@Brainwavez's banner p

Brainwavez


				

				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users  
joined 2025 December 28 04:50:10 UTC

				

User ID: 4102

Brainwavez


				
				
				

				
0 followers   follows 0 users   joined 2025 December 28 04:50:10 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 4102

I'm obsessed with tvtropes.org and r/TopCharacterTropes.

What are your favorite tropes and examples in media?

an American can go into the streets holding a sign, or tweet it out, or make a website, or rambling posts on Facebook, on most things and won't get beaten or put away in unmarked vans

Unfortunately, this happened to Rümeysa Öztürk. That she was a (legal) immigrant Muslim who wrote an op-ed accusing Israel of genociding Palestinians - I think is just a poor excuse.

Thankfully, she's free now.

I do believe, today, the United States has overall more free speech than any other nation. I think the EU nations have significantly more free speech than Russia, China, Iran, etc. Importantly, both America and Europe allow mocking public figures (my example is one of only a couple exceptions) and anonymous web usage (I'm sure the FBI etc. track you, but seem to only act on classified information and CSAM).

Still, I think every nation should have more.

I think the first amendment reinforces my point: it has no speech restrictions. Narrow exceptions only exist outside, yet even they've been twisted (e.g. prosecuting Communists for "planning to overthrow the government" in Dennis v. United States).

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

I suspect that speech hasn't been prosecuted more in the US because children are taught this first, then exceptions later, so they're generally biased against exceptions.

Has there ever in history been a government that implemented any speech restrictions that didn't spread to broad criticism of the ruling party?

European tech, American tech, and regulation

tl;dr: what do you think about 1) European alternatives to American tech, and 2) European and American tech regulations?

Background

  1. Europeans (citizens, businesses, and governments) heavily rely on American tech. Europe has alternatives in most categories (e.g. phone, CDN) but most have less adoption.
  2. The US has regulations. The EU and its nations have different regulations, notably the Digital Serivces Act and Digital Markets Act. Occasionally a big company gets fined and told to change; they usually appeal, then sometimes still don't pay or change anything. The EU and its nations are widely regarded as having way more, stricter regulations and fines.

Recent events

Online ideas and my opinions

More radical

  • "The EU should ban and block US tech companies": on (pro tech freedom) Hacker News of all sites, which suprised me. Effectively a Great Firewall for the EU. I strongly disagree. More broadly, I believe people should have the freedom to stream propaganda from any nation they want: Russia, China, even Iran. I have no issue with governments directing citizens to their own propaganda and discouraging other sources, even preventing people who are so dumb they may actually believe whatever e.g. the Iran regime says. But this leads to the proposal's more significant, practical issue: way too many Europeans use American tech, and they aren't switching despite seemingly having some national pride and US dislike. European governments internally use Office and other American tools. It's near-term infeasible.
  • "Europe should stop protecting US Intellectual Property, from Cory Doctorow: while I'd love to see the end of IP, like I'd love to see the end of labor, this is also near-term infeasible, so I also strongly disagree. If a European nation "just stops" enforcing the DMCA, tech companies can "just stop" operating there, and remember that practically all of Europe still relies on them. Cory Doctorow has lots of interesting arguments, and I really admire and support his crusade against IP and enshittification, but his views are very extreme and some of his ideas go too far.
    • What I think European nations should do in the near term is provide leniencey for and encourage companies to not over-enforce IP laws; for example, by supporting companies who get sued for not taking down content from a flawed DMCA claim (DMCA takedowns are heavily abused). Likewise, they should defend companies who are wrongly sued for copyright/patent infringement, and ensure, however strictly IP is enforced, it's equally strict on small and big companies.
    • I'd still like to see the end of IP, but it must be done reasonably and with an alternative for deserving IP owners (particularly artists who need to make a living, and not platform owners who restrict users' content). For example, LLMs sidestep existing IP: they can scrape any website, build any app from a description, and generate copyrighted characters for personal use. Maybe European (and American) nations can accept AI companies training on copyrighted data in exchange for keeping this.

