FiveHourMarathon
a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop
And every gimmick hungry yob
Digging gold from rock n roll
Grabs the mic to tell us
he'll die before he's sold
But I believe in this
And it's been tested by research
He who fucks nuns
Will later join the church
User ID: 195
I'm just going to throw out personal experiences and anecdata right here. I'm a lifelong Republican, living in a purple region of a purple state. I've been campaigning for friends in the primary election coming up for local campaigns, knocking on doors and going to events. I've spoken to somewhere around 500 likely Republican and 200 Democratic primary voters in the past two months. This is what I'm seeing...
-- The Rs are very much split between die-hard down-with-the-ship MAGA who will not vote against Trump, embarrassed Republicans who barely want to be Rs any more but are kinda stuck, and R registered voters whose knowledge of these issues is so shallow and uninvolved that they're not predictably committed to any ideology. The political equivalents of Pentecostals, Episcopalians, and Christmas-Easter Catholics; one group passionate and moronic, one group that treats what should be a whole-life commitment as a social club that they really only stay in because it already exists, and one group that doesn't really know what they believe but they're pretty sure they'll believe the hell out of it when they get around to it. I would guess the MAGA has the slim plurality, but not a strong enough one to be certain of victory depending how the Christmas-Easter contingent breaks.
-- There are really smart and interesting Trump supporters in the world, including a good number on this website, but his base is the Lumpen-Proletariat. The downscale end of the Republican party is where Trump gets yardage against Desantis. Desantis can carry the McMansion Suburbs that Biden did better with than HRC, but Trump dominates the houses with an old car parked on the lawn.
-- School board fights are vicious around here where they used to be staid. In my two local school districts, there are cross-party slates of people violently worked up about Trans Issues, opposing a group of Covidiots who would probably still have schools closed if they had their druthers. There are going to be vastly more schoolboard fights across the country this year, I predict school CW will dominate early primary headlines as they win some elections and implement new policies. Things are going to get much worse on that front, especially because the sole actual policy that seems universal is that all school board business should be operated by livestream. So (no offense to present company) assholes on the internet from Ireland to Russia to Canada to Missouri are going be able to tune into my small town schoolboard to criticize and look for something to turn into CW fuel? It's going to be a bloodbath.
-- Democrats are in a pissy mood. Even in very local races, where we're not CWing or really doing anything to do with national politics, nice old ladies would scream at me that they're never voting for any Republican ever again. This correlated strongly in a neighborhood with knocking on R neighbors' doors and getting a hard MAGA type. I'm not sure there's really any traction to crossing the aisle unless the R candidate renounces Trump. Desantis will not draw significant Democrat votes unless he personally renounces Trump/J6/etc. He will not be able to walk the line between the two, Trump must be slain before any moderate Reagan Republican run is possible.
I'm not sure where all that leaves your Desantis theories, and it's all just anecdotes collected by me personally (a white guy in a blazer or a patagucci vest depending on weather) knocking on doors and getting responses. But R candidates ignore it at their own peril.
Puberty is one of those critical development windows after which, if certain physical changes haven't happened, they're unlikely to happen at all. It affects the entire body, including the brain and skeletal system, not only the sex organs and secondary sex characteristics.
To say nothing of the vicious logic of delaying it.
Take a kid, maybe he's trans, maybe he's just having some trouble seeing himself as a young man when the other boys are bigger/stronger/rougher than him. Now prevent him from experiencing puberty normally, as the rest of his cohort starts growing beards and joking about hiding erections he will have nothing in common with them. They will be bigger and stronger, he will be smaller and weaker; how is that going to help him return to masculinity? How, exactly, is he going to come back to identifying with his cohort as it leaves him behind? As he becomes more and more different from his cohort, he will sink further and further into the trans identity.
Few desist off of blockers because they don't stand a chance, the slope here is very slippery.
*This can of course be gender reversed quite easily. A 12 year old girl who isn't feeling like one of the girls, isn't going to feel any more feminine when she never grows tits while all her friends do.
can anyone offer testimonials of having significantly altered their personality through conscious effort?
Let's break this down into a couple of components: Can circumstances significantly alter one's personality? And can one change one's circumstances through conscious effort? Put that way the answer is obviously yes to both. Circumstances are changing our personality all the time, and we can change our circumstances through conscious effort.
The way you have phrased it makes it seem as though one thinks really really hard about it and changes one's personality through sheer force of will. I don't have any experience with that, though others might.
