@self_made_human's banner p

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


				

User ID: 454

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

					

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


					

User ID: 454

Haven't read it, and don't think I've heard of it before! I had to Google it to confirm it was another work by Wales.

I just caught up with Thresholder , by Alexander Wales.

TL;DR, it's a cross-over isekai/Highlander kinda deal, where characters from across a multiverse are invited to cross through portals and find themselves in a new world. There's another one, and in true Highlander fashion, there can only be one. Once defeated, or victorious, a portal opens up to let the winner through, and if the loser is incapacitated but alive, they get one for themselves.

The MC starts off in media res, as knock-off Iron Man. Good AI assistant, but a suit that's far less powerful. He started off in 2022 Earth, went to Earth 2 that's about 20 years more advanced, where he picked up a genius inventor girlfriend and said suit. He rapidly loses said girlfriend at the hands of another Thresholder, and then continues journeying through worlds in an effort to find a way to resurrect her.

I'd say it's a 7.5/10 fic. Nowhere near as good as Worth The Candle or Metropolitan Man, but a decent enough progression fantasy and a way to kill the time.

Replying primarily because @MadMonzer was kind enough to report himself and this comment for being CW, and likely better suited for posting in the CWR thread. I presume that's where it was meant to go, but if this is, in your honest opinion, a small-scale question, then don't let me keep you haha. But I do think you meant the main thread.

I agree whole-heartedly with @MathWizard .

I write my own novel(s) for two reasons, one being that I want to establish, for reasons not much more noble than "I was considered a good writer back when that was a rare commodity", the other being that since there's very little of the very niche genre of fiction I enjoy, I might as well write my own.

Some authors view the rise of AI writing with fear and panic. I don't, both because I never relied on it for an income (and of course I'm worried about my own job going away) and I read far more than I write.

My default existence is boredom and ennui, desperate trawling and doomscrolling for literature (or any text) that assuages that thirst. There are never enough of the novels I enjoy, the authors I admire never seem to churn out novels faster than I can read them. Some of them, like Banks, are churlish enough to die instead of keeping on writing indefinitely.

Thus, even if I lose a small amount of utility from my writing becoming obsolete, I gain a great deal more from just having a near endless buffet of good writing to read.

Some would deny that AI can ever do that. Those people are idiots.

I think current LLMs are about 70% of the way to replacing me as an author, assuming they're given an excerpt of text I've written and then told to go wild with it. It's only a matter of years before the matter is settled. A year, if I'm being both highly optimistic and pessimistic.

So it goes for most people. For those who aren't making music as a career and who don't reflexively hate AI made music, the endlessly availability of fresh new music in the genres they like is amazing. While surgeons wouldn't be happy about being replaced, someone who got their appendix removed cheaper and safer would be happy about it. At any rate, it's coming for us whether we like it or not.

I think I've been in love, butterflies in the stomach, heart thumping at the sight of them love twice in my life. Mere lust or fondness? I think I've lost count.

The first instance was painful. A pining adolescent romance for someone who was emotionally unavailable, and just not that into me. I thought the fact we were going out on dates and that she was coming over was enough, while doing my best to ignore the fact that while we were in college and her friends were around, she'd treat me as if I was just one of them.

The second... It didn't pan out. At this point I'm well over the bitterness, and I wish I had understood we weren't compatible, but as the bitter and wise say, when you're in love and have rose-tinted goggles on, red flags look just like flags.

The two of them could have passed for sisters (if absolutely nothing alike personality-wise, barring a love for dogs). I guess twice bitten forever shy? I'm sure it'll happen again, if experience is any hint, I never have a choice in the matter. I thought both of them were the One (or two, in rapid succession), and was at the "We'll get married eventually" stages with the latter, but alas.

I tell myself I don't miss them. And it's mostly true.

I believe the term would be a joke, an intentional mixing of metaphors at the very least.

I'd recommend Blindsight by Peter Watts. The aliens are alien, far beyond on us, and don't particularly like us.

In Neal Stephenson's Anathem, a cloistered group of scientist-monks had a unique form of punishment, as an alternative to outright banishment.