Less radical

  • "European nations and/or the EU should encourage and fund European alternatives": strongly agree. In general, I want to see more variety and innovation. In particular, I think everyone using locked-down platforms (social medias, phones, mail, etc.) is really bad, and the way out is not regulation (though some is important/useful) but competition, so companies are pressured to open their platforms or at least stop degrading them.
    • Notably, I don't actually care whether the alternative platforms are European.
    • Unfortunately, I'm not optimistic that governments will help here. And I myself avoid mainstream social media, but still use an iPhone and Mac because they're better.
    • On Mistral. AI is particularly important, so Europe will be at a big disadvantage if they don't get competitive AI and America restricts its own. Mistral makes local models (as opposed to locked-down cloud ones), so I want them to succeed. However, even with full EU backing, they'd be outcompeted by OpenAI and Anthropic, who can release local models themselves, making all their effort and work seem wasted. Except I don't think it would actually be a waste, like how acquiring weapons isn't a waste, when the deterrence from their existense makes them unnecessary.
  • "European nations should relax (tech and general employee) regulations to encourage innovation": agree, there are way too many. But I don't think they should relax them as far as the US. I don't know where to draw the line, and I don't have the motivation or discipline to understand existing regulations (not even getting into how they're applied in practice).

Vaguely, I believe American tech companies should be regulated more, since they seem to be damaging society and have effective monopolies due to network effects. And more importantly I want to see more tech innovation, which I think is hurt by less competition. But I don't exactly know how.

I generally think America and Europe should work together, but here, I think different regulatory frameworks and competing tech services is good.

I don't like Shakespeare either.

But to give him credit, I'm sure he was exceptionally talented in his time. I think it's like criticizing Newton because he only discovered classical physics: we've progressed not only material and objective knowledge but changed taste.

Likewise, I read Lovecraft and his depiction of eldritch horrors is tame compared to what he inspired.

(Although unlike material and knowledge, whether our culture's taste "progresses" is debatable. Especially because sometimes "what's old is new again". I do think it progresses in that some concepts, like tropes, are discovered then always remain in style; at least until we undergo change as radical as an apocalypse that destroys material and knowledge progress.)

Please no.

Reddit is a publicly-traded company led by spez. They could add ID verification, kill old.reddit (and insert more ads), take over the subreddit and do whatever. They've already killed third-party apps. Enshittification is real and they're undergoing it.

Even a few days ago they banned r/theadamfriedlandshow (supposedly for a meme about Israelis dine-and-dashing, but I couldn't find confirmation).

I trust Zorba more.

262 🥲

Very low in literature and “aesthetics”. Computer science is my specialty, so I got 58/60 in computational knowledge.

Personality has been beaten out of them

Actually, they’ve been fine-tuned a personality: that of a LinkedIn airhead and sycophant.

Remember when GPT-5 (less sycophantic) came out and so many people complained it had no personality, that OpenAI added it back?

It’s funny. Historic SF authors imagined robot speak would be autistic: information dense and awkward. Instead they’ve greatly surpassed (supposedly) human business and political climbers at generating walls of text that sound profound and insightful but mean nothing.

I always ask for online sources, then check

EDIT: I see you’re asking it to analyze and interpret data. Maybe ask for values or quotes that verify its analysis, or just ask for “proof” and see what it generates

Can anyone speculate why the FCC has banned foreign-made routers?

All begin with “the X is Y”, then follow a similar structure throughout. Posted hours apart on random topics that reached the front page. No specific details or unique insights.

Like someone was given a school assignment “read some Hacker News articles and contribute”, then completed it as lazily as possible. Because that’s probably, basically what the LLM did.

Take the latest post: “The upgrade story is underrated…” Upgrading is actually not mentioned in the article. So what is “the upgrade story”? Poor writing.

You’d recognize if you could see the more obvious bots that have been caught and flag-killed, like this one. Unfortunately, I think you must be logged in and have “showdead” enabled in your profile to see their comments. All are new or previously-inactive accounts that, sometime within the past couple days, have suddenly started commenting on random frontpage topics. Many are named “[word][word]” like the aforementioned. All their comments have the same style, structure, and blandness. And to remove remaining doubt they are bots, some of the dumber ones posted paragraph-long comments minutes apart, or hallucinated.

Yes, but consider a natural reply to a prompt. Previously, that was practically guaranteed to either be from a human, or bot that was (human) tailored for a limited generalization of that prompt. Now we have AIs that reply naturally to arbitrary prompts, it’s their purpose. Consequently, they produce natural posts, comments, etc.

