@omw_68's banner p

omw_68


				

				

				
1 follower   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 08 10:28:31 UTC

				

User ID: 1014

omw_68


				
				
				

				
1 follower   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 08 10:28:31 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 1014

What your post mostly made me think, though, was--yeah, as it turns out, people don't usually identify and discuss problems because they are interested in obviously relevant solutions. They identify and discuss "problems" as a negotiating tactic for getting whatever it is they actually want--usually, greater leverage or control over whoever it is they're complaining to.

For the most part, I agree. At some level, everything is about signalling; playing status games; etc. Probably this very post is just an echo of a successful point made by some hunter-gatherer ancestor sitting around the campfire on the plains of Africa.

Luke got his friends tortured and lost his arm

Yes, but it wasn't only that. At the beginning, he's portrayed as kind of a whiny brat. And immediately encounters men (Ben and Han) who are superior to him in various ways. Even at the end of the movie, Luke needs Han's help to blow up the Death Star. At the beginning of the next movie, Han rescues Luke who has been stranded in the middle of nowhere on the ice planet. Probably there are other examples as well.

Feminists don't only object to female characters being flawed, they object to female characters being seriously harmed; defeated; outsmarted; humiliated; made to look immature; and so on.

So that's how you end up with really annoying Mary Sue type characters. It's not only that they have little or nothing in the way of flaws. They are also annoyingly superior to everyone around them. They undermine the opportunities of other characters to shine.

But does anyone have any examples where the original video is correct? Where are the thousands of immensely popular books with competent men who don't pay the tax?

Here's a possibility: Lazarus Long in Heinlein's Time Enough for Love. Basically a male Mary Sue.

But I think few critics would try to argue that Time Enough for Love is serious literature or that Lazarus Long is a complex character. He's basically just a Mary Sue who is always smarter and better and more competent than anyone around him.

I enjoyed Time Enough for Love and I also enjoyed the Honor Harrington series (which has a female Mary Sue as the lead character) but you have to approach both with the right attitude. Typically, science fiction is more about world-building and plot than it is about characters.

Anyway, I suspect what's going on is that in general people are a lot more sensitive to female suffering than male suffering. So if there is a story where a man "pays the price" or otherwise suffers, it's just not as noticeable or memorable. Thus the idea that only women "pay the price."

I remember that some of the early James Bond movies were criticized by feminists on the ground that they depicted women getting killed. But that if you did an actual count, far more men get killed than do women.

FWIW I use proprietary software for my business and the provider recently switched from a modest one-time-for-life fee for the software to a subscription model which was far more expensive. (I guess they were counting on the fact that for most users it would be time consuming, inconvenient, and expensive to switch over to something else.)

Anyway, I asked the AI to create a system for me which had all the features I needed and which could upload and incorporate my current data. It took less than an hour to get it running and so far everything seems to be working perfectly fine.

So yeah, I would say that AI poses a threat to software providers who try to engage in rent-seeking behavior with subscription fees.

has anyone ever had their mind changed by fact checking?

I would say "yes," in the sense that fact-checkers are part of the overall cultural milieu which sends a message to people about what they are supposed to believe.

But I think that's not what you are asking about. The real question is what happens in a specific situation when some partisan hears some really juicy news which puts his political enemies in a bad light, and then that news gets debunked by a "fact checker"

In that case if the partisan is on the Left, what I would expect to happen is that the partisan sees that this latest slander is "mostly true," feels basically vindicated; feels that to the extent the original report was incorrect it's a "fake but accurate" situation; the partisan's basic opinion about his political enemies remains unchanged, although he might not bring up that specific incident again.

On the other hand if the partisan is on the Right, what I would expect to happen is that the partisan sees that this latest slander is "false," doesn't put much credence in it because he believes the fact-checker has been captured by the Left; feels that to the extent the original report was incorrect it's a "fake but accurate" situation; the partisan's basic opinion about his political enemies remains unchanged, although he might not bring up that specific incident again.

So yeah, I don't think fact-checking does much in terms of changing peoples' minds.

It would be pretty great if there were a truly non-partisan fact-checking institution which was well-respected by everyone. But I think such a situation is basically impossible -- if such an institution started to develop it would be too juicy of a target to remain independent. Years ago, I had a fantasy about an AI system which could be programmed to be objective and non-partisan, but sadly it seems that our machines are inheriting our human foibles.