They would have a person memorize excerpts from books of nonsense. Not just any nonsense, pernicious nonsense, doggerel with just enough internal coherence and structure that you would feel like you could grokk it, only for that sense of complacency to collapse around you. The worse the offense, the larger the volume you'd have to memorize perfectly, by rote.

You could never lower your perplexity, never understand material in which there was nothing to be understood, and you might come out of the whole ordeal with lasting psychological harm.

It is my opinion that the Royal College of Psychiatrists took inspiration from this in their setting of the syllabus for the MRCPsych Paper A. They might even be trying to skin two cats with one sharp stone by framing the whole thing as a horrible experiment that would never pass an IRB.

There is just so much junk to memorize. Obsolete psychological theories that not only don't hold water today, but are so absurd that they should have been laughed out of the room even in the 1930s. Ideas that are not even wrong.

And then there's the groan-worthy. A gent named Bandura has the honor of having something called Bandura's Social Learning Theory named after him.

The gist of it is the ground-shaking revelation that children can learn to do things by observing others doing it. Yup. That's it.

I was moaning to a fellow psych trainee, one from the other side of the Indian subcontinent. Bandar means a monkey in both Hindi, Urdu and other related languages. Monkey see, monkey do, in unrelated news.

The only way Mr. Bandura's discovery would be noteworthy is if a literal monkey wrote up its theories in his stead. I would weep, the arcane pharmacology and chemistry at least has purpose. This only prolongs suffering and increases SSRI sales.

I don't have any way to do that, though I think Zorba might. I recall there was a measure of how close someone's volunteer janny choices correlated to final moderator action. It's just not exposed with my current privileges.

I'm a witch. Or a principled libertarian advocating for free speech, if one cares to split the difference.

The Motte grew out of a desire for more free speech, including speech on topics that are/were verboten on most of the internet. There is absolutely no pejorative intent, we invite all comers as long as they're polite about things. https://www.themotte.org/post/1657/culture-war-roundup-for-the-week/293159?context=8#context

You happen to have a quasi-ideological dispute going here, but I must remind you that this place is a watering hole for heathens and witches, and often all we ask is that we don't bare wands or claws at each other. Even if someone pisses you off, especially so

There you go. I'm on record saying the same thing with a mod hat on. It's a term I use with pride, and if it's deprecatory, then it must be conceded that it's also self-deprecating. Ever wonder why the volunteer janny page uses a picture of a quokka?

Enjoying your job is a luxury, and one taken for granted all too often. As far as I'm concerned, all I can really demand of a job is that it compensates me for the time spent doing it, at a rate I don't regret.

It's not that people can't enjoy their work. Quite a few do, and get to work on things they'd be doing as a hobby while getting paid for it. But that's too rare to be considered something to be counted on. The majority of people don't enjoy time spent working, but they don't detest it more than the dollars it brings in.

My job is something that I am mildly pleased to be doing, and occasionally rewarding when it's not bureaucratic makework and drudgery. It's still a job, I don't go into work skipping with a smile on my face, I go do it because it pays better than the alternatives. If you've genuinely exhausted your options when it comes to doing work you enjoy, then at that point you have to make peace with not having fun while at least being paid.

What @self_made_human articulated was more or less reddit with a right-shifted Overton window, but not far right enough (yet) to tolerate regular Jewposting. What's the difference between 'we treat anti-semites more harshly because our userbase finds their opinions inflammatory' and 'we moderate conservative opinions much more harshly because they're just sealioning single-issue posters?'

I will push back against this claim. The Motte isn't just reddit with a right-shifted Overton window.

Our Overton window is wider. Enormously so, though not as unique these days as Twitter competes in terms of permissivity if not quality.

There are very few topics that are outright verboten on this site. Most of them would be spam, harassment and the like. You can just about advocate for any viewpoint as long as you do it politely and with enough explanatory force behind the views you endorse.

There's plenty of garbage posts here with nary a fact in them and packed chock-full of opinions I find plenty inflammatory (and even articulated in a much cruder and more inflammatory way than the Jewposter!), and the only difference between them is the opinions of the majority.

Report them! Few of us mods have the time to read each and every comment posted on the site. I once did, when I was rather underemployed, but if something doesn't show up in the report queue, it is much less likely to be moderated, at least promptly.

