site banner

Culture War Roundup for the week of November 2, 2026

This weekly roundup thread is intended for all culture war posts. 'Culture war' is vaguely defined, but it basically means controversial issues that fall along set tribal lines. Arguments over culture war issues generate a lot of heat and little light, and few deeply entrenched people ever change their minds. This thread is for voicing opinions and analyzing the state of the discussion while trying to optimize for light over heat.

Optimistically, we think that engaging with people you disagree with is worth your time, and so is being nice! Pessimistically, there are many dynamics that can lead discussions on Culture War topics to become unproductive. There's a human tendency to divide along tribal lines, praising your ingroup and vilifying your outgroup - and if you think you find it easy to criticize your ingroup, then it may be that your outgroup is not who you think it is. Extremists with opposing positions can feed off each other, highlighting each other's worst points to justify their own angry rhetoric, which becomes in turn a new example of bad behavior for the other side to highlight.

We would like to avoid these negative dynamics. Accordingly, we ask that you do not use this thread for waging the Culture War. Examples of waging the Culture War:

  • Shaming.

  • Attempting to 'build consensus' or enforce ideological conformity.

  • Making sweeping generalizations to vilify a group you dislike.

  • Recruiting for a cause.

  • Posting links that could be summarized as 'Boo outgroup!' Basically, if your content is 'Can you believe what Those People did this week?' then you should either refrain from posting, or do some very patient work to contextualize and/or steel-man the relevant viewpoint.

In general, you should argue to understand, not to win. This thread is not territory to be claimed by one group or another; indeed, the aim is to have many different viewpoints represented here. Thus, we also ask that you follow some guidelines:

  • Speak plainly. Avoid sarcasm and mockery. When disagreeing with someone, state your objections explicitly.

  • Be as precise and charitable as you can. Don't paraphrase unflatteringly.

  • Don't imply that someone said something they did not say, even if you think it follows from what they said.

  • Write like everyone is reading and you want them to be included in the discussion.

On an ad hoc basis, the mods will try to compile a list of the best posts/comments from the previous week, posted in Quality Contribution threads and archived at /r/TheThread. You may nominate a comment for this list by clicking on 'report' at the bottom of the post and typing 'Actually a quality contribution' as the report reason.

5
Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

No equivalence is exactly one to one. But the West Bank isn't part of Israel proper, and Gaza certainly isn't. Should it be? Maybe. Is Israel doing bad things in both places? I think so. But turn that back on the US again, and people will talk about all the places we have "occupied" and exerted our will and even allowed bad behavior on the part of American settlers.

My point isn't that Israel isn't blameworthy or that the US and Canada are necessarily as bad. It's that most of these critiques of Israel are essentially isolated demands for legitimacy. They aren't motivated by anything Israel in particular is doing that's worse or more nefarious than what other nation states do. It's motivated by a very particular dislike of Israel, for Reasons. Oh, the US gives too much money to Israel? You know what, I agree. We should give less money to lots of countries, in my opinion. I have a list. Oh, Israel gets involved in US politics and we should Notice and push back? I agree! There are lots of countries who do that--I have a list.

There is literally nothing anti-Israel activists say that is more convincing than what anti-American leftists say about the US (and some of what anti-American leftists say about the US is actually fair criticism!). There is no criticism anti-Israel activists have of Israel's involvement in global and American politics that isn't true of a number of other countries, from Egypt to Qatar to South Korea to Russia. (Remember the 80s, when there was great concern about how much US property Japan was buying? Michael Crichton wrote a novel about it. Yeah, Rising Sun was a technothriller but it was really a screed about Japan buying up Los Angeles real estate. And then people pointed out how much real estate was owned by the UK. Today, hmm, where are Chinese and Russian billionaires investing?) Oh, but Israel is more involved, gets more money? Has more (ahem) "dual loyalists"? Maybe. Questionable. But let's say it's so. Are the critics really, truly objecting to Israel in particular because they weighted the factors and somehow Israel scores at the top of the threat index? Nah.

