Hey there! For complicated reasons, some of which I will explain later, I'm in the middle of dong a pretty gigantic revamp to the Motte codebase. Right now, this means "fix a bunch of small bugs". Later, other things will be happening.
The immediate goal of this is not to massively transform the site or do a Digg v4/New Reddit thing. Frankly, if the site remained exactly the same (but with fewer bugs) I would be happy.
The long-term goal isn't going to be quite that static, though. The long-term goal is to set things up to allow more subcommunities, similar to how subreddits work. This will be a larger set of changes. These changes will not obsolete The Motte itself; I am absolutely aiming for a site that can comfortably keep holding The Motte. I've talked about this before if you want to go read about it - this is still the same plan, for what it's worth, it's just now being (slowly) executed.
I will be posting more, and asking questions about next steps, when actual site behavioral changes are in the queue. This just isn't that! This is infrastructure work.
tl;dr: The site backend may be a little wonky for a bit, sorry about that, please report any bugs.
(and mods, feel free to unsticky this in a few days if I forget)

Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Notes -
Oh God please no. This is what killed reddit. Reddit was so much better when it was just a few people on a few official subreddits.
I mean I guess the correct thing to say would be that many many factors killed reddit over the course of 20 years. Our userbase here at TheMotte might be small enough that the existence of subreddits wouldn’t cause fracturing. But generally I view it as a bad sign, and the fact that all discussion here is centralized in the CW thread is one of the main draws of TheMotte for me.
I suggest federation. The Motte basically stays as-is, except users here can crosspost to and comment on other instances of the Motte’s infrastructure, and vice versa, with some support for Lemmy and Mastodon (I think the Motte should stay a bit different than Lemmy, IME this site is more user-friendly). Zorba keeps running the Motte, but also starts a couple other instances for hobbies, and maybe others run their own instances for whatever niches this site is lacking (a philosophy-focused Motte? Hacker News 2.0?)
Although, other instances overlapping with parts of the Motte threatens to split the community into nothingness, hence crossposting and commenting should be practically seamless; and I would be careful introducing ones that aren’t very disjoint (like hobby or finance…we have Tinker Tuesday and Spending Saturday but they’re barely active).
(EDIT: and I don’t think subreddits should exist, at least yet; because I expect these instances will be so small, everything in the same feed would not be an issue, and attract more discussion from people in one interest glancing at another (like the Motte).)
I will echo Lazuli and say that I haven't seen anything federated actually catch on and grow popular. The only people who use Lemmy or Mastodon are weirdos, usually pretty far left, too. Matrix is similarly obscure, despite being one of the more popular decentralized protocols.
I doubt the Motte or any spinoffs will grow that popular (sorry Zorba). Although even if they combined gained 10x as many posts and comments, that would still be niche, but more feasible.
Basically, I think federation is a middle ground between subreddits (which I echo others in thinking is a bad idea) and completely separate instances (which is OK, but loses the benefits of subreddits, like cross-community interaction and separate profiles under the same account): I think federation gives back most of these benefits without downsides, like brigading and central point of failure.
I don't know. I make top posts here on random stuff sometimes to see what Motte users will say about them. That would be the benefit of having other subMottes, you could just see what a different type of person than the average redditor has to say about whatever you're posting about.
On the other hand, Motte users don't grow on trees. If the site gets popular, normies could ruin everything.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link