@FiveHourMarathon's banner p

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users  
joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


				

User ID: 195

FiveHourMarathon

a worthless check, a total wreck, a flop

17 followers   follows 6 users   joined 2022 September 04 22:02:26 UTC

					

And every gimmick hungry yob

Digging gold from rock n roll

Grabs the mic to tell us

he'll die before he's sold

But I believe in this

And it's been tested by research

He who fucks nuns

Will later join the church


					

User ID: 195

/r/weightroom has the smartest commenters of any subreddit, because they mercilessly prune anyone who doesn't. You have to prove that you actually ARE big and strong, or it ain't happening for you. They gatekeep mercilessly.

So the question is, how do you gatekeep intelligence on an open forum? The only way outside of such objective tools as "What's your powerlifting total?" is to put something offensive to normies in the forum. Like long boring effortposts, or constant efforts to redefine everything, or whatever.

Yes but, in both cases, there is no cohesive conservative market to which one would target. There's no huge store of ideologically conservative high end workers to tap, because making money is the terminal value for many conservatives, they just won't take a pay cut for ideology. Affirmative action only produces bitter victims a tier below the one you were looking for. And despite what films tell us, given the option most leaders would prefer obedience to free thinking.

And in dating there is no significant subset of women who are single, attractive, conservative, and non religious.

You could potentially come up with a ruleset that would stop the clock when a player gave himself up. You'd have to tune it to situation to avoid it being used for advantageous clock-stopping, but that seems potentially feasible. This wouldn't be entirely novel, we already have the opposite of it at the boundary - if an offensive player goes out of bounds backwards, the clock doesn't stop, you have to be advancing the ball to get the clock stoppage.

In all sports, I'm in favor of more aggressive and crazy rules to eliminate situations where the game becomes completely different during the last 2-5 minutes. For example, I think in Basketball during the last 4-5 minutes the rule should be that every penalty committed by the losing team drops 25 seconds off the clock. Because I hate watching the Hack-a-thons at the end of playoff games, I'd rather just watch Basketball.

I don't know how you make penalties sufficient to prevent time wasting plays at the end of an nfl game, but there's got to be a way.

I believe this is true of the vast majority of corporations in the US! Identity politics are a small part of the business signaling that goes on every day. It’s directly proportional to how much the product is a cultural symbol rather than a material good. Apple products or Amazon media or Super Bowl ads are more likely to publicly proclaim their diversity because they’re selling an idea. It does not require true believers, though they help with credibility. The idea itself is what benefits from woke signaling.

This has implications for the trajectory of DEI. Debating whether woke ads are going to increase or alienate support is missing the point. That sort of identity politics is downstream of the culture war, and should not be used to make predictions about “peak woke.” It represents corporate ability to score points off the prevailing winds, not ideologues’ level of infiltration into corporations.

In a prior post talking about discrimination against conservatives in online dating we discussed almost this exact question as far as the value of signaling political beliefs in an asymmetric way.

I feel like on dating apps there's a certain Strawmanization of political spectrum where 'Right = Super fascist' and 'Moderate/Apolitical/whatever = Hiding Super Fascist'.

[I]f listing your politics as "Right Wing" or even "Moderate" is the objectively wrong answer in online dating, then doing so means you probably fall under either 1) or 2). Either you don't even know the socially correct answer, so you're a maladroit chump, that's not an attractive look; or you're so right wing that you can't possibly stay in the closet about it, it would be too obvious, which regardless of your politics isn't a good look, and quite likely maps onto something like "superfascist" anyway.

In the same way, it doesn't require that a company is "woke" or even that they want to signal "wokeness" to choose to advertise in that way. The company's officers merely must "know" that woke is the objectively correct answer in terms of how to advertise/signal. That's the way that the fashionable folks signal, so if you signal that way you are signaling that you know what you're doing and that you are aware of the social mores in question. Doing otherwise indicates that you are either ignorant of those social mores, or so incapable of hiding your politics that it would be pointless to try. Neither are good looks, in dating or in corporate marketing. The socially accepted provision of a "correct" answer makes using the incorrect answer a sign of stupidity or extremism.

The most fascinating difference between European Football and NFL play is the difference in approach to rules. FIFA approaches all rules as vague visual guidelines, the ball is out of bounds when you can see it is out of bounds so they throw it in and keep playing, a foul is when he, ya know, fouls the other guy, the clock just kinda runs for 90 minutes and they throw on a little extra at the end. The NFL approaches rules with Talmudic discernment. What really constitutes a catch? The clock stops at the precise moment when a pass is incomplete or a player goes out of bounds, we will take a 45 second timeout to determine the incorrect presence or absence of 2 seconds from gameplay. How many pass-interference calls can occur between Angels playing a game on the head of a pin?