My position is that they do seem to care, and are wrong to care.

Ok, and in your view, what are they doing to influence the outcome of the elections? And what would they do differently if they were desperate?

Sentiment and policy outcome are two very different things. In the GOP, the populists are strong and fighty enough to occasionally force an issue they care about. In the DNC, they're either too unagentic (in the case of migrant anti-Israelism) or too thoroughly 'buckbroken' (in the case of redditor anti-Israelism) to meaningfully contest the party establishment. AOC being made to vote in favor of an Israel aid bill that was already going to pass by a massive margin is a pretty useful case study.

I guess that means your answer is "yes"?

That seems off, because there are certain provocations (see 9-11 and Afghanistan) which would make all patriotic Americans support a war against Iran

That's kind of the point. By contrast, there are a lot of people who would oppose "transitioning" of minors no matter what.

The relevant comparison is "Are you categorically opposed to wars against far-off countries which are no more obnoxious than early-2020s Iran?

Perhaps, I would need to think about that one. But either way, a poll showing that X percent of Americans believe the war is being mishandled is very different (in my opinion) from a poll showing that X percent of Americans are against "transitioning" of minors.

All the numbers I've seen indicate that support for the war climbed slightly after it started compared to pre-war polling around questions like "Should the US launch strikes against Iran?" or "Should the US invade Iran?" but we can't get an apples-to-apples comparison because nobody polled the question

I think a more appropriate apples-to-apples question would be something along the lines of "Are you categorically opposed to war against Iran?" Certainly there are a lot of Americans who are categorically opposed to transing of children under any circumstances.

Similarly, just asking people if they have an unfavorable opinion about Israel is not apples-to-apples either. A more appropriate question would be something along the lines of: "Do you believe Israel has a right to exist"?

Anyway, the proof is in the pudding. It would be easy enough for supporters of Democratic candidates to start using support of Israel as an issue against Republicans. Kamala Harris could have made attack ads against Trump on the Israel issue just as he attacked her on the trans issue. He did move the US embassy to Jerusalem in his first term, after all.

The flag I don't care about, but the fact that they apparently chose to immediately lie at the drop of a hat and produce a deepfake as their response, is a pretty serious and telling flaw.

The most charitable interpretation I can think of was that some idiotic and incompetent staffer handled the situation. A more realistic (in my opinion) guess is that this is a kind of Jason Arday situation. That this woman is not that bright and used to just saying whatever is convenient without getting challenged on it or called out.

Trump's war of choice with Iran is actually managing to be less popular than transgender kids. Pew polling shows 56% of Americans favor banning medical care for youth gender transition. While close to 2/3 of Americans polled disapprove of the handling of the Iran war.

I'm not sure that this is an apples-to-apples comparison. Disapproval of how a war is being handled is not the same thing as categorical opposition to such a war.

But if in 2024 you put out a flyer saying "Don't elect Donald Trump, he'll start a war of choice without seeking public or congressional approval, raising gas prices;" Donald Trump would simply say that he won't start any wars while in office.

Assuming for the sake of argument that this is all true, why don't Democratic candidates such as Kamala Harris simply disavow the unpopular position, e.g. state that they oppose trans-identifying-men in women's locker rooms; oppose "transitioning" for youth; and so on?

Democrats have a unique problem regarding issues like Trans rights and Reparations where they can't publicly disavow these policies, because the parts of their coalition that want these policies are insane spoiled children lobbying for status rather than for material or political success.

I wouldn't frame it quite this way, but I think that's a big part of the answer to the question.

Where the Zionist lobby or the oil companies are sophisticated enough to not care what you say about them in public as long as you deliver in private

That may be a factor, but also I am pretty confident that Israel and even oil companies are more popular among the general public of Republican voters than trans-identifying-men in women's locker rooms are among the general public of Democratic voters. That being said, if it's really true that only 56% of people are in favor of banning medical care for "youth gender transition," I may be out of touch.

although Republican candidates tend to have considerably more leeway about sticking to strict ideological orthodoxy on the issues.

Well that's more or less the point.

I did an image search for "handsome male video game characters" and got the following back:

https://old.reddit.com/r/gaming/comments/1040z7l/game_rants_average_male_protagonist_image_but/

Can we agree that a lot of these characters are conventionally attractive?