On the other hand, I can attest to significant parts of my personality changing over time in response to circumstances, and to my ability to change my circumstances by conscious decision making. The guy attending the party typically acts differently than the guy throwing it, but all you need to do to become the guy throwing the party is to throw a party. Throw enough parties and you become that guy on a deeper level, a more permanent basis. Think of how people's professions and avocations become imprinted on their personality. The Marine Drill Sergeant, the kindergarten teacher, the mother, the surfer, the factory floor foreman, they weren't born with these personalities they were molded into them by assuming the role every day.
Think of it as the difference between buying a bag of chips and saying you won't eat them, versus choosing not to buy a bag of chips to begin with. One is a much easier use of will than the other.
So what circumstances can you create in your life to force sociality? To change how you interact with people? I have a couple random suggestions:
-- Are you American? If so, this is probably the middle of primary season in an off-off-year election in your state. This is a boring year around me: no governor, no legislative elections, no presidential election, just some local, school board, and county level stuff. This means that every election comes down to ground game, voter contact, and that no one gives a shit so they are desperate for interested volunteers and will take anyone. These groups are starved for volunteers, find someone you vaguely agree with* who is running for local office and get in touch with them and offer to work with them. Offer to knock on doors and speak to constituents about the candidate. For the most part even if you do a hilariously shitty job, the skin-in-the-game commitment of knocking on doors will have 75% of the value anyway for the candidate. And within a few days you will have your vibe down, your game down; you'll knock on the door and know exactly what to say when they open it.
-- Seek out a leadership/mentoring role. This can be in a work setting or in an avocational setting. I'm guessing here, but it sounds like you work in a technical white collar field in a junior role, you are talented but have no direct reports, no one is underneath you in the flow chart. This has accustomed you to a junior role, taking orders rather than giving them. You need to become accustomed to command. Volunteer to mentor new employees. Teach a class in something you know at a local community college or high school. Volunteer with the Boy Scouts or another youth org. Purely formal power, power with no meaning at all, will cause people (especially younger or dumber people) to automatically give you command, give you credibility and status, just find a way to get that title and you will start to learn how to use that power. When we think of the proverbial lost masculinity of our ancestors, a lot of it was wrapped up in the Great Chain of Being, even the serfs at the bottom of the pyramid ruled over their children and their animals. Right now you aren't used to giving orders, so it is unnatural, put yourself in circumstances where it is natural and you'll see a lot of social skills blossom.
-- Go to church. Piety is the single easiest valuable trait to fake your way through, where every other hobby has some buy in, churchgoers more or less have to be nice to you. Doesn't matter what church, just do it. Worst case ontario, Pascal's gamble right?
*Yeah yeah, all you extra special bois can chime in that there is no candidate who matches your views. I used to sympathize with this view, until I realized how much of it serves to substitute fantasy for action. If you wait until a movement appears that enacts your exact worldview, you'll never do anything, but the bright side is you'll never have to do anything.
The problem with your hypo is that if the entire banking system collapses, so does society, so the dollar bills themselves are worthless. The economy based on attenuated supply chains will break down. Center City apartments will become charnel houses under the strain of the famous trope about society being three meals from anarchy.
So the first thing you're looking for is to buy a ready-made isolated cabin with its own water supply and a relatively off-the-grid setup as far as electricity, heat, etc. You need a quick closing, cash offer, two weeks. Then see how many pallets of these CostCo will deliver in a hurry. You're going to overpay, because you need this done now, don't haggle over $100k and lose the whole $50mm. I recommend the North, far North, if you're handy with a chainsaw (buy a bunch of those too, electric will actually be easier to keep fueling than gas at a certain point) you can heat your house with wood, and a depression will see hordes wandering South where it's warm as it becomes harder to heat your home on broken supply chains.
The most practical way to cash out the rest of your $50mm is to buy something with it. Gold, for example, but anything else physical and storable and useful, is going to be better than literal banknotes in an emergency. Personally, ammo in a mix of 9mm, .223, and 22lr would be my first pick for a diversified "The Entire Fucking Banking System Collapses" portfolio. Ideally, take your weeks, and bury the gold and ammo in big plastic bins throughout your newly acquired woods.
Assuming the banking system, for some reason, doesn't collapse, you're probably going to take a big haircut if you have to get that stuff back to cash. Certainly the rush/freight shipping is going to brutalize you. What do we think, team, 20%? 25%? I don't think more than a third.
Weird. I definitely scroll through and get some shit that it just kinda throws in there, but it also definitely follows my likes and time watched. If I watch a single video of SCP narrated cartoons twice, I'll get a dozen of them in the next 20 videos. Ditto "Keep Your Rifle By Your Side" memes.
