@self_made_human's banner p

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


				

User ID: 454

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

					

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


					

User ID: 454

Interesting, I didn't know about this, but to be fair it was before my time.

The polio vaccine hasn't remained the same since inception, for example, in India the live polio vaccine is being phased out for an inert vaccine.

This is because the live vaccine uses an attenuated variant of the virus, which is much less likely to cause harm than the real one, while also having the perk of being infectious in itself.

However, it can cause full blown polio. This was once considered acceptable, but as the number of cases of natural polio dropped, the number of iatrogenic cases became more relevant, and the decision was made to switch to forms without any living virus whatsoever.

People win the lottery despite the odds not being in their favor.

If you've bought a ticket, and then you find a million pounds in your bank account, then congratulations, knowing that the odds were stacked against you doesn't mean you've not won.

I know literally zero people who have been "vaccine maimed". I used to be responsible for a COVID ICU before vaccines too, and I can definitely tell you that I saw plenty die of it.

It is far more likely that you are either:

  1. Lying. On the internet, anyone can be a dog, or claim to be one.

  2. Mistaken.

  3. Surrounded by people who are mistaken or lying.

Assuming 150 people you could "closely know" (Dunbar's number as a first approximation), then someone, somewhere, out there in the world will find 3 people who were harmed by vaccines. Because vaccines are not perfectly safe, and I've never claimed that. If you consider people who are mistaken about their illness being caused by a vaccine, then the number skyrockets.

I suppose I am confused. Development is more important than body weight, but I'll concede the point rather than double down because of my misapprehension

I do genuinely appreciate this, thank you.

To address the rest of your comment, I will point out what I see as potential errors:

  1. The measles vaccine isn't given by itself in most of the world, so you're looking at calculating the combined benefits of simultaneous vaccination for measles, mumps and rubella vs the combined risks.

  2. Restricting the potential harm to just death is incorrect. Even a mild bout of measles has quantifiable harm, and in the link you've provided, they quite clearly mentioned that before vaccination, 3/10 of measles victims had:

Ear infection

Pneumonia

Encephalitis (swelling of the brain)

Subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (a disease characterized by progressive neurological deterioration and early death)

Hemorrhagic measles – includes seizures, delirium, difficulty breathing and bleeding under the skin

Clotting disorder

Death

Pregnant women who are infected with measles can miscarry, deliver early, or have a low-birth-weight baby. People who are immune compromised are at risk of having prolonged and severe illness.

Measles infections can also pave the way for other bacterial and viral infections — even several years later. This may happen because measles infections can wipe out preexisting immunologic memory cells that protect against other infections, such as influenza. Because this same damage to immunologic memory doesn’t happen following vaccination, the measles vaccine also protects the integrity of the immune system.

None of these strike me as very pleasant, leaving aside that that's just one of the three diseases that the MMR shots protect against robustly.

If you wanted to quantify the harms of driving, then you also need to consider disability and not just death, and ideally monetary damages. You also need to look at the benefits, for many people in the US and elsewhere, living without access to a car is debilitating by itself.

I'm left with the conclusion that nobody is willing to discuss the actual risks, they just want to enforce compliance.

As you can see, both I and @throaway05 are more than happy to discuss risks. And so are most other medical professionals, in my experience. The average NHS paediatrician gains nothing personally by taking extra time to talk to patients about their concerns, but does it nonetheless. They don't get to bill you extra for the privilege.

It's unfortunate that your child had a vaccine reaction, but it was a mild one. Even if their wellbeing was your only concern then you should seek to sit a doctor down and go over a proper cost-benefit analysis and even potentially figure out the likely culprit for the previous reaction.

You might as well be feared, if you can't be loved, and there's little love lost for resident doctors on NHS wards.

You might get a kick out of reading this Very Serious case presentation in the BMJ:

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7839907/

This is begging the question.

The realistic question would be, for interventions, that at the time of invention, did not have conclusive evidence in either direction regarding making people "drop dead in 20 years", what proportion were found to do so after 20 years had passed?

The answer would be almost none.

I'm pretty confident that now that the dust has settled, ivermectin turned out not to do anything.

When did the majority of the media claim antiretrovirals didn't work? Paxlovid was a big deal, because it did reduce mortality.

There were "effective medicines" available even before vaccines or paxlovid, corticosteroids were found to help, but only were necessary for those in ICUs, not the average Joe with sniffles.

or ask someone who is not politically compromised (me! me!).

