pusher_robot
PLEASE GO STAND BY THE STAIRS
No bio...
User ID: 278
In the same way any tax isn't strictly voluntary, yes.
But this argument generalizes to literally any sort of tax you could impose. I'm happy to have that discussion.
But I thought we were engaging with the LVT idea itself.
The LVT is a taxation of 100% of land value. This is unlike any other tax we currently do impose that I am aware of.
Is it better to depend on the government to declare a valuation which you have almost no control over?
Yes, quite obviously, because I don't have to pay to vote. If I don't like the taxation level or think the assessments are wildly inaccurate, I have regulatory, judicial, and electoral recourse. In your system, if any person in the world decides they want to force me out, they can and I can't do anything about it except pay them their declared value.
Imagine how this affects investment, too: if you want to attempt a development, you have to pay extra taxes for the privilege of not having your investment bought ought from under you as soon as the risk is retired. If you're lucky, you get to just about break even. If you're unlucky, you lose your investment and the high taxes you paid.
They're free to name an arbitrarily high amount, but then they'll be held to that number by being taxed on it.
Well then it's not strictly voluntary, is it? If you can't afford to pay the taxes on your subjective valuation, you're forced out of your home just as surely as if the government re-assessed your property at a higher rate than you can afford.
This is why we don't normally tax wealth.
It is basically worthless to them, if you assume the landlord is charging the maximum possible rent they are willing to pay.
If we grant that people's feelings have moral weight then we're opening up quite the can of worms here.
I don't see how. We account for them in myriad other laws.
If people aren't willing to place a specific price tag on their 'feelings of attachment' then how can we know that their attachment outweighs that of the buyer's desire to have the house?
Because otherwise they would sell at that higher price voluntarily, presumably.
How ELSE can you figure out how to weigh the disparate interests here?
Voluntary transactions, the same way we clear most markets. This is only a problem because you're starting with the assumption that the owner shouldn't be able to benefit from the transaction.
I've not thought of nor seen a solid rebuttal to this proposal.
The simplest rebuttal is that it is immoral to tax people for having natural human feelings of attachment to their home. You could make the same case for forcing people to set a sale price for their children. Very efficient for clearing the adoption market. Or for their spare organs, even. By forcing people to pay for the right to not be forced from their home, you are turning a voluntary market into an involuntary one, which degrades the market and degrades basic human rights and dignity.
That said, I'm not totally against the use of eminent domain powers where you have obstinate sellers blocking genuine civic improvements. But I think the "public benefit" of such seizures needs to be adequately established.
Under LVT theoretically all property is basically worthless because its value is taxed away. It would be impossible for its value to grow that large, because the associated taxes would grow at the same rate, making its net value 0.
I'm definitely more of a YIMBY, I understand that losing a house can be a serious blow, but I am more concerned with the fact that our cities are becoming increasingly less dense, losing valuable network effects, and wasting huge swathes of land.
Build new cities! Sounds glib, I know, but there is really no shortage of unzoned, unoccupied land in the United States, in nearly every temperate zone. Sure, the best port locations and the most ideal of weather locations are taken, but this isn't Europe. There's no reason that building the cities you want must entail destroying the ones that exist, unless you are unwilling to settle for anything less than the maximum possible ideal locations, in which case no amount of land reform is ever going to solve the problem that millions of people want to live in those places without also living in proximity to millions of other people.
From what I can tell though, one of the big issues of community being destroyed in the U.S. especially is the lack of density. It's much harder to have a strong social group when you have to drive 15-30 minutes to see any of your friends, being able to walk to another building one block over is much easier.
I disagree, I think too much density is also harmful to community. There is balance between not having enough people to form a community and having so many people proximate that your community is too large to meaningfully participate in. I suspect that in reality, the ideal community is within an order of magnitude of Dunbar's number, and the physical size of one's "community" is simply scaled by the density. In a small town, the entire town is your community. In a suburb, it is your residential neighborhood. In a larger city, your block, and in a megalopolis, your building, or maybe even your elevator stop.
I could never get behind this, and you're changing my mind on the 100% LVT. How would you feel about an LVT that taxed away 80% of the land value?
Better, but still not very positive.
Of course, if someone aids and abets a campaign of harassment against that person
What would this consist of, exactly? I think this is the area most ripe for attack. Under the theory of stocahastic terrorism, public criticism itself, however valid, could certainly be considered "aiding and abetting a campaign of public harassment."
There would be no point for Nick and his attorneys to agree to a trivial settlement when they could go to trial instead and potentially win big.
Plural's contention was that there was in fact almost no potential to win big, so the settlement may very well have been trivial.
Also, what are the arguments against LVT, besides low-effort "taxes are always bad and raising them is evil?" Genuinely curious for well thought out reasons why an LVT would be a bad idea.
My understanding is that this is effectively an opportunity cost tax. I.e., if you are sitting on a valuable plat which could generate 10 M$ in rents with 1 M$ of improvements, the market value of the plat should be about 9M$, and you would be taxed on that value, even if you were only generating 100K$ of rents (including imputed rents).