Addiction I don't really see, though it's easy to get sucked into scrolling when I'm very stoned at the end of a long day, so maybe a lot of other people are closer to that mental state normally.
For decades, one could not get a security clearance if one were homosexual. On the one hand this was a "natural" disgust reaction by those who hand out security clearances, but there was also a logic to it that went: I myself might not be homophobic, I might have all the goodwill in the world to homosexuals, but most people hate and despise homosexuality, so a homosexual simply has far too much blackmail material lying around waiting to get got by the damn Reds. You can't trust someone who has secrets that could be revealed to his family and embarrass him. It's too much to expect him to successfully keep this secret forever.
We've since moved past this, homosexuals are perfectly capable of getting security clearances, because exposing his homosexuality isn't going to qualify as blackmail in America in the Year of our Lord 2023. Who are you going to tell, his husband and the other guests at their wedding? We didn't make it ok to have Homos in security clearances by figuring out a way to reliably avoid their perversion getting detected by enemies, we simply decided that we didn't care about the perversion. Expose their sordid personal lives all you want, we knew they were sodomites when we hired them. We didn't prevent their exposure, we transcended the need to avoid exposure. We didn't end liberalism, we expanded it.
Now, as the proverb goes whose attribution I can't recall, there is almost no one alive whose sex life, if fully exposed to public ridicule, would not inspire revulsion and horror. And of course the modern sexual menu is like the Cheesecake Factory in its variety and artificiality. So we don't worry we'll be revealed as fags or fairies or sodomites or Saphists, but we worry about all kinds of other things. Are you some kind of fetishist? Furry? Pervert? BDSM? Like toys? Noncon? Wincest? Power relations? Raceplay? Like 'em a little on the young side? Messaging hot young hung bottoms on Insta? Just having a good old fashioned affair? All that and more is in your browser history for many people.
So TikTok offers a threat of blackmail. TikTok reflects back your own desires, it shows you what you like to see, what you look at. Some of that is various strategies to trick you into watching a video, but much of it is thirst traps. When I first downloaded the app to try it, it showed me some MILF bikini reveals, and while I'm not a regular porn user it's not like I'm not a fan of great tits. But, especially early on, watch a couple of them, pretty soon your feed is flooded with them. Keep watching them, and really who wouldn't keep watching them?, and pretty soon your TikTok app is just a softcore porn button. I didn't really like that, but to get rid of it I had to make a concerted effort to swipe past instantly every time I saw an attractive woman who might be about to take her dress off. If I were a little more interested, like a normal person, in seeing random breasts on a daily basis, I guess I wouldn't have done it. I'm happy to report that now I get nothing but Roman History, pictures of books, and Tedposting Indomitable Human Spirit Memes, along with a smattering of cutesy "I love you so much" poetry and Psycho Girl memes that have cross pollinated from my wife sharing things to me.
If I were a little more desperate, like so many in this alienated and anodyne age, I might be one of those simps who sends messages to thirst traps, who watches lives and sends "gifts" to get her to say your username, I'm sure there are even men who hire sex workers over TikTok though I have no first hand knowledge of it (certainly that happens on Reddit). Listening to Lex Friedman have Aella on his podcast, and feeling him gravitate towards her, I really appreciated the mindset of the simp for the first time. Aella's personality is tailor made to appeal to my autistic demographic in a way most professional thirst traps don't, and I could watch Lex's guard drop and sense his salivation over her. I thought to myself, especially in the altered state I was in at the time, there but for the grace of God go I, if I didn't get lucky and have the relationship I have with my wife, I could see how that kind of parasocial relationship could tempt a man.
And that's not even getting into the weird and socially frowned upon politics or CW issues one might find on TikTok. One could equally be exposed as a racist, a misogynist, a virulent hater of Christians/Jews/Muslims/Hindus/Blacks/Atheists/Baseball/America/France/Books/TV-Watchers/Weightlifters/Gays. And you don't see it because you set out to see it, you see a racist joke and you laugh at it because you find it funny, maybe you watch the video again, pretty soon you are flooded with racist joke videos, your whole feed is nothing but CoonTown, without ever making the conscious decision to set it up that way. TikTok caters to our basest desires, whether they be sexual or cultural, and our Id is not what we want exposed to the world.