No, ask me! I promise I'm probably cheaper, and if I like you I'll do it for free!

It’s worth noting that the VA is paying for this resident to be there, despite the fact he will in fact not be able to do anything.

As always, American doctors have it better. In the UK, the spectrum of duties for psychiatry residents includes pigeon-control.

Now, I can easily see a British trainee ending up stuck on a placement because they haven't been signed-off to do the work, but the extent of the dysfunction would include not being paid for that month.

LEO rangers

I'm glad to see the Space Force has begun recruitment, and avoided the accusations of ripping off 40k's Space Marines in favor of poaching Airborne infantry.

(I presume this isn't as exciting as it sounds haha)

I'm past my best-by too, I'll see you in the nursing home eventually!

I must point out that for Hep B, if you're advocating for shots on the grounds it's a good idea for a medical provider to have, then you need to keep in mind it can be given at pretty much any point in life.

You don't need it to be a med student. I don't think it's mandatory for doctors in most places, legally or otherwise. I remember when I came to the UK, I put "unknown" as my Hep B vaccination status, because I genuinely couldn't recall, and if I had it, it must have been well after my paediatric vaccinations. This wasn't flagged or followed up on, though I think it's a good idea for a medical professional to get the shot.

I won't defend covid shots for kids. Marginal risks for marginal benefits.

HPV for boys? Infection with high risk strains can increase risk of anal, oropharyngeal and penile cancers. I have no idea if the risks are particularly high in absolute terms, at least not without doing more work than I want to this late. But unlike covid vaccines in kids, it strikes me as plausibly a good idea, even if I suspect that a lot of the net benefit is spreading herd immunity and protecting girls, where HPV actually is a big deal to my knowledge.

Note that this is very rough napkin maths, but I estimate that the average flu shot provides ~ 0.0015 to 0.003 QALYs per shot.

In other words, about a day's worth of perfect health per shot. This probably does matter at the population level, I think it comes to about $10k to $20k per QALY, which isn't bad at all, but per shot, it's rather negligible on an individual basis.

Being healthy for half a day versus having a rather sore arm (and a small additional risk of flu for a few days) is what it boils down to, and I will confess that I can't be bothered most of the time. If someone shows up with a shot and asks me to take it (my grandpa was a stickler about literally doing that), I'd go for it. If it posed even a trivial inconvenience, I wouldn't lose sleep over missing it.

I've had the flu maybe a dozen times (at least counting respiratory infections worse than the average cold) and covid 4+ times (that's how many times I tested positive, and eventually I stopped bothering). None of them were bad enough to overcome my general laziness these days.

Unless you're already sick, immunocompromised, or old, I think you wouldn't really notice the difference between getting a shot and not bothering.

I don't trust your calculations

You can't trust what I haven't presented. I could do so, and I strongly expect to be correct, but I already do enough trawling of medical literature when I'm being paid for it.

It's your child, and I have some respect for your right to make decisions on their behalf, even if I think they're bad decisions.

Furthermore, my children can simply get the shots later in life, when they are grown and have a much larger body mass with which to accommodate, after development has been mostly completed.

My man, you're going from wrong to confused. There's good reason why you don't see doctors or nurses pull out dose calculators to account for body weight when giving every vaccine I can think of it. It's because it doesn't matter. If little Tommy is 4'6 and 35 kilos or 4'9 and 45 makes next to no difference, and this holds true once you're past the size of a premature infant on death's door, going to a land whale who needs a mobility scooter. Vaccines aren't like paracetamol, the dose-response curves are VERY different when it's the immune system we're talking about. Someone with a peanut allergy isn't twice as likely to die if you give them two peanuts versus one.

The eczema finally went away, and there's no way to know the counterfactual, but I think if we were on schedule I'd still be seeing rashes all over the back and legs and ankles

You're not doing a good job at probabilistic reasoning, but an eczematous rash is a minor vaccine reaction, and of very little consequence. If it was life threatening, I presume you'd have pointed that out, and even then, you'd be better off consulting your pediatrician about whether they could narrow it down to a particular constituent of the two common rotavirus vaccines in the States (fetal bovine serum or porcine circovirus, if I had to guess from looking at composition), and take precautions when administering future vaccines with similar compositions. Believe it or not, most doctors would be happy to answer those questions and offer reassurance if warranted, especially if you're paying them.

