@self_made_human's banner p

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


				

User ID: 454

self_made_human

amaratvaṃ prāpnuhi, athavā yatamāno mṛtyum āpnuhi

16 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2022 September 05 05:31:00 UTC

					

I'm a transhumanist doctor. In a better world, I wouldn't need to add that as a qualifier to plain old "doctor". It would be taken as granted for someone in the profession of saving lives.

At any rate, I intend to live forever or die trying. See you at Heat Death!

Friends:

A friend to everyone is a friend to no one.


					

User ID: 454

*Everyone except me. I refuse to wirehead on principle. My Skinner box must be painted and well decorated to distract me.

There's definitely strong selection bias in effect. The people who aren't hardcore fans are almost certainly not paying money for access.

Funnily enough, I personally think that the war in Afghanistan wasn't violent enough. If you can't solve your problems through violence, you're not applying enough violence. The American brass thought you could win against an insurgency by being nice, and that never gets you anywhere I'm afraid.

I have heard of Combat Mission before, but haven't had the pleasure of playing it. Looking at it, definitely seems up my alley. I'll see about tracking down a copy, thanks!

Oh, I was a fan of the series, at least back when they were putting full episodes on YT. I'm not enough of a fan to pay for their bespoke platform. I know quite a few vets, and they heartily endorse the show, most of the jokes have a generalized kernel of truth to them.

That people might therefore hold practically unfalsifiable beliefs about the nature of this incident is more a reflection of lack of trust in the establishment than people desperately clinging to their priors.

That's why I explained general impressions and attitudes on the ground. Dundee has been entirely quiet, all the screaming and shouting has happened in Terminally Online circles. Funnily enough, I passed through the city today, and people do not give two fucks.

Disregard the police report, if you absolutely must (and I think this is dumb, but can't stop people), but nobody here is actually up in arms about it. That alone should be cause for update. Without naming names, certain Mottizens have, as I predicted, not updated one jot. They're lost causes, and I do not say that lightly. For the skeptical, we can disagree on the degree of skepticism warranted, but at least you haven't gone from the extreme of having a mind so open your brains fall out to the opposite, a brain so insensitive to new information that it's practically calcified. That makes us practically half-cousins.

With respect, the fuck is this? People believing themselves to be Napoleon or Jesus or fucking married to Professor Snape on the astral plane do not mean that any of those things are real. The systematic, extended, and horrific abuse of young women and girls in Great Britain by aliens, which was explicitly and deliberately covered up and minimized by the government and media, was a real thing that happened to real people, in spite of people claiming it didn't happen. Conversely, no one in Europe had social or sexual relations with Lucifer the Archenemy, uses hexes to spoil crops or kill livestock, spied on their neighbors through the eyes of a familiar spirit, or flew through the air on a broomstick.

Hang on. You're pattern matching something I've said, into something I did not.

My point was:

  1. There were a non-zero number of "witches", including people who self-identified as such.
  2. Such people obviously did not fuck Lucifer or ride brooms in the sky, unless they picked the wrong mushrooms.
  3. Far too many people were accused, of being witches, than there ever were "actual" witches
  4. This lead to many women who hadn't done anything objectionable cowering in fear. And to the Inquisitors and gullible peasants imagining witches behind every bump in the night and stillborn calf.

The UK has/had rape gangs. I have specifically alluded to the fact that I'm aware of this. I have explained that such rape gangs are thin on the ground in Dundee and similar cities in Scotland, and there is little reason to imagine their involvement in this scenario beyond rampant pattern matching.

On the Right, there is far more popular demand for Scottish rape gangs run by migrants than there are, in fact, actual migrant rape gangs. Specifically in the less urbanized parts of Scotland. I took great pains to make the limits of my knowledge, and that of my ignorance, very clear.

In fact, I have responded to the previous incident in Dundee:

https://www.themotte.org/post/2899/culture-war-roundup-for-the-week/359937?context=8#context

The police proactively tracked down the gang. There was, as far as I can ascertain, no period where citizens had to take to the streets, where whistleblowers went hoarse, while the coppers tried to suppress the magnitude of the case. That is the polar opposite of a cover-up! As far as I can see, that is a reason to trust the police there more than you would by default, for British cops.