The nightmare scenario isn't hard to picture: a politician rises who is a huge China Hawk, and then he is exposed by his TikTok, or threatened to be exposed, and his power is undermined. He was messaging Twink 18 year olds and buying them gifts during Lives, he was favoriting trashy negro jokes or Black nationalist rhetoric or antisemitism or whatever. ((Honestly, I'm surprised I haven't found out the sex toy habits or viewing history of politicians that publicly go after Amazon yet...)
But the solution isn't to abandon liberalism and ban TikTok, the solution as with homosexuality is to transcend our petty concern with the unimportant moral foibles that we all have but no one admits to. To quote Dan Savage who has written on the topic:
Back in the bad old days - the mythical 1950s, the era social conservatives pine for - most gay men were closeted, which made it relatively easy for them to arrange discreet trysts. You could rely on the discretion of your sex partners because they were relying on yours. It was the era of mutually assured destruction, both in terms of nuclear warfare and gay sex. Your partner couldn't reveal your secret without revealing his own.
His theory a decade ago was that we would hit a similar point with sexting and leaked nudes, we will reach a point where everyone has them and so no one cares when they are revealed because we did it too. I would guess that a supermajority of sexually active people under the age of 35 have sent noods at some point in their lives, and better than that number have sent otherwise explicit texts waiting to be leaked. But we haven't seen acceptance of it.
The way we beat TikTok and every other spy ring foreign and domestic isn't by abandoning Liberalism, but by expanding it, by accepting and addressing that what our Id enjoys in a six second video doesn't say anything important about our moral worth. We're all doing it, why not just accept it. Fuck you, CCP, show everyone that I love MILFs with great asses or Twinks with great asses or racist toilet humor, it doesn't mean anything about how I do my job. I think we should have taken the same attitude to the damn balloon! The Joint Chiefs should have given a press conference where they said: China, Mr. Xi, Generals of the Red Army, if you have questions come ask us! We'll take you on a tour of all our military facilities, so you can see just how powerful the United States Armed Forces are, how thoroughly capable we are of crushing any threat on any notice. If the Chinese want aerial photography they can just take it from a sat photo anyway, why piss ourselves about a fucking balloon?
TLDR: Don't end the first amendment to fight blackmail, end a culture that shames normal people for liking things that normal people like.
I can't imagine the mental toughness it would take to juggle:
Being isolated from friends and family for multiple weeks
Trying to act and build a personal brand for your financial future
Avoid committing crimes against leftist orthodoxy during a sexual pitfight
Deal with the perpetual threat of real physical violence from your housemates
I've always thought the skillset required to win The Bachelor/ette is actually very similar to the skillset needed to survive interrogation in a prisoner of war camp, or hold up under tough questioning in a police station, or run for Senate. What it's tough to think about is all the producers off camera who are asking them questions, leading them on that so and so is talking shit, pumping them up that they have a chance when they don't, or flat out lying to them about things that happen. And over and over the contestant has to look into the camera and repeat how he's there for the right reasons, how he loves love, never say anything negative or go against the weird mix of progressive feminism and brainless-protestantism that form the core values of the show. It must take a tremendous amount of mental fortitude to ad-lib playing the character in real time, never slipping up, never making a gaffe that becomes a controversy for an episode. A technically perfect contestant, like Katie Thurston when she was a contestant or Tyler C, is impressive in its own right, its own kind of performance.
Oh not at all, I think that is a very possible outcome. That's exactly why I find the possibilities fascinating. What level of violence would be attractive? At some point choosing for violence becomes maladaptive, but some degree of choosing violence is adaptive, where will it land?
Just depends on the year. You get some legendary male villains, like Chad and Luke P, who were all-timers. Or Nick Viall, the GOAT, sleeping with the lead midway through the season. I've never watched the German version!
Unless the woman, who has all the power (quite literally in this scenario) to reward or punish violence by keeping/removing contestants, chooses to prevent or punish violence. Which is the thing I am most interested in seeing play out! Keeping in mind that my theory is the Lead basically wants to end up engaged to a man she could marry at the end of the process; while I do think the contestants/leads are in it for fame, the best way to set yourself up for life fame-wise is to form a couple that stays together, have kids, etc.
The lead could send a man home after a fight even if he won, if she felt it was inappropriate to do so. She could probably send a man home early, before the fight even occurred. I suspect, logically, the group would quickly converge on moral rules for when fights are appropriate or inappropriate. Things like "If you challenge the same guy over the same thing twice, you're going home" or "if you're always getting into fights, you're going home" or "If a big former college football lineman challenges a scrawny programmer, he gets sent home (and maybe the programmer does too)." Or regulate reasons to start fights: "X claiming that Y said that he's only here to promote his Tequila Company" is good and Y has to fight for or apologize; but if X is trying to start a fight because "Y took my lunchmeat and ate it when he knew I was planning on eating it" then Y is under no obligation to accept.
