So in my initial reading of your post, I missed that an in-law confronted your father. I though it was a member of your own family. That is pretty wild to say the least, and an unhelpful approach to any conversation of weight. You have all my sympathies there.
At the same time, if you're response to the others who disagree with your behavior is Deal With It, expect to be returned the same when seeking sympathy that others are behaving ways you don't agree with.
trangender disphoria.i meant that as a catch all, men wading into transism
I'm suprised you haven't heard this before. I agree with your last sentence, especially with MTF. I think the phenomenon is multi-faceted, but AGP is a tremendous part of it, and I don't think anorexia is particularly fetishistic.
Just spend a minute looking up the concept of 'euphoria boner', and it lays waste to most of the narrative. Especially on trans forums where it gets brought up as the most crushingly painful example of pretending something isn't there by closing your eyes. The essential concepts is that it's really common for dudes with TD to get really turned on by crossdressing etc. Instead of accepting this as straightforward evidence that this is psycho-sexual in all the obvious ways, they've invented a tortured concept that no, no, just the opposite. This 'euphoria boner' transcends fetish and is a result of a much deeper sense of self-understanding.
Noone reflects on why this concept only exists conveniently in this use case of convincing yourself a clear turn on is more meaningful than that. Thinking with the wrong head and the related post-nut clarity is pretty well trodden and understood male pyscho-sexuality, and this is the most painfully transparent attempt at gaslighting this into the opposite.
A very common and sad gaslight is some recently cracked egg on these forums makes a comments like, "yo, I'm worried this is a fetish / sexual fantasy, because I get super aroused when I induldge" (usually much less concisely and straightforward, but that's their real point). To which, they are showered with " no no, it's the exact oppposite. Your sexual excitement in this context actually proves it's not a sexual indulgence.... because...um... euphoria boner".
Well I mean fallen short in advising you both not to enter a mixed marriage. Look, I don't know your family and would guess that 90+% percentage of inter-family value pressure and hostility (Christian or otherwise) is counterproductive just from a human nature perspective, so I'm not carte-blanc defending that.
But your wife, especially if she's a practicing Catholic, doesn't get to just make up the rules to force-fit her preferred marriage arrangement. Overall, by entering a Christian marriage, both of you should expect and act gracefully in the face of the Great Commission's demand's on your families, or else you shouldn't have entered into a marriage with a Christian.
This is where my charge of arrogance comes into play.
Maybe this isn't what you're saying, but it's not arrogance to act upon your convictions.
So let me get this right, to ever defend practices of Christians as straightforwardly how Christianity works is turbo-autism?
Well I assumed you don't ridicule her. But I assume she knows you don't believe and think it's 'idiocy' (if in lighter terms). I personal would advise people against marrying people with such fundamental moral epistemology mismatches It seems quite difficult for reasons you describe in your OP.
FWIW, my wife is Catholic, but her family isn't and that alone is hard enough.
should be left alone.
No disrespect back at you, but that's not how Christian marriage works. you knew that going in, and you're wife knows that. If either of you don't know that, your respective fathers have certainly fallen short here.
Whether or not your spouse is committed to raising your kids Christian is a private conversation.
From within the Christian worldview, it's not though and that's the disconnect. Christian ,marriage and baptism are necessarily public and community arrangements and within Catholicism, sacramental. Marriage is a living metaphor for the relationship of Jesus and the Church itself.
That doesn't mean everything is everyone's business all the time, but even if you come into the marriage as nonChristian, this is what you are getting into. Christian marraige is not a function of an atomic, private, liberal mindset even if you want it to be.
As I said in the other comment, it's true that OP didn't necessary make a vow to raise his kids Catholic, but he publically entered a union with a person who did and the other members of the Church to an extent have a right and even (in the right context) a duty to assure that commitment.
OP's whole post is "why can't Christians subject their faith to my standard of polite secular tolarance within our family the same way I expect it from our state?" Because Christianity doesn't work that way and isn't a servant of liberalism.
If you don't want to raise your children religious why get them baptized, if you had been clear with your intentions from the start I don't think you would have this conflict (might have other conflict but not this one!).
To be validly married in the Catholic Church in a mixed marriage, the Catholic party has to promise baptize and raise their children in the faith. Prior to 1970, both parties had to make the promise.
While I think mixed marriages are a very bad idea to begin with, assuming they had a valid Catholic wedding, @yofuckreddit is/was likely aware of this promise of their spouse and respects her enough to not obstruct it. If they are not validly married, I would spend my time pestering his wife about getting that fixed were I their relative, before I moved on to hassling @yofuckreddit himself.
I don't know why one marries someone who thinks their beleifs are idiotic, but love is love I guess.