The real image showed a Somali politician with the flag upside down, showing at best ignorance and at worst disrespect for the flag.

The most charitable interpretation was that the person simply wasn't paying attention. As a Trump supporter, if Trump appeared in front of an upside down flag, I would assume that he is old, distracted, and probably focused more on any attractive women in the area.

I think part of the issue here is that Somali-Americans are perceived by many as being completely hostile and disloyal to the United States, and appearing in front of an upside down flag confirms that perception on an emotional level.

Journalists who don’t want the immigrant community to be seen in either of those ways is strongly biased towards any way to “debunk” that idea.

I agree completely, and I would add that your typical journalist in the US probably has a very negative opinion about the sort of person who would spread these kind of images. Probably the journalist thinks such people are racist, stupid, etc. "Deplorable" is the right word. So yeah, it would be very easy to convince your typical journalist that the Deplorables are trading fake images to foment their own racism.

And this is why deep fakes will work most of the time. They don’t have to even be good, they just have to conform to what people want to be true.

Combine that with (1) convenient mechanisms, e.g. Twitter, for distributing such things; and (2) the lack of a credible authority as to what is fake and what is real, then yeah I think your prediction is probably accurate.

In fact, I would guess it won't be long before it's easy to create AI-generated "reenactments" of culture-war sensitive events. For example the sexual encounter at issue in the recent Cornell fiasco. It seems that if it fits their tribal allegiance, people will even accept "fake but accurate" materials.

These things are extremely hard to predict, but I would guess that AI generated materials will lead to significantly more polarization in the United States, even more than we have now.

I don't want this to be about a left/right thing,

Well I think it is in the sense that it threatens to help polarize the United States even more than the present. If the leaders from each side are able to present credible evidence/argument to their supporters that (1) the other side is full of bad people who want to do them serious harm; and (2) any evidence contradicting the narrative is fake, it really has the potential to cause a lot of trouble.

Personally, as a conservative, if a photo came out showing Trump or some other Republican doing something very embarrassing I would be automatically skeptical of it and predisposed to believe evidence that the photo was faked, even if that evidence came from the politician at issue. That sort of bias is just heavily ingrained in human psychology.

Democrats are constantly running on "Republicans want to cut spending on [widely used government service or one that serves a sympathetic category] and pay for it by lowering taxes on the wealthy".

Ok, and the analogous situation would be if there were some kind of conservative NGO with a website and literature promoting these sorts of tax and spending cuts; and some Democrat supporters started spreading their literature among people who would be offended by such proposals; and they concealed the fact that they were the ones spreading the literature.

I think that in that situation, a conservative Republican candidate might respond with something along the lines of "I support tax cuts for everyone and my priority would be to cut taxes for the middle class, not just the wealthy." Which might be a bald-faced lie, but I think @MaiqTheTrue 's point is plausible.

It seems that much more than the Republicans, the Democrats have positions which are very unpopular, very embarrassing, but which they still are reluctant to disavow. To be sure, I am a conservative so I am possibly biased on this issue, but if anyone can identity a few analogous issues on the Republican side of things I would be interested.

None of the popular bloggers, podcasters or anyone else in involved in AI foresaw the shortage or recommended those three stocks

Possibly those who did see it kept it to themselves? I had a buddy who had recommended a few stocks including SanDisk using this sort of reasoning.

That being said, I agree it's interesting that the market as a whole didn't predict something which seems in hindsight like it would have been pretty obvious.

I will note that it's possible for a game to have models that favor attractive-on-a-male features while not favoring attractive-on-a-female features,

Anything is possible, but given the totality of the circumstances (wokeification of video games in other ways; the uglification of female characters in general; the well known objection of feminists to attractive female video game characters; the preference of wokies for gaslighting everyone about what they are doing; etc.) I'm going to go with Occam's Razor on this one.

I see two additional issues here, which intertwine.

The first is that there is no objective way to tell if a person is "trans." It's purely self identification. Which is reason to be skeptical about gender ideology, but it also relates directly to the second issue, which is that in many circles, there is a lot of social status accorded to trans people. There are surely organizations which are very welcoming to trans people.

When you combine that with the facts that many young people are desperate for both social status and a feeling of being accepted, I think it's virtually certain that the desire for social status and acceptance will heavily inform the decisions of young people who are deciding whether or not to self-identify as trans.

