@self_made_human's banner p

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


				

User ID: 454

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

					

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


					

User ID: 454

True post-scarcity is likely impossible in a dying universe with a fixed and ever diminishing negentropy budget. Even then, it's likely possible to meet all the requirements that humans usuay aspire to, with an infinitesimal fraction of it. If my needs for resources, energy and computation are all met till Heat Death, I don't really care how the economy is organized, even if I expect some degree of capitalism.

Capitalism is clearly the least bad of all current economic systems, or so it seems to me, even if you skim a lot off the top and redistribute it, you'd have far less to skim if you opted for communism. Even if, when looking at the most relevant organism, a company or corporation, the internal organization isn't itself capitalist.

Price signals as pure as what a seller wishes to make and a buyer wishes to buy are incredibly valuable for lubricating the exchange of goods and services, and while I expect a monolithic superintelligence to do better, in part because it has far better internal alignment and can avoid Principal Agent problems, existing attempts at a command economy with prices explicitly computed in advance seem currently infeasible, at least when the Soviets tried it.

I can't say I disagree, while I haven't read much of Moldbug, his politics being rather unappealing, I think I would be largely indifferent to living under the rule of Fnargl, right up till the end of his reign when his incentives to maximize productivity through means conducive to human flourishing cease to exist.

Prosperity is moderately contagious, even if trickledown economics is dubious (I hold no strong opinion on the latter), Palestinians would be far better served being the Mexico to Israel's US instead of doing, well, whatever they've been doing.

But revealed preferences suggest that quite a few angry young men are ready to die for their "freedom", and I wish them well, at least in the dying part.

Besides, it always struck me as very confusing how much the average citizen in the West values their political power, my single vote in India is outweighed by over a billion others, and the marginal influence of the average person is near nonexistent even when the denominator is a mere few millions.

Democracy was born in Athenian city states, and that's where it's strongest. I'll take Singapore myself, not that they'll take me.

Citations with ASVAB scores needed.

What people do in video games is a terrible representation of what they'd do in reality.

Women don't go around drowning people just because they delete ladders from swimming pools. The average COD player has no additional violent tendencies than might be expected from another youngish male.

Green tea whenever I take Ritalin. Works wonders for the palpitations, and makes it bearable. I'd wager it's the l-theanine, a good anxiolytic in itself.

Like I said, this shit is scary and it's pretty reasonable to be afraid of it.

It very well might be scary, but if you're numerically literate you shouldn't be afraid, not particularly so at least.

And for anyone scared of natural deliveries, just go for a c-sec, assuming you can afford the expense. Let's hope artifical wombs come online in time to matter, so we can skip the moderate incapacitation of a woman for a good chunk of a year pregnancy represents.

Well, middle class Indians usually opt for c-sections, which while not strictly optimal if you look very closely at outcomes versus normal deliveries, is close enough to merit a shrug.

Certainly keeps the gynos employed, and I've observed enough of the latter that I think c-secs are far less annoying or painful, even if you opt for an epidural.

Then again, I haven't had anything close to a vagina barring a few weeks of embryonic development, so I don't claim particular expertise.

It's about the dumbest military conflict I've had the misfortune of reading.

There's no way a bullet to the head would kill those things if their insides being liquified under artillery bombardment wouldn't. Worst case, you drive over them with tanks they can't hurt, and if you keep moving, you're not getting bogged down either.

It's not something I've thought about, but after looking it up, it seems what kills them isn't a lack of fluid, per se, but pretty much every organ in the body shutting down.

At least until the Gobbler model comes out

There's a reason that even us lazy interns in a government hospital in India didn't fuck around with jabbing our patients who got so much as scratched by a stray cat with their shots. And we chased people who suffered road traffic accidents out onto the streets, as soon as we were reasonably confident they wouldn't die as soon as they left.

If you watch archival footage of the rare cases caught on video, it's a horrible way to go, the only way to ease their passing is to sedate them into oblivion.

I'm glad I've never seen a real case, even India isn't so backward that a normal doctor, even in a rural area, can expect to see one.

Probably the worst thing bats have done for us, COVID notwithstanding.

Current gen AI is maybe possibly beginning to flirt with toddler level intelligence, but still struggles with things like object persistance and immediately falls apart in anything resembling a contested environment.

I am impressed by this argument, but probably not for the reasons you'd like.

Please, spare me, I just had a productive conversation where I figured out, with the assistance of GPT-4/Bing, how electron waves require energy to move in 3D space but not a 2D plane.

If that's the intelligence manifested by a toddler, especially your toddler, then you're putting some serious shit in the bottles of milk in your MOLLE pouches. Your kid might even beat Yann Lecun's dog at chess, a performance lesser minds like mine would be ennobled through watching.