To beat it you need similar coordination, talent, and full team buy in. It wasn't just about being big and strong, the whole Eagles team really bought into it. Kelce and Hurts were the offensive team leaders, and they were always putting it all out there on every sneak.

The Eagles, through a mix of having essentially the pro-bowl offensive line, a QB who squats 600lbs and will do anything to win, and tremendous full team buy-in, call a QB sneak and get 2-3 guys behind Hurts who push him into the line scrum style. Hurts is the ball carrier, but in a very real sense he just curls up and becomes the ball, with 2-3 guys behind and 2-3 guys in front doing the actual moving.

It amounted to a cheat code for a lot of the season to get 1-2 yards automatically. Where that might get banned:

  1. Physical toll, or a public perception of the physical toll. It's actually relatively unlikely to result in injury, it is the big open field hits that do the worst damage, but it looks brutal and the NFL might not like that. QBs who aren't physical specimens might or might not use the NFLPA to bring this up.

  2. Changing strategy. The Eagles had a LOT of boring wins, part of which was that they could run the ball for 3 yards on 1st-3rd downs, and then push on 4th. I think 4 down football makes the game more exciting personally, but I could see teams complaining that it allowed the Eagles to just sit on 7-14 point leads and smother the game rather than play aggressively or give the ball back to the other team.

  3. Aesthetics. Some NFL magnates might not like how it looks. Just flat out think it is ugly, unentertaining, bad for the TV brand.

Resident Eagles fan: I'm profoundly NOT salty about that game. It was very much a good Super Bowl, the Eagles proved they are the second best team in the league, and Hurts proved he's a real QB at that level playing Mahomes to a 4th quarter field goal. No one can walk out of this game saying the Eagles were frauds, which concerned me way more than them losing in the Super Bowl.

At the end of the day, the Eagles win if it weren't for that Fumble Recovery TD given up to the Chiefs. The tendency is to focus on the mistakes in the 4th quarter, but any 3 expected points swing from any play is equally culpable.

The thing about the NFL and "defecting" against making it an entertaining game is that the NFL has the power to change the rules. It's likely that the Hurts QB Push is going to be made illegal next year, for example, because it's such a wild cheat code for the Eagles all season. At most you can defect for one season, and if it becomes an issue the collective will act to limit it. It wouldn't be hard for the NFL to institute a penalty for, eg, "Non Competitive Play" where Pacheco would have been required to run into the endzone on that play or something like that.

I once played pool in a friend's basement, his father (who had never played pool, just thought it's something he should have) put the table together with the bumpers attached backwards. As a result the corners were tiny, basically unusable unless you had a precise 45 degree angle, while the side pockets were enormous. It changed strategy significantly.

Plutarch was more or less writing for this exact purpose. Ditto Xenophon's Cyropaedia, which presented the education of an ideal leader. The Aeneid was largely also presenting an ideal hero/leader. Much of ancient history writing was pedagogic, meant to present ideal leaders to emulate, and mistakes to avoid.

INTUITION ESSAY CONTEST VOTING

My Intuition Essay contest, is concluded. Voting is today. The contestants are as follows

@TheDag entered Intuition in a Scientific Age

@f3zinker entered A Case For/Against Education, Intuition

@felipec entered My Intuition About Intuition

@Pitt19802 entered This Untitled Piece Comparing Statistical and Intuitive Approaches in Baseball and Politics

Technically, these two came after the deadline, but I also received quality submissions from

@Gaashk on a Jungian View of Intuition

and

@ryandv on Forming Connections via Similarity of Mental Models

In the tradition of my law school moot court contests, I will include these submissions in the poll, because I don't feel the need to be technical about deadlines in a casual game; if you feel strongly that they should not be included simply don't vote for them.

@DaseindustriesLtd also wrote this piece on the topic but explicitly asked to be excluded from the competition, hoping to leave the field to the rest of us mortals.

Vote here. It's going to be simple voting, I'm not doing ranked choice or anything. I will contact the winner on Wednesday, after the SSS thread is supplanted by the WW thread, and we will choose which charity I will donate $300 to.

If I missed any appropriate posts, please link them below and I will add them to the list and the ultimate voting. ANY EFFORTPOST ABOUT INTUITION, EVEN IF IT WAS NOT WRITTEN TO BE INCLUDED IN THE COMPETITION IS ELIGIBLE. As long as it was written between my original post and the end of the day Friday, it can be included in the ultimate voting. I looked through the CW threads for the appropriate period, and found nothing else which made sense to include, but feel free to point out anything I might have missed.