Also keep in mind that the men themselves can pressure the Lead. Either hard power by Unionization plays, more common in recent seasons, where we've seen a group of men go to the Lead together and say "X is dangerous/abusive/mean, if you keep him we're all going to walk." Or by simply speaking to her about what's going on.
As an experiment, I want to have a season of the reality TV show The Bachelorette with the rule modification that any contestant can publicly challenge any other contestant to a boxing match at any time. Currently the basic rule features one woman and thirty men competing for her affections, each week she chooses some men to stay and lets some go, until she gets down to the last guy, and then they get engaged and hopefully (though not typically) later get married. Typically they already do one boxing/wrestling or other forced violence date a season. Much of the show is about competition and dislike and hatred and other reality tv show drama created between the male contestants.
The new rule implemented would be that any contestant can challenge any contestant at any time to an amateur boxing match in front of other contestants and the cameras. If you do so, everyone (other contestants and the woman) knows that the challenge has been issued, but the challenged is under no obligation to take it up, and victory or defeat means nothing. Winning doesn't mean you automatically move on, or that you're right about the argument, losing doesn't mean you lost the argument or you have to go home. The lead woman is free to send the winner home and keep the loser, or send a challenger home and keep the man who refused to fight him. Win or lose you are free to go right on talking shit about what x said about y or whatever. The only impact of the challenge would be that everyone knew the challenge was made and whether the challenge was accepted, and then the men would fight publicly.
I'd love to see how this would play out. Would the lead favor winners? Favor smaller weaker men who accept challenges even if they lose them? Would she send big strong men home if they challenge a smaller weaker man over nothing worth the effort? Would she send a man home who challenges repeatedly, win or lose, because he is too violent? Would the men themselves behave differently, avoiding drama or giving bigger dudes a wide berth, to avoid challenges? Would there be a standard established, a Bach-verse "Code Duello" where x is a sufficient insult to require a fight but if you challenge over Y you're the weirdo and he is under no obligation to accept the challenge? I'm sure a lot of people think they know the answers, but I'm curious to see what they actually are. How is the willingness/skill to use violence valued in a romantic partner in 2023?
There have been real life examples of big violent dudes who try to start shit with smaller, weaker dudes and use their physicality to intimidate or injure others. Often a particular smaller, weaker dude will latch onto this for screentime and start playing "bait the gorilla" hoping to provoke a violent response. The violent dudes nearly always get sent home quickly, but the smaller weaker bullied dude also ends up getting sent home not long afterward. It's tough not to read that as the women saying: I don't want a violent moron, but I also don't want a pussy-boy who can't stand up for himself and runs to mommy to tattle. How would this dynamic change if there were a formal "let's fight it out" process?
Yes.
I've been getting super into Landmine exercises and complexes since my wife got one. Anyone have one? What exercises do you do? What are some weird ones I might be missing?
I would say most regulation of male-female interactions in the workplace involves a certain kind of capitalist autism common to accountants and business consultants. The reduction of man to only appropriate and not inappropriate tasks, the idea that all communication should be essentially "on topic" or "harmless." The idea that parts of your humanity can be checked at the door when you start work and resumed seamlessly upon leaving work. The way corporate capitalism has slowly eaten so much of the dating and broader social world that it is very much in question whether it is possible for the populations involved in an advanced capitalist economy to reproduce themselves.
The commonly expressed media/corporate HR view that it is perfectly reasonable to continuously narrow the circle in which people can meet, with no consequences, is based on social illiteracy.
If the doomerists are anyway right, he'll be just another one of the fleshbags. For someone who seems to live in a constant state of "I'm Jewish, so everyone wants to Holocaust me", I can see why he'd pin his hopes on machine intelligence being the boss of the world. But he's wrong - sure, the machine won't care that he's Jewish, but it also won't care that he's smart for a fleshbag. He's just more paperclip material.
I think Aaronson thinks of himself primarily by his intellect and lack of emotional range, and he's read/watched a lot of science fiction where the AGI is the intellect in the group and lacks emotional range (despite, at the end of the day, being a character written by a human), so he's come to subconsciously identify himself with the AGI. He sees a lot of himself in, say, Lt. Data. When an android like Data comes on screen he starts to identify with him instantly, that's the character that's going to act like me.