It's inevitable that unpopular topics will get reported more often, and will thus be moderated more often, even while holding the quality of the comment equal.

For this particular one, the volunteer janny system flagged it as a bad comment, it had multiple reports to boot. We take that into account when making moderation decisions, but it certainly isn't the only thing that matters, our discretion overrides it if we deem a comment to be within the rules despite people (rarely) reporting on vibes rather than the merits of a comment. There are users so consistently downvoted that they'd never leave the filter queue if we didn't override it. This place isn't a majoritarian free-for-all, we do our best to accommodate unpopular viewpoints.

Cirrus had multiple warnings, and was hit with a ban for a single day. That's a slap on the wrist as punishments go, and he is welcome to reframe the same point as long as he meets our other guidelines.

You're correct that that hypothetical comment wouldn't be moderated, even if it's not quite the level of quality we hope users aspire to.

If you had to ask for my rationale in not moderating it, my reasoning would be along the lines that it is a far less inflammatory claim. It doesn't take much effort to show a dozen examples of far-leftists strongly advocating for the death of the American Empire. I'm sure if we asked politely, we'd find a few on the site itself!

Our rules about inflammatory comments and evidence implicitly assume a subjective reference frame. That is sadly unavoidable. Someone advocating for the death penalty for pedophiles and rapists would be treated very differently from people saying that miscegantors and homosexuals should be put to death, in the former cases, the arguments being made draw on significantly more cultural consensus and common-knowledge (implicitly). We allow the latter class of argument, you can call for homesexuality and race-mixing to be made illegal, we demand additional explanation and rigour to your argument even if it bottoms out in subjective personal beliefs.

Speaking ill of the Jews is allowed, or else Secure Signals wouldn't be posting here. That he is, is a sign that he (usually) meets our standards of discourse.

It would be too much to expect that we can keep everyone happy when it comes to our judgement about what counts as inflammatory and needing justification versus what is a clear and self-evident Truth™, but that's unavoidable, and we try to find a balance.

Do you have concrete examples in mind? I don't think we treat Jews any different, it's just that they're probably the ethnicity most singled-out by our resident witches. I'm pretty sure we'd at least warn if not ban for similar comments for other groups that don't meet our standards for effort or pro-active production of evidence.

Everything is far more locked down, which can be good (less indiscriminate distribution of antibiotics), or rather annoying at best.

I was used to just asking for prescription meds at home by using my credentials as a doctor, or just writing myself a prescription. This, while not outright illegal in the UK, is highly frowned upon by the GMC. Which is bullshit paternalism, I find claims that doctors can't be trusted to judge their own health questionable.

The wait times can be terrible. If it's an urgent crisis, you'll get seen quickly, say someone contacting their GP with suicidal ideation. For something like getting assessed for ADHD, it can take >2 years for an appointment, unless you go private.

Oops. Thanks for the reminder.

As a side note, I moderate less than I could because I have to switch themes every time, and the default white flashbangs my eyes. Trivial inconveniences stack up :(

You're breaking so many damn rules in one comment I'm mildly impressed. You have not proactively (or on demand) produced any evidence to suggest a conspiracy of the Jews. Or that they have anything to gain from weakening the British state. Inflammatory, boo-outgroup, throw it all in, toppings are free with this sandwich.

You've been warned in the past, and I'm giving you a short ban so you know they have teeth. Even our most fervent anti-semites hustle to meet posting standards, and I'd advise you do so too.

I recall reading some evidence that antihistamines and anti-inflammatories slow down recovery from illness, but the effect sizes seem too small to make a real difference.

For something like a cold or a flu, I doubt it'll matter, and the trade-off of being able to be more active and productive outweighs things.

Hold up. India is catching strays here for no good reason.

We have DOTs programs. They're paid for domestically, and while I'm sure donations are accepted, the largest source of foreign aid I could see is a $400m loan from the World Bank. I believe USAID has spent about $140M since 1998.

TB treatment is a national priority, and immense amounts of effort are put into DOTs, surveillance and follow-up.