But the West Bank isn't part of Israel proper

The Israelis would certainly disagree, considering they exercise effective sovereignty over the West Bank, their citizens regularly enter the West Bank to steal homes and goats from Palestinians and their military provides overwatch to protect their citizens from any Palestinians attempting to defend themselves. Israel doesn't have defined borders, allowing them to exercise sovereignty over territory without granting the people there the rights that every other state grants to people living under its jurisdiction ie. citizenship.

But turn that back on the US again, and people will talk about all the places we have "occupied" and exerted our will and even allowed bad behavior on the part of American settlers.

What American settlers? America has certainly invaded plenty of countries but unless you go back over a hundred years it hasn't brought settlers along. Can you identify the country where Americans operate like Israeli settlers?

It's that most of these critiques of Israel are essentially isolated demands for legitimacy. They aren't motivated by anything Israel in particular is doing that's worse or more nefarious than what other nation states do.

Quite on the contrary, the Israelis take actions that, performed by other countries, resulted in their obliteration. South Africa tried to create a similar state of affairs to that of the West Bank but their equivalents were called "Bantustans", their state was crushed under sanctions and they were forced to give the black Africans equal voting rights that resulted in their destruction. The Rhodesians tried to justify their state under the principle of "might makes right" only to run out of fighters and ammo under the resulting international blockade.

There is no criticism anti-Israel activists have of Israel's involvement in global and American politics that isn't true of a number of other countries, from Egypt to Qatar to South Korea to Russia.

Let's compare with another country that occasionally is claimed to control American politics, Saudi Arabia. The Saudis received aid prosecuting their invasion of Yemen and they certainly spend more money on lobbying yet as soon as dead kids starting appearing on TV an anti-Saudi coalition assembled in Congress to pressure Trump and Trump forced the Saudis to give up after a year.

In contrast, Biden repeatedly refused to do anything to rein in the Israelis despite the enormous political cost. Then Harris refused to even pretend that she would do anything to rein in the Israelis, costing her the key swing state of Michigan and possibly the Presidency. Trump proceeded to do Israel's dirty work in Iran like a big dumb golem and blew up his entire Presidency as a result. All this and when Netanyahu shows up to visit Congress he receives dozens of comical, Stalinesque standing ovations despite having an approval rating from the American public of something like -50.

What other American ally stole American nuclear secrets to create a nuclear program without American permission and remained an American ally?

I predicted "Not one-for-one" would be ignored as you go through a litany of all your particular complaints about Israel. Thanks for not disappointing.

You can of course cherry pick similarities and differences-- this is what motivated partisans do. Is our support for Israel exactly like our support for Saudi Arabia? No. Are Israeli settler activities exactly like American occupation forces everywhere from the Philippines to Japan to Iraq? Nope. Americans can (justifiably) point out how very different we are, and the locals can (justifiably) point out how it looks the same to them. Likewise, is Israel similar to South Africa? Is it the same as South Africa? Is it different from South Africa? It all depends on what ideological point you are trying to argue. (A common tell is using words like "obliterated." South Africa was obliterated, forsooth! You might almost convince some young'un who doesn't know history that we literally bombed them, Dresden-style.)

We definitely have had other allied countries spy on us, meddle in our internal affairs, and be fair-weather friends (or outright bad faith allies). There's another tell with the very specific and emotive language (the dastardly Israelis booby trapped office supplies! They stole nuclear secrets! etc.)

Sure, I get it. You think Israel is the worst country and the worst ally. And it's entirely 100% based on a sober line-by-comparison with all the other bad countries and bad allies, right?

A reminder, for all the Israel-haters, that I don't actually care about or like Israel that much. I'd be fine with cutting off almost all foreign aid to them or radically curbing our support unless they start being more docile, like a protectorate should be. But I think we should do that with many other countries, and I don't think Israel is particularly bad. I cannot help Noticing these isolated demands for fidelity. It's all about ethics in international politics, right?