I think I've talked before on here how, in media, I realized that subconsciously I identified myself sometimes with Jewish and often with Asian or South Asian characters as soon as they walked on screen when I was growing up. Even though I personally have none of those traits, or anything close, in the 90s/oughts when a character from those groups popped up he was more likely to be off-beat but intelligent, more known for brains than brawn, didn't fit in with the "cool kids" and had to find his own way. Which was what I thought myself to be at the time. The Judaism wasn't really necessary to that plot, but it was an instant signal that would be his role. Where when a character that actually looked like me appeared on screen, he was likely to be a dumb blonde jock, someone I didn't identify with at all. This is, I think, what is going on when people talk about liberals preferring the outgroup.
Aaronson has taken this all the way to the extreme of making his preferred outgroup non-humans, because that's the group he identifies with when they walk on camera.
Is there something else I'm not considering?
Our regulation of modern means of travel is itself on very, very shaky constitutional ground, and only the fact that the majority of people impacted by these laws tend to be from disadvantaged and disorganized sections of the population has prevented the formation of any kind of interest group to oppose it. The government already has all the tools in place to thoroughly restrict the movement of individuals it deems unworthy, and that it has not done so in a way that harms most Americans is contingent rather than principled.
Freedom of travel within states is generally a protected right in all state constitutions outside of private property laws. The right to travel in between states is protected specifically in the federal constitution. But that right has been thoroughly eroded by restricting it to, essentially, walking; and then restricting walking on major limited access highways even if you were crazy enough to try. One can be placed on the no fly list with no notice and only a convoluted bureaucratic method to appeal one's placement. Mask and vaccine mandates were used to restrict use of public transit. Driver's licenses can be revoked for crimes, and insurance requirements mean that as we inevitably get our social credit system in place it will be impossible to own a car if one has committed too much wrongthink. After all, do you really want to be known as the insurance company that does business with Spencer or Bannon?
I'm not saying that car or other travel regulations are on a purely utilitarian basis wrongheaded, I'm saying that they are dangerously tyrannical in the same way that gun control is, and we need to think hard about the parallels both in the direction of protecting 2a rights, and in the direction of abolishing or due-process-ing the No Fly List.
Actuarial calculations do not consider eg parking and non accident hazards.
I love cars, but I'm pro tiered licensing at this point. Basic license as currently constructed should cover cars up to 180-230 horsepower, anything higher than that should require actual driving training, including track work on vehicle dynamics, and towing/large vehicle handling. I'm tired of people buying gigantic trucks/SUVs that they can't drive or park. Hazard to themselves and others.
Tons of great cars have less than 230 horsepower. You can get a Transit Van that will hit highway speeds with cargo or passengers, you can get a Toyota GR86 and have a ton of fun. But you can't get a car that is both big and fast; driving a Suburban or an F150 with a 220 horsepower engine isn't that enjoyable.
Fine, you want a Hellcat or a Raptor? If you've got $50k+ to spend on a car, pony up $10k and a couple weekends to take classes at the track.
I could do the same things with occurrences throughout Breaking Bad or (at least the later seasons of) The Wire; the difference being that when there's a yawning plot hole in those shows they shove a bomb into it or handwave corruption somewhere in the system as covering it up. An understanding boyfriend is a much more logical plot contrivance than a robot machine gun.
I can only really tell you that my wife hated it. It was probably something that everyone watched but no one was really satisfied by.
The first half season they're finding their legs, the show follows the book really closely the first season and a half. Between scooter to the first wedding is the peak of the show.
Feminism has no Scalable Answer for Female Promiscuity
The apex of consumerist-choice-Feminism just dropped: this product review disguised as a slutty memoir-thinkpiece in New York Magazine’s Strategist section (typically for product reviews and recommendations, I go there to find good sheets or sheet pans). The piece traces the writer’s life by the backpacks she uses: an overnight bag that she used to cart her things as a side-piece to various jerks for emotionally empty sex, to a laptop bag that held her work when she tried to ignore men altogether, to a small purse that was appropriate to her newly traditional role as a formal “girlfriend” to a “nice” guy. It’s the romanticized and thinkpieced arc of the feminist career woman, which I’m sure has already been “react”-ified and shouted down by various Red Pill commentators online. I’m not particularly interested in the woman-cum-backpack-reviewer at the center of the story, but rather in her portrayal of her new boyfriend, the “nice” guy she worries is too boring, and how he is portrayed as reacting to her actions. It raises the question for me: does Feminism actually have any realistic solution to how men should react to female promiscuity?