Don't we see this in, eg, online flirting and sexting? Text is cheap, pics, audio and video are more costly; at a certain point people demand they have some personal specific element to the videos/pics to show care and commitment.

  1. Reschedule to a more convenient date. Easier to get tables, tickets, etc. Because it is only you two that are relevant, it isn't hard to get buy in compared to other holidays.

  2. The right takeout meal can be a very convenient accompaniment to love making.

  3. Depending where you are, the "get a nice hotel room to fuck all night in" bit can work pretty well.

  4. Role play being a different couple shopping for something large. Furniture you'd never buy, art, an expensive car, an open house at a large home for sale. It can be so much fun. I may or may not have gone so far as to use fake business cards and names when out of town with my wife, just to fuck with the realtors.

  5. Buy a cheap fake engagement ring off of Amazon. Have your husband publicly propose to you somewhere like a public square, or mall, or restaurant. Loudly reject him, tell him you fucked his brother and you love his brother more, say you can't marry him because he has a wife, or because he's a scientologist, or whatever you like. If it's a bar, he'll probably get a free drink out of it.

  6. Take that same fake engagement ring, find out where one of your single friends is going for V day with a temporary partner, approach the maitre'd and tell him your friend wants this put in the lady's dessert. Sit back and watch.

  7. Get each other gag gifts, the worst least romantic thing you can find at a dollar store. See who wins. ((My prior winner was knee sleeves, because they implied both that she was old and that we were going to have rough sex, at the same time))

  8. Depending on the weather wherever you are, hiking is often doable but uncommon in February. Find a nice overlook or hillside to kiss and read poetry on.

Thanks for the car adapter tip, not sure why it hadn't occurred to me that there might be a solution to my setup, but that's seems like something I should own. Purchased.

They used to be really shitty, I had one growing up that could pick 4 frequencies and never worked well. I think the newer ones are just much more powerful and so do a much better job.

I'm currently in the first book, he's about to lose his first senate campaign to Pappy.

I think your observation of how Johnson was a product of his time is a good one. We don't reward politicians for that kind of work anymore. We're constantly on the lookout for the next big thing, and ignore the steady workmanlike stuff. Even Biden, though he's the ultimate insider/swamp creature, wasn't elected on a record of effectiveness merely one of continued existence.

INTUITION ESSAY CONTEST FINAL CALL

My Intuition Essay contest, in which a poll will be set up on Sunday to choose among the entrants who will get to pick the charity for the $200 donation, is drawing to a close. Any other submissions made today, 2/10, will be accepted and included in voting Sunday. Right now I count four (4) submissions, all of which were kind enough to note directly that they were entering:

@TheDag entered Intuition in a Scientific Age

@f3zinker entered A Case For/Against Education, Intuition

@felipec entered My Intuition About Intuition

and, last but not least,

@Pitt19082 entered This Untitled Piece Comparing Statistical and Intuitive Approaches in Baseball and Politics

If I missed any appropriate posts, please link them below and I will add them to the list and the ultimate voting. ANY EFFORTPOST ABOUT INTUITION, EVEN IF IT WAS NOT WRITTEN TO BE INCLUDED IN THE COMPETITION IS ELIGIBLE. As long as it was written between my original post and the end of the day today, it can be included in the ultimate voting. I looked through the CW threads for the appropriate period, and found nothing else which made sense to include, but feel free to point out anything I might have missed.

It's been a hot minute since I read Plato, but as I recall there was no self-important smugness in the analogy.

When people talk about Jordan Peterson, they're mostly talking about Jordan Peterson fans. When people talk about Barack Obama, they're mostly talking about their perception of Democratic voters more generally.

When OP talks about Plato, he's likely talking about the glosses that have been put on it, the secondary sources, etc.

I guess? Maybe it's a sample size issue, but if I sit down and list them out, there's almost no correlation in the first 5, barely any in the first 10, and it's pretty weak still. It's only if you look at the podium winners that a correlation is strong. So, no, I wouldn't say that this is experientially intuitive to me at all, as I experienced it in real life. Some of the most talented lovers I had were...not to everyone's taste. Some of the women who were really hot were bad in bed. And take out any one podium winner, if I slept in that day or left early or whatever, and the correlation gets much weaker.