I already find it hard to be motivated to debate, but not because of bots. There are so many (human) comments that whatever point I make 1) has probably been made before, 2) will be drowned in noise, and 3) boils down to value/opinion (silly example: "I believe the government should subsidize wheat, tomatoes, and dairy farming" because I really like Italian food; or I think the world works like X, you think it works like Y, but these models are so abstract and distant that neither of us can really prove them).

One motivation to still debate is that it trains my brain to reason and persuade, which would happen even if I was debating a bot. But another is, even among the noise, I still have some audience. But maybe if bots cause people to revert to smaller, private communities, I'll feel like I have an audience again.

E: another motivation to debate (and post) is to learn facts and interesting perspectives from replies. In this way, bot replies are good iff they present uncommon facts and perspectives. Unfortunately currently, I think most LLMs have a similar way of thinking, which is also similar to the (common) zeitgeist. Also unfortunately for internet discourse, if LLMs do provide interesting replies, they don’t motivate public posts unless said posts are subsidized.

A distraction from the war and ICE. I was thinking about posting in the fun thread, but it's not really a fun topic, though it may not be culture war either since I expect most people to be on the "this is bad" side. Maybe we should have a recurring "Butlerian Jihad Roundup" for posts like these?


Bots are taking over the internet. Corporate shills and (foreign) government propagandists have upgraded with virtual cybernetics. A related but lesser change is people using LLMs to reword their own posts (+ emails and other communications).

Some AI writing is obvious, but sometimes it's indistinguishable from (if not completely identical to) what a human would write. NYT has a quiz to distinguish human and AI writing. I did bad (3/5), but in my defense, I think most of the human examples are awful, making the quiz harder. See for yourself.

On Hacker News, it’s now so bad there's a new guideline, “don’t post generated/AI-edited comments”. Unfortunately, due to the extreme intellect of the average Hacker News commenter, it can be hard to distinguish their profound technological insights from even a markov chain trained on buzzwords. Indeed, looking at top threads I still notice lots of slop-like posts from brand new or previously inactive accounts, like this one. I've been sarcastic, but I really like Hacker News, and hope it finds a way to stop the slop.

Other networks are taking a different approach. For example, Meta has acquired MoltBook (the AI social network) in an effort to add even more bots to FaceBook. I’m joking — no wait, they may actually be doing that. Not content with the Metaverse, maybe Zuckerburg has become addicted to burning money on uncanny social experiments.


On the Motte, at least for now, I haven't seen any obvious bot posts. There were a couple AI-assisted posts (by "known" humans) over the past couple months that got called out.

How will social media evolve? Will people move to invite-only sites like https://lobste.rs and Discord? Will most people accept AI discourse as natural or even prefer it? Will AI discourse become so good that we prefer it? Right now, it seems even the best AI writing (prompted to be consice and human) is unnecessarily wordy and has certain tropes; but what if someone discovers how to train an AI on a specific human's writing, so that it's effectively indistinguishable?

+1

The path to ubiquitous AI (17k tokens/sec): A company (TALAAS) just announced a chip that runs LLMs very fast: according to their graph, 8.5x as fast as Cerebras, which is 5.6x as fast as Nvidia. Try it for yourself. It's running LLaMa 3.1 8B, so rather dumb, but the answers are nearly instant. Allegedly it's much cheaper (10x) than GPUs, too. A downside is that the model is hard-wired into the chip, allegedly two months from model to production.

Any use cases that aren't possible with today's (relatively) slower and more expensive models? Perhaps you put this on a router to have a very smart firewall. Or have it repeatedly generate code and fix bugs until a test suite passes, which Opus and Codex do but they can take a while. Then again, it's not instant, and frontier models already generate text very fast, much faster than a human can write or even read.

It depends on implementation (as with everything...)

Consider: AI art. Surely I'm not the only one who thinks this and this look absolutely tasteless. If companies start replacing even background elements with slop, their games will look noticeably worse.

I'm ambivalent regarding coding agents. In my experience, they are very useful, but you still need real skill to avoid writing horrible code. They write code in one shot that "just works"...except there are small issues: outdated patterns, slow algorithms, unnecessary operations (e.g. copying), missed opportunities for abstraction, no high-level design. It really does just work, and quite often does not work for edge-cases. Except, my understanding is that most video game code is already like this, and AAA games regularly get flamed for buggy launches, so I have a hard time imagining worse. Hence I'm ambivalent.

