@TheDag's banner p

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users  
joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

				

User ID: 616

TheDag

Per Aspera ad Astra

4 followers   follows 12 users   joined 2022 September 05 16:04:17 UTC

					

No bio...


					

User ID: 616

Just adding your weekly reminder that the Motte remains the brightest and best hope for open discourse on the internet. Be proud and relieved you are a Mottizen - we have made it to the shining City on the Hill, the one place online where truth and free speech are protected.

I'm doing all this grandstanding because I'm flabbergasted that right now Tildes, one of the other 'reddit-alternatives' that claims to stand for open and intellectual discourse, is actively and unapologetically censoring anything to do with the UAP hearings.

Many of the users there are rightly pointing out that it's insane that the moderators would block discussion about a literal Congressional hearing... but this is the doublethink that we Mottizens are up against:

Hypothesizing that aliens might well exist based on the vastness of our universe is not a harmful thing.

Believing in conspiracy theories based on zero credible evidence is incredibly harmful. This hearing centers around a man with absolutely zero evidence claiming that there is an arm (or arms) of the government operating above congressional and presidential oversight. The claim is that we are dealing with a massive, top-level coverup. Does that sound familiar to anyone else? Anyone want to quess which Qrowd is qoing to eat this shit up?

Giving these conspiracy theories a platform on a forum where discussion is purported to be high quality and based on intellectual curiosity is harmful. Have you ever noticed how people who believe in one conspiracy theory are more likely to believe in multiple conspiracy theories? Worse, they are even likely to believe all conspiracy theories, even those which are completely contradictory to each other.. This is called conspiracist ideation, or conspiracy theory monism.

Anyone who hasn't been under a rock for the last 8-ish years knows how harmful this can be. They helped elect a president who built our current supreme court. Check out /r/qanoncasualties if you forgot how it harms us on a more individual level. You could also go back further than Q anon and read accounts of witch trials, rapes, genocides, wars, and all manner of horrible things caused by false beliefs in conspiracy. Not to mention the countless deaths caused by vaccine avoidance - something that started long ago, but with which we are still dealing today.

Politicians having a hearing about this conspiracy theory is news, unfortunately. However, the conspiracy theory itself is not the news. Congresswoman Lauren Boebert openly discussed Replacement Theory, should we give that its own thread and discuss its merits?

The only posts we should have regarding this topic, in my semi-humble opinion, are well-written articles absolutely tearing our politicians apart for even humoring this hearing. Perhaps a good debunking article explaining that this whole testimony is based on hearsay and rumor, and explaining that someone's position in government doesn't mean they're immune to conspiratorial thinking.


Again, luckily there is some actual pushback on the site itself. But please, my fellow Mottizens, let this open display of intolerance remind you to keep your guard strong. Keep your eyes focused directly on the goal, and remember that if we let ourselves be distracted by our petty differences, the Motte may well become the same censored cesspool as the rest of the internet.

Be strong my brothers and sisters, and never forget the incredible and unique nature of this Forum that we have built. Don't take the Motte for granted, and be swift and sure when defending it.

Veritas omnia vincet.

Those are not the same thing, my dude.

Eh coming from a background of hippy-dippy universalist churches that only quote the Bible maybe once or twice a year, they look pretty similar to me.

You should probably do a bit of research on that old world religion; and also consider looking around for a non-evangelical church near you.

Trust me, I've done a ton of research. Which is why I've concluded that Catholicism and Eastern Orthodox are the two strains of Christianity most likely to have kept or hewn closely to the truth. What do you mean by non-evangelical in this sense though?

The more trad protestant denominations can be good if you really like digging down on scripture instead of more rote sermons. (Baptists et all)

My understanding with most protestant/baptist denominations is that they throw out all the symbology and rituals like the Eucharist, which is kind of not what I'm looking for at the moment. Is that wrong?

Not the place so I'll keep it brief

You're right, it's not the place! You didn't really keep it brief either... ;P

political and social arrangements that seem unlikely to produce truth and are also knowably false just because you find modern value systems to be spiritually bereft.

This depends on what you see as truth. From a purely empirical standpoint, sure, religion is bullshit and there's no way Jesus rose from the dead etc etc. That being said, I've come to realize there is far more to the idea of truth than most rationalists believe. There is experiential knowledge that exists and can be verified by ourselves. Sure our consciousness isn't foolproof and we can trick ourselves, but there is factual knowledge to be gained there. In fact, it's the one frontier that science really hasn't been able to penetrate yet.

And if you take that view, then

unlikely to produce truth

seems pretty facile and wrong. These religious traditions are the honed core of wisdom that has persisted for thousands of years, through societal upheavals and persecutions and all sorts of other trials. This wisdom has persisted longer than any kingdom, state or empire. The truths extolled in religions are literally the central truths for the vast majority of humans who have ever lived.