I'm putting up a poll to determine the winner, but if I were the one selecting it this would have had it in a laugher. Michael Lewis and Robert Caro are two of my favorite authors, Baseball was my favorite sport as a child, and the question of why was Barack Obama a wildly ineffective president (relative to expectations) is basically the second formative political question of my life (the first being Iraq War II).

Intuition is an interesting place to pin the difference between LBJ and Obama in terms of effectiveness. Say what you like about Lyndon and his legacy, he passed a ton of very important legislation, stuff that changed the face of the country on a permanent basis. Obama, for the most part, did not. Obamacare was an abortion of a piece of legislation, trying to fit a queen size sheet on a king size bed and call it coverage. Foreign policy barely changed from the Bush years. Etc.

I always thought that the difference could be placed in terms of a fundamental laziness on the part of Barack Obama, a "big speech" disease that caused him to constantly chase the big event, the big announcement, the big omnibus bill, the new direction new paradigm moment; while ignoring the little things, the relationships, that actually grind tough bills through Congress.

Listening to The Years of Lyndon Johnson literally right now, I'm struck by how (in Caro's inimitable verbosity) down and dirty it gets on what gathering political power actually meant. LBJ spent decades forming relationships, learning who to talk to and talking to them, shaking hands, doing favors. He accumulated positions in moribund organizations and then made those organizations powerful from his college frat to the DCCC. Most of those don't pay off, a few do pay off big, and he worked his way up. At every step it was a grind, it was putting in the work, going door to door, making phone calls, sending letters, sucking up and kissing ass where necessary, whipping subordinates into line. By the time LBJ became president, he had learned the value of hard political labor to get anything done.

Obama, by contrast, parachuted into national politics with his 2004 keynote speech, and was running for POTUS in earnest by late 2006 early 2007. He didn't have time to learn where the proverbial bathrooms were in the Senate before becoming president. He might have been an extraordinarily intelligent man, but he never learned the value of grinding away. Obama became president on the power of a few great speeches, and some great statistical environments for his run in the Post-Bush oncoming-Recession timeframe. He never spent time grinding away at any political project, and when he was president he never did that too much either. He constantly tried to give one big speech, and the media cooperated, that was going to change the whole direction. He never spent time whipping votes and trading favors, maybe he couldn't do it anyway.

And maybe that ties back to your Malcolm Gladwell 10k hours bit. LBJ put in the work in the trenches, from practically childhood with his father. Obama learned that wasn't necessary. LBJ needed that time to learn how to do what he was able to do, to get the Civil Rights Act passed. Obama's lack of that skill stalled the public option in healthcare.

Another lesson could be that intuition is useful at the top, but difficult to hire out. You can have an intuitive manager in the dugout, and the numbers crunchers back at HQ can feed him data; you can't have a numbers cruncher in the dugout and an intuitive guy back at HQ feeding him hunches. LBJ could hire numbers guys, Obama couldn't hire empaths.

PS: This product works beautifully for setting up bluetooth in all my old cars. Honestly I like it better than using the built in bluetooth on a lot of cars, which can be rather clunky. Just plugs into a cigarette lighter, and broadcasts FM signal to the radio. I really only couldn't find a station when I was driving through DC, once, and I didn't look all that hard.

We are at 3 that I have counted, I'm going to comb through the main threads to see if there are any posts on the topic I missed. But even if we were at 2 I would have done it, i just put in the 3 minimum to avoid having two that were absolute drivel, or just one that was our learned friend Dr. Pedofascist writing something wild about how to intuit when kids are into it, and being FORCED to give them the win by default. Everyone submitted excellent work, any one of them earned the win.

I'd encourage you to submit though, it might be better than you think.

How would you phrase it? Sexual partners seems odd to me, many of mine I have no idea whether they would have made good wives or not. From what you said, I don't think your one or two night stands would have given you much insight either. Sex isn't a good indicator of seriousness. I tried to leave that to each person up determine when they'd have that judgment.

What's the level of commitment of your membership?

If/once you're very committed, Russell's History of Western Philosophy will cover, well, what it says on the tin.

If you're looking for something short/easy; I second Marcus Aurelius, or I'll throw in Hesse "Siddhartha." It's practically a pamphlet, but it has a followable narrative and asks all the big questions.

I'm not sure that's a TRP or PUA approved term, just my own; but it's a trashy reflex that fits in with that kind of thing. "He's just not that into you" or the TikTok "If he wanted to he would" stands for the idea that if a man really likes you he's going to go for you. He's not going to tell you "work is hectic" or that "the timing is bad" or that he's "coming off a breakup and doesn't want to get into anything serious right now." He's going to love you and make love to you asap, anything else means he's keeping you on the hook but not going to stick around unless he's desperate.