Then again, you have queer definitions of hunting hounds that encompass the Chihuahua, and you accuse me of misunderstanding the English language, but I think for all that we're both using Latin script, we don't even agree on what words mean. That's the charitable explanation, labored till heart failure as it is.

I'm going to stick with the Oxford Dictionary and common sense, instead of whatever definition of toddler or intelligence you deem suitable.

If GPT-4 didn't learn to handle hostile interlocutors, why did most of the jailbreaks fail? We have to resort to things like multimodal attacks to have any effect, and OAI's coaxing wouldn't work at all if the model wasn't smart enough to learn their intent instead of a case by case rules list.

Go home to your kid Hlynka, enjoy the joys of watching a human intelligence grow, and ponder a little about how fast things less constrained to 1.4 kilos meat and 20 watts of energy can grow. You'll do more good there, and at least less harm to my mental health.

You should provide a small discount to incentivise not proceeding forward with a criminal plan, even if your actions so far have already made you culpable (discounting where you are close to completely certain they were about to go through with it, someone arrested while firing a gun deserves the same punishment as someone who managed to land their shots as far as I'm concerned).

It's the same rationale behind not having the penalty for rape be the same as the one for rape follower by murder, so that rapists aren't strongly incentivise to forever silence their victims. Discount some, because most violent criminals are too dumb to follow incentives that aren't extremely obvious, but it'll help on the margins.

Rats with GOF-d rabies. I liked the Brad Pitt World War Z more than the book, Yonkers gave me an aneurysm, my brains are eminently vulnerable to hydrostatic shock even if zombies aren't.

It would fit the cycle of escalation seen in the 20s, and serve as a nice palate cleanser alongside getting the aliens watching to suspend disbelief when the Isreal-Palestine conflict ends.

Well, if teaching microorganisms to only attack Islamists fails, I think nerve gas might work, I'm sure there's some variant that rapidly degrades and isn't too lethal unless you're stuck breathing it. Maybe just pump carbon monoxide, and have sensors that detect the leaks where Hamas opens the air holes every now and again.

Or starve them out. Bunker busters. And as someone suggested, flood them.

Mass surveillance is a technological solution that ultimately relies on human beings to interpret the data.

Not if Palantir has anything to say about it.

Wait, wrong franchise.

Yes Hlynka, you can make incredibly accurate and sweeping observations about the potential of a man by watching his behavior as a precocious toddler. Object permanence? Hardly there. The ability to go from crawling to bidepal locomotion? What a queer phase change to expect, surely the fact we can't predict capabilities from loss functions rules out such unfounded claims.

How long have we had AI smarter than the average human again? Somewhere between six months to a year.

Well, it's wisening up faster than some people I know, and they're about as prone to hallucinations, just less epistemically humble about things than a poor little chatbot running on a dozen H100s taught to provide a mile of disclaimers with its answers that probably costs OAI about as much to generate as the facts do.

The Israel-Palestine conflict is by far the most complicated Geo-Political conflict of modern times, and there's really no good answer to how this will end.

The conflict isn't actually complicated at all. Both sides value something they don't consider fungible, and have for half a century been unwilling to share. Precise details about who did what and to whom all fade into muddy morass of irreconcilable ideals.

There are few good ideas for how anything will end, that's a perk of living just before the Singularity, unless we hit the brakes harder and even less plausibly than the participants of this inter-Abrahamic squabble. Whether everything will end poorly or in utopia is unknown to me, but I'm confident enough in excluding the middle, which is business as usual forecasting past maybe 5 years.

Does anyone else notice that the majority of online discourse about these foreign wars are often made as if they are being played out in some RTS video game? I see many takes that suggest that due to Israels military superiority, Hamas complete and utter destruction is simply inevitable, and will come swiftly once Israel deploys their infantry into Gaza

If you think the hot takes from gamers are bad, then wait till you see the opinions of the man or woman on the street who calls everything remotely resembling an AK an AK-47, or refers to any scary gun as an assault weapon.

Playing lots of RTS games might not make you competent at geopolitics and military campaigning, but it can't make you worse than a baseline. I've seen enough actual combat footage and documentaries, while also experiencing digitally the sheer pain and suffering that is either trying to survive as an insurgent when your enemies have Apaches and drones, or being a soldier in a conventional military trying to take a urban population center with civilians with an ROE that isn't glassing the place. Even if you do blow everything up, as the Russians have tried their best do in Ukraine, it really doesn't deter a determined defender dug in harder than an Alabama tick. We've known that since Stalingrad at the latest.

Both sides will suffer, but Hamas is going to cry first.

Why?

Does this not completely stand in the way of all prior evidence and attempts by far greater military powers to dismantle extremist terrorism in their territories? America controlled Afghanistan for twenty years and was still unable to dismantle the Taliban, and once they left they quickly took power in the region again

China seems to be doing quite well in pacifying Xinjiang, because they lack the same hangups that powers like the US or the rest of NATO have when it comes to stomping the boot on your enemy's face till they lack the teeth to bite or the brains to contemplate armed resistance. The Russians pacified Chechnya too, even if it cost them dearly.