When I was in high school, I found I could do this by jumping out of bed immediately upon waking up either naturally or via alarm clock and moving, suppressing any reflection on how I felt or temptation to look at a clock. I stopped doing this after leaving college and felt groggy on waking up no matter what for the next decade or so. I have recently resumed something like this, as I have tried to shift myself into an early riser, and it has worked well.
For me, the 10+ minute loop of grogginess is somewhat re-enforced by a cycle of thoughtful awareness about how I feel, and my body trying to react by going back to sleep. If within 30 seconds of waking up, I am in the bathroom brushing my teeth, and within 2 minutes I am already beginning my day with activity, I don't have time to feel groggy (assuming I am overall well rested). The negative is I now get much tired-er at night right after dinner, but this could be a function of having small kids.
I think this kind of discussion gets wrapped up too quickly in accepting a liberal feminist frame to even make sense. Now sure, we can talk about the merits of specific policies or realities in isolation, which have gendered outcomes and discuss approaches. But to try to wrap it into 'men' as a class vs 'women' as a class and holistically discuss the social deal, cedes the entire frame that this is the appropriate way to modularize social policy.
When I think about how good or bad I have it, I think about my family in a unit. What's good for my wife is good for me and vice versa. Within our family, my wife certainly has it "worse" than me because she had to go through childbirth to get a child, where I didn't. Everything else is an equal share of reward and burden, even if we divy it up differently, because we are one unit yoked together. I feel sorry for people incapable of thinking like that.
I fully agree that at a social level, 'women are victims but also exactly the same as men' thinking has poisoned the well, and I don't disagree with pushing back on that thinking generally and in specific policy or social norms. I don't think men should just roll over at problems that affect men. But I completely disagree with simply taking the feminist frame and trying to reverse it.
I can't watch every movie, or even remember all the movies I've watched. Can you think of any other movies/TV shows/other media to add to the four I've identified?
I'm pretty sure the last Wolverine movie was this trope.
I also can't think of any inverted examples. Can you think of any media in which the trope is inverted? How often do hypercompetent heroes "of color" learn to love whites and then give up their lives to ensure that several white children can afford to go to college?
Maaaybe Dr. Strange. They essentially let a white man appropriate their entire Monk vibe so that he can become a super hero in the West.
People hike for status?
Quite the opposite. I was originally a CS major, planned to do SE, and bailed out in college after internships. I have a different career that I have little interest in but have been steadily moving up to the point of having a PhD related to what I do, all while trying half-heartedly for 10 years to get back into a technical space, even at one point having a start-up on the side. There was a time where I was involved at job with evaluating a commercial software tool, of which I had literally written my own (not enterprise ready though) only two years before. It was insult to injury knowing more about the inner workings than the Sales Engineer trying to sell it to me. AI + age + family, beat that plan out of me in the past year and I've only dug in deeper.
My career is one of those things that makes me most (insincerely) wonder about determinism and whatnot. It's such a sticky track for me that it almost feels like trying to pivot away is an unallowed path like in a video game.
Jump into #2 quickly*! Seriously. Giving your kid a sibling they can play with is something that will pay off for them their whole life. It will also help you out tremendously when they're tots looking for attention you don't have. It might seem crazy to jump back in quickly, but it's probably easier than starting all over again several years later.
*By this I mean within 1.5-3 years, My first two are 16 months apart and even though it was a total unexpected surprise, it was the greatest thing we ever could have done. They are best friends and they keep each other occupied for hours a day that they would either be lonely or staring at screens
One thing that rolls around in my head when talking about the rise in transgenderism is the complexity of comparing outcomes. Now I don’t personally think this topic should be primarily judged through an outcomes lens, and my position isn’t based on it. However, it inevitably gets tossed around, and it’s also related to the question of how much a rise in transgenderism is revealed preferences vs changed preferences, so to speak.
It shouldn’t be controversial to say that a person who transitioned in the past, say even 2003, would have poorer outcomes on average than a person who transitioned today, due to both medical progress and social acceptability etc. Consequently, the baseline unhappiness for a person to transition should end up being higher in 2003 than 2023.
Thus there’s a lot of argument that the rise in transgenderism is at least partly due to a lot of people who would have transitioned in 2003 in a 2023 environment. And I think that’s straightforwardly true.
But I still think that doesn’t show the whole picture Consider the difference in comparing the level of happiness of a person who transitions today as compared to…
• If they didn’t transition today vs
• If they didn’t transition in 2003.
I think social contagion is certainly partly responsible in cause. [There are certainly some people who would never have felt gender dysphoria if they weren’t socialized into this, and I think it accounts for a lot of ROTD in young women, but I suspect it’s also less so in men with AGP, though I definitely suspect things like porn as @2rafa suggest also cause an increase in amount of AGP.] But I think it is also responsible partly for degree of dissatisfaction. How many people in a social context where transition wasn’t an option, would have been happier not transitioning than people not transitioning in a social context where it is an option? Again, the answer seems obviously a lot.