This is economically very efficient, as it encourages land to be used for its most economically efficient purpose. However, this butts directly up against peoples' real-world desires to "settle" - to establish a home in a place and be able to stay there indefinitely. If, for reasons beyond their control, the price of their property increases, they can be financially forced from their homes, which is about as soulcrushing as being foreclosed upon, while also seeming much more unfair. It destroys a person's ability to make stable long-term plans regarding a very fundamental fact of life. It also destroys residential community, by creating a disincentive to make a community that people want to live in, which has the natural effect of increasing property value. These are already problems with existing property taxes, that would be greatly amplified by taxing away all of the land value (leaving only rents).
After all, most people recoil about applying the same logic in other contexts: should a person's income tax be based on the amount of money they theoretically could be earning, if they worked as much as possible in the most valuable field they are qualified for, in the location with the highest salary? Hard-core utilitarians have seriously proposed this, but the concept of being treated as an economic ends with no function other than to produce social benefit, rather than a sapient being with noneconomic needs and desires makes most people reject this with prejudice.
Same as with Gawker, the concern is using massive judgements to financially ruin someone such that they are effectively silenced by being unable to afford to publish.
Sorry, the parent post just reminded me so much of Lenina Huxley's litany of things that are bad, and therefore banned.
It requires either extremely high pressures or extremely low temperatures to store an appreciable amount of energy per volume. That's why rockets use super-cryogenic liquid hydrogen and vehicles use expensive COPV vessels capable of containing thousands of PSI. These problems in themselves are not deal-breakers, but the other hydrogen fuel cells needed to utilize it effectively have stubbornly refused to come down in price, namely I think due to the inability to find a suitable replacement for the platinum catalyst.
I'm cynical. I believe the plan is to get people so fucked that they need the government, and specifically a nanny-state, far-left, socialist government.
BZZT! You have been fined one credit for a violation of the verbal morality statute.
To do the work of dismantling their privilege
The taboo exists whether you like it or not, and flouting it provides no benefit that I can see.
I don't think that's quite true. Taboos are not objective facts, they are a social consensus. Your argument that an individual alone cannot move social consensus is true enough, but many individuals acting in concert certainly can. Likewise, while it is true that in any given election, your individual vote probably doesn't determine the outcome, it does not follow that all voting is pointless. Taboos can be destroyed, it this is normally done by a small group violating it and not being punished, then more and more, until there is no clear social consensus and the taboo is gone. What objection could you have to that, other than that the taboo is taboo, which is circular?
I predict that as he gets too old for leading man status, Cruise will be the new Eastwood: the Hollywood veteran who actually has a firm grasp on what makes a movie pleasurable for mainstream audiences, taking directing roles that give him lots of creative control and reliably turn solid profits, and the occasional vanity project to flex some underused acting muscles.
Itβs all black in background
Again, background is too dark,
-8:45 shot is too dark
I'm convinced Amazon broke something in the Prime Video app around HDR. I recently started rewatching Season 1 of the Expanse on my phone and could barely make out anything unless I set my phone on maximum brightness. I got an LG OLED TV and noticed the same thing, when I watch certain things on Prime that enable the TV's HDR mode, these same programs (all Amazon originals) are almost unwatchably dark. I don't remember the Expanse looking like that on my old TV, and it was a plasma that couldn't get anywhere near as bright. However, HDR movies like Oblivion or Batman have looked fine. Online, it seems like lots of people have similar issues, that the programs are not just dark in production, but dark to the point of being unable to see almost anything at all.
It's one day, right?
Just call in sick. The only winning move is not to play.
Pre-op trans women are literally hedging the hog.
Poster's point is that Smith is explicitly advocating a "great replacement".
Like /u/FarNearEverywhere says, the expectation of Wall Street is that growth is perpetual, outside of actual innovations that genuinely increase productivity β like a better kind of grape, or a better machine to process them.
And why shouldn't it be? Investors are the ultimate reality-based community, and economies have in reality grown basically forever. Where and in what form this growth happens changes, though. It can change a lot, which is why companies that fail to grow get capital removed and companies that do grow get capital applied.
This is not a moral judgment, though. Investors are not morally shunning companies that fail to grow. It's just that by all appearances, those resources would be more useful elsewhere. It's like selling a guitar you rarely play any more to finance a bicycle that you would ride often. This is not a judgment on the quality of the guitar, or its inherent moral worth, or driven by an unreasonable expectation that the guitar be more useful to you. It's purely an optimization.
You're not anti-semitic, but I would argue you are a dog. A "dog-whistle" is generally just a term of art or piece of jargon that reads differently to those in-the-know than those not in-the-know. I don't think that agreeing with the argument being made is a relevant part of it. The difference is between you hearing it (and disagreeing) vs. it going completely unnoticed by you.

I would think that in a lot of cases, the house would have negative value, since it would have to be demolished and cleared away in order to improve the land.
More options
Context Copy link