Flu vaccine? Well, if you want to single it out, then I'd be obliged to say that unless you're sickly, old, or work in healthcare, the benefits are largely a wash when compared to the minimal risk the typical annual flu strain otherwise presents. That would be the case even if the vaccine was perfectly safe. I'm on record saying the same thing, if someone wants to dig years deep into my profile.

If someone doesn't want to get it, no biggie. Hell, even I've missed shots that were offered to me for free because I didn't think it mattered enough.

If you think that citizens have no positive obligations towards improving the commons, I don't see why you'd want to make them worse off.

I don't know what you're pointing at when you say something like:

what with all the accomodations we're expected to make around "living in a society".

Hence I can't really engage with it.

At the very least, KMC's stated reason for opting out of vaccinating their kids, namely because other people are doing so too, and because of a minor drug reaction are terrible on merit alone. The COVID vaccine? I'm well past caring about it, or asking people to, but most others are recommended for very good reason, even for a person who doesn't care about the well-being of others.

Thank you.

I'm not sure if this is "people were lying out of their teeth" rather than "voters aren't smart enough to avoid black-and-white thinking so they don't insist their president be smart enough either", but I think the takeaway is that you can probably trust independently repeated and reviewed studies of vaccine effects and you probably can't trust most popular interpretations of those studies.

That seems like an eminently sensible take, though I can only reiterate that COVID was uniquely politicized, and by the time the typical vaccine reaches market (let alone when it becomes part of a national schedule), the evidence is very strong.

This isn't something I've given much thought before, but even on reflection, I don't think it makes much difference.

The most controversial vaccine is that for Covid. Even then, my impression (memory fades) is that the vaccines were lauded as being more effective than they turned out to be. I don't recall seeing evidence back then, that people were lying out of their teeth, they interpreted unclear, insufficient or ambiguous evidence as proof that vaccines would cut the pandemic short. They didn't, they reduced mortality, but not the spread of Covid.

I can't think of any other vaccine that was remotely as controversial, and my presumption is that the FDA and medical associations, normally do a decent cost-benefit analysis before advocating them. I know NICE does, in the UK.

This comment is a travesty. If it wasn't clear, it is the majority of parents opting-in for scheduled vaccinations that's what creates the commons for you to free-ride off.

Even in a purely disinterested cost-benefit analysis, the odds of your child getting an autoimmune disease from vaccines is so low that the general benefit of them getting sick less often outweighs it. The number of people avoiding vaccination isn't at the point where you're benefiting from opting out, or pointing to others doing so as an excuse. The majority of vaccines are net positive in expectation, regardless of what others do.

Meta-rationality is a hard art to practice. You point to a minority of people hitting defect to defect just as hard.

Excellent comment. One thing I'd like to add is that opting out of vaccination is, to an extent, mooching off the commons.

Herd immunity doesn't work, if parents look at the existing vaccination rates, reasons that their kids will be fine without vaccination as "everyone else" does it, and thus defects.

I corrected this on Reddit, but I guess my ghetto version of version control, copy-pasting back and forth, failed me somewhere.

I'm staring at the nearest tap, and the correct spelling is Tennent's, so I guess we were both wrong haha

Ketamine has merit for treatment resistant depression. Now, I don't know what it would do for someone who is bipolar (Musk has claimed, and then denied, having it), but as drugs to try to solve your mental health concerns, there are worse.

I do expect that whatever he does want to use, recreational or otherwise, he has the best doctors money can buy nominally overseeing it. Not that he necessarily listens to them.

Man, even in the UK, I would get my kids vaccinated for everything on the recommended schedule, and a few extras, such as gardasil even if they're male. Do I need to mention what I'd do in India?

Kids fall sick a ton, and they bring it back home with them.

That being said, I don't see the point of giving the average kid a COVID vaccine, especially if you're paying.

I certainly don't disagree that Altman shouldn't be trusted further than you can throw him, but I do appreciate you being able to say that you concede that one (of many) reasons to distrust him no longer count. Most people, once they've made up their minds, are content to let arguments be soldiers and always count them as MIA even when the body was dropped off with the dog-tags attached.

Given that senior psychiatrists in the business of ADHD prescriptions can charge as high as 800 a go (at the least for the first visit), I don't think you need an aristocrat. Do that long enough and you can probably slip someone money to knight you.

I was looking at 400 for a new assessment to confirm that yes, I have ADHD, that would be done by a psychologist, and about the same for all the rest, including the psych.