A person tempted to drink, but trying to remain sober is probably going to have a harder time at a party where they’re being encouraged to drink than in an environment where everyone is sober and encouraging them to stay so. So the real comparison is how much happier is a person who transitions in 2023 than that same person would have been if they hadn’t transitioned in 2003.
Obviously it’s a difficult if not impossible measurement. But I think there’s reason to believe that the answer on average is less happy. And if that were true, there’s an argument for a society that is less accommodating, knowing that the person who transitions is less happy, but on average the individual doesn’t transition and is happier for it.
Consider it a related thought experiment that could be measured:
Take a group of children and divide them into four blind groups. **Groups A and B **are given an enthusiastic conversation about and shown advertisements etc for Disney World and told they might get to go there this weekend. Only Group A is taken. Group B is brought to a local playground for the day.
Group C is also shown the advertisements and get the topic presented, but not told that they have a chance to go, and are told upfront they will be taken to a local playground, which they are. Group D is also taken to the local playground after being told they would be, and not shown any adversement for Disney, even though they are likely aware of it.
Even though we might expect that the kids in Group A might have a better time than the kids in group D, it’s reasonable to assume B will have the worst time of it.
Now suppose one wanted to make an argument that A’s overall satisfaction was not great enough over D’s or even C’s to be worth the expense of taking them there, and that C’s and B's satisfaction could be most effectively increased by including them in group D (avoid showing them DW promotions), rather than A’s (taking them to Disney World).
Now imagine that your opponent’s response was to compare A to B (the group who was told might go and then denied) and used B’s dissastisfaction to argue for making D’s into C’s, dissatisfied C’s into Bs, and then arguing it’s human decency to make A available to all Bs.
TLDR, my, not particularly unique point, is that I bet there's a lot of people with a given level of dysphoria, who would have lived a hardly affected life untransitioned 20 years ago, but would suffer much more for it in today's context, and that should be accounted for in extending social permissiveness.
Since many here will already agree with me, I'll go ahead and make the more controversial: The same argument above but for divorce, extramarital sex, and religious participation.
Threads probably won't succeed, but I think the idea of a TikTok For Text will at some point.
Interesting take. For the sake of playing devil's advocate, I wonder whether TikTok with Pictures and Video will always be better enough dopamine rush that TT4Text can't compete on that front.
Claiming that this doesn't count because Susan's only being penalized for non-Christian sexuality, instead of for sexuality, is a nitpick that makes no real difference to the criticism.
It depends what the criticism is though. As I stress, if you are using the "Problem of Susan" as a way to criticize Christianity at large, its a stupid starting point because you are reading into an intentionally vague line whatever you happen to want to criticize instead of criticizing it directly.
Due to the Penseveerseres's discretion, there's not much to work with, but that not much to work with is intentionally and incorrectly spun into excluded from heaven without much reason. My entire point is that it's insincere and distracting to translate, Lucy et al's explanation is thin into the reason is thin.
The problem of Susan is completely contrived, because Christianity is already the coda for interpreting Peter, Edmund, and Lucy's, euphemistic vagueness for the in-world sake of discretion.
Had Lewis, said something explicitly at odds with Christianity, there'd be something there to criticize. Alternatively, if one is simply looking to criticize Christianity, we need not strangle a passing line about a fictional character, written out of a story for the sake of showing "stakes" to do so.
Because Lewis left it vague and intended it to be Christian allegory, we need only to read Christian beliefs into an understanding of it.
Q: Was Susan left out of heaven because she was sexually mature, or generally a grown up?
Decoder: Does Christianity exclude adults or the sexually mature from heaven?
A: No.
Q: Was Susan left out of heaven because she lost her faith?
Decoder: Does Christianity exclude people without faith from heaven?
A: Quite possibly so.
Q: Is it really that binary, she goes to hell because she misremembered fantastical journey?
Decoder: What does Christianity have to say about morally upright people who get the details wrong?
A: Here Lewis does have something to say in the contrast with the pious Caloremene, Emeth. Here one can actually earnest debate Lewis' message about nonChristian salvation or inclusion into heaven. For those who don't remember, he was a pious and morally upright believer in Tash (a false diety), but found himself in heaven, and is told essentially that his proper moral conscious was unknowingly done in honor of Aslan himself.
Now, one might fall on either side of Christian inclusivity, but let's put that a theological debate aside and return to Susan, because even in a world of inclusivity, Susan doesn't make it, which means that within TLB, Susan is clearly both not a believer in Aslan, and relatedly living impiously / immorally.