That is a rather important thing to keep in mind. Which way, Western Man? Trust the Dundee constabulary more for cracking down on a minor sex trafficking ring, or despise and distrust them because of something that happened on the other end of the country? It is, at the very least, exceedingly poor form to use their success to condemn what they say later.

For everyone else, the police statement, local skepticism, and sociological context should nudge your priors at least a little.

I think that sums up my stance, and is, in fact, what I actually said. I am not leaning uncritically on the police report, I consider it significant, but I have taken pains to explain the local sociocultural milieu.

Just like trusting a random dude on social media, trusting official sources is just outsourcing your critical thinking to people that have repeatedly proven themselves unworthy of that trust.

Also lol at the idea distrusting the authorities is the modern equivalent of a witch hunt. Was it Matthew Hopkins Witchfinder Footsoldier? Who ran the Spanish inquisition again?

The fuck? Scott has a point about "bounded distrust". Governments, and their official mouthpieces are neither infinitely trustworthy nor untrustworthy. You can throw just about anything Pyongyang says into the trash, other nations command more credibility. Britain is not North Korea.

If firefighters ask you to evacuate your building because of a gas leak, don't tell me you're going to go lighting matches to see for yourself, because you don't trust a damn thing The Man tells you.

What is that I imagine hearing you say? I'm strawmanning you? Then I'd invite you to reconsider attempting to brand me as someone slavishly dependent on the "official" take.

A very important thing to note here:

The police proactively tracked down the gang. There was, as far as I can ascertain, no period where citizens had to take to the streets, where whistleblowers went hoarse, while the coppers tried to suppress the magnitude of the case. That is the polar opposite of a cover-up! As far as I can see, that is a reason to trust the police there more than you would by default, for British cops.

Further, while the people involved seem reprehensible, their crimes seem far tamer than what was going on in, say, Rotherham.

This specific example:

One of the charges he was convicted of was under the Human Trafficking Act, by forcing a woman into prostitution.

Prosecutor Lisa Gillespie KC said this victim had been sold a "pipe dream" of how she could make "lots of money" from selling her body.

Excuse me? It sounds like this particular lady signed up for this. Doesn't sound like she was beaten or drugged. At worst, she was a victim of false advertising. If being sold dreams of money were illegal, most influencers on TikTok or Insta would be in jail tomorrow.

(Just to make it very clear, these guys were also convicted of relatively more clear-cut cases of rape, but this is not what people normally imagine when they think of forced prostitution or sex trafficking)

I appreciate it, and trust me, I know. In this particular situation, I was blindsided. I expected person A to call me to figure out how to potentially exfiltrate their brother from a British hospital (and I have a consultant uncle who works nearby, might even be the same trust). I was in very deep with Person B before I realized, hang on a second, when are we getting to your brother? By that point, I was concerned for her life.

In this particular case, everyone involved needs to be involuntarily committed, and the keys thrown away. A whopping two of them were, in fact, hospitalized, but had family pull strings to get them out. After they had made a good faith effort to murder said family! One of those incidents happened in the States! Half the people involved are American citizens! I knew the Indian psychiatric system can be... less than ideal, but this had me rolling around in the throes of a seizure.

The bad news: your family will ask for medical advice. Your friend's partner will complain about her vaginal discharge. Your barber will start telling you about their suicide attempt in the 8th grade.

This is just how it works in India. Doctors are expected to dish out advice for free, especially to friends and family. And you know what? I support this. It works fine. My dad and grandpa delivered me by c-sec, while my grandma would have been in there too if it wasn't for the fact that there was no more room for grossly overqualified assistants. The world didn't end, nobody died, and nobody can ever accuse my dad of not being there in the delivery room.

This is normal. This is good. In India, the expectation that you will treat your own kin is as natural as chai at 5:00 pm, and - at risk of being stripped of my NHS badge - I genuinely think it mostly works. The West, meanwhile, has spun this elaborate theory that doctors must not treat their own families because they’ll lose “clinical detachment” or “objectivity” or some other deontological talisman. This, in my opinion, is a spectacular act of collective catastrophizing. The reality is, my parents cared more about our family’s gynae problems because it was their family. They didn’t suddenly forget the Krebs cycle or lose their ability to prescribe antibiotics at the whiff of a cousin’s maiden name.