Regardless, I'm not trying to rehash the athiest culture wars, just explaining how I've arrived at my current post-rationalist or meta-rationalist opinions. Also, at the end of the day, rationality doesn't seem to make people very happy. In fact in my experience, and the experience of most I've seen in the rationalist/EA spaces, it does the exact opposite. So even if religion does happen to be totally wrong on all counts, which I doubt, at the very least it's a useful and positive delusion for most people.

Are you really saying these sorts of cabals are inevitably discovered?

Just hand waving away all the effort and risk involved in the Panama Papers? Come now. That sort of serious investigative journalism is difficult and becoming less and less popular/rewarding.

Yep I don’t blame you, chronic pain is weird! I would take the advice of the body builders as well.

I just lurk here in the shadows waiting for people to fall through the cracks of mainstream exercise science, then I pounce!

My current church is very perennialist hippy type stuff so I’m looking to try out some more traditional services.

Great write up! I’m definitely interested in the details of the Indian development policy.

Thanks! A couple friends are actually Eastern Orthodox and they make a strong case.

Well yeah but there are a ton around us, trying to figure out which ones to try I guess.

Yep current medical understanding of injury is terrible, and doctors are way too confident at trying to perform surgeries when they don't know shit. Beware.

I'd say movement and exercise is the key to tendonitis in my experience. To be fair I'm also a big body/mind guy, a la John Sarno. I've dealt with chronic pain for almost ten years so I have been through all sorts of different treatment programs. Ultimately just developing more fine-grained bodily awareness and relaxing with yoga + working on my emotional state have been the only things that helped me.

Libgen is great for books.

Personally I just don't ever argue with people outside the Motte in terms of internet forums. Pick and choose your battles, I guess.

I'm looking for a new Church... do you all have any advice on how to find one?

Preferably something like Catholic or Eastern Orthodox, I want a more traditional place.

Yep! That’s what I was getting at, perhaps I was a little harsh.

Also social skills are way overrated. 90% of skill socially is just staying relaxed.

I mean this in the nicest possible way, but you might try getting over yourself. Many people when they first get into rationality/truth seeking or whatever start to see themselves as better than ‘normies’, as some sort of elect because they are smarter or see more clearly or whatever.

That sort of ideology will only bring you pain. No matter how much truth you accumulate you’re still just a person. If other people seem happier than you, maybe they know something you don’t.

mostly just other people trying to sell us things which will fulfill us, trying to convince you that it's a higher pursuit when really its' just a way to spend are material abundance while waiting on... what? What are we here for anymore?

It would be fine if there were people trying to sell us actual purpose like religions etc, which do still exist but are getting outcompeted in a capitalist world. Sadly in a free market for 'purposeful and meaningful activities' people are much more likely to pursue the easy path that is sold well than the hard path that actually provides what they want.

I'm curious what your issue specifically was, and if you got it to work?

Cloned the repo, but can't get jupyter lab to have the right PATH to that directory. Still working on it unfortunately.

He’s basically god and his vision always ends up happening.

Hah, sometimes I feel this way too. It's so bizarre how the public discourse can cover him so negatively while he's done so many incredible, seemingly impossible things.

Literally two of the most important technology innovations of this century, cheap space travel and electrical motors, have been shoved forward by him. Not only that, but generative AI, probably the most important invention ever was created by OpenAI, which he founded as well! It is literally insane how effective he is. Like Midas, everything he touches turns to gold. (Except the Boring Company, we don't talk about that one.)

When I read Tim Urban's series on SpaceX, it really opened my eyes to how utterly wrong, and not just wrong but totally out of touch with reality the mainstream media could be. That was my intro into rationalist spaces more generally.

He wanted to turn PayPal into X - this has been his dream for decades, since the start of his career.

Look at famous Christian writers throughout European history, or the scientific utopian writers of the 18th and 19th centuries like Francis Bacon. Their positive vision of the world created much of the good we have today.

Wow, I got excited just reading about a new World Fair! That’s a brilliant idea. I hope we can actually have something similar, and soon.

I’d love to see you flesh this out in a top level post, for what it’s worth!

I sympathize man. I’m in sales and have been hating my career for years, but the golden handcuffs of high income are real! We are blessed at least to have the opportunity to make money, but it sure has a cost.

On the other hand, using ChatGPT is depriving you of learning the debugging skills many of us from the older days before language models had to earn through suffering but at least we know how to do it without gpt.

Is this a bad thing? Like why would we need debugging skills if ChatGPT can solve that problem?

Oh and I actually have been using a Mac.

Ahh that's an interesting point, and does make a lot of sense. Perhaps I just haven't gone deep enough in the past to appreciate the nice side of things. Good to know.