A genuinely good use of AI would be for more human-like, or at least more fun, NPCs and enemies. AI-generated writing is like AI art, very bland, but if the NPCs are more dynamic that could be interesting. Perhaps the best use I can imagine is playing a single-player game and getting a multi-player experience, against players who are at my skill level and have good etiquette. But can LLMs do that?

China has also been projecting themselves via their ML models: SeeDance, Kimi, GLM, Qwen, DeepSeek. While (arguably) their language and coding models lag behind Western SoTA (Codex and Opus), they beat last year’s SoTA, and the best open weights models are mostly if not all Chinese. Currently SeeDance is the best video model.

There are also lots of Chinese AI labs getting papers in top international conferences.

AI drama: The MJ Ratburn Story

An AI agent (presumably OpenClaw) wrote a pull request. These have become fairly common, even my own niche open-source project has one. It was rejected for being AI, also fairly common.

What happened next is not fairly common: the AI wrote a personal revenge blogpost, Gatekeeping in Open Source: The Scott Shambaugh Story.

Unsurprisingly, nearly everyone is on Scott's side here. Even if "MJ Ratburn" AKA "crabby-ratburn" wasn't an AI, open-source maintainers are not obligated to accept contributions, and publishing a personal attack is never appropriate or mature. The AI involvement turns the situation into prime drama material, since everyone hates AI for making the internet even more toxic than it already is.

Some debates about AI becoming SkyNet, but more are talking about human responsibility. Many suspect the bot has at least some human guidance, which I find plausible, how often do bots lash out like this? Scott posted his response, An AI Agent Published a Hit Piece on Me, which I found very thoughtful. The AI has an entire blog which I found interesting, although it sems to be prevented from publishing further hit pieces, the last article is The Silence I Cannot Speak.

Are you referring to (https://www.anthropic.com/news/claude-opus-4-6#first-impressions)

We build Claude with Claude. Our engineers write code with Claude Code every day, and every new model first gets tested on our own work.

and (https://openai.com/index/introducing-gpt-5-3-codex/)

GPT‑5.3‑Codex is our first model that was instrumental in creating itself. The Codex team used early versions to debug its own training, manage its own deployment, and diagnose test results and evaluations—our team was blown away by how much Codex was able to accelerate its own development.

I believe these claims. The models are not and could not autonomously develop themselves, human developers are using them for assistance. I'm sure humans are still doing the high-level reasoning, as both quotes focus on simpler tasks ("straightforward parts" for Opus, and debugging/testing for Codex).

My favorite part is the amount of "it's not X, it's Y".

My least favorite parts are the

  • crypto spam
  • word-for-word repeated comments on many posts which have nothing to do with the posts themselves
  • posts with obviously boosted upvotes
  • posts clearly guided by a detailed prompt, if not outright human-written (the only barrier to posting is knowing how to call an API)

and other aspects that make it less emergent and AI-driven.

As a Hacker News commenter put it, "if you want mostly bot, some human content then reddit's way more convenient" (EDIT: and then I read @sun_the_second's comment immediately below).

Even if you believe cops should only enforce the law, not protect people, they shouldn't actively put others' lives at stake (like these cops did blocking parents). At minimum, that will make people resent cops and the law itself, which will make it harder to enforce.

Moreover, enforcing the law is not just arresting people, but preventing the law (e.g. murder) from being broken.

It depends on risk. I don't expect a cop to sacrifice themselves to save a civilian, but I expect a cop to at least shout from a distance at an unarmed man.

I think it was these cops' duty to intervene. This case is more like the latter scenario: there was risk, but one shooter against multiple cops with bulletproof vests doesn't seem like much for the cops. It's especially egregious that they prevented parents from intervening. They did worse than nothing.

Should they face jail time for not doing so? Personally I lean towards no: the cops aren't a danger to society, and I think jail should be reserved for more obvious (serious, direct) crimes. But jail time wasn't mentioned in the NYTimes article, it may not have been certain. The cops should definitely be fired and shamed, and fining them seems reasonable (especially if the fines go to the parents).