("I can't operate on that boy, he's my son!" - An absolute pussy, that's the solution to the riddle)

When I was back in India recently, I gently confirmed what I already suspected, my nephew had all the hallmarks of ADHD. I pushed, with the full force of my reputation and family standing, for my cousins to get him properly assessed. If I hadn’t, nobody else would have. He’d have spent another decade wondering why school was a personal hell designed for someone else. My family listened, partly because I’m a psychiatry trainee, but mostly because I’m family.

Let’s be honest: nobody objects when the family architect drafts blueprints for free, or the family mechanic fixes your brakes after dinner. Nobody gets a lecture on “professional boundaries” when Auntie fixes your tax returns. Yet somehow, doctors are supposed to recuse themselves because of the overwhelming risk that love and affection will erode our capacity to wield a stethoscope.

I consciously refrain from doing much of this, these days, at least in the UK, both because it's not the culture and because the GMC lacks a sense of humor.

Also with respect to psychiatry - don't sleep with your patients. It sounds stupid advice but it isn't.

Haven't fallen into that trap, and I don't intend to! The GMC had me remove "Grippy socks, grippy box" from my flair, on pain of death. Goddamit, are there any perks left in the profession?

Maybe we can at least have the family C-section, even if it makes for a very confusing set of post-op notes and insurance claims.

I need better professional boundaries. I gave well-intentioned general advice to a Redditor back in India, after their brother had ended up committed to a psychiatric hospital in the UK. They'd commented in /r/India seeking advice on how to bring them back. I was surprised when I received a DM request from a new account, wanting to talk to me. I had assumed it was related, and was happy to guide them through things step by step or put them in touch with medicolegal aid.

No, as I found out, only after I assented to their request to get on a phone call with me. I have probably scandalized or traumatized half the compartment in my train back to Scotland, solely on the basis of what they could overhear of my end of the conversation. I am definitely conked. I did not expect to hear Soprano-tier drama, involving petty Indian royalty, murder, rape, arson, fraud, kidnapping and levels of familial dysfunction and violence beyond belief. Almost everyone in this story is an awful person who almost deserves the things that have happened to them. I have a new benchmark for generational trauma.

The only thing preventing me from calling the cops is that I'm not entirely sure that the lady I was speaking to was sane. Nothing I have said is an exaggeration, I have a splitting headache and need some sleep.

The only real blondes I've seen up here are the Golden Retrievers. They've usually got better, silkier lashes too.

There are very brown secretaries, almost guaranteed to have fake lashes and nail extensions alongside lips that look like an anaphylactic reaction! Scottish beauty standards for women are wack, some of them are more bronzer than water by body weight.

I used to be Caucasian before being exposed to the merciless heat of the Caledonian countryside?

Eh? Smartphones have made my life immeasurably better (well, I can measure it, in the sense I would willingly pay a lot of money for a phone if there was no other way to get one cheaper).

  1. It's a phone. People forget these devices do, sometimes, allow for phonecalls.
  2. It is a very convenient and half-decent camera.
  3. I can use the internet anywhere I please.
  4. I read books on it.
  5. There are very few tasks that make me want to shift to my iPad, gaming laptop or gaming pc. Mostly if I need to handle complex forms, multitask a lot, or need the screen real-estate. I do 99% of my writing on my phone, I can touch type on a virtual keyboard with my eyes closed, no joke.

The ball is very white as far as I'm personally concerned. Being even 50% as good at {everything} as a larger, more dedicated device is inherently valuable, especially when they fit in your pocket and carry charge for a whole day. I'd say it's closer to 80-90% in actuality.

I am, in fact, rather fond of Wikipedia. It is a handy utility.

It also, quite helpfully, notes that the ethnogenesis of modern Bulgarians, includes, among others:

Bulgars – a semi-nomadic Turkic tribal federation, possibly from Central Asia, which settled in the northeast of the Balkans in the 7th century CE, federated with the local Slavic and Slavicized population, organised early-medieval Bulgarian statehood and bequeathed their ethnonym to the modern Bulgarian ethnicity, while eventually assimilating into the Slavic population

The couple in question, while ethnically ambiguous, look "Turkic". It is certainly not out of the question, unlike labeling the offspring of two Nigerian immigrants as Welsh might be. I have functioning eyes, and the myopia is corrected by glasses.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cunning_folk

"I'm a witch, but I'm one of the good ones you see!"

I obviously do not think that "witches" ever had any form of supernatural power.