The author of the piece describes her relationship to her new boyf:
This new guy is single — a.k.a. actually available — hot, and nice. I used to think “nice” was an insult, or that if someone were “nice,” I’d grow tired of them, but with him, it excites me even more. [NB: She also states that she has been with him for FIFTEEN DAYS making the boredom question a little…strange]
I don’t know what’s going to happen with this new man. In fact, my past year of dating has made it hard to feel like anything good will happen. I’m pretty convinced I’m still destined to live a life jumping from affair to romance to affair. I’m self-sabotaging. I tell this new man about all of the men I’ve fucked over, who have fucked me over. I name drop. I body count. I say things with the screaming subtext of: Why would you want to be with me?
But this time, I realize what I’m doing. Sorry — this time he realizes what I’m doing. He says hearing about all of the guys I’ve slept with hurts his feelings and asks me why I continue to do it. This kind, goofy man makes me feel like I can apologize. Like I can tell him I lied. Like I can tell him that what I’m doing is obviously me trying to blow up whatever good thing we’re beginning to create.
The author presents her sexual and romantic history to her boyfriend, and he engages in heroic acts of self-abnegation to comfort her for hurting him. He reacts to her efforts to harm him with love and care. This is ideal partner territory, someone who loves you unconditionally and will react to any action with affection, totally unrealistic after fifteen days. This isn't any kind of scaleable solution. And I’m reminded of one of the great artistic works of consumerist-choice-Feminism: Sex and the City.
SATC gets unfairly scratched from midwit lists of great TV shows because the Chapo Trap House types who get excited about TV shows love unrealistic “masculine” fantasies of violent crime stories, and not romantic sex comedies. But SATC was critical to the birth of high concept TV, was a key tent pole that kept HBO making shows like Sopranos and The Wire, and presaged so much of modern culture that it’s a crime to miss it. My wife and I watched the whole series together just after we got married, late at night after studying or working, we joked that arguing about the characters was our “Post-Cana” sessions. What SATC was good at was asking really interesting questions, over and over my wife and I would argue late into the night and over coffee in the morning over which character was right and what one should do in that situation; what it was bad at was pussying out when it came time to face the answers. The characters would always be put into interesting situations, then saved from the consequences of their own actions in a way that sort of neutered the original dramatic/philosophical tension.
In a season 3 episode trenchantly titled “Are We Sluts?”; Big-Law attorney Miranda gets diagnosed with Chlamydia and has to list her sex partners so that she can call them and tell them that they might have gotten it from her. My wife and I counted the lines on the second sheet of notepaper, assuming it was a regular legal pad (and one man per line) she had sex with ~42 men. The character was 33 at the time, so using Slate’s handy slut calculator she is in the 96th percentile, so, yeah, up there. Miranda is naturally…concerned...by this realization, and how her boyfriend Steve will feel about it. Much of the episode is the characters debating the value of chastity and promiscuity, telling the truth, should it matter, etc. There’s a lot of tension around will this ruin Miranda’s relationship. She tells Steve and, guess what? Steve just laughs; I’m a cute bartender, my number is much much higher than that. Dramatic tensions wasted, values crisis resolved: Steve’s fucked a ridiculous number of women so Miranda having fucked a huge number of men is a nothing burger.
Similar plots are wasted later: protagonist Carrie cheats and ruins her relationship with her fiancé, only to have her adulterous partner actually chase her down years and partners later, champion-slut Samantha ultimately only settles down because her man puts in unrealistic efforts of understanding and care and loyalty. The show spends whole seasons asking questions, only to deus-ex the problems right out of existence when they want to make the characters happy. Smart enough to know there is a problem, not smart enough to come up with a satisfying realistic solution.
And this is what connected in my head reading that bullshit little dialogue in this advertisement-cum-confessional: Feminism knows that a sexual past can be a problem, but can’t imagine a realistic solution. Like so many wasted episodes of Sex and the City it is smart enough to understand that tension exists, but not smart enough to come up with a real solution. The only solutions presented are either Christ-like acts of self-control on the part of the male, or for the women to marry a man with an unrealistically high partner count himself. The supply of Christ-like and mega-player partners will never meet the demand, particularly as those men are not similarly limited. It simply will not scale: the solution to female promiscuity can never be greater male promiscuity except through fuzzy math. And those waiting for the one really good man who really loves her may be waiting in vain.