So to me, it's completely reasonable to use the word "trans" as a transitive verb. In effect, offering acceptance and social status to a young person in exchange for an acknowledgment.

they got transed?

Funny that "trans" is a transitive verb.

Average people can also easily understand how it's possible to achieve sexual pleasure throug homosexual activity even if they do not personally want to participate. Meanwhile the average person cannot understand why soemone would gain satisfaction from severe genital and body mutilation. Therefore they can only conclude that it must be the result of either mental illness or brainwashing.

I agree that's probably a factor, but I think there's more to it than that. Humans are pretty good at guessing the sex of other people. A lot of the time when I meet a trans-identifying-man, my subconscious brain instantly says "man" even if the person is wearing lipstick, makeup, and a dress. So it feels like I am being asked to believe a lie. Of course it doesn't help that a lot of these trans-identifying-men seem to derive personal benefits from being treated as women such as an advantage in sports or easy access to women's changing facilities.

I think my reaction is pretty typical: "No, that's a dude pretending to be a chick" says my monkey brain. "This seems like a scam" says my frontal cortex. "Ewwww" says my lizard brain.

I'm not following. If it's a small number of True Believers, and they wouldn't get to set the agenda, why not just openly oppose them and ignore their little freak-out?

To be clear, I'm not saying that they definitely wouldn't get to set the agenda, just that the mainstream Democrats sincerely believe that they won't.

But anyway, to answer your question, the primary issue I see is that major candidates need to have an organization supporting their candidacy. These organizations are staffed heavily with low paid and volunteer campaign workers, who tend to come heavily from the ranks of True Believers. So that if a candidate went against the True Believers on a hot button culture war issue, there would be a serious chance of a mutiny, sabotage, mass-quitting, etc. And the person's campaign would be in deep trouble even if the candidate's overall appeal to voters on the issues had improved.

Even putting aside the issue of campaign organizations, provoking a sense of betrayal among the True Believers could result in a lot of damage in obvious ways.

By contrast, once the candidate is elected, appeasing the campaign workers and other True Believers is less of a concern. And the agenda of the True Believers can be stalled in ways that are not overtly confrontational, for example if the candidate, having been elected, votes for some progressive bill but the Democratic party doesn't make an aggressive effort to get the bill through.

By the way, I'm not an expert on this issue but what really stuck in my mind was the most recent presidential election. Kamala Harris and other Democrats desperately needed support from male voters but were largely unable to release the kind of advertisements which would have resonated with male voters. And they were unable to release an ad countering Trump's infamous "they/them" ad. What I attribute this to is the campaign worker problem.

So, from a Republican perspective, it seems like just advertising the true beliefs of Democratic politicians in their own words is a good campaign trick.

Yeah, especially on the trans issue. Your average American parents are horrified at the thought of their children being secretly transed at school.

I'm pretty confident that even in places like New Jersey or New York, if there were a straight up referendum, a significant majority of people would vote to ban transing of minors along the lines of the law in Tennessee.

A cares deeply about X, and X is largely indifferent to B, it may well be that B pretends to be extremely worked up about X to fight A.

Well in that case, it wouldn't really make logical sense for B to argue that A's beating the drum on issue X is just an attempt to distract from some more important issue. Both sides are taking the position that issue X is important. Ok, so B is being dishonest and hypocritical, but so what?

If those issues are so unimportant, then why don’t you just… give them up?

I think the most charitable answer to this question is that (1) there is a small core of True Believers in the Democratic party which would freak out and sabotage things if the Party adopted the popular positions on trans issues and immigration; and (2) the Democrats genuinely and in good faith believe that if they get into power, the True Believers won't actually get to set the agenda. Therefore, from the Democrat perspective these issues are moot and irrelevant.

But to me, this is one of those partisan politics kind of things where partisan hacks from both sides engage in total and shameless hypocrisy. Democratic Party supporters don't hesitate for a millisecond to seize upon any issue which can be used to gain a political advantage, regardless of the overall importance of the issue and whether it's being used as a distraction. So it's hard to take this sort of complaint seriously.

I'd guess it's probably between SF and Japan in terms of treating housing as an investment, and thus the level of zoning also lies between SF and Japan in rigidity.

Hard to believe that Texas is unusual among US states in terms of seeing housing an investment.

But anyway, I take it your evidence for the link you posit is (1) the example of Japan; and (2) your guesses about the cultures of other jurisdictions?