I dunno dawg. I googled "Bulgarian people", and they pass to me.

Next, you'll tell me the people of Brownland are actually yellow.

(Thanks, even if I meant brown as in the standard definition of "brown people", I'll correct it)

Although 'hand axe' and 'hatchet' are often used interchangeably in contemporary usage

I presume this axe was wielded by hand, unless the young lady had unprecedented access to heavy industrial equipment.

Respectfully, I don't find "Scotland is not England." persuasive in and of itself. Can you elaborate on what factors are present in England that aren't in Scotland that should change our priors in this case?

There are far fewer migrants about. That's the big one. In the small town I used to live in, we had about five brown people, including yours truly. Think the couple running a hotel, a few working part time at an Indian restaurant or convenience store. Dundee is larger, sure, but it is far from cosmopolitan. Most Asians present are either students in the local unis, professionals like me, or working in small businesses. There is no massive, self-perpetuating nucleus of questionably employed refugees, asylum seekers or layabouts on the dole. I presume such folk are less constrained by the vagary that is the availability of psych training posts, or, like them, I'd have moved to somewhere with better weather. They prefer to go to the nearest mini-Mirpur once they've stashed the boat and made a run for the hills, and that would be somewhere in England.

This, in turn, breeds a more congenial attitude towards those of us who do live up there. While there are many Scots who dislike immigrants, they're not constantly confronted by massive ghettos or the government handing away hotels to asylum seekers. Even the working class aren't as anxious about losing jobs or facing competition.

This analysis is restricted to places north of Glasgow and Edinburgh. I have not spent enough time there to comment. I have, in fact, spent enough time in places like Dundee to know how things work there.

All I know about Scotland's justice system is the Dankula debacle, which is more than enough for me to default to assuming dishonesty from it. But if there are some moderately high-profile cases of immigrants running into the same kind of tyranny, that would be evidence against the expected racial discrimination and two-tier justice system from the non-US Anglophone world.

I had no idea what's up with "Dankula", and looking it up suggests I'm not as terminally online as I thought. I do not see how a (stupid, overreaching) action against a small-time YouTuber over his "Nazi" dog is enough to entirely discredit the veracity of statements made by the local police. That looks to me like throwing the baby out with the bathwater, or squeezing one against the grate so hard it turns into juice.

I also think that you are poisoning the well big-time with your witchcraft analogy. Witches are not real.

Eh? Witches were real, at least in the sense that there were women in medieval Europe who believed that they possessed supernatural powers acquired by heretical means. There were not nearly enough of them to meet local demand, and the epistemics behind identification of such ladies had a rather intolerable rate of Type 1 error.

There are "alien rapists" in the UK. There are probably several in good old Scotland, and I'm not talking about Viking raids. I do not deny this. I say that there are far fewer, in total and per capita. If you hear about a sexual assault case in Greenland Iceland, you probably shouldn't assume the perpetrator was brown.

With that being said, I am at least open to the possibility that this was naked unprovoked aggression from our dual-wielder. But to me, the BBC weighing in is not evidence, and neither is the justice system, until I can be shown how this is different than the position we were in with Rotherham ten years ago.

Then I must invite you to explain what form of evidence might, in theory, sway you.

I am of the opinion that most people who haven't entered this discussion having already made up their minds will at least consider alternative explanations given the new evidence. My ire is reserved for those who are beyond convincing by any means known to man or deity. When this whole story kicked off, I refrained from running my mouth (despite severe temptation) because I retain sufficient skepticism, preferring to wait for further evidence one way or another. We are unlikely to get anything better than this.

Update on the Scottish Dual-Wielding Incident:

The BBC has now published a brief but informative report on the Scottish “dual-wielding” incident, mostly relaying statements from the local police. If you missed the story: a Bulgarian couple, male and female, were approached by local youths in St Ann Lane, Lochee, at about 7:40 pm on Saturday. At some point, an axe made an appearance. The police have issued a statement, and the BBC, in a notably careful choice of words, clarifies: “BBC News understands that officers have found no evidence to substantiate claims being made online the youths were at risk of sexual assault.”

Of course, I have every confidence that some corners of the internet, including select denizens of The Motte, will find this hopelessly unconvincing. If your current epistemic stance is “If she floats, she’s a witch; if she sinks, she’s a witch,” then no combination of facts, logic, or official statements will ever suffice. If your model of the world is that everyone is lying except you and your Telegram group, my ability to shift your priors is probably limited.