India has a compulsory licensing scheme for life-saving drugs, which you're free to disagree with (good luck coercing a nuclear power or directly attacking it). It sells generics for about 10% of the retail price in the States.

I did some napkin maths:

The Indian state saves about $1 billion through CL a year, so about 5 billion USD by 2030. The US would lose a maximum of around 3 billion a year on pharma revenue, but that's with the unrealistic assumption that there wouldn't be any cost-negotiation or the availability of generics.

The CDC shows that TB treatments in the US can cost tens of thousands for normal TB, 150k for MDR and >500k or more for XDR.

You guys have around an order of ~100 MDR cases a year already. That is despite screening for immigrants and travelers being put in place.

If India paid standard prices, they're looking at about $100 billion for the same level of care. This would be untenable in practice, and TB incidence would soar. This would have knock-on effects, both globally, and in the States, existing screening is already rigorous, so God knows how much you'd end up paying when more MDR and XDR TB cases pop up. I'm not qualified to put firm numbers on the expense, but it ranges from anywhere between 10 million USD to 1 billion USD a year in treatment costs.

You'd be looking at quite serious economic fallout from sanctions, and the theoretical gains of about $2B USD PA are unlikely to manifest, since if India somehow was forced to stop using generics, they'd likely just spend less and then face an explosion in TB cases that wouldn't particularly respect borders. If the US really put the squeeze on, then India could well retaliate by flooding international markets with generics for other drugs.

And of course, do you really want to piss of another >billion strong nuclear power which is a willing partner against China? From a pragmatic point of view, I'd wager not.

In India, we have TB treatment protocols that mandate observation by a doctor or nurse when the medication is dispensed, and the patient has to take it while they're watching. That's the only real way to deal with poor adherence, which often leads to MDR or XDR TB.

They'll chase you to your home if they have to, though I don't think they have any legal recourse beyond strongly insisting you take your damn medicine.

At any rate, the generic drugs are dirt cheap, and within the budgets of even most third world countries to begrudgingly dole out even if the aid tap is cut off.

Once I started working in the UK, I discovered to my frank confusion that the standard treatment of a cold was to do nothing. No actual meds, maybe treat the fever symptomatically with paracetamol or ibuprofen.

Back in India, we used to prescribe antihistamines for it on the regular. I looked up the evidence base, and most studies claimed that they didn't help. I still disagree, both from seeing patients benefit, and personal use. Levocetrizine +- montelukast got me through multiple bouts of covid, and they mitigate the sniffles in normal colds enough that you can at least be functional while you're sick. I presume you should be able to acquire either cetirizine, levocetrizine or another OTC antihistamine, though I'm not going to handle the headache of looking up brand names. If you can get the original Sudafed, with pseudoephedrine, that might help too.

Thank you! I doubt I'll be maxing that out anytime soon, so it's good to know.

Thank you! I'll try and make good use of it.

There is a leader board, that AFAIK only mods can view. Last time I checked, which was a while back, I think I was tied first for most blocked user. Not that I mind, I prefer high variance and strong appeal to a minority over blandness in an effort to be slightly liked by everyone.

I appreciate your concern, but if it helps, I'm willing to explain my stance.

I strongly expect widespread technological upheaval and even widespread unemployment by the turn of the century. If that does not come to pass, and human skilled labor retains its value, then a more standard portfolio that sacrifices returns for stability would be something I would be willing to pivot to. In hindsight, that would represent half a decade of suboptimal investment.

I don't intend to YOLO onto tech stocks, I seek to invest heavily in American index funds, which I am happy to hear is more or less sensible according to the responses. I intend to spend only a few thousands, per year, on more volatile actions like stock picking.

Even if I suddenly realize, oh shit, I need to save for retirement and college for my (future) kids, that realization would take hold in my early 30s. I would only need to liquidate some of my holdings and reinvest them. I'm not advocating for taking short timelines as an excuse to put * all* financial planning out the window, but I think that a 5 year cutoff is reasonable according to my beliefs about the future of technology and its ramifications on industry. Some might want to withdraw into unchecked hedonism, content in hopes that a post-scarcity civilization will bail everyone out, but I acknowledge that as a possibility while not forgetting that hey, it's good to hold onto your money and grow it for now.