I’m not sure what a Feminist-compatible solution is, beyond rejiggering the entirety of masculinity and sex-positive culture to accommodate for it. I can’t imagine anything New York would print that would be a realistic answer, rather than a scolding “get better, men” that would achieve nothing but catharsis for angry women. A solution to this problem seems outside the Feminist range of imagination. 20 years after Sex and the City aired, promiscuous New Yorkers are no closer to an answer to that age old question: “Are we Sluts?"
This type of behavior is exemplified by shows in the 2000s like Gilmore Girls, where you have a single mother who is consistently acting like a teenage girl, while literally getting emotional support and advice from her teenage daughter. You can have your cake and eat it too folks - have a kid while also having a fun teenage buddy to chat about boys with!
Oh man I have thoughts on Gilmore Girls. ((Weirdly this is "Chick flick analysis on themotte" day for me)) My wife watches it all the time, it's her anxiety blanket of a show. Which is weird because she kind of hates it too.
The whole series is fascinating when you consider it in light of the reboot. To summarize for the vast majority of straight men who have no idea what I'm talking about: Gilmore Girls tells the story of Lorelai and Rory Gilmore, a mother and daughter living in Connecticut, and then to a lesser extent Rory's wealthy grandmother Emily. Lorelai got pregnant as a teenager and ran away from home, despite coming from a wealthy family she worked her way up through service industry jobs at hotels because she cut contact with her rich parents after getting pregnant, raising Rory as a single mother with virtually no contact with the father and no long term partners (iirc); Rory is a brilliant child and always presented as destined for great things, going to a fancy private high school before going to Yale. As Dag said, the core of the show is the mother-daughter relationship, and to bring it back to my original diagram it fits right in! Emily is the thesis, staid, stubborn and traditional, a controlling DAR matron; who uses her money to control the lives of her subordinates and family. Lorelai is the antithesis, she chooses to cut all contact with her wealthy parents and work low-class jobs rather than put up with her mother's controls. Rory is the synthesis, the star-baby, contrasted with every other character that must choose a side she is all things to all people, she is able to bring peace between the prior generations, she is comfortable with the commoners and with the aristos, she can walk with Kings [but not] lose the common touch. Her graduation from Yale with plans for a sparkling journalism career is the culmination of the first run of the show, all is solved and all is golden, Rory will avoid Emily and Lorelai's mistakes while hanging on to their positive qualities.
Then Netflix came along with a truckload of money to run a brief reboot Gilmore Girls: A Year in The Life which ran four episodes, and revisited everyone's favorite characters. (Except Melissa McCarthy, who they could only afford for a cameo after she was a side character for the original) A bunch of irrelevant shit happens, but the main points are (spoilers ahead) Rory is unemployed and broke and moves back in with her mother, having failed to have a sterling journalistic career or to succeed in any other field, has no long term romantic partner while having a series of flings, and in the climactic final scene reveals to her mother that she is pregnant. Which sets the entire prior point of the show on its head: Rory isn't the starchild after all, she is instead trapped in a cycle of failure and single motherhood. Rendered incapable of forming real romantic commitments by the lack of a father figure or a strong male presence in her early life, she allows herself to be used as a side piece, convincing herself that her refusal to commit is her freedom, when in reality it traps her and those around her in an endless cycle of slavery. The first seasons of the show are tragic in light of this conclusion, knowing that Rory won't make good makes her journey through Chilton and Yale Sisyphean rather than Herculean, the ultimate destination is right back where her mother started: single, jobless, and pregnant in small town Connecticut.
At a meta level, this is the difference between late Washington Consensus/End-Of-History plots (Gilmore Girls debuted in 2000), and post-Obama plots. The first seven seasons hope to reconcile the family, to bring everything together in a hopeful conclusion. The Netflix reboot tells us all of that was nonsense, we're all trapped in a cycle of failure, nothing matters or will ever get better. The characters that come out of the reboot looking smarter are those who didn't try: Lane and Zack "tend their garden;" they have kids together, they still play music, and they're happier than the Faustian characters like Rory and Paris who were supposed to be their natural betters. The best Rory can hope for is that her mother's journey will bring understanding to her journey with her own child...but how much fucking understanding do we need before one of these girls can father a baby in wedlock for a change?

Lightrat. I'm surprised I scored so high, to be quite honest. But I'm curious how people said "studied" for different things. Studied advanced physics like, at a university course you passed, or like on a youtube playlist from a random guy with crazy eyes? But then, maybe the Rats who didn't actually study physics thinking they study physics is what makes them rationalists.
More options
Context Copy link