Still, let me offer my own semi-informed perspective as someone who is, if not a local, at least more familiar with the Scottish context than your average Redditor. From the beginning, both /r/Scotland and /r/Dundee expressed skepticism toward the popular Twitter narrative. You know the one: a pair of wide-eyed local waifs accosted by a “brown pervert,” who then had no choice but to brandish medieval weaponry in righteous self-defense. You can practically hear the John Williams score.

Now, Scotland is not short on delinquent youth. The British white underclass is, in fact, legendary for its supply of teenage hooligans. Here in Scotland, the local taxonomic label is “ned.” While “non-educated delinquent” is probably a post hoc invention, the behavioral phenotype is easily identified. There is a rich ecosystem of teenagers hanging around bus stops, acting tough, and performing questionable antics. One of their favorite tactics, if challenged, is to shout “pedophile” at the nearest authority figure, thus flipping the script from “annoying brat” to “potential victim.” This tends to work, at least until they age out of the game and (statistically) either get jobs or fall prey to Dundee’s prodigious drug scene.

On the question of weaponry, it bears repeating that it is illegal in Scotland to carry anything that even vaguely resembles a weapon for self-defense. For the Americans in the audience, this is not Texas. Not only is it illegal, it is also, in local context, not normal to walk around with an axe. While I actually find this arrangement not to my libertarian sensibilities, that's neither here nor there. My own priors, which seem to match those of most actual Scots I’ve spoken to, lean toward a more mundane explanation. The girl went out carrying because she wanted to impress her boyfriend, or at least to raise her standing among her peers. She might have been looking for trouble, or simply wanted to show off, and twelve is not too young to have social status games on your mind. Puberty isn’t the only thing that comes early in these parts.

I can only reiterate that an axe is not normal to carry, even if one feels threatened. A pocket knife? I can understand, sure. But this is about as 'extra' as taking a hand-grenade to a seedy pub when you're worried about being roofied.

As for the “migrant crime” angle, I want to point out that Scotland is not England, and certainly not Rotherham. The “migrant problem” is much less pronounced here. Outside Edinburgh or Glasgow, brown skin is still a curiosity, more likely to prompt a friendly question than suspicion. Most of the time, it’s just an excuse for conversation. Scotland has its own problems, but racialized sexual predation is not at the top of the list.

I would like to believe that this clarification settles things, but I am also not naïve. If your epistemic filter is tuned to maximum paranoia, then the absence of evidence is merely further evidence of a cover-up. For everyone else, the police statement, local skepticism, and sociological context should nudge your priors at least a little.

Of course, if you prefer your axes in the hands of twelve-year-olds fighting imaginary Bulgarian sex pests, I suppose nothing I write will convince you otherwise.

I didn't really play much of Arma 2, and DayZ never really appealed to me. The gameplay seems like an exercise in misery, even watching highlight reels never sold me on the concept.

I feel that this is rather unlikely. We did not have "rivers of blood" for ineffective and ridiculously prolonged lockdowns. We did not have a mere stream for when the vaccines turned out to be ineffective at reducing transmission (while working okay for reducing the actual damage of an infection).

Then there's the fact that Russia and China adopted mRNA vaccines several years after the West. Why would they set themselves up for failure, if they knew it was a bad vaccine and they already had their own? Why wouldn't they take their perfect opportunity to screw over the West by boosting claims that mRNA vaccines cause novel harms, or harm more than they help?

If a conspiracy needs buy-in from your worst enemies, for years.. Being a conspiracist is not the idea career choice for such a bureaucrat.

I keep saying I've reached the point in my Motte career where I've discussed every topic under the sun. That's true for this one.

In this specific case, assuming it's the incident from a year or two back, the child was almost guaranteed to die regardless of where they were taken. The main objection of the doctors and the government against them being taken was both that transfer would be highly expensive, and that it wouldn't make a single jot of difference other than prolonging the anguish. If you know any paediatricians, you'll know that they're the kind of people who love kids and will move heaven and earth to help them. If they're saying it's a write off, I am highly inclined to believe them.

From my own, liberatarianish position, I would have preferred the family got to try nonetheless. But there is no clear cut answer, and it was a decision made in good faith.

Oh dear. It's fixed now.