But I think we should do that with many other countries, and I don't think Israel is particularly bad. I cannot help Noticing these isolated demands for fidelity. It's all about ethics in international politics, right?

If you could name a country that both a) you believe the USA should cut support for, and b) receives more US aid than Israel does, that would go a long way toward proving your claim that opposition to support for Israel is indeed (in the USA) an isolated demand for rigour. Otherwise, this would not seem to be obvious motivated reasoning but simply a case of "tackle the biggest pointless money sink first before the smaller ones".

(In the rest of the West, this is a very-different kettle of fish, of course.)

Why does it have to be more money than we give to Israel? If I think we should cut/reduce aid to a lot of countries, and Israel happens to be at the top of that list, I assert that my reasoning is consistent. I claim that people who only talk about cutting aid to Israel did not pick the top country on the list as "the biggest fish to fry first." I claim that if Israel were #2 or #3 or #7 on the list, most such critics would still be making the most noise about Israel.

Indeed, right now Ukraine is the #1 recipient of foreign aid, depending on how you count the money. Some of the same people against Israeli aid are also against support to Ukraine, but not all, and mostly for political reasons, not because they counted numbers.

You've gone to a lot of trouble in this thread to insinuate that people who want US aid to Israel cut just hate Jews. My point is this: all you need to get to "cut foreign aid, Israel biggest offender" is:

  1. to think aid to Ukraine is useful
  2. to think aid to Israel is not useful.

That's it. Israel is AFAIK #2, so once you accept those Israel is indeed "the biggest fish [worth frying] to fry first", no special animus against Jews required. This is of course much less true once you get out of US politics, as the other Western nations do not donate large sums of money to Israel every year (I have recently argued, offsite, that banning Palestine Action was essentially required to preserve the British social contract - although arresting the thousands of people who whined about it was not).

If you're wondering why I chose to drop into this thread (beyond the part that brought this thread to my attention i.e. "you got reported and I volunteer every day" :V), it's because I do think that Israel sticks out as an unusually-(large-and-undeserved) recipient of US charity which means you're accusing me of false pretence (and, y'know, also accusing me of subscribing to anti-Semitism, which... okay, I suppose I'm supposed to feel horrified by it, or something, since I'm part Prussian Jew and all, but honestly I just find it stupid and tiresome; Jews are white, the end, shut up already).

You've gone to a lot of trouble in this thread to insinuate that people who want US aid to Israel cut just hate Jews.

No.

I said I want to cut US aid to Israel.

There's always been a tension between "opposes Israel" and "hates Jews." I've long found it frustrating that many (usually Jewish) pro-Israel people will go straight to accusations of antisemitism when anyone criticizes Israel. Often this is disingenuous. But often it is not. And increasingly I am sympathetic to a suspicion that opposition to Israel is motivated by antisemitism. I think this suspicion is well-founded when you notice people not applying the same standards anywhere else. I've seen white nationalists who normally despise Muslims in particular whose hearts suddenly bleed for the plight of Palestinians and Iranians.

It is plausible that someone believes supporting Ukraine is in our national interests and supporting Israel is not. I start to have doubts when their concern stops at Israel (because countries listed lower on the list don't matter, but surely if we cut aid to Israel then they'd start worrying about Jordan and Ethiopia?).

It's not "everyone." But my priors, admittedly, have shifted from "some" to "most."

So you're not accusing me of making excuses to cover up a case of Judenhass?

(Ethiopia seems like more of a charity case than Israel, much as Ukraine does, but yeah, I did notice Jordan when I was looking this up prior to my first post. What's the story there, do you happen to know?)

I never accused you of anything.

Jordan is basically as stable and reliable a partner as we get in the Arab world. So it's in our interests to incentivize that and help keep them stable.

More comments