyone agrees that to have legitimate ownership over a piece of land you need a corresponding NFT, you can incorporate that into a smart contract. The hard part is getting public buy in.

In my opinion smart contracts on the blockchain are an interesting answer. I expect them to become more relevant as more and more of our useful work happens in a digital environment.

Is property taxed at all under this system? Wouldn't this usher in a landed gentry situation?

Trust games are a fascinating construct. Seems like with the levels of power getting thrown around in modern society especially we need a binding compact more than ever.

Unfortunately the ruling class is more instrumental and sociopathic than ever. Do we need a modern religion to bind us all together in fear of hell or something?

In history most academics still see be defining work on this as Jared Diamond’s Guns, Germs and Steel.

I’m ready Neal Asher’s Polity series from a rec on here. It’s alright, enough to keep me reading, but not as good as other AI driven sci fi I’ve read like The Culture or The Commonwealth Saga.

I'm interested! Do we submit as a comment here or privately to you?

Watts is great! I love that book.

Quotes writing random thoughts etc.

Ahh to be a programmer. You truly are the ubermensch of our times.

I'll keep you posted. Obsidian has the canvas thing which... maybe supports drawing? Also they have a million plugins. Idk might be worth another look.

Edit: maybe this? https://medium.com/produclivity/editable-graphics-in-obsidian-notes-is-the-best-thing-since-plain-text-d8bd75454397