The Most Favored Nation idea is the sexual, hetero-male equivalent: if she's attracted to you she will want to fuck you, she will want to fuck you fast and she will want to fuck you wild, and that basically scales in terms of the wildness of the sex versus the level of attraction. So if you know, or especially if she lets it be known, or double especially if she specifically tells you, that she's been wilder with other partners, that means she was more attracted to them than she is to you and you should move on.* It's basically a rejection of women following The Rules or the FDS approach to dating; if she really liked you she'll throw out the handbook and be with you immediately. Giant red flag if she tells you about all the gross things she used to do with other guys, but doesn't do with you because you're nice to her; either she was more into them, or she is telling you how she likes to be treated while giving herself plausible deniability. You should demand in partners the best, wildest sex they've ever had with another partner, anything else means she is Just Not That Into You.

The basic concept is the same: if someone really likes you, the logical rules are suspended, and you shouldn't accept anything less than someone who really likes you. Which relates back to @Harlequin5942 's point: romance is a matter of motivation, not capability or situational context. You want someone who is motivated to be with you, not someone who is Just Not That Into You.

*The common female objection to this is that women shouldn't be obligated to perform sex acts with future partners which they did with past partners, they might not have enjoyed them after they tried them, they might be ashamed of having done them, they might be in a different place in their lives, etc. Which is why I'd offer the addendum that you shouldn't pry into a partner's sexual past, if she is really ashamed of or didn't enjoy X she'd keep X a secret. If she's flaunting her history of X all over, bragging about it to friends, she probably at least kinda liked it. Either way, it might not be perfect but it seems to be a useful heuristic every time I've seen it, with a few minor exceptions that serve to demonstrate the purpose of the rule.

I'll check my library for it. Thanks!

I've noticed a trend among the rationalist movement of favoring long and convoluted articles referencing other long and convoluted articles--the more inaccessible to the general public, the better.

Two competing Pre-Reqs on this: Watch This TikTok video and read This Borges Short Story. Both are short, the TikTok is a minute and the short story is 4 pages, so plenty concise.

Now compare the two. The notch on the book is so precise a metaphor that while the whole book is communicated by that notch, it is a code so complex that it would require absurdly accurate skill in measurement and mathematics to interpret. Even within the thought experiment, most people would assume that it would require some kind of complex microscope and computerized calculator to achieve. But let's go a step further. Let's imagine a superhuman who can see the notch on the metal rod and instantly measure the ratio visually, calculate the ratio, and interpret that into the written work. So that merely by showing such a man astick, I've sent him Funes the Memorius as surely as emailing you the pdf. But that requires both an immense amount of baseline skill, and a huge degree of education and recall. In understanding the code, and in the mathematics necessary to interpret it.

On the reverse of the coin is Funes, who Borges' narrator describes as

...not very capable of thought. To think is to forget differences, generalize, make abstractions. In the teeming world of Funes, there were only details, almost immediate in their presence.

Part of what makes Funes the way he is, is that before his superhero origin story he is an uneducated farmhand. He is raw intellect undiluted. He does not have the mental processes to encode things in a quick and useful way.

The reason so many Rationalist/Adjacent writers, and Mottizens are in this group, write at such length is because they and their audience lack metaphors and symbols for the concepts they are discussing. Two well read and well trained philosophers or theologians can argue almost entirely in metaphors; Baridan's Ass or Schrodinger's Cat or You Can Never Step in the Same River Twice or the Melian Dialogue or Pascal's Gamble or a Faustian Bargain or Funes the Memorius.* A few words and a whole mass of concepts and ideas and metaphors floods the brain. To a well-read Westerner, just by saying Funes the Memorius (or in some cases, "hey remember that Borges short story you read in undergrad with the guy who remembered everything?") I have achieved the same thing the stick did in the thought experiment. But both require common education and skill. The rationalist writer is often stepping out of his own education, and his audience is a generally intelligent but not particularly specialized group of readers. Everything has be explained from first principles, like Funes' useless numbering system.

*This is why I'm in favor of a classics based education. I gives you common ground to discuss. And the metaphors you get from the Bible and the Iliad are critical to interpreting Faust and Dante, which are critical to interpreting all the literature that comes after that.

Do you have more material on this theory of relationships? A quick Google didn't come up with much.

This matches my experiences/intuitions, and my favorite relationship advice: Sex and the City's "He's just not that into you"; and the more TRP/trashy Most Favored Nation theory of past experiences. I'd love to read a good serious treatment of it.