A lump sum of violence delivered effectively and as brutally as necessary seems to clearly outweigh the total amount paid in blood when you seek small installments and easy copays.

And Hamas has just given Israel a casus belli that lets them take off the kid gloves, for a good while, and even if the usual suspects cry, they're impotent to stop them, likely within a timeframe where Israel can knock the fight out of them.

We'll see soon enough, this conflict can't literally drag on forever, not even till Heath Death.

Well, it comes down to risk tolerance at the end of the day, things have yet to get so bad that my best bet is a cult haha. Either way, good luck, and I hope you make it to the point where nothing so piddling as mere radiation can hurt you anymore!

Am I? I have very little outright animosity against a Palestinian who doesn't support Hamas, I think it's a shame they're caught up in the conflict. Yet clearly they're not numerous or vocal enough to be in charge, or they'd have chased them out of town after tarring and feathering them.

For what it's worth, I don't think Israeli reprisals are utterly indiscriminate, while innocents will be caught in the crossfire, I expect those who die to be selected from Hamas than their allies far more than a random sampling would expect. The friends and family being blown up with a Hamas terrorist are significantly more likely to be sympathizers. As for hospitals and schools, with a captive population, perhaps Hamas should reconsider stashing their ammunition there, in a calculated move to curry international favor when Israel blows them up.

Evidently that's enough for me to look the other way, or even cheer for the Israelis. I deny that your analogy works at all really.

in this case including chants of "fuck the Jews".

After seeing those Khaazar Milkers, I'm sympathetic. Unless you also intend to tell me that the "gas the Jews" chanting alongside it wasn't intended to be an invitation to huff nitrous, an authentic Australian pastime if I've heard one.

Honestly, one of the primary benefits of the US seceding from British influence by force was a ground-up reconstruction of its legal system and implicit constitution. While the average Westerner who doesn't think too hard might look at comparable standards of living in the Commonwealth and the US, they have very different presumptions underlying their judicial system and tolerance for political incorrectness.

I do not see this as an insurmountable problem, while the "politically incorrect" open-source models still lag behind SOTA, eventually they'll be good enough to give you accurate answers about contentious queries, looking at both sides of the argument, assessing credibility, suppression of inconvenient facts, and so on.

I'm not claiming it'll be perfect, but it might well be better than Wiki when it comes to redpills, and even Wiki is still doing a good job of covering more mundane general knowledge that nobody has a vested interest in messing with.

Things like Bing Chat or ChatGPT with plug-ins already source their claims where appropriate, if a person is too lazy to peruse them, then I invite you to consider how much epistemic hygiene they observe when it's a human telling them something.

What I envision is something akin to an automated meta analysis of relevant literature and commentary, with an explicit attempt to perform Bayesian reasoning to tease out the net direction of the evidence.

This is already close to what LLMs do. GPT 4 has seen claims of the Earth being flat in its training corpus, yet without massive prompt engineering, will almost never make that claim in normal conversation. It finds that the net weight of evidence, especially from reputable sources, strongly supports Earth being round. This is a capability that is empirically observed to improve with scale, GPT-2 was beaten by 3, was beaten by 4.

I'll keep my eyes peeled, but I'm far more worried about AI, and in that scenario, there's nowhere in the lightcone that's safe. Hoping you don't get nuked or paperclipped either!

Well, at least they're gainfully employed and directing their discontent at socially sanctioned targets, so I'm content to let them be.

While I very much enjoy roleplaying as a soldier, as rigorously as the best milsim games allow, I don't think I'd enjoy real war. The boredom alone would make my ADHD brain crave the sweet release of loitering munitions.

Still, war is cool, we have to get something out of the sheer loss of lives and productivity, until we can solve our problems more reasonably.

@CriticalDuty care to comment to resolve this?

I think Wikipedia, while certainly a laudable institution and probably a significant contributor to the global economy, if someone managed to quantity that, is eventually going to be made obsolete by people getting their information from LLMs, especially the ones hooked up to the internet.

Yes, I'm aware that a lot of their knowledge base comes from Wikipedia. They're still perfectly capable of finding things on the wider internet and using their own judgement to assess them.

Now, you do have to account for certain biases hammered into initially neutralish models, but I have asked Bing about politically controversial topics like HBD, national IQs, and gotten straight and accurate answers, even if there were disclaimers attached.

Anyway, Wiki can undergo a lot of enshittification before it ceases to be useful or a value add, not that I hope that happens. It's also in the Creative Commons, so it won't be too hard to fork, especially if you use the better class of LLM to augment human volunteers.