Do you have a dumb question that you're kind of embarrassed to ask in the main thread? Is there something you're just not sure about?
This is your opportunity to ask questions. No question too simple or too silly.
Culture war topics are accepted, and proposals for a better intro post are appreciated.

Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Notes -
I was reading the bio of Grizzly Bear’s frontman and learned he comes from the Forbes family. Coolest family I’ve ever read about. Opium traders in the Orient, railroad magnates, founding stock of Boston, neuroscientists, Beethoven scholars, an elector of Lincoln, president of the Bell Telephone Company, a governor-general of the Philippines, Ralph Waldo Emerson… and you yourself compose one of the greatest indie song of late 00s? A song still so resonant that it has a million uses across shortform video content 15 years later?
There’s a pattern of indie musicians coming from elite families. The daughter of former secretary general of NATO Stoltenberg is an indie musician. And the father of the frontman of Phoenix started TNS Sofres, the most important political data company in France in his time. I have two theories on this: (1) indie music is often about conveying nuanced and high feelings of mirth and love, something that is easier to develop when you grow up knowing you have infinite resources; (2) there’s an epigenetic musicality gene that is triggered when perceived resources are high, to signal your high level of resources, like a bird singing loudly to signal his nutritional resources
Does everyone have their two weeks worth of hibernatory grizzly bear supplies in case things go south? May be worth doing that today.
edit meant to post this in the fun thread but I suppose I’ll just turn it into a question. What’s everyone’s favorite indie song, or if you don’t like indie music, why?
As ever, the UK and the US are two countries separated by a common language, and the term "indie rock" refers to something very different depending on which side of the pond you're on. Per the American variant, Death Cab for Cutie's album Transatlanticism would probably be one of my desert island discs, and when listening to it there's not one track I ever feel the urge to skip, a rare feat indeed. It bears the unusual distinction where, if pressed, I'm pretty confident I could write out the lyrics to the entire album from memory without listening to any of the songs, a consequence of singer Ben Gibbard's unusually precise and clear diction.
In the UK and Ireland, the term is primarily associated with the legion of bands that mushroomed in the wake of Arctic Monkeys' initial chart success. I bought the Monkeys' first album the year it came out and listened to it a great deal, but don't really rate it anymore, nor any of their later material. Within a few years, some music critic had begun derisively referring to these hordes of interchangeable soundalike bands (Scouting for Girls, The Enemy, Editors etc.) as "landfill indie". I was amused to learn a few months ago that the term is being applied to all those execrable insufferable post-punk bands like Fontaines DC, Sprints and Yard Act: "landfill post-punk".
The only indie rock album from the UK or Ireland I ever remember really enjoying was Bloc Party's debut Silent Alarm, which was actually released before Arctic Monkeys'. If you played a FIFA game between 2005-7 you probably heard either this song or this one (I think I first encountered the band when the latter song was used in a video game called Getting Up), but the whole album is well worth checking out.
We can agree on this. I had vaguely heard of them, couldn't name a song of theirs if you put a gun to my head, but recently on the radio stations I listen to, DJs are absolutely losing their minds over them with praise. A lot of indie bands are that kind of insufferable, for the few good ones. They do tend to fizzle out, so "landfill indie" is a good term. Where are The Kaiser Chiefs or Franz Ferdinand now?
Though to me, "last indie band I know" ends with The Cocteau Twins so I am badly out of date.
Apparently both are still touring. Even those bands had much more staying power than many of their contemporaries: 22 years post-release I still occasionally hear "I Predict a Riot" and "Take Me Out" played on the radio. When's the last time you heard The Wombats, Editors or Glasvegas without actively seeking them out? I haven't even heard of most of the bands on this list, but all of them were apparently big enough at their peaks to secure record deals. The whole thing had the feel of a speculative bubble which abruptly burst at the end of the 2000s.
I realise my argument sort of proves too much: for any given genre or musical scene, >90% of the content produced therein will be forgotten within two decades. But I do think that, even acknowledging this fundamental law of the universe, the landfill indie (and landfill post-punk, by extension) genre had an unusually high ratio of noise to signal.
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link
More options
Context Copy link