So whether or not a lack of faith in Jesus is enough to keep one out of heaven, we know that Susan had both a lack of faith and a lack of moral uprightness within the context of Lewis's narrative. This isn't an interpretation, it's deductively so.
Q: Was Susan's immorality a simple appreciation for lipstick, nylon, and/or invitation?
Decoder: Does Christianity condemn lipstick, nylon, or invitations?
A: Here Lewis used the characters' discretion to leave it vague, in order to be inclusive of a wide range of Christianity. And the reader is best served reading into as a placeholder for un-Christian lifestyle. If you are a Puritan, maybe it does render correctly to read it straightforwardly as immodesty.
But it's weird and dishonest to interpret a vague euphemistic line in a particular way for the sake of disagreeing with that reading. But how can we interpret it?
Q: Can we draw anything from Susan's behaviors?
Decoder: What does Christianity have to say about sexual immorality or worldliness?
A: Quite a bit. If you want to render Susan's behavior as a sexual awakening at odds with Christian sexual ethics, what's the problem with Susan that isn't just a problem with Christian belief? You don't have a "problem of Susan", but a "problem with orthodoxy".
If you want to render Susan's behavior as a sexual awakening not at odds with Christian sexual ethics, then clearly that isn't what kept her out of heaven. It makes no sense.
Old post of mine at the old place, but I want to reiterate my objection to referring to education as a public good:
Particular College education, but primary education is a public good, and I think the people is support of affirmative action take the same framing and extend a position of what college ought to be. Even if not economically a true public good, college as part of education collectively as a public good, not in the "benefits the public way", but in a way that is somewhat more abstract.
(tbc this isn't actually my opinion)
Suppose one claims that water should be a public good, in the technical sense. In economics, "both non-excludable and non-rivalrous." However, particular water fountains and taps can't themselves be accessed non-rivalrous or excludable due to their limited availability adn disproportionate desirability or pressure. One solution could be truly truly treat water fountains themselves as public goods with completely even lotteries for access.
Another solution could be to maintain that 1. water is a public good, that 2. access to particular water fountains isn't, and yet that 3. laissez-faire access to water fountains collectively leaves access to the public good unfulfilled. They could make an argument that targeted affirmative access to water fountains is a tool for keeping the water publicly accessible, while allowing the specific taps to be excludably regulated in their availability.
I'm not saying this is correct or has no holes in it, but it is a way of squaring the abstract concept of education as a public good with universities not being so, without resorting to a 'good for the public' definition.
Is there an underlying principle at work here that explains both positions (opposition to AA plus opposition to debt relief) that doesn't just reduce to bare economic or racial interest?
The quickest and imo most accurate answer is that it's teams, not principles holding the two groups of support together.
But for a more effortful reconciliation, I don't think you need to go all in on race or bare economics. Support or opposition to both rulings can cleave rather nicely into a broader philosophical disagreement of social responsibility and the purpose of education for democratic equality & social efficiency. The argument for both is a collectivist view that goes:
Education is a public good, which should provide broad social benefits. Universities and the government should maintain the right to press on the scale to ensure democratically available and efficient outcomes.
In other words, both are united by a philosophy of social responsibility to both sides of the college as a public good bargain: "access" and "outcomes".
The anti-side of both is one about individual / meritocratic fairness. In both cases someone is getting to skip the benefits line, not based on personal merit, but on a collectivist effort to balance some measure. Education is a private good, and proper democratic access is one of equal, unbiased cost/availability, not collective equal access.
EDIT: Other replies below are even more parsimonious about a dichotomy between clear interpretation of existing rules and activist creep. But the most parsimonious in terms of popular opinion, remains teams.
I'm not saying it won't augment the current toolset in new ways I can't well predict. But, the nice thing about mice and keyboards is that, when I want the computer to respond, I touch them. When I'm not touching them, the computer isn't responding. I can do whatever I want with my hands and eyes, and they computer isn't trying to figure out whether I'm asking something of it. There's an inherent limitation with asking the entire attention of your eyes and hands or trying to constantly double task the input devices.
There an analogy with voice-to-text on phones. It may be easier or more convenient at times, but when you are also using your mouth to have an in-person conversation, it's worse.
I'm confused because I thought this was already the case
It was and then it wasn't again with varying steps along the way. There was a point before Musk took over where you could see a particular tweet or scroll a timeline one or two down before the sign in wall would come up. Then it seemed to have all been removed. Then recently, you couldn't actually run a search unless signed in, but could click a username that popped up in the search bar and navigate to their timeline. Then last week, you couldn't even see the search bar, but still open timelines through hyperlinks.
You are hitting on the three competing and unreconcilable goals of education: Democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility.

Dreher's Law of Merited Impossibility: "It will never happen. And when it does, it's a good thing, you bigot!"
More options
Context Copy link